User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Veteran Abilities are...
Page:
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cactus71
Originally posted by skeets4001

Can we get a confirmation for sure hands working defensively? Since VA's seem to act a bit differently than normal abilities it would be nice to know for sure.


I'm not positive but failing a catch would be a drop and only offensive players get those that's just my opinion that it is only for offense


See that's the problem with the description, it just says, catch pass, it doesn't say anything about a drop or anything to clarify if an interception is a "caught pass".

Currently, very very unclear, should be clarified asap imo
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by skeets4001
Originally posted by Cactus71

Originally posted by skeets4001


Can we get a confirmation for sure hands working defensively? Since VA's seem to act a bit differently than normal abilities it would be nice to know for sure.


I'm not positive but failing a catch would be a drop and only offensive players get those that's just my opinion that it is only for offense


See that's the problem with the description, it just says, catch pass, it doesn't say anything about a drop or anything to clarify if an interception is a "caught pass".

Currently, very very unclear, should be clarified asap imo


How is it unclear?

If you attempt to catch the ball, and fail, you get another try.

It's super simple.
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
I hope I am not repeating a previous question, but here goes:

With the Mentor ability:

Say I have a plain old L25 linebacker, a L28 LB, a L31 LB, and a L34 LB. So they're all separated by 3 levels.

Let's say:
The L28 has 1 mentor point.
The L31 has 2 mentor points.
The L34 has 3 mentor points.

Does the L25 LB get the effects of:

- 6 mentor points, because that's the total amount of mentoring above him at his position?
- 3 mentor points, because that's the highest number of points for any individual above him at his position?, or
- Anywhere from 1-3 mentor points depending on who the game thinks is his "mentor" at any given moment?

Also, it seems you have to be on the bench (sidelines) to be a motivational speaker. Does a Mentor have to be specifically playing (on the field) for his mentoring to work?

Thanks, anyone with hard info on these questions.
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by skeets4001

Originally posted by Cactus71


Originally posted by skeets4001



Can we get a confirmation for sure hands working defensively? Since VA's seem to act a bit differently than normal abilities it would be nice to know for sure.


I'm not positive but failing a catch would be a drop and only offensive players get those that's just my opinion that it is only for offense


See that's the problem with the description, it just says, catch pass, it doesn't say anything about a drop or anything to clarify if an interception is a "caught pass".

Currently, very very unclear, should be clarified asap imo


How is it unclear?

If you attempt to catch the ball, and fail, you get another try.

It's super simple.


you moron....
once again...the question is does it work defensively, or just for recievers :/
 
Link
 
500 thank you!
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by skeets4001
Originally posted by Maddoc

Originally posted by skeets4001


Originally posted by Cactus71



Originally posted by skeets4001




Can we get a confirmation for sure hands working defensively? Since VA's seem to act a bit differently than normal abilities it would be nice to know for sure.


I'm not positive but failing a catch would be a drop and only offensive players get those that's just my opinion that it is only for offense


See that's the problem with the description, it just says, catch pass, it doesn't say anything about a drop or anything to clarify if an interception is a "caught pass".

Currently, very very unclear, should be clarified asap imo


How is it unclear?

If you attempt to catch the ball, and fail, you get another try.

It's super simple.


you moron....
once again...the question is does it work defensively, or just for recievers :/


Do defensive players attempt to catch the ball at any point? (Hell, CBs get at least one of the same SAs as WRs)
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc


Do defensive players attempt to catch the ball at any point? (Hell, CBs get at least one of the same SAs as WRs)


I understand you are trying to save face, but can I get an answer from someone who knows?
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by skeets4001
Originally posted by Maddoc



Do defensive players attempt to catch the ball at any point? (Hell, CBs get at least one of the same SAs as WRs)


I understand you are trying to save face, but can I get an answer from someone who knows?


How am I trying to save face? Players on defense make a catch attempt if they try to intercept the ball, and this can fail, I have seen it happen. There's no logical reason to believe that it would not work exactly the same for them.

Granted, the VA might work in a totally unintuitive way contrary to the simple fashion in which it's worded, but then you might as well go ahead and distrust every VA on the grounds that it doesn't work as worded.
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by skeets4001

Originally posted by Maddoc




Do defensive players attempt to catch the ball at any point? (Hell, CBs get at least one of the same SAs as WRs)


I understand you are trying to save face, but can I get an answer from someone who knows?


How am I trying to save face? Players on defense make a catch attempt if they try to intercept the ball, and this can fail, I have seen it happen. There's no logical reason to believe that it would not work exactly the same for them.

Granted, the VA might work in a totally unintuitive way contrary to the simple fashion in which it's worded, but then you might as well go ahead and distrust every VA on the grounds that it doesn't work as worded.


but in Bort terms, the wording "pass catch attempt" may be enough in his mind to make it clear that it DOESN'T work defensively. We know that catch works differently on defense than it does on offense, so how can you be so sure that defensively it isn't "interception catch attempt" instead of the "pass catch attempt" because they work on different percentages to begin with . I don't think it's as cut and dried as you assume.
Last edited Dec 27, 2008 14:21:58
 
HULK
offline
Link
 
Skeets, you are really ruining this thread. Please stop.
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HULK
Skeets, you are really ruining this thread. Please stop.


not really, unless this thread is meant for butterflies and dandelions.

It's a thread about VA's and it is meant to help people understand them. There has yet to be an answer on this, so I am doing everyone a favor of ensuring there is one.

You are welcome.
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
and now I got my answer,

Originally posted by Bort
no - failing a catch is not the same as failing an interception. You're hoping to stretch the definition

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1724050&page=last#14085227

I'm sure this will be useful to many people who were unsure, so it's a good thing I asked
 
SoCold
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
um while the op is great, do we really need a thread stickied that's filled with this kind of arguing?


my god you have a soft throat!
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
Any input on the Mentor skill?

Secondarily: The Motivational Speaker skill specifies only 1 can activate at a time.

Does that mean if you have 6 of them, it is 6 times more likely to activate? Or is it always "on"?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BellyCheck

Does that mean if you have 6 of them, it is 6 times more likely to activate? Or is it always "on"?


It will NEVER have 100% chance to activate...but having multiple players with it will increase the chance.
Last edited Dec 27, 2008 16:35:31
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.