User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
D~Town
offline
Link
 
If I have to have a coach. Give me an Inactive one.
But don't force feed me, If I want it I will buy it.

________________________
Wambulance Academy EMT's
 
kdunkin
offline
Link
 
i hate the coach idea
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kdunkin
i hate the coach idea


 
czman
offline
Link
 
I do not hate the idea of coaches but I hate this idea.

there has to be a better way of doing this.
 
seorang
offline
Link
 
Will coaches be able to move between teams? Will they also have contracts?

I've got S1 and S2 players, and I'd rather not have coaches. That said, I might have to do that for my teams to stay competitive, even if I don't like it.

Right now, the idea is just too raw for me to agree with it.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
I have two ideas about how coaches could be implemented.

1) You retire a player and the player becomes a coach. Charge what you see fit.
The coach gives points to the part of the team he affects.

Head coach—entire team
OC—offense only
DC—Defense only
ST—Special team only
Position coaches—players of that position when they are playing that position. So WRs at the TE position do not get any gains or position players on ST. The position coaches have to be players of that position. A player can fill any role once they are a coach as long as their position allows it. Offensive players can only be OC, HC, or their position. Defensive, DC, HC, their position.

The gains are determined by the build of the retired player.
An attribute at the 2nd cap gives a bonus of .1
3rd cap .2
4th cap .3
5th cap .4
6th cap .5
Any SA over can give a bonus +1 to the attribute.
It is based off of naturals not gear. For a game only 3 attribute/SA bonuses can be active at a time. This allows coaches to make choices about what they want active at any time.

You could even add a bonus based on coach status. The position coaches could add a +1 to any attribute. The coordinators could get a +2 bonus points but have to spend them on different attributes. The HC could get 3 bonus points and only be able to add a maximum of 2 to any one attribute.

Idea 2:
Coaches are not based on builds.
Position coaches get to add a +1 attribute and 1 SA for their position per game.
Coordinators get to add 5 attribute points and 2 SAs but the SAs have to be different and no an attribute can only be taken to +2.
HC can add +7 and 3 SAs. No attribute can be taken over +2 and the SAs have to be different.


Works with either idea.

Coaches get VAs, or whatever you want to call them. They would be specific for the position they are filling. They are not set in stone and can be changed each game.

The bonus to both of these ideas is making a coach first does not give a clear advantage to anyone. Avoiding a system where the first group that does it getting a huge advantage is very important for keeping balance.
 
D~Town
offline
Link
 
Just make the ones you wanted to make Coaches. Make them Mentors. That way they are assured to stay in the Pro, AAA and World leagues.



________________________
Wambulance Academy EMT's
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Maddoc

Personally I think that a retired player ought to be given the option to convert into three (plus whatever weird shit like Scouting coaches) styles of coaches. These should all cost the same FP, for reasons forthcoming.

Using the general template from the OP, they would be as follows.

Head Coach would give a bonus to every player on the team.

Offense/Defense Coach would give a bonus to Offensive or Defensive positions, respectively. (For sake of simplicity, this would work even during Special Teams, and Kicker would fall under the Offense coach, and Punter under the Defense coach)

And Positional Coach, the player would be able to convert into a specialized coach for the position they were prior to retirement, which they are most familiar with.

No No No, for the reasons I just stated. Coaching positions should be decided by the team, not the coach.


You'll find that I care far more about good game balance than "real life football sensibility", so your "suggestion" or lack thereof beyond "that's not how it works in real life" is of little interest.
 
Link
 
Coaches = $ for Bort. Nothing more.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
The more I read alternate views of how coaching *could* work, regardless of how sane and well-meaning those alternatives might be, the more I realize how value-less the whole concept is.

The coaching concept was first raised by those concerned about decline and they wanted dots to continue after decline, etc, add a new dimension to the game. That's fine, lots of ideas get thrown around.

The concept was embraced by Bort for quite understandable reasons - its a big "cool" new thing he thought he could add that has the added benefit of reducing the flex hit caused by retirements. He's running a business and the idea seemed solid and lots of people chimed in with suggestions - seemingly great stuff that adds a whole new dimension to the game, blah blah blah.

But in practice, in a game driven by attributes and RNGs and the ability of agents to build players, and the ability of teams to recruit and gameplan, the concept of coaches as another part of the mix doesn't make sense. Teams already have coaches - they are the humans who control the players, determining how SP are allocated and what to train. And they are the humans who do the gameplanning, who scout the opposition and set direction for the team.

Adding dots that influence this as well makes no sense.

Coaching as a way to boost attributes for chosen players or group of players will simply become a tit-for-tat game where benefits will cancel each other out. And enabling some coaches to actually negate the attributes of opposing players sounds ok until you consider that paying human customers paid to get those attributes where they are - do you really think those attributes should be negated because an opposing coach waves some pixie dust around?

Equipment crafting? Seriously? If the store had some semblence of logic behind it, this wouldn't be necessary, and would still create some fun combinations for players to try.

As someone else noted early in this debate, all coaching is going to do is force everyone to stock up on coaches to get the same bonuses and magic pixie dust that every other team has. What's the point of that other than increasing the amount of admin and mindless attribute clicking that owners and agents must perform.

.I've yet to see one iota of fun or gameplay improvement that will be added by coaching.

It sounds fine as a concept - the people who support it can't be faulted really because it all seems reasonable in theory. But in practice, its nothing but work and complication that won't really make the game any more fun or make the dots behave in a more realistic fashion.
 
soulcrshr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
The more I read alternate views of how coaching *could* work, regardless of how sane and well-meaning those alternatives might be, the more I realize how value-less the whole concept is.

The coaching concept was first raised by those concerned about decline and they wanted dots to continue after decline, etc, add a new dimension to the game. That's fine, lots of ideas get thrown around.

The concept was embraced by Bort for quite understandable reasons - its a big "cool" new thing he thought he could add that has the added benefit of reducing the flex hit caused by retirements. He's running a business and the idea seemed solid and lots of people chimed in with suggestions - seemingly great stuff that adds a whole new dimension to the game, blah blah blah.

But in practice, in a game driven by attributes and RNGs and the ability of agents to build players, and the ability of teams to recruit and gameplan, the concept of coaches as another part of the mix doesn't make sense. Teams already have coaches - they are the humans who control the players, determining how SP are allocated and what to train. And they are the humans who do the gameplanning, who scout the opposition and set direction for the team.

Adding dots that influence this as well makes no sense.

Coaching as a way to boost attributes for chosen players or group of players will simply become a tit-for-tat game where benefits will cancel each other out. And enabling some coaches to actually negate the attributes of opposing players sounds ok until you consider that paying human customers paid to get those attributes where they are - do you really think those attributes should be negated because an opposing coach waves some pixie dust around?

Equipment crafting? Seriously? If the store had some semblence of logic behind it, this wouldn't be necessary, and would still create some fun combinations for players to try.

As someone else noted early in this debate, all coaching is going to do is force everyone to stock up on coaches to get the same bonuses and magic pixie dust that every other team has. What's the point of that other than increasing the amount of admin and mindless attribute clicking that owners and agents must perform.

.I've yet to see one iota of fun or gameplay improvement that will be added by coaching.

It sounds fine as a concept - the people who support it can't be faulted really because it all seems reasonable in theory. But in practice, its nothing but work and complication that won't really make the game any more fun or make the dots behave in a more realistic fashion.


amen, preach on preacher man. preach on. maybe to deaf ears up in the higher ranks of glb, but +1000000000000
 
soulcrshr
offline
Link
 
And the biggest cool thing bort can do for this game is fix the SIM first. The sim is the core of the game. not va, not coaches, not sideshow bob and his bearded lady girlfriend, the fucking sim is what needs to be priority 1. MY god season 11 is almost over and still no 4 wr sets. thats basic football. the bugs are insane, blocking is retarded. but they ignore these issues with these huge additions that are really subtractions if you sit and think about a minute.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 

===
I'd also like to see about 20 other things done to the game before coaches go in, but at this point it looks like Bort has them well under way and coaches are coming like it or not. Given that assumption here's what I think should happen with coaches...
===


What could really work, is changing the whole coaching process from what has been suggested so far.

Instead of going through the whole retirement and re-creation process. Just make coaches additional slots on the team roster and depth chart.

Separate retirement from coaching, and the system makes much more sense. Coaching could be an alternative to retirement for those at that age. An aged vet can still continue to contribute to a team; he can play through his decline, or he could stay off the field, in a coaching slot.

I'm thinking something along the lines of a natural extension of the Mentor VA.

===
Other players sometimes make the best coaches. Each level of Mentor gives a +1% in-game bonus to vision and confidence for all lower-leveled teammates who play the same position and were created at least 1 season after this player, to the day, as long as the player is on the depth chart for the game. This ability stacks with other mentors on the team, up to a maximum of 25% bonus per position.
===


I'm thinking this kind of mechanic would be much less game breaking, compared to what we already have.

By turning Coaches into depth chart slots, it sidesteps a whole bunch of issues. In theory any player could be a coach. The catch would be the coach wouldn't be able to play in the game.

The coach would give bonuses based on his own attributes (somehow) like maybe based on his scouting bars or something like that. The better the coach-slot player, the higher the bonus to his "squad" or whatever you want to call it.

There could be overall coaches (head coaches and maybe an assistant or 2) but most coaches would be position coaches i.e. o-line coach, QB coach, WR coach, LB coach and so on.

Coaches slots would have to be given special consideration to get around roster size limits, and this approach might allow for some flexibility in the level caps for each league, like teams may sign players over their level cap, but they can only go on the depth chart in coach slots.

I think that salaries could be the limiting factor... like a L13 cap team probably wouldn't be able to afford the salaries of 15 max level coaches, but this also might require some tweaking of team funds a little to make it somewhat workable.

This coaching idea also gets around the need to create special coaching items, as players would continue to do their upgrades the normal way to improve their bonuses granted to players.

Then retirement would go the same as always planned. Maybe have a HoF or whatever, and all costs would be normal (70/30 and new players), and would have nothing to do with coaches. Decline would work the same for everyone, as has been laid out before. That would prevent 200 year old coaches.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
I have to agree with TJ. The Mentor VA is a perfect example of how coaches should work.

OC & DC set the game plan, the coaches help players prepare for the games.
 
43Hitman
offline
Link
 
GLB's version of health care tbh. Bad idea, more trouble than it's worth, milks more money out of our pockets for nothing more than fluff.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.