User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Builds can compensate for the problem. Although, it's just a band-aid fix... eventually things will swing totally out of control in the opposite direction, unless changes are made.

I could be wrong and all that, but I have over 8 years of playing MMOs and am quite good at noticing trends. Hopefully I'm wrong, but I foresee cries by DEs next season or the season after that (barring any changes are made).
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 16:58:43
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Look at the interaction between RDE and LT here, it's absurd...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213395&pbp_id=2162786


That LT has about 80 strength, 60 agility, 70 blocking, 35 speed, 35 confidence, vision, etc.

The way the RDE seems to like push him back with brute strength (LT looks pancaked), even tho Speed DEs are all built with hardly any strength, and just the overall speed at which these ends can fly around the pocket is unlifelike. In real life, the best DEs would reach the QB in about 3-4 seconds. It's been timed that that is roughly the time it takes for a DE to fly right around the edge unhindered.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 18:09:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Look at the interaction between RDE and LT here, it's absurd...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213395&pbp_id=2162786


haha that is ridiculous
RE gets shoved about 5 yards and it actually helps him get to the QB faster
 
commando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Look at the interaction between RDE and LT here, it's absurd...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213395&pbp_id=2162786




lol...that RDE hurried the passer and was already 15 yards down the field when the WR caught the ball. he is blazing fast.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by commando
Originally posted by GG

Look at the interaction between RDE and LT here, it's absurd...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213395&pbp_id=2162786




lol...that RDE hurried the passer and was already 15 yards down the field when the WR caught the ball. he is blazing fast.


Laws of physics being defied. Almost in two places at the same time.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Actually both the blitzing CB and DE are able to be 15 yards downfield in a split second after the QB passes the ball, even tho there are three blockers still obstructing their path.

Last edited Nov 15, 2008 18:22:46
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Look at the interaction between RDE and LT here, it's absurd...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213395&pbp_id=2162786


That LT has about 80 strength, 60 agility, 70 blocking, 35 speed, 35 confidence, vision, etc.

The way the RDE seems to like push him back with brute strength (LT looks pancaked), even tho Speed DEs are all built with hardly any strength, and just the overall speed at which these ends can fly around the pocket is unlifelike. In real life, the best DEs would reach the QB in about 3-4 seconds. It's been timed that that is roughly the time it takes for a DE to fly right around the edge unhindered.


That's not quite true, they ran tests on "sports science" and the DE they had, was hitting the QB in about 2.5 secs, unhindered. When they moved the pylon over six inches, the QB could just get the ball away before getting hit (increasing the time to just under 3 secs).

This is the primary argument I was making, if the OT gets a little push on the DE (even just an arm push), it will throw the DE's angle off, sometimes just enough to prevent the sack. Those plays IRL football, where the DE gets low and underneath the OT's block (allowing him to basically run right around the OT), happen pretty rare.

Most DE sacks come from good moves and/or good coverage by the secondary. Every so often they just manhandle the OT and sack the QB before he can even finish his drop.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
True.

Well, that pylon moving over six inches = an OT moving back to establish a pocket.
In pretty much all DE sacks that occur on GLB, the DE is flying right around the edge. I dont think ive ever seen an RDE make a move on the inside for a sack.
The DE getting a sack around the edge should take 3 seconds bare minimum, and with an OT providing some engagement, a sack should occur 4-6 seconds---if the QB holds onto the ball.

All this regardless of player build is what should be established as a norm or standard. Where good DEs mismatched against bad OTs will make a "3 sec sack" (a couple times a game tops), while the mediocer DEs should either not get a sack or maybe 1 if the QB holds onto the ball forever allowing a DE to eventually get there in about 7 seconds.

Last edited Nov 15, 2008 18:55:45
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
True.

Well, that pylon moving over six inches = an OT moving back to establish a pocket.
In pretty much all DE sacks that occur on GLB, the DE is flying right around the edge. I dont think ive ever seen an RDE make a move on the inside for a sack.
The DE getting a sack around the edge should take 3 seconds bare minimum, and with an OT providing some engagement, a sack should occur 4-6 seconds---if the QB holds onto the ball.



Trust me, I agree. I want to see pathing improved and DE/OTs engaging. Once they engage, it's time for the dice to determine the winner, based on who has the better build and/or luck. A single roll shouldn't make or break a play... like I believe is currently happening. The OT fails his vision roll and bam sack by fast DE, giving the QB no chance to even finish his drop back (let alone try and throw a pass).
 
GG
offline
Link
 
At the same time, hurries should be more prevalent, as a lot of the time QBs release the ball around about 4 seconds and around that time protection has begun to break allowing some pressure on the QB in his face and/or around the edge.

Meanwhile, every now and then you should also get the OL pwning the DL for those 7+ sec protections, where the QB just stands there all day able to find an open receiver.

Imo the right balance would be something like...

In every 10 plays, 1 would be a sack, 3 would be the OL pwning, and 6 would be that 4 second drop back and throw where there's hurries and pressure, but just not sacks.

And of those 6 plays, probably 3/6 would be completions and 3/6 incompletions...ie, coupled with the 3 pwned plays as well, it would all amount to about 65% completion rate. {6 completions, 1 sack, and 3 incompletes or INTS}

Those sorts of numbers should be roughly aimed for as set in stone inside the game regardless of builds. And then when you factor in builds, big mismatches, you would key in only a slight variance up or down on that. Things like 40-50% completions, maybe 2/10 sacks. Or at the other end of the scale...80-90% completion and 0 sacks.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 19:12:02
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mbking
here is list of my league it has been fixed too much other way. one way to fix is vision strength, vision agility. what this would do is who ever had higher would more likely engage in that if i have a better vision strength than the de has vision agility then strength is used. but if my de has more strength and this happens gets around.







this is my idea have an engaging ability if you engage physical(strength or the evasive (agility)but what would happen is it would role who engages and how high points=higher chance of engaging at that skill. The downside is if you engage me and when engage check but i have more points in the area you engaged in I get around quicker than normal.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by SAGA45

Here's a couple plays of my OT(LvL 33 at the time of these replays) getting beat by a LvL 36 speed DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419932
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419862

Here are the rest of the pass plays in that same game where my OT faced the same DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419744
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419802
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419809
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419879
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419978
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419982
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420022
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420040
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420048
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420072
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420095
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420101

As you can see, outside of the 1 play where the DE just blew by my OT for the sack, none were plays where the two didn't engage.

Also, my OT did a solid job of keeping the DE at bay when facing him 1-on-1 with no help from a RB.

You always see my OT getting back, set quickly, and then engage the DE - keeping him at bay except for the two sacks. But even on one of those the DE had to work for it by shedding my OT's block first.

Again, this was against a speed DE who was 3 levels higher. Some good, realistic battles to. Probably the result of a couple of good builds going at it.


If possible, I'd like to get Bort's thoughts on what's likely happening under the hood on these replays as far as the math and interaction between my OT and the DE. I doubt Bort responds but I'm just curious, especially since that DE was one of the 100+ sack guys in season 5 that prompted the code adjustments.


 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eastcoastbrian
This isn't just the training "guide", it's "free" points you get at OT for leveling and the specific combination set by the guys who develop the game for intense training.

If an OT gets "0" in speed for leveling up & Pass Block in Advanced training is Block and Agility then it seems to me needing speed to pass block is a Bug, which is what this thread is about.

Seems to me a waste that folks have to spend points in areas that should not be relevant. I mean if an OT gets +.5 to tackle and +0 to speed on a level up...that tells me speed should be as useful as throwing to an OT.

Hence need for speed = BUG!


While I agree with your logic and your analysis, you're not including one key thing.

The Protect SA.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
yeah, if speed is important for pass blocking, I really don't understand why it was not included as a minor attribute while tackling (a waste) was.
 
Jarl
offline
Link
 
Being a football coach myself, an oline coach even.

All I can say is, its not working, there are several "problems" that unite to cause this situation.

-Unrealistic fast DE
Should a Defensive End with 90 speed be as fast as a receiver with 90 speed?

The very first play features a sack in 1.2 seconds, now from the Tackle to the Center, there will usually be 5-7 yards, depending on splits and size of the linemen.
Usually, your Tackles will line up 1-1½ yard away from the LOS, they can line up like this as long as their head is infront of the Centers hips.
That means the DE will have to travel atleast 6 yards, including a turn.

Now, even the fastest DE´s have a Ten Yard Split(How fast they run ten yards) of approx 1.45 seconds.
Thats without a turn of anykind.

So I find it highly unreal that a DE can reach the QB in less than that time.

-Unreasonably slow Tackles.

The notion that speed matters for a Tackle Pass Protecting is downright ridiculous, Tackle pass pro is a matter of technique, and nothing else.
He will start taking back steps(slide steps, etc etc) at the snap, waiting for the DE to either try to engage, try running around, or try going inside.
Once the DE has commited, the LT will engage him.

In this game however, it looks more like the LT is trying to backpedal or something, and that the DE is just beating him around the corner, in real life, that practically never happens, and definately not that fast.

In real life, the Tackle would have turned his hips and once the DE tries running around him, he would engage, and push him, by doing this, the DE will get deeper, and the QB can step up in the pocket.
In the first play, we have a 263 pounds DE against a 310 LT, by reasoning, we can easily figure that the tackle most likely has around 80+ strength, and the DE propably has 50-60 strenght.

What would happen IRL, would be this.

The tackle gets his hands on the DE and pushes, the DE being fairly light, and not very strong would get pushed off and would have to find his footing to try to get back into the game.

Or

The DE gets far enough past him, for the OT to not be able to get his hands on him properly, the OT would try to drive him around the QB.
Here the DE can try different moves to move "through" and sack the QB.

There is no speed involved from the OT, there is some agility, but most of it is basic movement and OT technique.

The last, and most important problem, imo atleast

These DE´s should be manhandled in the run game, a 310 tackle with 80 + str 60-70 blocking and solid agility vs a 263 DE with 50-60 str? complete ownage, there is no way that DE should have a chance of standing his ground against that OT in the run game.

Another way to fix this, would be to change Cut Block so it actually worked the way a Cut Block works.

As a Oline Coach, and as a RB myself, I know one thing.
Players who run full steam ahead like that, are the easiest in the world to Cut Block, even if they are incredibly agile, they come so hard and fast, that they have 0 chance to avoid the Cut Block, especially if its done decently.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 13:10:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.