User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Guess what, all CBs have the same builds right now and very few WRs builds outside of speed being the primary even have a chance to work.

Really not trying to bust your balls here, but that's just not true. The first part is closer to true since there is a general consensus as to what attributes are best for CBs, but even then there is variation from one to the next, as you'll notice if you need to recruit some. And as for the second, while it is true that most WR builds have speed as their highest attribute, there's considerable variation in types. High agility builds and others work very, very well, they just need different routes than the extreme speed WRs.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
High Agility WRs work very, very well?

Where are they?
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah

but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Not true at all. If speed=speed and nothing else and not even considering shutdown coverage on a CB then 130 speed WR (about the max on GLB with other decent attributes) and a CB with 110 speed (very easily obtained) the WR would be 11.8% faster. That means for every 50 yards the WR runs in a dead streak he would outrun the CB by 5 yards. A 5 yard cushion could eliminate a WR running by him at all.

I'm not even saying speed should just be speed. I don't care if it is tied to agility or even if agility is made more important but to put a governor on WRs is just simply ludicrous. Tying speed to all other attributes is just as ludicrous. No matter what there are diminishing returns since each cap it costs more and more to increase speed. You could have a 150 speed WR (wont happen) and a well built FS can keep up with him in zone coverage.

DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas


DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.



The problem with that, is someone would have to actually admit that it was tampered with.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Guess what, all CBs have the same builds right now and very few WRs builds outside of speed being the primary even have a chance to work.

Really not trying to bust your balls here, but that's just not true. The first part is closer to true since there is a general consensus as to what attributes are best for CBs, but even then there is variation from one to the next, as you'll notice if you need to recruit some. And as for the second, while it is true that most WR builds have speed as their highest attribute, there's considerable variation in types. High agility builds and others work very, very well, they just need different routes than the extreme speed WRs.


Yeah, I'd be interested in seeing one as well. I just sold the agility equipment I had on this WR in season 7 and 8. I put speed back on in season 9 and the production shifted gears instantly. Jearly also had a high agility WR that he retired because he couldn't do much after season 7.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=158382

I know CBs don't all have the same builds but all the good ones are pretty damn similar.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:19:31
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by PierreThomas



DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.



The problem with that, is someone would have to actually admit that it was tampered with.


How could anyone possibly deny it after this thread?
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:18:02
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by PierreThomas




DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.



The problem with that, is someone would have to actually admit that it was tampered with.


How could anyone possibly deny it after this thread?


That's what I would think too.

But that one guy a little while ago, was still making excuses as to why we were wrong.

I don't know, i just have little faith of things being fixed correctly anymore.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Deathblade



If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.


And if getting open = speed then you wont need these things any longer. And can therefore put even more points into OMG speed.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Deathblade




If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.


And if getting open = speed then you wont need these things any longer. And can therefore put even more points into OMG speed.


What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not. See, there is another solution. Fix the way QBs read who is open by the separation they get from the CB instead of the attributes of the WR/CB interaction.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:23:17
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Yeah, I'd be interested in seeing one as well. I just sold the agility equipment I had on this WR in season 7 and 8. I put speed back on in season 9 and the production shifted gears instantly.

Like I said, it depends on the OC and how the WR is used. If you primarily use streaks or other routes that require little change in direction, then extreme speed builds will work better. On the other hand, if you use them on ins and other types of cuts, then the agility WR pretty easily creates separation. They also seem to be better at eluding defenders after the catch and gaining additional yardage.

Originally posted by
I know CBs don't all have the same builds but all the good ones are pretty damn similar.

All builds converge at a position eventually, especially if there is a clear distinction between 4 major attributes and everything else. I will say that my CBs have different sets of equipment, one being pure speed because I have had them get burned in the past.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
It is a game of angles. It is not a footrace.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Yeah, I'd be interested in seeing one as well. I just sold the agility equipment I had on this WR in season 7 and 8. I put speed back on in season 9 and the production shifted gears instantly.

Like I said, it depends on the OC and how the WR is used. If you primarily use streaks or other routes that require little change in direction, then extreme speed builds will work better. On the other hand, if you use them on ins and other types of cuts, then the agility WR pretty easily creates separation. They also seem to be better at eluding defenders after the catch and gaining additional yardage.

Originally posted by

I know CBs don't all have the same builds but all the good ones are pretty damn similar.

All builds converge at a position eventually, especially if there is a clear distinction between 4 major attributes and everything else. I will say that my CBs have different sets of equipment, one being pure speed because I have had them get burned in the past.


Sounds good in theory, got a link to a high agility guy and care to play him against an equal level team I GM?

Your CB probably got burned for having too much speed and not enough agility and vision. I'm willing to bet any link you can show me of your higher level CBs getting burnt he failed a vision check.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:26:44
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by PierreThomas


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Originally posted by Deathblade





If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.


And if getting open = speed then you wont need these things any longer. And can therefore put even more points into OMG speed.


What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not. See, there is another solution. Fix the way QBs read who is open by the separation they get from the CB instead of the attributes of the WR/CB interaction.


Bort posted a list of like 5 factors, in order of priority, that determine whether or not a QB thinks a WR is open. Separation I think was online one.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not.

Agility can make a huge difference in getting open. I believe that Bort has also said that the QB targeting code also takes into account a receiver's jumping and catching attributes in determining where to throw the ball, but like so many things Bort says, I read that a long time ago in some random thread and could have the details wrong.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas

What do you think factors in a WR getting open now? Speed. A QB favors WRs with high speed regardless if they are running faster or not.

Agility can make a huge difference in getting open. I believe that Bort has also said that the QB targeting code also takes into account a receiver's jumping and catching attributes in determining where to throw the ball, but like so many things Bort says, I read that a long time ago in some random thread and could have the details wrong.


Bort also said that there were no diminishing returns on speed.


What Bort says and what is actually showing up on the sim are two very completely different things.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 23:27:56
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.