User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
I thought you were 6'5" 280lbs of pure muscle.


6'3" 280lbs with a 20% body fat, so not pure muscle but not a pile of shit either (I should really weigh ~255lbs for my build).
 
Hugestballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
I love knowing that my newly created dots are going to be worthless next season and that they are a complete waste of time, effort, and money thanks to this new change. The only way to make this right is to offer a 100% flex refund on those newly created players OR to give a significant amount of bonus SP to those older players to compensate for what they would have missed out on had they had the benefit of this new system.


By the way this game works, no matter what you are going to be playing against people that were made at roughly the same time (with the exception of SSB people who will, of course, be older/further out).

Your dot is only as good or as bad as the other people on the field with it.

Can someone please explain to me at what point the 'Now my dots are bad!' argument makes sense?
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hugestballs
By the way this game works, no matter what you are going to be playing against people that were made at roughly the same time (with the exception of SSB people who will, of course, be older/further out).

Your dot is only as good or as bad as the other people on the field with it.

Can someone please explain to me at what point the 'Now my dots are bad!' argument makes sense?


It makes sense when not used with any type of context. A S15 archetype player, *could* be built better than a S14 non-archetype player (who picks the same archetype in S15), due to the better ALGs... of course this only relates to a direct comparison and only for some positions.

Also at certain points of a player's career, it's quite possible to see up to 80 or more days difference in player age (not including SSBs). For example, a 80 days difference is ~10 levels, we've all seen level 70's playing level 60's at one point or another. So while not widespread or extremely common, it does happen.

Granted, you're right about how good or bad that a dot performs is relative to who they face. This is a contested build based game after all.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hugestballs
By the way this game works, no matter what you are going to be playing against people that were made at roughly the same time (with the exception of SSB people who will, of course, be older/further out).

Your dot is only as good or as bad as the other people on the field with it.

Can someone please explain to me at what point the 'Now my dots are bad!' argument makes sense?


It doesn't. If you really look at the archetypes, there are no power builds there, with the exception of Strength DL which everyone would pick over the other two.

Many builds will be more difficult to perfect with this new system. Powerbacks don't get a speed major, elusive and scat don't get any strength alg at all. They all present a challenge to the user. People who think this will render theirs builds obsolete are overlooking some of the most basic facets of this game.

Oh, and lol at the people who want to riot for more refunded flex to needlessly retire their guys. They are up in arms about 2$ worth of flex, but are more than willing to throw away months of player building for no reason.

I could see if you were hard up for flex and wanted to try out the new stuff, but that's still a choice your not being forced to make..
 
fogie55
offline
Link
 
I haven't seen anything about whether the archetypes would be visible or not-- would a player still be labeled "Linebacker" or would he be "Blitzing Linebacker."

It would be much more interesting if this information was private--only the agent knowing the player's archetype.
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
You can't make people care about the minors, they never will. It's what every mmorpg comes down to, people want to get to the highest level to see how they stack up. Even those stupid sword games are about spending a month going into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant so you can go into the woods to kill a dog then taking his teeth to town to sell them to the merchant.....and so on before you ever even get to battle other people! At least the minors are getting restructured to try and get some good competition for the lower levels.


Really now?

Show me one SUCCESSFUL mmorpg that is player-full at endgame but where leveling wasn't fun the first few times you do it. Really. Go. Find me one example.
 
Link
 
I suggested player archtypes about 5 seasons ago. I think I even started a thread called 'Player Archetypes' and suggested almost the same structure that's being implemented...

And yes, I do want a cookie.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
Really now?

Show me one SUCCESSFUL mmorpg that is player-full at endgame but where leveling wasn't fun the first few times you do it. Really. Go. Find me one example.


Guild Wars barely even had leveling. It was such a brief and minor part of the game that it's difficult to argue that it was fun.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Guild Wars barely even had leveling. It was such a brief and minor part of the game that it's difficult to argue that it was fun.


The main draw of GWs was the PvP, leveling was optional as you could create a PvP player (with all the bells and whistles) and PvP to your heart's content. The PvE aspect of GWs was merely an additional feature, kind of like being a coordinator in GLB (shitty and optional, but you need someone to do it to help the team/guild). The meat and potatoes of GW and GLB is the PvP model...
 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
Question?

In the announcement...catch 22 mentions everyone getting the use of 300 Flex for any player(s) they want to use to create their player. And of course he also says that it's a non-refunable freeby as well. Another words..use it or lose it,when they offer it.

My question?
When? When are we going to be allowed to created our "free" Archetypes player?

Will it be on day 40? Day 1 of season 15?
Anyone know?

Thanks...
ace
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Anyone know?


Probably only Catch has an idea at this point of when specifically that will be, but nothing is definitive anyways. Just sit back and relax.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Question?

In the announcement...catch 22 mentions everyone getting the use of 300 Flex for any player(s) they want to use to create their player. And of course he also says that it's a non-refunable freeby as well. Another words..use it or lose it,when they offer it.

My question?
When? When are we going to be allowed to created our "free" Archetypes player?

Will it be on day 40? Day 1 of season 15?
Anyone know?

Thanks...
ace


I am positive that there will be an announcement when it's available.
 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
OK...Cool.

Thanks guys
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Hey kids, rock and roll, rock on.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
i thought i heard somewhere that you can chose sa's is this true and also how can you become part of the group that gets to test this on another server cause this sounds cool.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.