I can't go back and read this whole thing but if coaches need to spend cash then obviously teams are paying them. I can barely afford equip for players and level 64 equip is damn near impossible. Will teams get more income?
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Defeugo
offline
offline
OK, I will admit that I haven't read through this whole thread yet so I hope something like this hasn't been discussed. While I don't like the idea of having too many coaches (I hate recruiting and don't need another group of players to sink my money into), I do like the idea of having a head coach and coordinators. My favorite idea is to have the number of plays a team has access to determined by their coordinators. This could work well on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
Originally posted by Defeugo
OK, I will admit that I haven't read through this whole thread yet so I hope something like this hasn't been discussed. While I don't like the idea of having too many coaches (I hate recruiting and don't need another group of players to sink my money into), I do like the idea of having a head coach and coordinators. My favorite idea is to have the number of plays a team has access to determined by their coordinators. This could work well on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
I actually like this idea.
OK, I will admit that I haven't read through this whole thread yet so I hope something like this hasn't been discussed. While I don't like the idea of having too many coaches (I hate recruiting and don't need another group of players to sink my money into), I do like the idea of having a head coach and coordinators. My favorite idea is to have the number of plays a team has access to determined by their coordinators. This could work well on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
I actually like this idea.
butler312
offline
offline
Originally posted by Defeugo
OK, I will admit that I haven't read through this whole thread yet so I hope something like this hasn't been discussed. While I don't like the idea of having too many coaches (I hate recruiting and don't need another group of players to sink my money into), I do like the idea of having a head coach and coordinators. My favorite idea is to have the number of plays a team has access to determined by their coordinators. This could work well on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
Someone else said things similar to this and I agree. It would be great if Bort could include unqiue packages such as the Wildcat or option packages that had to be bought/earned by coaches. I actually went as far to suggest each play be able to be leveled up to make it more effective but I think that kind of got too complicated.
The other coaching idea I have liked is the ability to run intrasquad practices to test these plays against specific offenses/defenses.
OK, I will admit that I haven't read through this whole thread yet so I hope something like this hasn't been discussed. While I don't like the idea of having too many coaches (I hate recruiting and don't need another group of players to sink my money into), I do like the idea of having a head coach and coordinators. My favorite idea is to have the number of plays a team has access to determined by their coordinators. This could work well on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.
Example of an OC.
-When an OC is created they would have to pick the offense they they ran (Coryell, West Coast, etc with possible variations). This would give that coach the ability to run specific plays for his team.
-As the coach goes up levels he would get points to buy more plays. All plays could have equal value or they be tiered based on complexity. They could also buy plays outside of their type of offense once they get to a specified level.
-A coach could daily train in proficiencies with specific plays that would give his players a bonus (probably a small one) when running that play.
Example of a DC.
-Similar to OC except they pick a 3-4, 4-3. You could also make them have to pick a type of D to go with their package (Cover 2, Blitzing, etc).
-They would get to buy plays as well the ability to add created plays to the playbook.
Head Coach
Head Coaches would have access to buy both offensive and defensive plays.
The reason I like this idea is because it would give each team more of a personality as to what they do. You would have less 16-0 teams as they could not be absolutely great at everything which is a good thing in my mind.
Someone else said things similar to this and I agree. It would be great if Bort could include unqiue packages such as the Wildcat or option packages that had to be bought/earned by coaches. I actually went as far to suggest each play be able to be leveled up to make it more effective but I think that kind of got too complicated.
The other coaching idea I have liked is the ability to run intrasquad practices to test these plays against specific offenses/defenses.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by ceinthehouse
Head Coach=1000 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
The Highest title in the game.Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves the whole team.
Offensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves all players on the Offense side of the ball.Defense and Special teams are NOT included.
Defensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and All upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all players on the Defense side of the ball.Offense and Special Teams are NOT included.
Team Scout=500 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
All players and coaches can use the default scouting option that is available. However,having a hired Scout allows for this position to look at all opposing teams skills and attribute distributions and other cool scouting options for this postion as well.
QB Coach=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all QB's on team roster.
RB Coach(& FB's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all RB's on team roster.
WR Coach(& TE's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Defensive Line Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Linebackers Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all LB's on team roster.
Secondary Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Secondary on team roster.
Offensive Line Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Offensive Line on team roster.
Special Teams Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Special teams players on team roster or Depth Chart.
Equipment Manager 50 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements with equipment is for only 1 player at a time.But an equipment manager can get equipment that the other Coaches don't have access too.
Note...the "any and all upgrades" I have listed in particular Coaching positions refer to equipment,% upgrades and anything that said coach would improve.
So if you are a WR coach and you have available equipment to share to the team,then you can only share that equipment to WR core.
Off coor...the whole offense only...
Head coach..everyone and so on.
Any player that retires after the required 440 days of age can choose to pay whatever Flex for whatever Coaching position he desires.
HOWEVER...Any player that chooses to Coach the position for which he retired from, gets bonuses that a regular retired player/different position coach would NOT recieve.
Haven't quite decided on whether I would want to allow a player to move up in the coaching ranks/position by paying additional flex like from equipment manager to head coach if you pay the additional 950 flex....or to make it a "set in stone" once you decide decision.
Anyways...this is what I would like to see personally. More individuality,more coaching positions and options for teams to hire instead of a guy that just does everything...lol and of course difference salaries for these coaches,so teams can actually hire a coach they can afford,one they specifically need but enough restriction to add a bit of realism.
Oh, wow. Please throw this suggestion out the window immediately. This is a horrible fail. It should be up to the team to decide what position a coach has. You can't just say "Oh, I want to be a head coach" and then just go be a head coach. A team needs to offer you the job first. Also, you shouldn't be locked into one position your entire coaching career. Pretty much all NFL and college head coaches started off as assistants, and when head coaches fail, they often go back to being assistants. That's how it should be here, imo. There should be a linear progression and regression for coaching titles. If you do good as a defensive coordinator, you have a shot at becoming a head coach. If you suck at being a head coach, then you should go back to being a coordinator.
Edit: Sorry if this has already been talked about. I just opened this thread for the first time, and this was the first thing I saw and wanted to say what was on my mind.
Head Coach=1000 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
The Highest title in the game.Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves the whole team.
Offensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improves all players on the Offense side of the ball.Defense and Special teams are NOT included.
Defensive Coordinator=750 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and All upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all players on the Defense side of the ball.Offense and Special Teams are NOT included.
Team Scout=500 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
All players and coaches can use the default scouting option that is available. However,having a hired Scout allows for this position to look at all opposing teams skills and attribute distributions and other cool scouting options for this postion as well.
QB Coach=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all QB's on team roster.
RB Coach(& FB's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all RB's on team roster.
WR Coach(& TE's)=300 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Defensive Line Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all WR's on team roster.
Linebackers Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this coach,improve all LB's on team roster.
Secondary Coach=200 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Secondary on team roster.
Offensive Line Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Offensive Line on team roster.
Special Teams Coach=100 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements for this Coach,improve all Special teams players on team roster or Depth Chart.
Equipment Manager 50 Flex
----------------------------------------------------------
Any and all upgrades and improvements with equipment is for only 1 player at a time.But an equipment manager can get equipment that the other Coaches don't have access too.
Note...the "any and all upgrades" I have listed in particular Coaching positions refer to equipment,% upgrades and anything that said coach would improve.
So if you are a WR coach and you have available equipment to share to the team,then you can only share that equipment to WR core.
Off coor...the whole offense only...
Head coach..everyone and so on.
Any player that retires after the required 440 days of age can choose to pay whatever Flex for whatever Coaching position he desires.
HOWEVER...Any player that chooses to Coach the position for which he retired from, gets bonuses that a regular retired player/different position coach would NOT recieve.
Haven't quite decided on whether I would want to allow a player to move up in the coaching ranks/position by paying additional flex like from equipment manager to head coach if you pay the additional 950 flex....or to make it a "set in stone" once you decide decision.
Anyways...this is what I would like to see personally. More individuality,more coaching positions and options for teams to hire instead of a guy that just does everything...lol and of course difference salaries for these coaches,so teams can actually hire a coach they can afford,one they specifically need but enough restriction to add a bit of realism.
Oh, wow. Please throw this suggestion out the window immediately. This is a horrible fail. It should be up to the team to decide what position a coach has. You can't just say "Oh, I want to be a head coach" and then just go be a head coach. A team needs to offer you the job first. Also, you shouldn't be locked into one position your entire coaching career. Pretty much all NFL and college head coaches started off as assistants, and when head coaches fail, they often go back to being assistants. That's how it should be here, imo. There should be a linear progression and regression for coaching titles. If you do good as a defensive coordinator, you have a shot at becoming a head coach. If you suck at being a head coach, then you should go back to being a coordinator.
Edit: Sorry if this has already been talked about. I just opened this thread for the first time, and this was the first thing I saw and wanted to say what was on my mind.
Edited by Punk Rock Jocks on Sep 9, 2009 09:53:17
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Oh, wow. Please throw this suggestion out the window immediately. This is a horrible fail. It should be up to the team to decide what position a coach has. You can't just say "Oh, I want to be a head coach" and then just go be a head coach. A team needs to offer you the job first. Also, you shouldn't be locked into one position your entire coaching career. Pretty much all NFL and college head coaches started off as assistants, and when head coaches fail, they often go back to being assistants. That's how it should be here, imo. There should be a linear progression and regression for coaching titles. If you do good as a defensive coordinator, you have a shot at becoming a head coach. If you suck at being a head coach, then you should go back to being a coordinator.
Edit: Sorry if this has already been talked about. I just opened this thread for the first time, and this was the first thing I saw and wanted to say what was on my mind.
Good point. It goes along with the suggestion a couple of posts up. You could create the coach and learn abilities of your choice that would determine what sort of coach the team would hire you as. As your career progresses you of course would be more qualified for higher positions.
Oh, wow. Please throw this suggestion out the window immediately. This is a horrible fail. It should be up to the team to decide what position a coach has. You can't just say "Oh, I want to be a head coach" and then just go be a head coach. A team needs to offer you the job first. Also, you shouldn't be locked into one position your entire coaching career. Pretty much all NFL and college head coaches started off as assistants, and when head coaches fail, they often go back to being assistants. That's how it should be here, imo. There should be a linear progression and regression for coaching titles. If you do good as a defensive coordinator, you have a shot at becoming a head coach. If you suck at being a head coach, then you should go back to being a coordinator.
Edit: Sorry if this has already been talked about. I just opened this thread for the first time, and this was the first thing I saw and wanted to say what was on my mind.
Good point. It goes along with the suggestion a couple of posts up. You could create the coach and learn abilities of your choice that would determine what sort of coach the team would hire you as. As your career progresses you of course would be more qualified for higher positions.
dawgs1235
offline
offline
yeah, if we ever implement coaches, it should be a separate category, not something for retired players to do.
And since there won't be anyway to see them on a field, they should have advanced team statistics, etc.
And since there won't be anyway to see them on a field, they should have advanced team statistics, etc.
RMiller517
offline
offline
Why can't we just create a coach if we want to ? why does he have to be a former player?
make a coach more expensive to create, or make owning a coach like owning a mini-team (i.e. cost per season rather than up front)
make a coach more expensive to create, or make owning a coach like owning a mini-team (i.e. cost per season rather than up front)
HueyK
offline
offline
1. How much are you thinking coaches will cost in terms of team money?
2. Are you going to have coaches in the minors?
3. Will there be 10 per team?
These questions are important, because of when you compare teams that have been dropped from higher leagues to teams that are working up in the leagues.
For comparison:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=6610 The Santa Cruz Coasters Stadium
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=5802 And the Arctic Road Truckers Stadium.
Both teams are in the same league. The Truckers are the #1 team and the Coasters were #8.
Which team do you think will be able to afford more coaches?
Basically, the suggestion is:
1. Keep coaches out of minors/casual leagues/pee wee.
2. Keep coaches affordable for everyone if you are going to have them in minors/casual/pee wee.
PS. This thread is pretty ridiculous IMO. Bort's going to sift through dozens of pages?
Doubt it.
2. Are you going to have coaches in the minors?
3. Will there be 10 per team?
These questions are important, because of when you compare teams that have been dropped from higher leagues to teams that are working up in the leagues.
For comparison:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=6610 The Santa Cruz Coasters Stadium
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=5802 And the Arctic Road Truckers Stadium.
Both teams are in the same league. The Truckers are the #1 team and the Coasters were #8.
Which team do you think will be able to afford more coaches?
Basically, the suggestion is:
1. Keep coaches out of minors/casual leagues/pee wee.
2. Keep coaches affordable for everyone if you are going to have them in minors/casual/pee wee.
PS. This thread is pretty ridiculous IMO. Bort's going to sift through dozens of pages?
Doubt it.
Mitch54
offline
offline
Perhaps there could be a bonus for a coach based on what position he was before retiring, i.e. a CB or Safety could get some sort of pass defense bonus. Or, maybe just a defensive or offensive bonus in general.
Raiders12
offline
offline
Originally posted by HueyK
1. How much are you thinking coaches will cost in terms of team money?
2. Are you going to have coaches in the minors?
3. Will there be 10 per team?
These questions are important, because of when you compare teams that have been dropped from higher leagues to teams that are working up in the leagues.
For comparison:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=6610 The Santa Cruz Coasters Stadium
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=5802 And the Arctic Road Truckers Stadium.
Both teams are in the same league. The Truckers are the #1 team and the Coasters were #8.
Which team do you think will be able to afford more coaches?
Basically, the suggestion is:
1. Keep coaches out of minors/casual leagues/pee wee.
2. Keep coaches affordable for everyone if you are going to have them in minors/casual/pee wee.
PS. This thread is pretty ridiculous IMO. Bort's going to sift through dozens of pages?
Doubt it.
Look this whole thing fit the continuing pattern we have in GLB now.....the rich get richer....especially Bort.
They will let teams add these coaches and then drop and keep them and whatever advantage they provide just like they do the money and stadiums now when they gut and drop...something that should have been fixed seasons ago!!
As you can see by the flex it is going to cost to make your player a coach, it's all about making money and not whatt is good for the game as a whole....SOS.
1. How much are you thinking coaches will cost in terms of team money?
2. Are you going to have coaches in the minors?
3. Will there be 10 per team?
These questions are important, because of when you compare teams that have been dropped from higher leagues to teams that are working up in the leagues.
For comparison:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=6610 The Santa Cruz Coasters Stadium
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=5802 And the Arctic Road Truckers Stadium.
Both teams are in the same league. The Truckers are the #1 team and the Coasters were #8.
Which team do you think will be able to afford more coaches?
Basically, the suggestion is:
1. Keep coaches out of minors/casual leagues/pee wee.
2. Keep coaches affordable for everyone if you are going to have them in minors/casual/pee wee.
PS. This thread is pretty ridiculous IMO. Bort's going to sift through dozens of pages?
Doubt it.
Look this whole thing fit the continuing pattern we have in GLB now.....the rich get richer....especially Bort.
They will let teams add these coaches and then drop and keep them and whatever advantage they provide just like they do the money and stadiums now when they gut and drop...something that should have been fixed seasons ago!!
As you can see by the flex it is going to cost to make your player a coach, it's all about making money and not whatt is good for the game as a whole....SOS.
Edited by Raiders12 on Sep 9, 2009 12:32:54
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by dawgs1235
yeah, if we ever implement coaches, it should be a separate category, not something for retired players to do.
And since there won't be anyway to see them on a field, they should have advanced team statistics, etc.
I like the idea of retired players being coaches, but yeah, you should be able to create a coach even if you don't have a retired player.
When creating a coach, one should be given two options: Create or Convert.
yeah, if we ever implement coaches, it should be a separate category, not something for retired players to do.
And since there won't be anyway to see them on a field, they should have advanced team statistics, etc.
I like the idea of retired players being coaches, but yeah, you should be able to create a coach even if you don't have a retired player.
When creating a coach, one should be given two options: Create or Convert.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by RMiller517
Why can't we just create a coach if we want to ? why does he have to be a former player?
make a coach more expensive to create, or make owning a coach like owning a mini-team (i.e. cost per season rather than up front)
We should be able to create new guys to be coaches, but I think retired players should have a little bonus to coaching their position. For example, a team w/ Need Ur Love as a coach, would have a small bonus to the DT position.
Why can't we just create a coach if we want to ? why does he have to be a former player?
make a coach more expensive to create, or make owning a coach like owning a mini-team (i.e. cost per season rather than up front)
We should be able to create new guys to be coaches, but I think retired players should have a little bonus to coaching their position. For example, a team w/ Need Ur Love as a coach, would have a small bonus to the DT position.
Maddoc
offline
offline
Personally I think that a retired player ought to be given the option to convert into three (plus whatever weird shit like Scouting coaches) styles of coaches. These should all cost the same FP, for reasons forthcoming.
Using the general template from the OP, they would be as follows.
Head Coach would give a bonus to every player on the team.
Offense/Defense Coach would give a bonus to Offensive or Defensive positions, respectively. (For sake of simplicity, this would work even during Special Teams, and Kicker would fall under the Offense coach, and Punter under the Defense coach)
And Positional Coach, the player would be able to convert into a specialized coach for the position they were prior to retirement, which they are most familiar with.
Head Coach would give the smallest bonus, Offense/Defense would give middle of the road bonuses, and Positional Coaches would give the highest bonus.
Now, the balancing aspect of all of this is a factor I like to call "Too many cooks". This means that each player only receives coaching from one coach, or in other words only the largest bonus that their position would receive counts. In this way, Head Coach would be very useful for his ability to boost players maybe not important enough for a positional coach, but at the same time won't overshadow anyone else.
Now, the downside here is that an Offense+Defense Coach would totally invalidate a Head Coach. For this reason I suggest severely cutting back the max number of coaches to three, perhaps five at most.
That way you could go for the mid-range full team bonus of OC+DC, but you would then be sorely limited in your choice of positional coaches. (The difference between Offense/Defense Coaches and positional coaches would need to be fairly significant in order to prevent every team from just doing OC+DC+RB or something)
Additionally to make sure that some positional coaches aren't overshadowed by others it may be wise to wrap them into one coach. O-Line coach, D-Line coach, Safety coach, and some sort of FB+TE coach
Using the general template from the OP, they would be as follows.
Head Coach would give a bonus to every player on the team.
Offense/Defense Coach would give a bonus to Offensive or Defensive positions, respectively. (For sake of simplicity, this would work even during Special Teams, and Kicker would fall under the Offense coach, and Punter under the Defense coach)
And Positional Coach, the player would be able to convert into a specialized coach for the position they were prior to retirement, which they are most familiar with.
Head Coach would give the smallest bonus, Offense/Defense would give middle of the road bonuses, and Positional Coaches would give the highest bonus.
Now, the balancing aspect of all of this is a factor I like to call "Too many cooks". This means that each player only receives coaching from one coach, or in other words only the largest bonus that their position would receive counts. In this way, Head Coach would be very useful for his ability to boost players maybe not important enough for a positional coach, but at the same time won't overshadow anyone else.
Now, the downside here is that an Offense+Defense Coach would totally invalidate a Head Coach. For this reason I suggest severely cutting back the max number of coaches to three, perhaps five at most.
That way you could go for the mid-range full team bonus of OC+DC, but you would then be sorely limited in your choice of positional coaches. (The difference between Offense/Defense Coaches and positional coaches would need to be fairly significant in order to prevent every team from just doing OC+DC+RB or something)
Additionally to make sure that some positional coaches aren't overshadowed by others it may be wise to wrap them into one coach. O-Line coach, D-Line coach, Safety coach, and some sort of FB+TE coach
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by Maddoc
Personally I think that a retired player ought to be given the option to convert into three (plus whatever weird shit like Scouting coaches) styles of coaches. These should all cost the same FP, for reasons forthcoming.
Using the general template from the OP, they would be as follows.
Head Coach would give a bonus to every player on the team.
Offense/Defense Coach would give a bonus to Offensive or Defensive positions, respectively. (For sake of simplicity, this would work even during Special Teams, and Kicker would fall under the Offense coach, and Punter under the Defense coach)
And Positional Coach, the player would be able to convert into a specialized coach for the position they were prior to retirement, which they are most familiar with.
No No No, for the reasons I just stated. Coaching positions should be decided by the team, not the coach.
Personally I think that a retired player ought to be given the option to convert into three (plus whatever weird shit like Scouting coaches) styles of coaches. These should all cost the same FP, for reasons forthcoming.
Using the general template from the OP, they would be as follows.
Head Coach would give a bonus to every player on the team.
Offense/Defense Coach would give a bonus to Offensive or Defensive positions, respectively. (For sake of simplicity, this would work even during Special Teams, and Kicker would fall under the Offense coach, and Punter under the Defense coach)
And Positional Coach, the player would be able to convert into a specialized coach for the position they were prior to retirement, which they are most familiar with.
No No No, for the reasons I just stated. Coaching positions should be decided by the team, not the coach.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























