Originally posted by Hugestballs
By the way this game works, no matter what you are going to be playing against people that were made at roughly the same time (with the exception of SSB people who will, of course, be older/further out).
Your dot is only as good or as bad as the other people on the field with it.
Can someone please explain to me at what point the 'Now my dots are bad!' argument makes sense?
It makes sense when not used with any type of context. A S15 archetype player, *could* be built better than a S14 non-archetype player (who picks the same archetype in S15), due to the better ALGs... of course this only relates to a direct comparison and only for some positions.
Also at certain points of a player's career, it's quite possible to see up to 80 or more days difference in player age (not including SSBs). For example, a 80 days difference is ~10 levels, we've all seen level 70's playing level 60's at one point or another. So while not widespread or extremely common, it does happen.
Granted, you're right about how good or bad that a dot performs is relative to who they face. This is a contested build based game after all.