User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
What a relevant point way to add to the debate! You sure showed me how wrong I am for thinking that it's retarded to change things radically without mention and expect everyone to adjust just like that!


You missed the part where I disclosed that fumbling formulas STAYED EXACTLY THE SAME as last season. Many defenders have altered their strategies to focus on forcing fumbles. Changing the game on them would be the very thing you are arguing against - pulling the rug out.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Grim Truth



So, the consensus in this thread is that for Speed and Elusive RB's to stay competitive with Powerback's and not fumble the ball every 5 carries, they need to kill their production to move their carrying unreasonably high... So, you'll only get 2.1ypc, and you won't be fast or agile... but you won't fumble. It's genius, really. Let's make Speed/Elusive backs less productive... That's how they'll compete with the Powerbacks in Season 9.

And dpride's idea is superb. Take all your EQ off Speed/Agility (essentially making your RB have 70spd or 70agl) and put it into carrying... Yeah, that'll be great. So now your Speed RB is slow, and your Agile RB can barely cut, if at all... That's how we'll make those RB's stay somewhat productive and not have them fumble every other carry..

Thanks to Bort linking Speed and Agility, it's unrealistic, and impossible for Speed/Elusive's to keep up. Powerbacks can hike up Carry, Strength, and one or two SA's all they want and be ultra effective, but the Spd/Agl RB's need Speed, Agility, Carry, Strength, Vision, and every SA on the tree to have a chance... How the hell does that work? Even if your RB has decent carrying, capped or higher, he's fumbling 3x/game. In the end, the only way Spd/Agl backs work is if you don't make them very fast or agile so you can pump their strength and carrying like power RB's... What's the point in that? So, power RB's can be power RB's, but the only effective way to have a Speed/Elusive back is to not build them like a fast or agile back?


Excellent post.

-1.


Carrying contributes To rbs success. That is the entire point. The fact you can't tell that carrying makes your Rb a more productive better rb is just silly to me


The fact that you can't tell that HBs need to have speed and/or strength and/or vision and/or the ability to hold onto the ball is just silly to me. If you require HBs to get carrying to 60 or near it to nut fumble every 15 times they carry the ball, then the running game is going to be useless.

Stop arguing, and read and think. You're wrong.

I got a rb right here, not even 50 carrying. plays vs equal competition, http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1046440 9 fumbles 12k + yards. Doesn't seem to fumble 1 outta every 15 x. The super unrealistic builds are the one that fumble, and top teams with the best built speed/power backs don't seem to be having a problem

 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Bukowski


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=654080 i opened his build.
Only one fumble though. Some top NFL running backs fumble the ball too.
Darkus, get the fish and chips out of your ears, babe. He's not bitching about his own guy's performance.
I know this. However, his player seems to be built ok and has only one fumble in his game. His example player proves that it is possible to build an elusive back that doesn't fumble, so I am not sure what is being argued anymore.
Darkus, listen.. He's had 4 fumbles in the last 4 games. Honestly, it's not about him.. But I do think it's a bit overpowered. Darkus, you know I build decent, well-rounded players. I don't think a lvl 50 RB should only have 35 Carrying.. But there needs to be some kind of balance.
Oh I know, I understand what you are saying. I know you build decent players. What I am saying is that I acknowledge that there is an increase in the number of fumbles. I just don't see the issue being as a result of the 'sim' but more as a result of not paying attention to factors within a players build. A fumble or two in a game is part of football.
Darkus, I'm gonna pull some NFL stats for you. And all of you with your GLB != NFL arguments, fuck off for a second. This is relevant.


http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?season=2008&seasonType=REG&d-447263-o=2&tabSeq=0&statisticCategory=RUSHING&d-447263-p=1&d-447263-s=RUSHING_FUMBLES&d-447263-n=1

Darkus, as you can see, the league leader in fumbles only did so every other game.


But did he have to contend with the opposing LBers pumping up their strength and power in the gym all of the previous season because they were getting ran over every game?

Pull up the stats on missed tackles now and compare it. I am saying that I agree there is an increase, I also think it will even out next season as HBs pay attention to the stats that matter. I reckon if Bukowski got MI's confidence up he wouldn't fumble as much.


I reckon if he spent his next 25 SP on carrying and confidence, he wouldn't be able to beat any of those LBs to the edge.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Keep the discussion civil please.


So should a level 43 RB.. that has the Carrying/Strength that I showed you, average a fumble per game?

Even you can say, that is not quite realistic.

Show me a RB that fumbles every game, and I will show you a RB that doesn't start anymore.


I think he has 0 cover up


I don't think cover up is the key. Helpful, but not the full answer.


Well if someone would show me a build of one of these guys fumbling other then the guy with 0 cover up i might be more willing to listen
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Bukowski



Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Bukowski



http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=654080 i opened his build.
Only one fumble though. Some top NFL running backs fumble the ball too.
Darkus, get the fish and chips out of your ears, babe. He's not bitching about his own guy's performance.
I know this. However, his player seems to be built ok and has only one fumble in his game. His example player proves that it is possible to build an elusive back that doesn't fumble, so I am not sure what is being argued anymore.
Darkus, listen.. He's had 4 fumbles in the last 4 games. Honestly, it's not about him.. But I do think it's a bit overpowered. Darkus, you know I build decent, well-rounded players. I don't think a lvl 50 RB should only have 35 Carrying.. But there needs to be some kind of balance.
Oh I know, I understand what you are saying. I know you build decent players. What I am saying is that I acknowledge that there is an increase in the number of fumbles. I just don't see the issue being as a result of the 'sim' but more as a result of not paying attention to factors within a players build. A fumble or two in a game is part of football.
Darkus, I'm gonna pull some NFL stats for you. And all of you with your GLB != NFL arguments, fuck off for a second. This is relevant.


http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?season=2008&seasonType=REG&d-447263-o=2&tabSeq=0&statisticCategory=RUSHING&d-447263-p=1&d-447263-s=RUSHING_FUMBLES&d-447263-n=1

Darkus, as you can see, the league leader in fumbles only did so every other game.


But did he have to contend with the opposing LBers pumping up their strength and power in the gym all of the previous season because they were getting ran over every game?

Pull up the stats on missed tackles now and compare it. I am saying that I agree there is an increase, I also think it will even out next season as HBs pay attention to the stats that matter. I reckon if Bukowski got MI's confidence up he wouldn't fumble as much.


I reckon if he spent his next 25 SP on carrying and confidence, he wouldn't be able to beat any of those LBs to the edge.


Sure wouldn't.. His Elusive days would be over.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

What a relevant point way to add to the debate! You sure showed me how wrong I am for thinking that it's retarded to change things radically without mention and expect everyone to adjust just like that!


You missed the part where I disclosed that fumbling formulas STAYED EXACTLY THE SAME as last season. Many defenders have altered their strategies to focus on forcing fumbles. Changing the game on them would be the very thing you are arguing against - pulling the rug out.


Exactly.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Speed affected both imo. And D has been nerfed many times over actually. And lol I do pay attention, so sorry that I had to go get dinner.


Speed affected both, but was asked for by the defense and primarily affected the offense. By the way, trust me when I say that I know that the D has been nerfed many times over (actually, that's not technically true, as the only real D nerfs were the ongoing DE-related debacle, which I've been strongly on the pro-DE side for, the LB omniscience nerfs and the vision check for balls in the air).

Regardless, I don't understand the whole we've-been-screwed-and-now-you-should-be-screwed argument. Shouldn't we be looking for some sort of sensible balance to the sim on both sides of the ball?

 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by dpride59


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Grim Truth




So, the consensus in this thread is that for Speed and Elusive RB's to stay competitive with Powerback's and not fumble the ball every 5 carries, they need to kill their production to move their carrying unreasonably high... So, you'll only get 2.1ypc, and you won't be fast or agile... but you won't fumble. It's genius, really. Let's make Speed/Elusive backs less productive... That's how they'll compete with the Powerbacks in Season 9.

And dpride's idea is superb. Take all your EQ off Speed/Agility (essentially making your RB have 70spd or 70agl) and put it into carrying... Yeah, that'll be great. So now your Speed RB is slow, and your Agile RB can barely cut, if at all... That's how we'll make those RB's stay somewhat productive and not have them fumble every other carry..

Thanks to Bort linking Speed and Agility, it's unrealistic, and impossible for Speed/Elusive's to keep up. Powerbacks can hike up Carry, Strength, and one or two SA's all they want and be ultra effective, but the Spd/Agl RB's need Speed, Agility, Carry, Strength, Vision, and every SA on the tree to have a chance... How the hell does that work? Even if your RB has decent carrying, capped or higher, he's fumbling 3x/game. In the end, the only way Spd/Agl backs work is if you don't make them very fast or agile so you can pump their strength and carrying like power RB's... What's the point in that? So, power RB's can be power RB's, but the only effective way to have a Speed/Elusive back is to not build them like a fast or agile back?


Excellent post.

-1.


Carrying contributes To rbs success. That is the entire point. The fact you can't tell that carrying makes your Rb a more productive better rb is just silly to me


The fact that you can't tell that HBs need to have speed and/or strength and/or vision and/or the ability to hold onto the ball is just silly to me. If you require HBs to get carrying to 60 or near it to nut fumble every 15 times they carry the ball, then the running game is going to be useless.

Stop arguing, and read and think. You're wrong.

I got a rb right here, not even 50 carrying. plays vs equal competition, http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1046440 9 fumbles 12k + yards. Doesn't seem to fumble 1 outta every 15 x. The super unrealistic builds are the one that fumble, and top teams with the best built speed/power backs don't seem to be having a problem



Yeah, and I'll bet rushing QBs can average 15 YPC in the Pros.

Oh wait, lower levels != Pro Leagues.
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by ShakeNBake



Originally posted by Bukowski




Originally posted by Darkus Black





Keep the discussion civil please.


So should a level 43 RB.. that has the Carrying/Strength that I showed you, average a fumble per game?

Even you can say, that is not quite realistic.

Show me a RB that fumbles every game, and I will show you a RB that doesn't start anymore.


with 0 cover up


You don't have a RB.




That doesn't make me wrong, i have 2 NTs and a LB


Exactly.

You're biased.

Thanks for proving my point.


I don't have an elusive back, I have tons of defensive players, but even I think that suddenly changing things like this is killing this game and needs to stop.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
No, but he could train those up over the season.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Speed affected both imo. And D has been nerfed many times over actually. And lol I do pay attention, so sorry that I had to go get dinner.


Speed affected both, but was asked for by the defense and primarily affected the offense. By the way, trust me when I say that I know that the D has been nerfed many times over (actually, that's not technically true, as the only real D nerfs were the ongoing DE-related debacle, which I've been strongly on the pro-DE side for, the LB omniscience nerfs and the vision check for balls in the air).

Regardless, I don't understand the whole we've-been-screwed-and-now-you-should-be-screwed argument. Shouldn't we be looking for some sort of sensible balance to the sim on both sides of the ball?



Damn, what a crazy sentiment!
 
Demboyz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Grim Truth

So, the consensus in this thread is that for Speed and Elusive RB's to stay competitive with Powerback's and not fumble the ball every 5 carries, they need to kill their production to move their carrying unreasonably high... So, you'll only get 2.1ypc, and you won't be fast or agile... but you won't fumble. It's genius, really. Let's make Speed/Elusive backs less productive... That's how they'll compete with the Powerbacks in Season 9.

And dpride's idea is superb. Take all your EQ off Speed/Agility (essentially making your RB have 70spd or 70agl) and put it into carrying... Yeah, that'll be great. So now your Speed RB is slow, and your Agile RB can barely cut, if at all... That's how we'll make those RB's stay somewhat productive and not have them fumble every other carry..

Thanks to Bort linking Speed and Agility, it's unrealistic, and impossible for Speed/Elusive's to keep up. Powerbacks can hike up Carry, Strength, and one or two SA's all they want and be ultra effective, but the Spd/Agl RB's need Speed, Agility, Carry, Strength, Vision, and every SA on the tree to have a chance... How the hell does that work? Even if your RB has decent carrying, capped or higher, he's fumbling 3x/game. In the end, the only way Spd/Agl backs work is if you don't make them very fast or agile so you can pump their strength and carrying like power RB's... What's the point in that? So, power RB's can be power RB's, but the only effective way to have a Speed/Elusive back is to not build them like a fast or agile back?


Thank you.


good point but really cmon if everyone besides the CBs are power tacklers on the def side of the ball who are aiming to knock the ball out. what were you expecting not to happen when they make contact with you multiple times esp if you are the main back.

plus the SAs and VAs that lower energy and moral dramatically.

ur at disadvantage to begin with.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Originally posted by ShakeNBake



who's performance are we bitching about?


Take a look at the stat leaders in each of the pro leagues. With the exception of WEPL, every league has at least 5 guys with at least 2 fumbles after one game.




This is the base of Bukowski's argument.


Bump.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

What a relevant point way to add to the debate! You sure showed me how wrong I am for thinking that it's retarded to change things radically without mention and expect everyone to adjust just like that!


You missed the part where I disclosed that fumbling formulas STAYED EXACTLY THE SAME as last season. Many defenders have altered their strategies to focus on forcing fumbles. Changing the game on them would be the very thing you are arguing against - pulling the rug out.


In fairness, though, Bort, fixing Sure Tackler has, in my opinion, made Power Tackler a much more powerful VA this season than it was previously.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by Bukowski


Originally posted by ShakeNBake



Originally posted by Bukowski




Originally posted by Darkus Black





Keep the discussion civil please.


So should a level 43 RB.. that has the Carrying/Strength that I showed you, average a fumble per game?

Even you can say, that is not quite realistic.

Show me a RB that fumbles every game, and I will show you a RB that doesn't start anymore.


with 0 cover up


You don't have a RB.




That doesn't make me wrong, i have 2 NTs and a LB


Exactly.

You're biased.

Thanks for proving my point.



You are biased to bitching and don't wanna hear the answer


YOU SUCK!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.