User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Rusty Trombone




now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?



Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.


if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.

if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.



should the scale be equal? I mean throwing is there for us to put into...but we dont have to throw any points into it....blocking is said to help defenders break blocks...but nobody needs to throw 100 into that stat to be amazing at getting through the line (i think)...not all stats should have to be equal...altho I would rather Bort keeps it to himself on whether we should have to over power a single attribute in order to be successful


no, that blocking helps you break blocks nonsense is crap

but so is assigning arbitrary numbers.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW

HBs should have carrying extremely high as well. At level 40, I think they should have it at 70 at the minimum. The one thing they teach you as a HB more than anything is to HOLD ONTO THE BALL. Instead, we have HBs with speed and agility nearing 180 combined and carrying in the low 30s.

It'll be interesting seeing a 30 carrying / strength HB getting tackled by 70 / 70 TCK/STR LBs. I wonder if this would lead to more FFum. No one has tried this out really yet.


This is really the whole point...folks will continue to follow the gospel of "speed is everything," UNTIL other folks actually make GOOD quality builds that exploit their weaknesses.

Like Powerbacks.

Let the agents solve these problems, the sim works fine (for the most part)
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:57:16
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48.

But then again throwing is a Football skill that needs to stay at the current caps place, where tackling, catching and such should move the cap
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:58:16
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Deathblade

Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Deathblade


Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.


 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Deathblade


Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.


This has been suggested 10000 times, it makes sense, but you can't go back and change a million player builds now. It's another inherent flaw in GLB

Honestly Jed's entire new sim league idea is the only way to cure GLB.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 21:00:59
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Deathblade

Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


what do we define a football skill? they are all a skill...
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Deathblade


Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.


ESPECIALLY STAMINA.

Seriously, ever seen a lineman run the whole field? They need oxygen afterwards.

Half the storyline of the Cal-Miami game was Cal's lineman having to run 60 yards downfield to get to the huddle. That's embarrassing.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Originally posted by Anarcho

Originally posted by britdevine316


Originally posted by Deathblade



Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


Honestly, each position should have different caps.


ESPECIALLY STAMINA.

Seriously, ever seen a lineman run the whole field? They need oxygen afterwards.

Half the storyline of the Cal-Miami game was Cal's lineman having to run 60 yards downfield to get to the huddle. That's embarrassing.


stamina is just fine...no need to redo that...
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Deathblade


Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


what do we define a football skill? they are all a skill...


They're already broke down for you (Go to Assign Skill points, you'll see the attributes separated)
 
Link
 
I tried to read all 30 pages, but I don't think I'm winning that battle...

I think a few things need to be changed and a lot of this focuses on strength

The arguement that CBs can't put much into tackling b/c they must keep up with WRs is a valid point. It is valid because WRs need Speed, Agility, Vision Catching (plus stamina jumping and other stuff shared with CB needs)- while CBs will need Speed, Agility, Vision, Tackling, and Strength to be good defenders (basically the WRs have 1 or 2 less areas to focus on and be successful). The problem is that WRs often get to neglect strength for the most part. This needs to be fixed. Players with 20 strength should fumble half the time when they get their clocks cleaned by a 50 or 60 strength safety or linebacker and flat out die if they get pummeled by a 100 str NT. Or at the very least they should lose a ton of morale and stamina.

However, missed tackles are a part of football- at all levels. Even at the college level there are games with 20+ missed tackles. Its just part of football and we are going to have to allow for some amount of broken tackles at some point, whether it be 25 or 10.
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/wire?section=ncf&id=3004605
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/columns/story?columnist=pasquarelli_len&id=1953143

It happens- I could look for more but missed tackle stats are hard to come by.

So how to fix it? I am all for a reduction in speed following a broken tackle. Then just like the start of a play, depending on agility (acceleration) could the player start moving rapidly again. As Bort posted earlier, you have a "balance meeter" that when goes up when you run, so if you take longer to run and go further, your meeter couldn't refill quickly, allowing other defenders to make the tackle. I also like the concept of the RB dragging a weaker defender a couple of yards before finally being brought down.
 
kanzaki
offline
Link
 
You need to consider "gang" tackling in the formula, or weigh it more heavily...

The backs shouldn't be breaking 3 tackles simultaneously.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
Originally posted by bhall43

Originally posted by britdevine316


Originally posted by Deathblade



Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48


what do we define a football skill? they are all a skill...


They're already broke down for you (Go to Assign Skill points, you'll see the attributes separated)


i dont see what taking the soft caps off is going to do really...its only essentially going to be right where we are...with a different look...

taking the caps off of "football skills" isnt really going to solve much to be honest...just makes something like blocking or throwing more exploitive...
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Really, I think Power Backs should be less about totally breaking tackles and more about pushing forward for a few more yards.
 
amo368
offline
Link
 
I think it all depends on the angle at which the defensive player takes for the tackle.

Generally speaking a head on tackle is usually made even by weaker players but strength would probably play more of a role in this type of tackle. If your chasing from behind then strength really has no bearing but your tackle skills do. If your going at an angle toward the player then strength can play into it but mainly your skills as a tackler on whether you can catch up and wrap up or just trip up the player...

I would say in general for that type of running back you would need in the range of softcapping strength, maybe a little higher for the defensive backs/Safeties. Maybe around 60ish for tackling and some special abilities to back it up plus wrap up tackle style... I dont think they need to be really high to make those tackles, but I would expect some missed tackles if the particular RB has some special abilities or Veteran Abilities to counter the defensive player...

Dont know if you will even read this but thought I would give my opinion...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.