User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Sounds good in theory, got a link to a high agility guy and care to play him against an equal level team I GM?

I'm not giving away build information just to satisfy your curiosity. If you don't want to believe me, I understand, but I'm telling you that I do know such players who have had high level (as in AA-AAA, but not Pro, as I've never been in a Pro league) success.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
The problem with that, is Agility isn't just Agility and Speed isn't just Speed.

High Agility WRs don't work for the same reasons that high Agility RBs don't work.

There is always going to be a better ratio of Speed/Agility, with higher Speed.

The main reason being, is that there are SAs that can help with quick acceleration and cutting, but none for top end Speed.

My WR accelerates just fine, with much higher Speed than Agility
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 9, 2009 23:32:20
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 9, 2009 23:28:46
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
I've seen some good WRs from Fanaticsfins54. Don Henley and Marley Bob always performed well and i remember some plays from earlier this season (haven't watched them lately) where they juked a ton of people out. One of them made a dot blink from a jukefake after the nerf but was tackled by someone else.

I've seen some WRs have success with higher strength and breaking some tackles. We've had a guy with only average (as far as pro leagues go) speed have a few plays this season where he catches it , breaks a tackle and runs for a 50yd td. I think there are some variation in builds.


I see some CBs with varied builds. Nothing crazy but usually significant (up to 20-30points) in speed, agility, vision, strength, jumping, catching and various SA/VAs


Some of the performances of the builds i'm thinking of may succeed/falter for reasons other than their build like the system though so who knows.
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 23:29:39
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
I've seen some good WRs from Fanaticsfins54. Don Henley and Marley Bob always performed well and i remember some plays from earlier this season (haven't watched them lately) where they juked a ton of people out. One of them made a dot blink from a jukefake after the nerf but was tackled by someone else.

I've seen some WRs have success with higher strength and breaking some tackles. We've had a guy with only average (as far as pro leagues go) speed have a few plays this season where he catches it , breaks a tackle and runs for a 50yd td. I think there are some variation in builds.


I see some CBs with varied builds. Nothing crazy but usually significant (up to 20-30points) in speed, agility, vision, strength, jumping, catching and various SA/VAs


The only reason there is some CB variation is because some people still think speed makes your run faster and they can't comprehend that they don't need high speed to cover fast WRs. There aren't too many left on good pro teams.

I'd love to get a link to either player you are talking about.

edit: found Marley Bob http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=150662 He has had 1 100 yard game that came in a 56 point win.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:34:05
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
I wish I had my other computer in here, so I could look up replays. You have to ask yourself whether a receiver is running as fast as they can, or if they are running to a spot. Does the corner try to get to the man or to the spot? Who is the primary target on the play?

Instead of trying to look at just speed, ask yourself how much ground can be gained in the time it takes the QB to throw.
 
Link
 
Pierre, what I think you are off-track with is your passion for GLB to revert back into a foot race.

In real football (at all levels), two things are true.

1) WRs and DBs have virtually the same speed. If this isn't true in the sim, then we're not playing football as much as having a track meet.

2) When you're playing/watching football and a WR gets a few steps ahead of the DB, it's usually due to the DB failing to diagnose the route in time (vision) and/or failing to transition into the correct position/force the WR to run a certain way (agility). Or it's due to the WR diagnosing and manipulating the defense (vision), running the route well in the context of what the defense is giving (vision/agility), or making a superior maneuver (agility). And or course of a pass comes with coverage in place, there's a fight for the catch (jumping/catching/strength)

Raw speed is clearly of secondary importance.


What you're advocating for isn't even football. I don't know what it is TBH.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 9, 2009 23:35:25
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by chronoaug

I've seen some good WRs from Fanaticsfins54. Don Henley and Marley Bob always performed well and i remember some plays from earlier this season (haven't watched them lately) where they juked a ton of people out. One of them made a dot blink from a jukefake after the nerf but was tackled by someone else.

I've seen some WRs have success with higher strength and breaking some tackles. We've had a guy with only average (as far as pro leagues go) speed have a few plays this season where he catches it , breaks a tackle and runs for a 50yd td. I think there are some variation in builds.


I see some CBs with varied builds. Nothing crazy but usually significant (up to 20-30points) in speed, agility, vision, strength, jumping, catching and various SA/VAs


The only reason there is some CB variation is because some people still think speed makes your run faster and they can't comprehend that they don't need high speed to cover fast WRs. There aren't too many left on good pro teams.

I'd love to get a link to either palyer you are talking about.


Don and Marley? Marley had a sick juke play early in the season. Go look in the USAPL forums under the thread from earlier in the season called "Week 2 best TDs" or something like that. Another play Don had was a useless juke against the golfers where he made 1 guy blink but because there were 2 players there only one blinked and the other tackled him so he didn't gain much extra yards. that was after the nerf.
 
Link
 
Also, in real football the FS is a lot more useful.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by PierreThomas


What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not.

Agility can make a huge difference in getting open. I believe that Bort has also said that the QB targeting code also takes into account a receiver's jumping and catching attributes in determining where to throw the ball, but like so many things Bort says, I read that a long time ago in some random thread and could have the details wrong.


Bort also said that there were no diminishing returns on speed.


What Bort says and what is actually showing up on the sim are two very completely different things.


There aren't diminishing returns on speed that I know of (unless you are bringing skill points into the equation). There is a limit on how many yards a player can run without having to react to something.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Your CB probably got burned for having too much speed and not enough agility and vision. I'm willing to bet any link you can show me of your higher level CBs getting burnt he failed a vision check.

That was my CB who got butt-raped in the earlier Jericho Brooks link. He never stopped moving, so it wasn't a vision issue.

Also:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13919047
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13914305 (CB1 was the step-forward bug, but CB3 got burned legitimately)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13916841
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Your CB probably got burned for having too much speed and not enough agility and vision. I'm willing to bet any link you can show me of your higher level CBs getting burnt he failed a vision check.

That was my CB who got butt-raped in the earlier Jericho Brooks link. He never stopped moving, so it wasn't a vision issue.

Also:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13919047
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13914305 (CB1 was the step-forward bug, but CB3 got burned legitimately)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=475728&pbp_id=13916841


Just because he never stopped moving, doesn't mean that it couldn't have been a Vision issue.

Why would you think that?

Vision does a ton of things in this game, especially for defensive players.
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 9, 2009 23:37:21
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Also, fastest receivers don't always burn corners in real life because the CBs should know when the WR is running a all out fly route and be able to stay in position with the extra room he has. Hell, i've defended a guy on the track team much faster than me and he never got behind me. Way too obvious that he was running a fly as he had the same tells (like in poker) when he was running a fly or running a stop and go or running a post.. Works the same in the NFL with great route runners with good footwork and mechanics vs. corners with great footwork and fast players without the mechanics. This doesn't have to do with dotball but just dispelling the myth that the fastest player always wins in a fly pattern. GLB definitely does not work like real football most the time.

If only speed mattered in the NFL, then the raiders' draft picks the last 5 years would've made the raiders unstoppable.


Pierre......are you Al Davis? It's ok if you are
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 23:38:46
 
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by PierreThomas



What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not.

Agility can make a huge difference in getting open. I believe that Bort has also said that the QB targeting code also takes into account a receiver's jumping and catching attributes in determining where to throw the ball, but like so many things Bort says, I read that a long time ago in some random thread and could have the details wrong.


Bort also said that there were no diminishing returns on speed.


What Bort says and what is actually showing up on the sim are two very completely different things.


There aren't diminishing returns on speed that I know of (unless you are bringing skill points into the equation). There is a limit on how many yards a player can run without having to react to something.


I believe him that there are no diminishing returns on the speed attribute. But I also believe he's hiding a whole lot about how actual in-game speed works. He's been sitting around letting us believe that the speed attribute = how fast your dot can move, pretty much laughing at us.

Then one of his moderators wrote a script and busted this thing wide open.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 9, 2009 23:40:22
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
High Agility WRs don't work for the same reasons that high Agility RBs don't work. There is always going to be a better ratio of Speed/Agility, with higher Speed.

It's fine if you want to ignore reality and just repeat the same thing over and over until you convince yourself that it's true, but there's no point in asking anyone else to buy that nonsense. Having agility equal with speed does not make you retain full speed through a cut, just a much higher percentage than someone with lower agility. So having Quick Cut on top of that helps you retain an even higher percentage of your speed.

Originally posted by
My WR accelerates just fine, with much higher Speed than Agility

So does my experimental HB with more than twice as much speed as agility. Acceleration /= agility. Agility and speed both factor in, but agility alone determines how much speed you retain through cuts. A Viper will blow away a Porsche on a drag strip, but the Porsche will win any road course race because its disadvantages in acceleration and top speed are overcome by better cornering.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak.

Speed definitely does not cap at 100 and doesn't even seem to have diminishing returns after looking at the player analyzer and checking builds between guys with 90-100 speed and guys with 118 to approx 120 speed
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 9, 2009 23:43:59
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.