User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
I also think that focusing on S10 production is misguided because right now HBs are so much more effective in the passing game that WR stats are suffering regardless of their quality.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
I also think that focusing on S10 production is misguided because right now HBs are so much more effective in the passing game that WR stats are suffering regardless of their quality.


I've said this like 5 times now and finally someone agrees.

PS - just be glad you dont have a TE.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 9, 2009 23:45:45
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Well as an OC I've been trying whatever I can think of to get the ball to our receivers, many of whom have had high level success in the past, but my QB is too smart for that and keeps throwing to the open HB.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jdbolick

I also think that focusing on S10 production is misguided because right now HBs are so much more effective in the passing game that WR stats are suffering regardless of their quality.


I've said this like 5 times now and finally someone agrees.

PS - just be glad you dont have a TE.


You mean you don't like watching the TE and the defensive player guarding him go into that weird robotic movement where they mimic eachother until the catch when they suddenly snap out of it and play norma?
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak


Great example to look at. Look where the WR gained max acceleration and max speed. Then look at the CB. The CB breaks in at his highest acceleration, the turns around. The CB wasn't leaving any cushion, and attempted to press a guy running a streak route. There is less speed involved in that play than people realize.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Pierre, what I think you are off-track with is your passion for GLB to revert back into a foot race.

In real football (at all levels), two things are true.

1) WRs and DBs have virtually the same speed. If this isn't true in the sim, then we're not playing football as much as having a track meet.

2) When you're playing/watching football and a WR gets a few steps ahead of the DB, it's usually due to the DB failing to diagnose the route in time (vision) and/or failing to transition into the correct position/force the WR to run a certain way (agility). Or it's due to the WR diagnosing the defense (vision), running the route well in the context of what the defense is giving (vision/agility), or making a superior maneuver (agility). And or course of a pass comes with coverage in place, there's a fight for the catch (jumping/catching/strength)

Raw speed is clearly of secondary importance.


What you're advocating for isn't even football. I don't know what it is TBH.


1) How could you possibly say this? If CBs and WRs virtually had the same speed some college CBs wouldn't fall from 1st round picks to late round picks just because of a slow 40. In the NFL and college they recruit and draft fast corners because they understand they need raw speed to keep up with receivers at that level. There aren't slow CBs out there because teams don't want them. That isn't the case here. If I was recruiting a CB I wouldn't even send a message to a CB with over 100 speed. HUGE difference.

2) That isn't true either, you see WRs blow by Cbs all the time using raw speed. If a CB takes a false step or one stutter against Devery Henderson he'd better hope to god he has safety help or else it is 6 points. Devery Henderson does one thing well, run really fast.

On #2 I understand completely what you are saying and for most players that is completely true. Most NFL WRs aren't going to just run by people but there are some who can.



Please understand what I am saying. I don't want a fucking foot race. I probably have the most to lose if this gets changed because all of my CBs are 90 or less speed. A WR with 10 more speed shouldn't burn a CB without something else impacting the CB like a pump fake or head fake or juke. A WR with 10% more speed should be able to get some separation from a CB that doesn't give up a cushion, not much but some. A WR with 20% more speed should eat a CB alive.

It is the defenses job to stop the WR and with the defensive play creator it shouldn't be a problem at all. I do think agility should be tied to speed to a point. I do think a WR needs decent catching, vision and confidence to catch the ball, it shouldn't be extreme but they should need it.

Quit trying to act like I am asking for a sim that is totally dependent on speed, I am not, nor close to it. I do think that shutdown coverage should make an impact and boost speed but 2 skill points in SDC shouldn't add up to 90 skill points for a WR to pump speed to overcome it.

Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks. That is beyond pathetic. If you don't think defensive coordinators stay up at night trying to figure out how to stop guys like Steve Smith, Randy Moss, Calvin Johnson, etc then you are dead wrong. They don't stick any CB on him because they have good vision or good speed. They have to gameplan to slow him down. That is all I am asking.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
This thread is still going?
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
No diminishing returns does not mean the progression is linear.

The input values do not diminish, the outputs do. There's nothing dishonest about it.

You will never see a 3.8 second 40 time no matter how many points you spend on speed.


Oh, and how about QB confidence not being high enough to throw that super deep ball to the stone fingered speedster?.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
This thread is still going?


This thread needs governed speed.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
This thread is still going?


I'm still working under the theory that Pierre Thomas is Al Davis. But then again, Pierre knows how to win so i think i'm out of ideas
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by chronoaug

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak


Great example to look at. Look where the WR gained max acceleration and max speed. Then look at the CB. The CB breaks in at his highest acceleration, the turns around. The CB wasn't leaving any cushion, and attempted to press a guy running a streak route. There is less speed involved in that play than people realize.


Great example even though he is running much faster than most WRs with 120+ speed. It is also a great example at how poor the cushions and pathing for CBs and FS are. There is no way a FS playing cover 2 with deep strong half coverage should get abused like that.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
This thread is still going?


Can we get to tomorrow's one day 50 pager? Monday probably had thread on elusives started, a Tuesday night had the thing about permabans, Wednesday had Windhoek, this is today. Smart money on Friday is DEs.
 
Also Banned
offline
Link
 
stop crying.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by chronoaug


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak


Great example to look at. Look where the WR gained max acceleration and max speed. Then look at the CB. The CB breaks in at his highest acceleration, the turns around. The CB wasn't leaving any cushion, and attempted to press a guy running a streak route. There is less speed involved in that play than people realize.


Great example even though he is running much faster than most WRs with 120+ speed. It is also a great example at how poor the cushions and pathing for CBs and FS are. There is no way a FS playing cover 2 with deep strong half coverage should get abused like that.


TBH, i see separation like this a fair amount on breakaways with receivers i suspect have 120speed
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 23:56:55
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Great example even though he is running much faster than most WRs with 120+ speed.


So...maybe speed isn't the only attribute in the game that effects top speed?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.