Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?
Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.
if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.
if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.
should the scale be equal? I mean throwing is there for us to put into...but we dont have to throw any points into it....blocking is said to help defenders break blocks...but nobody needs to throw 100 into that stat to be amazing at getting through the line (i think)...not all stats should have to be equal...altho I would rather Bort keeps it to himself on whether we should have to over power a single attribute in order to be successful
no, that blocking helps you break blocks nonsense is crap
but so is assigning arbitrary numbers.
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?
Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.
if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.
if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.
should the scale be equal? I mean throwing is there for us to put into...but we dont have to throw any points into it....blocking is said to help defenders break blocks...but nobody needs to throw 100 into that stat to be amazing at getting through the line (i think)...not all stats should have to be equal...altho I would rather Bort keeps it to himself on whether we should have to over power a single attribute in order to be successful
no, that blocking helps you break blocks nonsense is crap

but so is assigning arbitrary numbers.





























