User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > "I love you Grandma." "I love you too. Let's $%!#."
Page:
 
Venkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
but...but...your opinion matters so much to me...



Sorry I am not going to reinforce your world view and that it upsets you.


it has nothing to do with reinforcing a fucking world view, and everything to do with the way you 'debate'.
simply put, it's shit, for precisely the reasons that oppco wrote above and have been pointed out to you in the past.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

Foo, many of us might disagree with Cat's assertion; however, the way you went about attacking it --- is simply confusing at best.

If you no longer care why he thinks the way he does --- what is the point in responding to it? Nothing of value comes from conversations where at least one party does not care why the other says what it says --- it breaks down into garbage --- very quickly.


I wanted to know who the rapist was in his view. Simple as that. I asked it multiple times. I knew the rest of the story because I have heard other liberals make the same claim, so there was no need to rehash it.


Except you acknowledge Cat is a progressive --- not a liberal in other threads. Going so far as to create a thread trying to get more info on the difference as has been noted to you over and over again. However, you continue to use the same term --- regardless of its applicability? That is not very honest!!!

Then you generalize as to what others have said --- knowing it is not what he has said; however, that is of zero importance to you --- as the group you knowingly and wrongly lumped him in with --- members have issued statements on this? That is sinking to the levels of the oblivious (specific reference).
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seths99
Originally posted by foofighter24

but...but...your opinion matters so much to me...



Sorry I am not going to reinforce your world view and that it upsets you.


it has nothing to do with reinforcing a fucking world view, and everything to do with the way you 'debate'.
simply put, it's shit, for precisely the reasons that oppco wrote above and have been pointed out to you in the past.


Again, I don't play by high school debate club rules. I am not going to follow someone's script when I have already seen this script play out numerous times. The only thing I did not know was who he considered to be the rapist, which is why I asked.

At some point, it was gonna come back to "Why do you hate the vicim?", and if you don't see that, I am sorry.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.

 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by seths99

Originally posted by foofighter24


but...but...your opinion matters so much to me...



Sorry I am not going to reinforce your world view and that it upsets you.


it has nothing to do with reinforcing a fucking world view, and everything to do with the way you 'debate'.
simply put, it's shit, for precisely the reasons that oppco wrote above and have been pointed out to you in the past.


Again, I don't play by high school debate club rules. I am not going to follow someone's script when I have already seen this script play out numerous times. The only thing I did not know was who he considered to be the rapist, which is why I asked.

At some point, it was gonna come back to "Why do you hate the vicim?", and if you don't see that, I am sorry.


It is certainly not about debating rules; rather, it is about understanding the opposing view points before you proceed. A key step that is constantly missed.

I certainly did not see that line of reasoning coming --- and I feel like I have a somewhat decent understanding of Cat's logic.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by foofighter24

How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.



I do not disagree --- which, is why that question had to be asked --- it was avoided over and over. That was the larger issue.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by foofighter24

Originally posted by oppco80


Foo, many of us might disagree with Cat's assertion; however, the way you went about attacking it --- is simply confusing at best.

If you no longer care why he thinks the way he does --- what is the point in responding to it? Nothing of value comes from conversations where at least one party does not care why the other says what it says --- it breaks down into garbage --- very quickly.


I wanted to know who the rapist was in his view. Simple as that. I asked it multiple times. I knew the rest of the story because I have heard other liberals make the same claim, so there was no need to rehash it.


Except you acknowledge Cat is a progressive --- not a liberal in other threads. Going so far as to create a thread trying to get more info on the difference as has been noted to you over and over again. However, you continue to use the same term --- regardless of its applicability? That is not very honest!!!

Then you generalize as to what others have said --- knowing it is not what he has said; however, that is of zero importance to you --- as the group you knowingly and wrongly lumped him in with --- members have issued statements on this? That is sinking to the levels of the oblivious (specific reference).


Liberals and progressives are the same thing. They burn out one label and move to the other. I have no problem referring to Cat as a progressive. I have heard the same argument from people who self-define as each. Wait a few years, and they will change how they define themselves, it isn't a big deal.

I never claimed to not generalize about what others have said. It is still the same basic formula. Generalizing is not always a bad thing.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Originally posted by foofighter24


How do you think an innocent woman who was violently raped would feel about you comparing her situation to a woman who offers a handjob to someone for money?


This sums it up right here. Rape is rape and prostitution is prostitution. Conflating the 2 mirepresents prostitution and cheapens the term rape.



I do not disagree --- which, is why that question had to be asked --- it was avoided over and over. That was the larger issue.


It is the larger issue, but it also falls right in line with all Cat's other beliefs. I am surprised you are surprised by his stance.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


Really, because there used to be alot of self-defined liberals, and now those exact same people refer to themselves as progressives. Cat will swear up and down that Barrack Obama is not a liberal, but look up liberals on his beloved source, Wikipedia, and tell me what you see.

Liberals run from that label now, but it was once a source of pride. This is not the first time "progressive" has been a popular term for that same group, either.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927

 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by oppco80

They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


Really, because there used to be alot of self-defined liberals, and now those exact same people refer to themselves as progressives. Cat will swear up and down that Barrack Obama is not a liberal, but look up liberals on his beloved source, Wikipedia, and tell me what you see.

Liberals run from that label now, but it was once a source of pride. This is not the first time "progressive" has been a popular term for that same group, either.


I do not put any stock in Wiki and Cat has stated over and over it is simply a jumping off point. Not the end source ---

The two sets may have similar goals (in part); however, there process by which they seek to accomplish their goals is vastly different. The process is what hangs many up ---
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003
Originally posted by oppco80

They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



That is hardly symbolic of the entire left. Additionally, many do not really understand where they sit and where they stand in relation to others --- which, is hardly surprising as well.
 
pkrplyr2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Originally posted by pkrplyr2003

Originally posted by oppco80


They are not the same thing --- that is dishonest at best to refer to them as such.

Generalizing can often lead you to mistaken understanding --- as it did not last.


The American left also conflates the 2 terms. Here is evidence right here on this forum.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3964871&page=1#35384927



And that is incorrect as well.


I am just saying to get upset with Foo for not knowing the difference between the 2 groups when said members of the groups cannot distinguish themselves from each other.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.