1) "Quality of tackle" (ability to hold onto the tackle) should be independent of (but a significant modifier to) the "bring to ground" aspect of tackling (which is where strength comes into play).
2) In-game speed and relative angles of players at time of impact should also be factored into the calculation (head-on hits require more strength for O player to break, hits from side require more agility for O player to break... high-speed hits have more impact on ball carrier, etc.).
3) End result of tackling roll (with considerations above) should not be "make or miss"... there should be make, miss, partial miss (but affect/slow down ball carrier somewhat), and gang tackling (hold on until help arrives while getting slowly dragged downfield). An "accurate" tackle that is broken due to strength is still going to slow the power back down a bit. On the other hand an elusive back's agility and juking will make the "quality of tackle" generally lower, and result in more complete misses (but an accurate hit will not require much strength to bring him down).
2) In-game speed and relative angles of players at time of impact should also be factored into the calculation (head-on hits require more strength for O player to break, hits from side require more agility for O player to break... high-speed hits have more impact on ball carrier, etc.).
3) End result of tackling roll (with considerations above) should not be "make or miss"... there should be make, miss, partial miss (but affect/slow down ball carrier somewhat), and gang tackling (hold on until help arrives while getting slowly dragged downfield). An "accurate" tackle that is broken due to strength is still going to slow the power back down a bit. On the other hand an elusive back's agility and juking will make the "quality of tackle" generally lower, and result in more complete misses (but an accurate hit will not require much strength to bring him down).
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:54:53






























