User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes

===

I'm thinking something along the lines of a natural extension of the Mentor VA.

===
Other players sometimes make the best coaches. Each level of Mentor gives a +1% in-game bonus to vision and confidence for all lower-leveled teammates who play the same position and were created at least 1 season after this player, to the day, as long as the player is on the depth chart for the game. This ability stacks with other mentors on the team, up to a maximum of 25% bonus per position.
===


I'm thinking this kind of mechanic would be much less game breaking, compared to what we already have.


How many levels of stacking of attribute bonuses do we really need?

Edited by OttawaShane on Sep 10, 2009 09:09:44
Edited by OttawaShane on Sep 10, 2009 09:09:30
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
Look, im not even going to try to get into the Xs n Os of this crap.

you people..(the peeps that approve) and come up with ideas. do you know what your doing?? you are contributing to helping this dude(bort) come up with an idea, and in the end he is going to charge you with your OWN ideas!! wait wait wait, dont touch our mouse.....read that last line again! then read it again! let it sink in. you guys are comming up with ideas and then he is going to charge you for those ideas. AND YOUR OK WITH THAT?? really?? REALLY??

he has stated that "its not about the money aspect" in another thread. so....why cant this coaching crap be implemented WITHOUT us needing to spend flex pts????? think about it......keep thinking....and think some more. i still wouldnt be ok with it becasue of numerous more issues, but at least it would be a start.

there is no way in hell knowingly... would i help a staff come up with ideas for a system to turn around and charge me for it. and im blown away at alot of this customer base who's VISION(since GLB likes to blame everything on vision) to see this comming is blinded.
 
Mitch54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DTRAIN
Look, im not even going to try to get into the Xs n Os of this crap.

you people..(the peeps that approve) and come up with ideas. do you know what your doing?? you are contributing to helping this dude(bort) come up with an idea, and in the end he is going to charge you with your OWN ideas!! wait wait wait, dont touch our mouse.....read that last line again! then read it again! let it sink in. you guys are comming up with ideas and then he is going to charge you for those ideas. AND YOUR OK WITH THAT?? really?? REALLY??

he has stated that "its not about the money aspect" in another thread. so....why cant this coaching crap be implemented WITHOUT us needing to spend flex pts????? think about it......keep thinking....and think some more. i still wouldnt be ok with it becasue of numerous more issues, but at least it would be a start.

there is no way in hell knowingly... would i help a staff come up with ideas for a system to turn around and charge me for it. and im blown away at alot of this customer base who's VISION(since GLB likes to blame everything on vision) to see this comming is blinded.


I haven't thought of it that way, but well said. If the players of GLB come up with the idea, we shouldn't have to pay a dime. Technically, its a copyright violation. So, really, the whole coach idea should be free.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mitch54
Originally posted by DTRAIN

Look, im not even going to try to get into the Xs n Os of this crap.

you people..(the peeps that approve) and come up with ideas. do you know what your doing?? you are contributing to helping this dude(bort) come up with an idea, and in the end he is going to charge you with your OWN ideas!! wait wait wait, dont touch our mouse.....read that last line again! then read it again! let it sink in. you guys are comming up with ideas and then he is going to charge you for those ideas. AND YOUR OK WITH THAT?? really?? REALLY??

he has stated that "its not about the money aspect" in another thread. so....why cant this coaching crap be implemented WITHOUT us needing to spend flex pts????? think about it......keep thinking....and think some more. i still wouldnt be ok with it becasue of numerous more issues, but at least it would be a start.

there is no way in hell knowingly... would i help a staff come up with ideas for a system to turn around and charge me for it. and im blown away at alot of this customer base who's VISION(since GLB likes to blame everything on vision) to see this comming is blinded.


I haven't thought of it that way, but well said. 1If the players of GLB come up with the idea, we shouldn't have to pay a dime. 2Technically, its a copyright violation. So, really, the whole coach idea should be free.


1: You've never contributed feedback to any game (or anything else) you pay for before? I have, and sometimes rewards for ideas that get used are nice, but acknowledgment is usually sufficient.

2. No it isn't. Don't rely on CrackJack boxes for legal advice.
 
Dukester100
offline
Link
 
Have coaches earn salary just like players: minimum salary depending on level, different salaries (not all one "set salary") for various teams.

What do they spend it on? Maybe a special type of equiptment for certain players, maybe a certain amount for a +1 to a certain attribute for all players (or specific players), maybe spend money and see a more in-depth scouting report, I don't know, just throwing out ideas.
 
soulcrshr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dukester100
Have coaches earn salary just like players: minimum salary depending on level, different salaries (not all one "set salary") for various teams.

What do they spend it on? Maybe a special type of equiptment for certain players, maybe a certain amount for a +1 to a certain attribute for all players (or specific players), maybe spend money and see a more in-depth scouting report, I don't know, just throwing out ideas.


i don't want a coach adding anything to my players. sorry but is my player and i build him how i want too.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by soulcrshr
i don't want a coach adding anything to my players. sorry but is my player and i build him how i want too.


This.
 
dbm326
offline
Link
 
Allow the coaches to have 1 specialty that gives slight performance boosts on certain plays. This would probably work better with more formations added though.

Some examples:
Offensive Coordinator A specializes in the West Coast offense, giving the offense a bonus on HB, short TE, and quick passes.
Offensive Coordinator B specializes in the Air Raid offense, giving the offense a bonus on Shotgun and long passes.
Offensive Coordinator C specializes in the Spread offense, giving the offense a bonus while in Spread formations.
Defensive Coordinator A specializes in the 3-4, giving the defense a bonus while in the 3-4.
Defensive Coordinator B specializes in the Nickel, giving the defense a bonus while in Nickel packages.
Edited by dbm326 on Sep 22, 2009 01:24:19
Edited by dbm326 on Sep 22, 2009 00:52:36
Edited by dbm326 on Sep 21, 2009 22:50:22
Edited by dbm326 on Sep 21, 2009 22:48:48
Edited by dbm326 on Sep 21, 2009 22:47:27
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
1) LETS GET THIS DONE BORT! ITS TIME!

2) In the morale area, of the coach, have that go down with losses, come up with wins and over time, AND have it get a boost when signing with a new team (and maybe even go up with time more when not in a coaching slot aka when resting). This would allow some simulation of that odd phenom where a coach is wonderful, then loses some and is fired, but then rehired by some other team down the road, sometimes more than once.

3) Ignore the less coaches crowd. Have more. HC OC DC Assts for both of the Cs, ST, Equipment Manager, and a Financial GM, Physical Trainers and Position Coaches.

4) Financial GM would be able to improve gate, concessions, buy stadiums with less money, get cash from the city (loans that do not have to be repaid), get cheaper interest on loans and longer payment periods, allow teams to make offers and bonuses higher and lower than the standard contract limits, and allow contract terms longer than three seasons. You could break that into two positions, player personnel and finance GMs.

5) Allow one player to fill more than one slot (so that the HC could also be the player personnel GM the way some are). This would have the result of his being forced to do more with the same activity limits so not ideal, but it happens so make it an option here.

6) Physical Trainer. Asst Coach that could improve physical attributes way others improve skills.

7) Position Coaches would be able to give boosts like HC OC DC but only to the guys in their positions (ie offensive line, receivers etc). Place to let more players sample coaching. Where you would expect to get people focused on the stat boosting stuff more than tactics.

8) Personal Trainers. Allow players to hire "coach" like positions to individual players that could help them get discounts for training (ie train with 1 and 3 instead of 2 and 5) or to get more from training or to get flat out boosts to stats etc. Maybe allow a personal trainer to be hired by more than one player (skill based so the higher level he is the more players he can be the personal trainer for).

Edited by yello1 on Oct 22, 2009 22:16:59
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure coaching will never happen, kind of like how video killed the radio star...
 
Guan Yu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
BORT, If you really want coaches to work and be realistic. Allow us to "Watch film" with our position coach. Then give us say 5 options per player.

Free safety watches film, decides team A runs 5 Favorite plays. He studies plays, and when he sees these plays he gets.

Play 1) HB Screen Ace X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 2) Strong I slam .8X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 3)Shotgun Screen .6x% boost
Play 4 etc
Play 5 etc
This way we could actually game plan, and use "Coaches" to give our players boosts to these teams who abuse the same 4-5 plays game in game out. Would force teams to truly devise schemes, and really come up with new game plans week to week.

Edit: this would take more work, but I Don't want coaches to be some BS thing that just gives people a reward for having them. I Want people to have to study, and work to get advantages out of these coaches, not just some Free pass for finding this website first.


Winner... this is the best idea in the whole thread.
 
Guan Yu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Quas
This is exactly the type of thing that has caused me to lose interest in this game. Why wait untill the players get to 440 days? Because it's continued oldschool favoritism. Players should be aloud to retire and become coaches after more like 220 days.

Most of us a re sick of this carrot that is dangled just out of reach all the time. I'm actually at a point where I've built the reputation that I could make this work for me, but I still see and empathize with the guys who did not discover this game until the 4th season or later. These players are treated like second class citizens around here and it really should stop.



Here's another keeper idea I'm just now digging up. I really hate that season ones were born on third base, played their whole careers in AAA/Pro and now will make the best coaches too since they'll always be a step ahead of all other coaches.
 
vinman
offline
Link
 
The last thing we need is coaches,hope it is never implemented.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vinman
The last thing we need is coaches,hope it is never implemented.


 
shadowmane
offline
Link
 
My question is this... if we have all these coaches out there, is that going to mean I have to spend flex just to let someone OC my team and adjust the tactics for it? This is the first time I've run across this idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.