User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
BBB teams can get maxed out stadiums. Teams do relegate. Teams also gut and rebuild. It happens. You're going to see more and more of it as season 1 and 2 players are forced into retirement or chose to retire because GLB has lost its luster for them and they get their flex points back and start new players.

Lots of teams are doing/have done or are planning to do it.

We're not looking to be placed in a tier with level 4 or level 13 players. Just one where the average/media is close to our own. Level 32's I'm perfectly happy losing half our games as long as those games we lost we were actually in.

Its no fun for anyone to be in a 100-6 blowout. Its even less fun to looking forward to 12 of those blowouts a season for several seasons. At least when you are starting out with new players you expect this, but at level 29 you expect to be in a competitive league for awhile, not forced to promote way above your head.

Of the 16 teams in our League (Actually 15 because our own team doesn't count) Fully 2/3's of them (10 teams) went to BBB#6 or lower. More than HALF of those (6 teams) Went to USA BBB#10 or lower.

Yes we look good compared to them, and its why we went 14-2 for season 8. But these teams all dropped quite far in the Shuffle. If we had been allowed to stay in BBB we would have gone down to BBB#5-#3 most probably, maybe #2, looking at those teams and their rosters. We would have been really good in BBB#5, likely winning 11-3 games and having a tough playoffs., BBB#4 and up would have been progressively harder.

USA A#1 or USA BBB#1 or USA BBB#2 we would have been i the bottom third for a couple seasons at the very least. In USA A#1 we're not even the worst team (and I advocate for all the teams that got shafted) so its unlikely we would relegate, nor would they, so several teams in USA A#1 are now saddled with 2-3 horrific losing seasons all because they played a bunch of teams that really weren't that good. We couldn't help that, we were dropped into the USA BBB#1.

Bort should have, at most, promoted ONLY those teams that played in our League Finals. And even those two teams are going to have a tough go of it in USA A#1. But at least then he would have been promoting by the rules.

Doing everything with scripts and such can cause problems. I am fairly certain Bort did not know, did not look into, the former USA BBB#1 and see where its teams actually stood compared to their competition. We had several 9-7 teams in the playoffs. With some of those losses coming against CPU teams. Promotions of peopel outside of the league championship game was a bad idea.

Last edited Apr 8, 2009 10:55:48
 
Titletown
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2659

The shuffled hurt us pretty badly. Slighty confused on how we were placed. I would say our average level is 17 or 18 and we got placed into a level 24 capped league while, there is an African A league with a capped level of 21 and it has some CPU teams, so there's space??? In this 24 capped league, most teams seem to be slow builds as well, so it will prove to be a several season up-hill battle. Not seeing the value to really continue with the team. Unfortunately, not everyone would be extremely happy with the shuffle, but it only hurt for us to be moved.
 
levy24
offline
Link
 
where was the option to move down, i have all lvl 1.2.3 players on my team in a A league
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
BBB teams can get maxed out stadiums. Teams do relegate. Teams also gut and rebuild. It happens. You're going to see more and more of it as season 1 and 2 players are forced into retirement or chose to retire because GLB has lost its luster for them and they get their flex points back and start new players.

Lots of teams are doing/have done or are planning to do it.

We're not looking to be placed in a tier with level 4 or level 13 players. Just one where the average/media is close to our own. Level 32's I'm perfectly happy losing half our games as long as those games we lost we were actually in.

Its no fun for anyone to be in a 100-6 blowout. Its even less fun to looking forward to 12 of those blowouts a season for several seasons. At least when you are starting out with new players you expect this, but at level 29 you expect to be in a competitive league for awhile, not forced to promote way above your head.

Of the 16 teams in our League (Actually 15 because our own team doesn't count) Fully 2/3's of them (10 teams) went to BBB#6 or lower. More than HALF of those (6 teams) Went to USA BBB#10 or lower.

Yes we look good compared to them, and its why we went 14-2 for season 8. But these teams all dropped quite far in the Shuffle. If we had been allowed to stay in BBB we would have gone down to BBB#5-#3 most probably, maybe #2, looking at those teams and their rosters. We would have been really good in BBB#5, likely winning 11-3 games and having a tough playoffs., BBB#4 and up would have been progressively harder.

USA A#1 or USA BBB#1 or USA BBB#2 we would have been i the bottom third for a couple seasons at the very least. In USA A#1 we're not even the worst team (and I advocate for all the teams that got shafted) so its unlikely we would relegate, nor would they, so several teams in USA A#1 are now saddled with 2-3 horrific losing seasons all because they played a bunch of teams that really weren't that good. We couldn't help that, we were dropped into the USA BBB#1.

Bort should have, at most, promoted ONLY those teams that played in our League Finals. And even those two teams are going to have a tough go of it in USA A#1. But at least then he would have been promoting by the rules.

Doing everything with scripts and such can cause problems. I am fairly certain Bort did not know, did not look into, the former USA BBB#1 and see where its teams actually stood compared to their competition. We had several 9-7 teams in the playoffs. With some of those losses coming against CPU teams. Promotions of peopel outside of the league championship game was a bad idea.



WHichever....best of luck with your season whether or not Bort decides to move you.

IF you put half the effort that you put into complaining into recruiting , you'd own Canada A.

good luck
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Looked over Enkidu's team, and i certainly feel for him. A lot of reading, but he's definitely got a point... and you have to admire his passion for his team, whether you agree with him or not. To those who keep telling him to recruit better players: with his own high level guys, and certainly all the ones he's associated with on pro teams, i dont think this is the problem, as he's clearly stated. Any system that forces team disbanding every few seasons in order to compete obviously needs work. Kudos to Bort though on at least making the effort to fix this. It's easy for us to complain about everything, but Ive sat and thought about how to make this league structure better myself, and it seems there are always loopholes to consider. In any case, I think Enkidu has a legitimate case here. Hope it gets resolved
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 11:59:15
 
Sin City
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sin City

Just bringing this to the end so you see it Bort & not miss it. Thanks for all your hard work we do appreciate it.


You should be good to go...


THANKS BORT YOUR DA BEST!!
 
the7trumpets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by the7trumpets

Thanks for everything. I know growing pains can be hard, but we really do appreciate your work.


I'll get back to you guys tomorrow - we'll figure something out, even if it's just getting you down to AA or something. We'll have to find teams to swap with down through the tree first.


Just an update, I and other future members of Nintendo Power have found teams that are interested in moving up a slot. Hopefully this help you out, Bort and admins. If you need more from us, let me know.

Again, Nintendo Power (http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1008) needs to be relegated to at least AA, if not A, because we intend to rebuild with level 5 players this season, and Pro and AAA have level minimums above that. Also, there are two other primarily CPU player teams in SEA Pro Garuda, which need to move down to at least AAA. They are: The Guild of Calamitous Intent (http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3122) and Ho Chi Mean Hot Mamas (http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=459).

SEA AAA teams which have expressed interest in moving to SEA Pro:

Laos King Pongers
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=987
confirmed by owner: aeakers

Buffalo Rampage AAA#2 went 16-0
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3102
confirmed by GM: ICRockets
confirmed by owner: BLeonard

Sumatra Sting - AAA#1
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4899
confirmed by owner: djjacket

Winona Warriors:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3139
confirmed by GM: Madcow8me

Palembang Drunken Monks:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3073
confirmed by owner: mastawoo

Batdambang Killer Koalas
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5124
confirmed by owner: Pirate23


Obviously, we only need three of those to be promoted, for the three CPU player teams that need to go down. There you go, we deliver more than necessary


SEA AA teams that might want to go to AAA:
??? Don't have any confirmed yet


SEA A teams that have expressed interested in moving to AA:

Hanoi Chaos Masters
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5033
confirmed by owner: Theli

Macau Gamblers
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5094
confirmed by owner: GarrettFoster



So, that should do it. Good luck, Bort and company. If you need anything, let me know as JT83 is already out of the country. Again, I'm sorry for all this confusion, but we thank you tremendously for rectifying it. The leagues will be better as a result.
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 14:31:43
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Looked over Enkidu's team, and i certainly feel for him. A lot of reading, but he's definitely got a point... and you have to admire his passion for his team, whether you agree with him or not. To those who keep telling him to recruit better players: with his own high level guys, and certainly all the ones he's associated with on pro teams, i dont think this is the problem, as he's clearly stated. Any system that forces team disbanding every few seasons in order to compete obviously needs work. Kudos to Bort though on at least making the effort to fix this. It's easy for us to complain about everything, but Ive sat and thought about how to make this league structure better myself, and it seems there are always loopholes to consider. In any case, I think Enkidu has a legitimate case here. Hope it gets resolved


I'm totally on board with Bort fixing leagues. and working to achieve parity in leagues season over season. I stand behind the efforts to make these changes.

I just believe the system used did not really take into account too many factors and so was doomed to create a lot of situations like my own. We were promoted before we even had a chance to be shuffled. We were promoted because we had a 14-2 record and went to the conference finals (and lost to a better team). But if he looked at the league we played against, with 66% of them being shuffled down to USA BBB#6 or lower and 45% of them or so being shuffled to USA BBB#10 or lower.. Yeah.. we played well, but this is because there was really no competition for any of the 'top' teams in the tier.

His method of determining the median was flawed as well. He's got access to so much data, he really should be getting someone with a statistics background to determine the best methods for 'leveling' leagues rather then trying it himself.

I appreciate the work Bort has done, but its time he starts hiring more people to help him run the game, more coders to help the sims run smoother, and people with the right sort of backgrounds and knowledge to make systems changes like the shuffle.

Anyone with a basic knowledge of Statistics would have been able to explain how this result we have presently was predictable and yet also avoidable. Taking the top 25% of a team (with a team needing 40 players, that's just 10 of 30 players) and using that to determine the Median for the team? Why not remove the top and bottom 12% and then determine the mean from there? Why not instead look at the MOUNDS of data he has about teams, players, the number of downs played per game, etc, and spit out a numerical value for each player on the team, and add these values and then compare teams that way.

All sorts of ways this could have been handled more smoothly.

I am passionate about my Team. I feel for my players and I want them to have fun. I think most of my players will have the most fun if they are playing teams who they can compete with. If every game played is against a team we could win or lose against because things are equal, we'll have a fun season.

I see no fun involved in forcing owners to have to retool their team, get rid of or 'demote' starters and recruit higher level players to take their place, and still be in a situation where they may not be competitive.

I find the most satisfaction, as a team owner, in being able to retain as many players from the previous season as possible. Doing so indicates that generally everyone is having a good time.
 
Link
 
Shuffle hurt my team too...we're matched up against teams that have nearly the entire stadium built because they got moved down...how can we compete in salary offerings when the other guy can offer 5x as much
 
kfd277
offline
Link
 
I don't need to be the highest leveled. I don't even mind being the lowest averaged leveled team in the league. I just want to have the highest averaged leveled teams NOT be 12 levels higher. When 9 teams are 10 levels higher than you are, I fail to see any relative parity in the league. I also realize that someone has to be last and while I don't want to be last, I don't mind it if I I had a fighting chance to do something.


Originally posted by kfd277
We have a similar situation in a Canadian A league. My team has an average level of 26 while the top three teams have an average level of 38. One team has an average level of 10 but they have 128 players on the team. If you take their top 38 players, their average level is ~40. I don't know that we be able to compete. I guess we will see.

Average level of teams in league:
38.57
38.46
38.08
37.26
37.11
36.55
36.34
35.85
35.20

34.66
34.49
34.31
34.28
34.24
34.23
34.05
33.64
33.48
33.17
32.94
32.78
32.68
31.35
30.82
30.81

30.20
29.81
28.91
28.84
26.55

10.86
5.68


 
Jsamps07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jsamps07
Bort

I sent a request in yesterday for a guy to be release from my team because a GM resigned him to get more money when I lost my team after I went MIA and didn't renew the contract due to family issues. I ended up getting it back and then asked for the demotion but never was demoted. Someone released the guy from my squad, but never sent a PM back telling me anything. Is there any chance I can still get my team demoted to the lowest league possible?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5672

That's the team page. Right now I am sitting in Canada AA#3 with just over $200,000. I obvious don't have the money to recruit high level guys, and is the reason for wanting to be demoted. If I don't get demoted, I'll be in a league with Level 40+ guys and my team having guys level 10+ and below.

Justin


Bump
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the7trumpets
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by the7trumpets


Thanks for everything. I know growing pains can be hard, but we really do appreciate your work.


I'll get back to you guys tomorrow - we'll figure something out, even if it's just getting you down to AA or something. We'll have to find teams to swap with down through the tree first.


Just an update, I and other future members of Nintendo Power have found teams that are interested in moving up a slot. Hopefully this help you out, Bort and admins. If you need more from us, let me know.


Thanks for the update trumpets - will see what I can do.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Hey bort --

I know youre super busy right now, but maybe you could discuss the future and reshuffling of the second tier leagues when you get a chance, so people can have more than a few days to prepare for it...

Like....will the shuffle only be the second tier, or will teams be shuffled 'vertically' as well as 'horizontally' next season ETC..
and also what the caps will be in the A leagues...etc...


I am really looking forward to shuffling / capping of the second tier (the "A" leagues in most cases) next season, so PLEASE fill us in and make everything as clear as possible when you can!

THANKS in advance.
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 15:03:23
 
_JohnDoe_
offline
Link
 
I hope this does not happen every year.
I would like to plan my team.
 
neoliminal
offline
Link
 
I, for one, am happy with the shift and I hope it makes for more competitive games for my team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.