User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > "I love you Grandma." "I love you too. Let's $%!#."
Page:
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

Originally posted by pkrplyr2003


Originally posted by foofighter24



How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.



I do not disagree --- which, is why that question had to be asked --- it was avoided over and over. That was the larger issue.


It is the larger issue, but it also falls right in line with all Cat's other beliefs. I am surprised you are surprised by his stance.


If you acknowledge that the characterization of 'form' is the larger issue --- why did you not ask? Instead you jump off onto something that be definition can no longer be the larger issue; therefore, of lesser importance.

 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by oppco80

Originally posted by pkrplyr2003


Originally posted by oppco80



They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.


I am not upset at Foo over that --- I get upset when he knows that Cat has over and over again explained the difference so many times that it is burnt into my head --- yet, he still knowingly uses the wrong term to get a rise out of him. It muddies up this board --- turning a conversation into one of molasses in two posts.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Originally posted by oppco80


Originally posted by pkrplyr2003



Originally posted by oppco80




They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.


I am not upset at Foo over that --- I get upset when he knows that Cat has over and over again explained the difference so many times that it is burnt into my head --- yet, he still knowingly uses the wrong term to get a rise out of him. It muddies up this board --- turning a conversation into one of molasses in two posts.


Note, I am only using Cat's description for the purposes of Foo's understanding of Cat's stance.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by foofighter24

Originally posted by oppco80


Originally posted by pkrplyr2003



Originally posted by foofighter24




How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.



I do not disagree --- which, is why that question had to be asked --- it was avoided over and over. That was the larger issue.


It is the larger issue, but it also falls right in line with all Cat's other beliefs. I am surprised you are surprised by his stance.


If you acknowledge that the characterization of 'form' is the larger issue --- why did you not ask? Instead you jump off onto something that be definition can no longer be the larger issue; therefore, of lesser importance.



Because I knew where he was going. I did not know who the rapist was, however. You seems hellbent on blaming me for asking the "wrong" question. Is it my obligation to set the ball on the tee for Cat to hit? He could have clarified his stance at any time, and chose not to. He also could have answered my question at any time.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by oppco80

Originally posted by pkrplyr2003


Originally posted by oppco80



They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=2#35395116

Last post in that thread --- should clear up any confusion regarding Cat's viewpoints.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

Originally posted by foofighter24


Originally posted by oppco80



Originally posted by pkrplyr2003




Originally posted by foofighter24





How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.



I do not disagree --- which, is why that question had to be asked --- it was avoided over and over. That was the larger issue.


It is the larger issue, but it also falls right in line with all Cat's other beliefs. I am surprised you are surprised by his stance.


If you acknowledge that the characterization of 'form' is the larger issue --- why did you not ask? Instead you jump off onto something that be definition can no longer be the larger issue; therefore, of lesser importance.



Because I knew where he was going. I did not know who the rapist was, however. You seems hellbent on blaming me for asking the "wrong" question. Is it my obligation to set the ball on the tee for Cat to hit? He could have clarified his stance at any time, and chose not to. He also could have answered my question at any time.


Foo, that point has been addressed at least three times now --- the confusion was not on his part --- it was yours. You did not ask the questions clarifying that confusion. Instead you asked as it turns out a somewhat unrelated question --- over and over again.

Note: I am not going to debate the relative worthwhile of the 'who is the rapist' question as it has been addressed several times earlier.

I sure as hell am hellbent on bringing up the wrong question. It hurt your overall viewpoint considerably. I am sick and tired of watching conservatives completely miss the obvious points that can be addressed --- instead, picking obscure notions and latching on like they are a pit bull on a steak. It is mind numbingly frustrating.
Edited by oppco80 on May 3, 2010 13:37:32
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Originally posted by oppco80


Originally posted by pkrplyr2003



Originally posted by oppco80




They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=2#35395116

Last post in that thread --- should clear up any confusion regarding Cat's viewpoints.


I have him on ignore.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by oppco80

Originally posted by pkrplyr2003


Originally posted by oppco80



Originally posted by pkrplyr2003




Originally posted by oppco80





They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=2#35395116

Last post in that thread --- should clear up any confusion regarding Cat's viewpoints.


I have him on ignore.


The issue is not whether you have read it ---
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80

The issue is not whether you have read it ---


I don't care to read it. I considered taking him off of ignore due to the ridiculousness of his claims but instead opted to leave it as it was. I sticking to my guns so to speak regarding ignoring the trolls and not reading their posts regardless of the content.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
I am sick and tired of watching conservatives completely miss the obvious points that can be addressed --- instead, picking obscure notions and latching on like they are a pit bull on a steak. It is mind numbingly frustrating.


And I am sick and tired of conservatives allowing the left to shift the window by engaging in stupid debates. Too many fall for the same old ploy, over and over so they can be friends and act like any compromise is a good one.

Sometimes it takes balls to make a stand and say "This is not up for debate" rather than allowing chunks of your freedom and money to be whittled away with every action. There is a large group of phony conservatives who will sit down at a table with liberals/progressives and discuss a plan that completely violates the constitution and the American way, and settle for a modest infringement, instead of a major one.

 
showa58taro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Sometimes it takes balls to make a stand and say "This is not up for debate" rather than allowing chunks of your freedom and money to be whittled away with every action. There is a large group of phony conservatives who will sit down at a table with liberals/progressives and discuss a plan that completely violates the constitution and the American way, and settle for a modest infringement, instead of a major one.



It takes supreme cowardice to not be willing to examine things even when you find them to be beyond doubt because, guess what, you could be wrong. It is the biggest pile of arrogant wank to think that something is not up for debate. EVERYTHING is up for debate.

Plus, if you don't want to debate it, what the hell are you doing on a "General Discussion" subforum called "Politics and Religion"? Why not just not type inane tripe to those who you disagree with about how you don't want to have a discussion. Just leave, go do something productive with your time.
 
showa58taro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003


I don't care to read it. I considered taking him off of ignore due to the ridiculousness of his claims but instead opted to leave it as it was. I sticking to my guns so to speak regarding ignoring the trolls and not reading their posts regardless of the content.


Maybe you should stop being a bad human being and either ignore those you have on ignore, or take them off ignore and argue with them. Taking pot shots and then saying you can't read their replies is pretty bad.

As for the 'ridiculousness' it is pretty easy:

progressives believe in the necessity of "progressive institutions" to gradually increase social justice -- such institutions can be anything from schools and jails to concepts like the separation of powers or practices like voting. as such, progressivism is almost as much of a historical viewpoint as a political one. instead of assuming that there is a single perfect human governance, the idea is that our governance gets better (and more moral) as we get better at crafting/reforming institutions. (of course, this means that progressives make a rather large conflation of 'governance' with 'institutions', which places them instantly at odds with any type of anarchist or government minimalist.)

to keep these institutions strong/viable/legitimate, progressives crusade against corruption and are always strong supporters of campaign and finance reform. while they're not afraid of large government, progressives are in no way seeking to create some sort of totalitarian/statist regime. in fact, they view such an outcome as impossible, so long as institutions are kept in check and the public remains empowered. this is one of the reasons why they agitate for more direct democracy (as opposed to republicanism and/or mass appointments) -- in their view, true political equality is the first prerequisite of social justice, so the only way to move forward is to embrace democracy and make sure everyone is educated and voting.

obviously, there are some concerns here... although more about "progressives" who misunderstand their own ideology than about progressivism itself. a broad view of what constitutes an 'institution' is all well and good, but enjoying one's right to vote is a completely different thing than moralizing compulsory education. progressives may avoid the mistake of consequentialism (i.e moralizing the result), but they in turn moralize the process, which is almost as bad. there's obviously no risk of a progressive become a fascist, but there is a tendency for progressives to think governance can solve everything (just like marketists think that the market can solve everything) -- hence the caricature of the overly eager "don quixote" progressive state... or al gore claiming he invented the internet (which he never said, but is actually true in an unthinkingly progressivist way).

liberals are a bit easier to get a handle on, considering they're essentially the mirror opposite of libertarians. technically, both follow liberalism... it's just that (modern american) liberals follow social liberalism (which values 'positive liberty') while libertarians follow classical liberalism (which values 'negative liberty'). in other words, libertarians stress "freedom from" while liberals stress "freedom to".

of course, the problem with enforcing positive liberty is that it usually encroaches on negative liberty. for example, society may have said that blacks couldn't use certain bathrooms or sit in certain seats or go to certain schools or hold certain jobs, but liberals agitated for legislation that ensured that all races had the "freedom to" do those things. did such positive liberty infringe on the negative liberties of racists and bigots? yup... just as freeing the slaves could also be termed as a state appropriation or infringement on the negative liberties of the slaveholders to buy and sell whomever they damn well pleased. so the idea (and it's the main pillar for liberals) is that collective negative liberty is actually a form of positive liberty. put differently, liberals claim that positive liberty is actually the first prerequisite of negative liberty (cf. social libertarians).

there are some obvious concerns here as well. any ideology that embraces consequentialism (i.e. the ends justify the means) is in danger of becoming both totalitarian and oppressive (nb. not the same thing). moreover, democracy itself suffers a bit of a chilling effect -- by assuming a consequentialist pose, a state thus moralizes its own policies and demonizes (and even dehumanizes) any dissent. as the state becomes less democratic and more insulated from its own citizens (or even adversarial to them), the judicial and legislative collapse into an increasingly secretive executive branch. not only does this make voting pointless, but there is a pronounced risk that the state will simply begin misinforming/manipulating its citizens for the sake of political expediency and suddenly 1984 is real. this is not to say that liberals are in any danger of becoming statists, but it's a similar ideological predicament to progressivism -- only those who fail to understand it are at risk of perverting it.

some oversimplified differences:
-- progressives typically work through the legislative branch, liberals through the judicial
-- progressives emphasize process (means>ends) and are (by definition) anti-consequentialist.. liberals emphasize results (ends>means) and sometimes veer towards consequentialism
-- if they think voting and education can save the world, they're a progressive... if they think social programs and court cases can save the world, they're a liberal
-- if they think of social justice in terms of participatory political egalitarianism and/or civic virtue, they're a progressive... if they think of social justice in chiefly economic terms, they're a liberal

and i know i've mentioned this before, but it's worth repeating -- the radicalism of the late 19th century begat the populism of the early 20th century which, during the great depression, morphed into the sort of progressivism that marked the democratic party at that time. but following ww2, liberals suddenly took center stage and many of the more culturally conservative progressives (like ronald reagan and charleton heston) declared that the democratic party had "left them". ironically, it was reagan's proto-neocon presidency that did much to kill the liberal movement and produce the radical centrism of clinton's "third way" politics and the even more radical neo-progressivism that put obama in the white house.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

I am sick and tired of watching conservatives completely miss the obvious points that can be addressed --- instead, picking obscure notions and latching on like they are a pit bull on a steak. It is mind numbingly frustrating.


And I am sick and tired of conservatives allowing the left to shift the window by engaging in stupid debates. Too many fall for the same old ploy, over and over so they can be friends and act like any compromise is a good one.

Sometimes it takes balls to make a stand and say "This is not up for debate" rather than allowing chunks of your freedom and money to be whittled away with every action. There is a large group of phony conservatives who will sit down at a table with liberals/progressives and discuss a plan that completely violates the constitution and the American way, and settle for a modest infringement, instead of a major one.



Foo, one has to first understand what they are articulating so one can respond accordingly. If you stick your head in the sand for the why --- they are not going to listen to the no. You do not know me --- outside of my posts. If you recall back to the HC debates --- I was very outspoken in my criticisms. For many reasons ---

I am willing to sit down and talk to anyone about anything. That does not mean I will agree with one point they bring up; however, I will use their own words, including what they mean (the why) to respond to their requests (the what).

 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by foofighter24

Originally posted by oppco80


I am sick and tired of watching conservatives completely miss the obvious points that can be addressed --- instead, picking obscure notions and latching on like they are a pit bull on a steak. It is mind numbingly frustrating.


And I am sick and tired of conservatives allowing the left to shift the window by engaging in stupid debates. Too many fall for the same old ploy, over and over so they can be friends and act like any compromise is a good one.

Sometimes it takes balls to make a stand and say "This is not up for debate" rather than allowing chunks of your freedom and money to be whittled away with every action. There is a large group of phony conservatives who will sit down at a table with liberals/progressives and discuss a plan that completely violates the constitution and the American way, and settle for a modest infringement, instead of a major one.



Foo, one has to first understand what they are articulating so one can respond accordingly. If you stick your head in the sand for the why --- they are not going to listen to the no. You do not know me --- outside of my posts. If you recall back to the HC debates --- I was very outspoken in my criticisms. For many reasons ---

I am willing to sit down and talk to anyone about anything. That does not mean I will agree with one point they bring up; however, I will use their own words, including what they mean (the why) to respond to their requests (the what).



It is not sticking one's head in the sand, it is understanding how and when to negotiate. For instance, if someone is offering something to you that you simply do not want, you have no obligation to sit down and negotiate with them about it.

If I want to sell you some piece of shit car for $10k, we don't have to discuss it to the point where you purchase the piece of shit car at $3k. Unfortunately, this is what normally happens because the left is using the softness of people to negotiate. It is a good strategy. If I want $100 from you, I am more likely to get it by asking for $1,000.

How do you recognize a professional negotiator in real estate? He is the guy who is willing to advise his client to flat out reject certasin offers, instead of the hack who always tell his client to give the person their bottom line or meet them half way.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Business negotiations are not political ones --- not even remotely close.

You are obligated to listen to what the other side says in the political realm --- after all --- we are all supposed to be 'represented.' Piss poor representation if one side cannot sit at the table. Can you think back two months to when you were advocating just that? Lack of representation in a major bill --- lack of say.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.