Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Grim Truth
So, the consensus in this thread is that for Speed and Elusive RB's to stay competitive with Powerback's and not fumble the ball every 5 carries, they need to kill their production to move their carrying unreasonably high... So, you'll only get 2.1ypc, and you won't be fast or agile... but you won't fumble. It's genius, really. Let's make Speed/Elusive backs less productive... That's how they'll compete with the Powerbacks in Season 9.
And dpride's idea is superb. Take all your EQ off Speed/Agility (essentially making your RB have 70spd or 70agl) and put it into carrying... Yeah, that'll be great. So now your Speed RB is slow, and your Agile RB can barely cut, if at all... That's how we'll make those RB's stay somewhat productive and not have them fumble every other carry..
Thanks to Bort linking Speed and Agility, it's unrealistic, and impossible for Speed/Elusive's to keep up. Powerbacks can hike up Carry, Strength, and one or two SA's all they want and be ultra effective, but the Spd/Agl RB's need Speed, Agility, Carry, Strength, Vision, and every SA on the tree to have a chance... How the hell does that work? Even if your RB has decent carrying, capped or higher, he's fumbling 3x/game. In the end, the only way Spd/Agl backs work is if you don't make them very fast or agile so you can pump their strength and carrying like power RB's... What's the point in that? So, power RB's can be power RB's, but the only effective way to have a Speed/Elusive back is to not build them like a fast or agile back?
Excellent post.
-1.
Carrying contributes To rbs success. That is the entire point. The fact you can't tell that carrying makes your Rb a more productive better rb is just silly to me
The fact that you can't tell that HBs need to have speed and/or strength and/or vision and/or the ability to hold onto the ball is just silly to me. If you require HBs to get carrying to 60 or near it to nut fumble every 15 times they carry the ball, then the running game is going to be useless.
Stop arguing, and read and think. You're wrong.I got a rb right here, not even 50 carrying. plays vs equal competition,
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1046440 9 fumbles 12k + yards. Doesn't seem to fumble 1 outta every 15 x. The super unrealistic builds are the one that fumble, and top teams with the best built speed/power backs don't seem to be having a problem