User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Excellent point, but so long as a select few are the only ones who get to see the changes before the season, it's a real pain in the ass for the rest o f us trying to catch up with their knowledge of what to use in the new season's game plans.

Maybe, but I don't have any clue about what goes on the test server, so I can't comment. On games where there have been public test servers, I usually check them out for about 10 minutes and get bored. Cyberdunk had/has one, where they upload the new version of the sim and let people try it out. Yeah, I never used it and still kept up just fine.

Obviously it should just be another server that people can log into and check out for themselves, but I'm /facepalming at the drama queens.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Iceman16

Imo, buying flex is like buying a donation. You pay into the game so that it can improve, and you get back flex as compensation.


Wow.


Did that just blow your mind?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Iceman16


Imo, buying flex is like buying a donation. You pay into the game so that it can improve, and you get back flex as compensation.


Wow.


Did that just blow your mind?


With stupidity, yes.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Iceman16



Imo, buying flex is like buying a donation. You pay into the game so that it can improve, and you get back flex as compensation.


Wow.


Did that just blow your mind?


With stupidity, yes.


I don't see where I'm wrong.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

Hey Boon,

Read my post on Medellin, it tells you how much I care about this issue lol,

To respond to your post here, I don't see it as failed logic, simply because, he is right. Let's take your amazing FS who you refused to sign with me and test him out.

A. How many different offenses to test him out?
B. How many different WR builds to test him out?
C. How many different TE builds to test him out?
D. How many different FB builds to test him out?
E. How many different HB builds to test him out?
G. How many different defenses to test him out in?

Anyone care to do the math on that just on how many different groups can be made there? But we are gonna go through all that to test out how effective jumping makes him vs catching, for interceptions?

We have to believe that the testers, don't have a job, don't have a family, don't have their own players/teams on GLB, and only create EVERY SCENARIO, to test on.

Cmon now.


Agreed. And they don't have to test EVERY scenario. They could find something that works for more interceptions, etc. on their first few tries of "testing."
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captainsexy
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

hot girl in the OP......is that why this thread was chosen...?


I think so


Haha.

Perhaps.

It was the first response thread, though.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Well then tell me this. What happens to real GLB with the following situations.

1) 30ish trusted people are given testing privileges.

What happens? 30ish people may discover new build kinks, lets say 27 are honest enough to report bugs. We have 3 people who are gonna run off and use what they have found out with builds and try to exploit them. With how much the game changes and the tightnit testers I doubt think that 'found' exploit is going to work. If they rip an AI, no AI is a one-size-fits-all pwn to teams. Sure they could try to recreate the opposite team as mentioned in one of these threads but that would take..well..a long time to figure out, and also make an AI for them. Lots of communication happens between everyone

2) All of GLB is given rights

What happens?
GLB itself becomes an arms race to see who can get to X or Y build before it is nerfed or changed, moreso than now. More people are exploiting builds and AI and it makes the game even more complicated. Something many people were opposed to (IE why we need casual leagues). Nothing would be found out except for the times Bort sits down with people on the 2-3 occasions you need to and seriously discuss what you are testing, what the results are, and possibly how to fix it.

I am probably way off on the 2nd situation, but it just doesn't make any sense. Why does Sony give their best employees new video games systems well before release? Because they trust them enough to play it and not let it get out too heavily if at all and allow feedback on the system before its' amss release so they can be fixed quicker.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Just.

Give.

Us.

The.

Names.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by jamz

Excellent point, but so long as a select few are the only ones who get to see the changes before the season, it's a real pain in the ass for the rest o f us trying to catch up with their knowledge of what to use in the new season's game plans.

Maybe, but I don't have any clue about what goes on the test server, so I can't comment. On games where there have been public test servers, I usually check them out for about 10 minutes and get bored. Cyberdunk had/has one, where they upload the new version of the sim and let people try it out. Yeah, I never used it and still kept up just fine.

Obviously it should just be another server that people can log into and check out for themselves, but I'm /facepalming at the drama queens.


cyberdunk is a fail of a business and shouldnt be used to support any argument.

you cant really compare knowledge gained on a GLB test server to knowledge gained on a WoW test server rly, GLB is completely dependent on competition and what others know, in other games like WoW your experience isn't based 100% on the knowledge of other players

and even if someone on WoW gets information before you do, you can change your build down the road when it is public knowledge, same can't happen here
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme

Maybe, but I don't have any clue about what goes on the test server, so I can't comment. On games where there have been public test servers, I usually check them out for about 10 minutes and get bored. Cyberdunk had/has one, where they upload the new version of the sim and let people try it out. Yeah, I never used it and still kept up just fine.

Obviously it should just be another server that people can log into and check out for themselves, but I'm /facepalming at the drama queens.


It's worth pointing out that the chief difference between GLB and all other MMORPGS is that it's entirely PvP, with no PvE. Which makes things a bit different. There's no other game like it in that regard, as far as I know.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
There is a valid need for a test server that is separate from the general GLB servers. The reasoning behind this is so that the thousands of GLB players do not have to deal with the stability issues that come from introducing raw code into a live environment. The other factor is that a rather large part of the GLB experience is the exploration of builds and team dynamics. If the general GLB population had access to the raw data, and you could look up exact numbers in the Wiki, the game would loose one of its most interesting facets.

That being said, people are paying money to play the game. The people who have access to the test server, by their very nature have a competitive advantage over people who do not. It is imperative to the integrity of the game that this competitive advantage be eliminated.

As I see it there are only two ways this could be done. Either in some way open up the data so that any knowledge gained via this testing is available to everyone, or to not allow the people who are on the test server to play with the general GLB population.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Well then tell me this. What happens to real GLB with the following situations.

1) 30ish trusted people are given testing privileges.

What happens? 30ish people may discover new build kinks, lets say 27 are honest enough to report bugs. We have 3 people who are gonna run off and use what they have found out with builds and try to exploit them. With how much the game changes and the tightnit testers I doubt think that 'found' exploit is going to work. If they rip an AI, no AI is a one-size-fits-all pwn to teams. Sure they could try to recreate the opposite team as mentioned in one of these threads but that would take..well..a long time to figure out, and also make an AI for them. Lots of communication happens between everyone

2) All of GLB is given rights

What happens?
GLB itself becomes an arms race to see who can get to X or Y build before it is nerfed or changed, moreso than now. More people are exploiting builds and AI and it makes the game even more complicated. Something many people were opposed to (IE why we need casual leagues). Nothing would be found out except for the times Bort sits down with people on the 2-3 occasions you need to and seriously discuss what you are testing, what the results are, and possibly how to fix it.

I am probably way off on the 2nd situation, but it just doesn't make any sense. Why does Sony give their best employees new video games systems well before release? Because they trust them enough to play it and not let it get out too heavily if at all and allow feedback on the system before its' amss release so they can be fixed quicker.


You forget thise three people tell 10 people each, they also are not discovered for atleast 3 seasons due to lack of scrutiny because the community does not know who they are, in this time they crack all of the sim code and learn the inner workings of every thing. They never unlearn this and it spreads to the rest of the team, then to those players other teams and so on.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PS3
Originally posted by Asheme

This will turn out just like alpha testing. An insurmountable advantage that will never be over come.


Personally I think access to a test server is significantly more advantageous than alpha testing was.

Just another reason for me to not spend any more money on this game.



Yeah, wasn't alpha testing = still 48 hours between games?
Test server = unlimited?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
There is a valid need for a test server that is separate from the general GLB servers. The reasoning behind this is so that the thousands of GLB players do not have to deal with the stability issues that come from introducing raw code into a live environment. The other factor is that a rather large part of the GLB experience is the exploration of builds and team dynamics. If the general GLB population had access to the raw data, and you could look up exact numbers in the Wiki, the game would loose one of its most interesting facets.

That being said, people are paying money to play the game. The people who have access to the test server, by their very nature have a competitive advantage over people who do not. It is imperative to the integrity of the game that this competitive advantage be eliminated.

As I see it there are only two ways this could be done. Either in some way open up the data so that any knowledge gained via this testing is available to everyone, or to not allow the people who are on the test server to play with the general GLB population.


Bort posted in his final post that he plans to open up all the data.

I still think it would have been better if TPat plus a few others trusted by both the public and Bort reported on it, but he stated he will open up the data.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
cyberdunk is a fail of a business and shouldnt be used to support any argument.

you cant really compare knowledge gained on a GLB test server to knowledge gained on a WoW test server rly, GLB is completely dependent on competition and what others know, in other games like WoW your experience isn't based 100% on the knowledge of other players

and even if someone on WoW gets information before you do, you can change your build down the road when it is public knowledge, same can't happen here

Don't play WoW, and never have. Did play WAR, though, which, like GLB, is entirely PvP (well, the good parts, anyway), and all about finding builds that work.

Yes, Cyberdunk is the epitome of fail, but it's a valid comparison when talking about early exposure to new versions of the sim. The particular time I'm talking about was a drastic change to the coaching/team-management aspect of Cyberdunk that was pretty massive. And also completely ignored by me, mainly because the game sucked.

Originally posted by Capaneus
It's worth pointing out that the chief difference between GLB and all other MMORPGS is that it's entirely PvP, with no PvE. Which makes things a bit different. There's no other game like it in that regard, as far as I know.

See above. Also, Cyberdunk is the same (entirely PvP), although mind-numbingly shitty.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.