wall of fucking text. but since its PT, i will most likely read it.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB - aren't you removing the fun out of the game?
Catch22
offline
offline
I missed the 2nd long post by PT - just read it. Too busy to respond right now but a lot of very good points made.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Any chance of putting a cap on how many SPs people can save up? That seems like a much more sensible idea to me than getting rid of ALGs.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
PLAYMAKERS
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Allow full account mergers for one week again then put the clamps down on multi's because it seems like everyone I talk to has multiple accounts now
you lost me at allowing account mergersO_o
Allow full account mergers for one week again then put the clamps down on multi's because it seems like everyone I talk to has multiple accounts now
you lost me at allowing account mergersO_o
Hagalaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by odg62
For the rest of your post - You talk about reasons people ar losing intrest and all legitimate, but i feel pretty confident saying that none of those reasons even come close to the fact that anyone with any intellegence can look at the game now and realize in about 15 seconds that they will never be able to compete with the teams that are on top due to the way they condense all the talent and anyone who has been playing for even a few seasons can predict within a game what their teams record will be before the season even starts.
I feel you GREATLY overestimate the new players' desire to play in pros. You and many people. Remember the outroar that happened 2 or 3 seasons ago about the cloud? Think any of those cared about playing in the pros 5 or 6 seasons later? Nope. They wanted tun "right now" not eventually in the far future.
As to that "results being too predictable" yes, that is a BIG issue.
For the rest of your post - You talk about reasons people ar losing intrest and all legitimate, but i feel pretty confident saying that none of those reasons even come close to the fact that anyone with any intellegence can look at the game now and realize in about 15 seconds that they will never be able to compete with the teams that are on top due to the way they condense all the talent and anyone who has been playing for even a few seasons can predict within a game what their teams record will be before the season even starts.
I feel you GREATLY overestimate the new players' desire to play in pros. You and many people. Remember the outroar that happened 2 or 3 seasons ago about the cloud? Think any of those cared about playing in the pros 5 or 6 seasons later? Nope. They wanted tun "right now" not eventually in the far future.
As to that "results being too predictable" yes, that is a BIG issue.
Bladnach
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
Any chance of putting a cap on how many SPs people can save up? That seems like a much more sensible idea to me than getting rid of ALGs.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
no one really saves more than like 15
Any chance of putting a cap on how many SPs people can save up? That seems like a much more sensible idea to me than getting rid of ALGs.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
no one really saves more than like 15
tonylieu
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
Any chance of putting a cap on how many SPs people can save up? That seems like a much more sensible idea to me than getting rid of ALGs.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
that's a bad bad bad idea
Any chance of putting a cap on how many SPs people can save up? That seems like a much more sensible idea to me than getting rid of ALGs.
I like ALGs. The concept is a realistic one. I don't like the players spending all of their improvement on two or three attributes.
that's a bad bad bad idea
Raiders12
offline
offline
Part of PT's post
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
PierreThomas
offline
offline
Originally posted by Raiders12
Part of PT's post
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
SSB teams aren't competitve in AAA, Pro or WL though.
Part of PT's post
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
SSB teams aren't competitve in AAA, Pro or WL though.
5STAR
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Raiders12
Part of PT's post
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
SSB teams aren't competitve in AAA, Pro or WL though.
Which means a player will not face them for about 1/3rd his career
Originally posted by Raiders12
Part of PT's post
"The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers"
This would only be a good idea IF the game had a reset, otherwise, it is just a rich get rich deal. barring a reset, they would at least need to fix the SSB issue first.
The competitiveness of the leagues will continue to be a joke until this exploit, AND YES IT IS A EXPLOIT, is taken out of the game. It is a much bigger issue than the stadium/money issue was.
SSB teams aren't competitve in AAA, Pro or WL though.
Which means a player will not face them for about 1/3rd his career

77racing
offline
offline
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Hey Bort and Catch, do you know why people slow build?
They slow build because BORT, not the players, came up with the idea of auto leveling gains which benefits players to build a set way in order to maximize points. Your customers don't want to pay $10 a year to have a player that is better than average in a high league next January. Unfortunately you Bort set the game up this way.
Do you know why teams merge?
They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging. Team owners don't want to start a team build it up for 10 seasons with loyal agents they become friends with and then combine their baby with another team just to cut loose half the agents that got them to the spot they were at but they just realize it becomes a necessity.
Do you know why people shell out 400 flex a season to own a farm team or cash team?
They set up farm teams because Bort made equipment too expensive and didn't have the foresight to see that the way equipment is set up a team has to have home field advantage in the playoffs just about every season. Teams that don't get this can't fully upgrade equipment and can't lure free agents to the team and in the teams 10th season they may be being punished for something that happened in season 5. This sets up unbalanced play and teams quickly scramble to find other ways to level the playing field. This game isn't the NFL but you can blow smoke up everyone's ass and try to claim it isn't based on professional football because the last time I checked college players don't have contracts. Every NFL team is on an equal playing field with finances every season. In fact, the teams that spend less and lose one season typically have more to spend the next. This system is so bad it is like it was created with one too many chromosomes.
This new rule isn't going to keep teams and agents from abusing cash, you are just simply making it harder and more time consuming which in the end is the reason people are leaving the game faster than they are coming in.
I would have loved this rule 8 seasons ago when the first collusion was going on instead of waiting 8 seasons to put your foot down and going back trying to penalize teams that are no longer competitive.
So the next time I get a player stuck on a bad team owner that promises equipment but doesn't deliver and when he becomes available he needs about 6.8 million to get equipment fully upgraded and he can't find a way to get that taken care of guess what I'm going to do?
Retire him
Guess what is going to happen with the cash teams that are out there you are collecting 400 flex a season on?
Sold back.
There is nothing worse in this game than slow building a player up for 8 seasons to finally have him ready to compete at a high level just to have the sim change completely away from the vision of your player. We now can't afford to switch equipment and your customer has thrown $40-100 down the drain because of your poor foresight. What should we do with these players?
Would you suggest retiring them or the agent just losing interest in the game and quitting because these are the only two options you leave the agent with.
This announcement is going to cause chaos. I know that my teams little move this season caused plenty of crying but we didn't steal money from my team before leaving, we spent it all trying to get fully equipped for the playoffs before even deciding it. Sad that a USA Pro team that has won multiple trophies along the way with an elaborate farm system and took a season off to rent players off for max cash raising over $75 million still wasn't fully equipped but it just goes to show how fucked up the financial part of this game is.
So what are you going to be doing about the teams that dropped down and started over with huge bank accounts prior to this announcement that will have a massive advantage on everyone else when they reach the top levels of the game in a few seasons?
Think before you act for christ's sake!
I read this post...

balls on! Too BAD Bort and Company will IGNORE it
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Hey Bort and Catch, do you know why people slow build?
They slow build because BORT, not the players, came up with the idea of auto leveling gains which benefits players to build a set way in order to maximize points. Your customers don't want to pay $10 a year to have a player that is better than average in a high league next January. Unfortunately you Bort set the game up this way.
Do you know why teams merge?
They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging. Team owners don't want to start a team build it up for 10 seasons with loyal agents they become friends with and then combine their baby with another team just to cut loose half the agents that got them to the spot they were at but they just realize it becomes a necessity.
Do you know why people shell out 400 flex a season to own a farm team or cash team?
They set up farm teams because Bort made equipment too expensive and didn't have the foresight to see that the way equipment is set up a team has to have home field advantage in the playoffs just about every season. Teams that don't get this can't fully upgrade equipment and can't lure free agents to the team and in the teams 10th season they may be being punished for something that happened in season 5. This sets up unbalanced play and teams quickly scramble to find other ways to level the playing field. This game isn't the NFL but you can blow smoke up everyone's ass and try to claim it isn't based on professional football because the last time I checked college players don't have contracts. Every NFL team is on an equal playing field with finances every season. In fact, the teams that spend less and lose one season typically have more to spend the next. This system is so bad it is like it was created with one too many chromosomes.
This new rule isn't going to keep teams and agents from abusing cash, you are just simply making it harder and more time consuming which in the end is the reason people are leaving the game faster than they are coming in.
I would have loved this rule 8 seasons ago when the first collusion was going on instead of waiting 8 seasons to put your foot down and going back trying to penalize teams that are no longer competitive.
So the next time I get a player stuck on a bad team owner that promises equipment but doesn't deliver and when he becomes available he needs about 6.8 million to get equipment fully upgraded and he can't find a way to get that taken care of guess what I'm going to do?
Retire him
Guess what is going to happen with the cash teams that are out there you are collecting 400 flex a season on?
Sold back.
There is nothing worse in this game than slow building a player up for 8 seasons to finally have him ready to compete at a high level just to have the sim change completely away from the vision of your player. We now can't afford to switch equipment and your customer has thrown $40-100 down the drain because of your poor foresight. What should we do with these players?
Would you suggest retiring them or the agent just losing interest in the game and quitting because these are the only two options you leave the agent with.
This announcement is going to cause chaos. I know that my teams little move this season caused plenty of crying but we didn't steal money from my team before leaving, we spent it all trying to get fully equipped for the playoffs before even deciding it. Sad that a USA Pro team that has won multiple trophies along the way with an elaborate farm system and took a season off to rent players off for max cash raising over $75 million still wasn't fully equipped but it just goes to show how fucked up the financial part of this game is.
So what are you going to be doing about the teams that dropped down and started over with huge bank accounts prior to this announcement that will have a massive advantage on everyone else when they reach the top levels of the game in a few seasons?
Think before you act for christ's sake!
I read this post...

balls on! Too BAD Bort and Company will IGNORE it
Originally posted by PierreThomas
You may think that the agents with big accounts that have been around forever and are constantly online are trying to whine to game the system but you might be surprised how many people are not. You might be quite surprised to find out just how many of these players are really concerned about the state of the game because they not only have a lot of money, time and energy invested in the game but they also really enjoy playing it and enjoy the friendships that have been made. Most of the long term agents in this game really do want improvement for the game. When we first started in season one and two, it was almost impossible to find level one players willing to sign. I remember the day I got my team I spent 30 consecutive hours recruiting and managed to sign on about ten level one players. I made about fifteen more players and the agents that had already signed created a few more dots and over the next couple weeks managed to get a full team. It probably took 80 hours of recruiting to get it done, now new players have a very difficult time even finding a team. There were 600-750 teams a season being released and the game was doubling in size every few days. By season 7 there were a hundred really good teams and the parity from pro league all the way down to A leagues was pretty damn good. There were some teams in A and BBB leagues that could beat some pro teams. The game was full of excitement, people stayed on the game all day long and the forums had hundreds of threads a day.
Since that time the game has gone down. More people are leaving or losing interest now than are coming in. One of the main reasons is that the game has gotten so damn complicated that a new player can't walk in and possibly fully grasp the game for months. When the game started, a defensive coordinator could set to defend the pass XX%, defend the run XX% and choose how often to defend the inside/outside run or how deep to defend and whether to run zone or man. That is it. A gameplan took ten minutes. Now I'm not saying it should be that simple now but I do think the more we as agents crave the ability to do new stuff like custom depth chart spots, tagging, packages, defensive play creator, route progressions, etc. we are improving the realistic aspect of the game and open endless possibilities. However, at the same time we are making it harder and harder to bring in new players so when the old die out there aren't enough people there to take their place. Not only are there not enough newer players but they can't connect to the game like the early agents could because it was so easy to get involved in the early seasons compared to now where you need to get an online bachelor's degree in AI management just to understand how to play. Before you could worry about stuff like posting in the team forum and shooting the shit with other players, now you have to spend hours on gameplanning. While I would love parity, I'm sure as hell glad that the two main teams I do the most with wont have another competitive game until week thirteen. I used to look forward to the competitive games, now I like looking forward to them way off but as they get close I lose the excitement because I know I'll have to spend hours gameplanning...
...Now that you have gotten here, condense the leagues instead of filling the holes with computer teams. Computer teams and players should be a last resort of sorts. When reworking the leagues have them set up with appropriate level caps and floors. You can still have some uncapped minor teams but make the owners choose whether they want to play in a competitive league or have their friend with an inappropriately high/low level player on the roster. It they are in uncapped leagues then it is by their own choice and they can't complain about the lack of parity. When setting up the cap leagues find a way to work in creation date to get rid of SSB teams. Make it to where there is a limit on how many SSB and non boosters can play on one team.
Those things will instantly create parity where there is none. Sure, every game wont be a nail-biter but at least people will log on to see if they won, they might even go into the league forums to see rankings and find discussion. This will go such a long way to really help the game as a whole.
Now if only someone could come up with a suggestion that would cover those issues...*Cough* *Cough*
You may think that the agents with big accounts that have been around forever and are constantly online are trying to whine to game the system but you might be surprised how many people are not. You might be quite surprised to find out just how many of these players are really concerned about the state of the game because they not only have a lot of money, time and energy invested in the game but they also really enjoy playing it and enjoy the friendships that have been made. Most of the long term agents in this game really do want improvement for the game. When we first started in season one and two, it was almost impossible to find level one players willing to sign. I remember the day I got my team I spent 30 consecutive hours recruiting and managed to sign on about ten level one players. I made about fifteen more players and the agents that had already signed created a few more dots and over the next couple weeks managed to get a full team. It probably took 80 hours of recruiting to get it done, now new players have a very difficult time even finding a team. There were 600-750 teams a season being released and the game was doubling in size every few days. By season 7 there were a hundred really good teams and the parity from pro league all the way down to A leagues was pretty damn good. There were some teams in A and BBB leagues that could beat some pro teams. The game was full of excitement, people stayed on the game all day long and the forums had hundreds of threads a day.
Since that time the game has gone down. More people are leaving or losing interest now than are coming in. One of the main reasons is that the game has gotten so damn complicated that a new player can't walk in and possibly fully grasp the game for months. When the game started, a defensive coordinator could set to defend the pass XX%, defend the run XX% and choose how often to defend the inside/outside run or how deep to defend and whether to run zone or man. That is it. A gameplan took ten minutes. Now I'm not saying it should be that simple now but I do think the more we as agents crave the ability to do new stuff like custom depth chart spots, tagging, packages, defensive play creator, route progressions, etc. we are improving the realistic aspect of the game and open endless possibilities. However, at the same time we are making it harder and harder to bring in new players so when the old die out there aren't enough people there to take their place. Not only are there not enough newer players but they can't connect to the game like the early agents could because it was so easy to get involved in the early seasons compared to now where you need to get an online bachelor's degree in AI management just to understand how to play. Before you could worry about stuff like posting in the team forum and shooting the shit with other players, now you have to spend hours on gameplanning. While I would love parity, I'm sure as hell glad that the two main teams I do the most with wont have another competitive game until week thirteen. I used to look forward to the competitive games, now I like looking forward to them way off but as they get close I lose the excitement because I know I'll have to spend hours gameplanning...
...Now that you have gotten here, condense the leagues instead of filling the holes with computer teams. Computer teams and players should be a last resort of sorts. When reworking the leagues have them set up with appropriate level caps and floors. You can still have some uncapped minor teams but make the owners choose whether they want to play in a competitive league or have their friend with an inappropriately high/low level player on the roster. It they are in uncapped leagues then it is by their own choice and they can't complain about the lack of parity. When setting up the cap leagues find a way to work in creation date to get rid of SSB teams. Make it to where there is a limit on how many SSB and non boosters can play on one team.
Those things will instantly create parity where there is none. Sure, every game wont be a nail-biter but at least people will log on to see if they won, they might even go into the league forums to see rankings and find discussion. This will go such a long way to really help the game as a whole.
Now if only someone could come up with a suggestion that would cover those issues...*Cough* *Cough*

jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
Now if only someone could come up with a suggestion that would cover those issues...*Cough* *Cough*
Please, please, please shut up.
Now if only someone could come up with a suggestion that would cover those issues...*Cough* *Cough*

Please, please, please shut up.You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.


























