User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
VegasABD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by Pariah

Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla


Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN



I still believe it is not for the best and people truly do not know what is best for them.
I think that's how slavery started.



I was going to point out how dangerous this statement is.

Voting is the best system and the results are clear.


No. Do you have any idea how fucked up our country would be if the general population got to vote on laws? There is a reason why we vote for competent people to make our decisions for us and have their own small vote. Most people don't truly understand most issues at hand.

For instance, I did my own little poll in different Pro regions only among Pro team owners. USA Pro and SAPL both were around 50/50 on whether they want the world league. Other regions like EEPL, APL, ect were overwhelmingly in favor of the World pro league (we are talking 95%+), with one of the favorite themes of posters that it'd even out the talent and get rid of the USA Pro bias, since teams will want to go to other leagues to have a shot at the WPL.

The reality though, is teams in their final season or 2 want to go to the best league possible and the best team possible to compete for a championship. You've already begun to see it in free agents this season who say (WPL, USAPL, or CPL only)... They think that the chance to promote to the WPL will get them more pull with free agents.

THE REALITY is that those free agents don't want to waste one of their final seasons just attempting to get into a league they want to be in, and in reality by forming the WPL you are making EEP, OP, AP, ect into 3rd rate leagues instead of 2nd rate leagues, and a lot of them are going to be fucked when retirement comes and have to gut as a result.

Imo of course...


You just said 95% of people voted in favor of something, yet you spin the "reality" of what you feel.....I as an owner voted yes to your poll that I wanted WPL, not for your reality but for what I voted yes on....So don't spin my vote around.
Vegas
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by lukin83


If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.


100% right on.




Look you just demote randomly. Whoever stays stays. This will close the gap a TON. I mean say MEM misses the playoffs and goes to OPL? They can probably win their way back up right? By complaining that random demotion breaks up teams, you aren't thinking out the possibilities.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Fuck, bort always leaves threads when I post. My page 30 post is gold imo..

Bort, if you see this, a much more pressing slam dunk issue than this stupid Pro talk, minor league caps really need to continue and be staggered up to at least LVL 45-50. The current diversity in uncapped minor leagues is simply retarded... I mean, ffs my buddies team with a LVL 40 average played a team with a LVL 60 average in the conference championship game...


Indeed you raise a lot of good points in that post that I have to agree with a lot of what you say there.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HULK
FWIW, I think I favor random demotion.



I actually think "random" is a little too random in such a small sample size. I also like the ability to retain league identity and the forum smack-talk that comes with it.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN

Fuck, bort always leaves threads when I post. My page 30 post is gold imo..

Bort, if you see this, a much more pressing slam dunk issue than this stupid Pro talk, minor league caps really need to continue and be staggered up to at least LVL 45-50. The current diversity in uncapped minor leagues is simply retarded... I mean, ffs my buddies team with a LVL 40 average played a team with a LVL 60 average in the conference championship game...


Bort's not gone, theres just a buttfuck ton of reading for him to do ITT. Before he can respond. If he skips posts, he might miss a valid solution


Good to know buddy. Btw bort, whitelist me too. k thx.
 
HULK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by HULK

FWIW, I think I favor random demotion.



I actually think "random" is a little too random in such a small sample size. I also like the ability to retain league identity and the forum smack-talk that comes with it.


If you let people choose, I don't think you'll ever quite get the situation with all the top teams at the top, which imo, should be the goal.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
I want to explain why random is best but no one is going to listen to me. I need a seperate thread tbh.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83


If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.


Everyone would have equal access to get into the league each season and an equal opportunity to stay once they've arrived. I don't see how the divisional system changes/improves that. I asked a few pages back, but it was skipped over.


Doing it that way does not allow for parity across GLB and results in USAPL remaining the top league in the game (outside of the WL). How does doing it any other way promote parity throughout the game and also allow teams to keep their regional affiliations? Those seem to be the biggest two issues with the WL (along with the number of teams permitted from each region).


Doing it the that way (?? non-playoff teams demote) doesn't allow for parity and keep the USAPL as the top non-WL league? I think I may be missing what you are saying.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83


If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.


Everyone would have equal access to get into the league each season and an equal opportunity to stay once they've arrived. I don't see how the divisional system changes/improves that. I asked a few pages back, but it was skipped over.


Doing it that way does not allow for parity across GLB and results in USAPL remaining the top league in the game (outside of the WL). How does doing it any other way promote parity throughout the game and also allow teams to keep their regional affiliations? Those seem to be the biggest two issues with the WL (along with the number of teams permitted from each region).


You reeeeeally don't get it, do you?

The parity you are talking about will happen by virtue of the mere existence of a World Pro League. Your plan for that league does not do anything to galvanize it.
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gabrosin

Bort... no comment on divisions? Or maybe I missed it? Or maybe you're implementing it right now? C'mon, throw a little CSS together, add a database field, we're good to go! Problem solved!


I dunno if I like divisions. It's more NFL-y, but NFL scheduling is kinda confusing if you're not familiar with how it works.

If we do a set number of teams from each region it makes it easy to deal with, but we aren't ensured the best of the best year in and year out, which I see as a desirable feature of the world league.

I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


Well, that's why I listed NFL-style scheduling as purely an option. You can implement divisions and still have the current scheduling system. Personally, I don't like that every single playoff matchup in a conference is a guaranteed rematch from the season, and that you never play cross-conference in a meaningful game unless it's the league title... but whatever, that's an optional part of the idea.

Bort, you've GOT to trust that the best of the best players will be clawing and fighting for WPL spots regardless of which teams hold them, and the best of the best teams will find their way up with time. If a USA Pro team thinks the competition for USA Pro WPL spots is too fierce, they can man up and work harder, or find a team to switch Pro leagues with them.

If you want something to vote on, make it real simple:

Should teams demoted from the WPL be sent back to the league they came from, or reassigned randomly?

Yes
No

THAT will get you your answer... beyond that, it's all trivial details, like how many teams stay and how many go each season.

I guarantee that any scheme which randomizes demotions will have a negative effect on one of the most compelling aspects of this game: rivalry. It's already difficult to build a good rivalry with another team, since you're likely to get promoted at different teams. But the Pros are the most stable of all leagues, and some awesome rivalries have developed there. You'd be skimming the cream of the crop every season, the STRONGEST of all rivals, and replacing them with essentially random teams, teams with no history in the region. If you allow teams to retain their league identity in the WPL, you encourage the cross-league rivalries that have sprung up over the seasons (like CPL vs. SAPL). Honestly... would the Kai belong in Eastern Europe? Would the Legionnaires belong in Southeast Asia? Do you gain anything by seeding the WPL with a dozen USA Pro teams and then randomly demoting them into other regions after S11? It makes no sense.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


This has got to be the best and simplest option.

Second option - the two participants from each region who are in the WPL play the top 2 from that region's Pro league at the end of the season in a 'winner takes all' playoff - winners go to WPL, losers go back to Pros.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SheVegas

You just said 95% of people voted in favor of something, yet you spin the "reality" of what you feel.....I as an owner voted yes to your poll that I wanted WPL, not for your reality but for what I voted yes on....So don't spin my vote around.
Vegas


My appologies Vegas. i did not have you guys vote for me to spin it, but tbqh bort made a better poll than mine, so me objectively showing my results is no longer important.

Rather, I choose to take my time to interpret the results as I see them, and how I feel the WPL will work out. Think about it, 2 days ago the WPL was widely accepted by high LVL FA's as a certain reality. Yet, not one person has posted saying "WPL, OPL, OPL, EEPL, WEPL only". Players still want to go to WPL/CPL/USAPL, and some stupid world league is only gonna make those other pro leagues fucked even more since they won't have a single top team to draw the FA's and regional pride...
 
Link
 
Edited by Dirtmcgirt66 on Jul 27, 2009 21:00:27
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by lukin83



If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.


100% right on.




Look you just demote randomly. Whoever stays stays. This will close the gap a TON. I mean say MEM misses the playoffs and goes to OPL? They can probably win their way back up right? By complaining that random demotion breaks up teams, you aren't thinking out the possibilities.


Random demotion is fine accept that so many are against losing league affiliations. Personally, I am against it. If my team is from Cincinnati, I want to stay in USA. If my team is from Ghana, I want to stay in Africa. That is why I am opposed to losing league affiliations.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
season 11...

conf. playoff champion and conf. regular season champion promote for each pro conference. if a team is one and the same, then take the conf. 2nd seed.

that means 4 USA, 4 CPL, 4 OPL, etc.

non playoff teams in WPL go back where they came from. every pro league gets at least two teams there every season, while theoretically you could have 18 teams from one pro league there

to promote after that, promote the pro league gold trophy champions and the top regular season team. if those are one and the same, promote the 2nd best regular season record

16 games determine the best teams better than a 1 game situation. someone told me teams don't gameplan hard for the regular season, well maybe if there was more importance to it, they'd gameplan more

if extra spots open up due to guts, use some type of GLB BCS ranking system or have bort handpick new teams

i'm a college football fan by the way
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.