User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
1) "Quality of tackle" (ability to hold onto the tackle) should be independent of (but a significant modifier to) the "bring to ground" aspect of tackling (which is where strength comes into play).

2) In-game speed and relative angles of players at time of impact should also be factored into the calculation (head-on hits require more strength for O player to break, hits from side require more agility for O player to break... high-speed hits have more impact on ball carrier, etc.).

3) End result of tackling roll (with considerations above) should not be "make or miss"... there should be make, miss, partial miss (but affect/slow down ball carrier somewhat), and gang tackling (hold on until help arrives while getting slowly dragged downfield). An "accurate" tackle that is broken due to strength is still going to slow the power back down a bit. On the other hand an elusive back's agility and juking will make the "quality of tackle" generally lower, and result in more complete misses (but an accurate hit will not require much strength to bring him down).
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:54:53
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Bort is it possible to have a penalty that lasts for a certain amount of ticks after just breaking a tackle, or coming into contact with a defender.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Another problem with broken tackles when a tackle is broken the ball carrier has practically zero loss of speed, while the defender stays on the ground for 2 seconds every time.
 
Rutang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Originally posted by Rutang

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by britdevine316



If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


NFL teams have brought in track stars (speed, agility) even without much of a football background. You don't see them bringing in high jumpers, or weight lifters. So, I think speed/agility are just more important to football than jumping. or strength. You need those attributes, but not as much as others.



A lot of players did other things e.g. Stephen Neal - college wrestler


Exactly. Wrestling is a great example. It requires strength, agility, and anticipation (vision).

Just having 105 strength, or 90 jumping shouldn't do much for you. You need to have the right mix of attributes.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
It seems that a really important piece is to have partially successful tackles... you slow down the runner considerably giving other defenders a chance to get there, even if you can't tackle yourself. All the SAs activating should slow down the runner also.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Maybe there should be an option for cut-tackling?

allow people to go straight for the legs, but realize they'll give up 1-3 extra yards for this type of tackle. this would allow power backs to be successful, but not screw over CBs who can't afford as high tackling/str because they have to cover WRs. The DEs/LBs should prevent a power back from getting to a CB and if he does get to my CB, I'm more interested in preventing a td than an extra 3 yards.

Of course, with sub soft-capped tackling, the CBs will still miss the tackles even on cut tackling. I would say my 31 str 31 tackle CB should miss tackles on power backs at least half the time.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone


now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?



Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.


if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.

if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.

 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Rusty Trombone



now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?



Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.


if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.

if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.



Physical attributes =/= football skills. At all.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Personally, I think there should be two types of tackling to address the different HBs: Tackle high and tackle low.

Tackle high = good against elusive, bad against power.

Tackle low = good against power, bad against elusive.

Of course this could be an individual tactic, but what about against teams that carry both types of backs?

Well, aside from any individual tactics, each player making a tackle should go through a vision check to determine which type of tackle they try to make. If they pass the check they tackle based on the runner's attributes (if strength = x tackle low, if speed = x tackle high or some such thing). Perhaps the higher the vision, the better the tackle attempt.

That would just determine the type of tackle they go for.

After that, tackling and strength would determine if they actually tackle the runner. In order of effectiveness, it should go Tackling, Strength, then Tackle Type.

The logic behind this suggestion is that defensive backs typically have a high level of vision, and defensive linemen typically have low levels of vision. Instead of making it so that CBs need 100 tackling/strength, you make them more likely to tackle properly (because they HAVE to).

So lets do this numerically. Let's say a D lineman has 80 strength, 20 vision, and 40 tackling. He likely doesn't make the vision check, but his strength and tackling are decent enough to take down a HB with 80 strength.

Let's say a CB has 20 strength, 60 vision, and 30 tackling. The CB likely makes the vision check which would increase his tackling to a level where he would have a similar chance as the D lineman of making the tackle.

Obviously I'm just throwing out numbers, but the idea is pretty basic. Vision check to determine type of tackle. Type of tackle increases or decreases your chance of making the tackle significantly. It doesn't affect people with high strength or tackling much, but it helps players with high vision and low strength/tackling, and hurts players with low vision, strength, and tackling.

This way everyone can keep building their players they way they are. If everyone builds their players correctly, they have a decent chance at tackling a power back. With this suggestion CBs have a better chance at tackling power backs, DTs have a slightly lower chance (negligible due to strength and tackling levels), Speed/Agility DEs have a higher likelihood of missing tackles (low strength, tackling, and sometimes low vision), LBs don't really get affected since they typically have high vision, decent strength and decent tackling, and power HBs benefit against the speed/agility DEs that try to tackle them. I think that's a fair balance.

I think.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:54:27
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by britdevine316

Basically what needs toned down in GLB is offense. When 2 top teams meet the outcome is always 40+ to 30+ or 52-48, something like that.

Maybe a total nerf on O is needed somehow.


Make football skills more important.

I mean really...top WR's have 50 catching, top HB's have 40-50 carrying, and 100 speed.


Exactly. Make catching more important. Seriously, WRs have 60 catching at level 40 is laughable. I think Bort should nerf these WRs with all speed / agility (100/80), and make catching a LOT more important. After all, a WRs job is to CATCH the ball.

HBs should have carrying extremely high as well. At level 40, I think they should have it at 70 at the minimum. The one thing they teach you as a HB more than anything is to HOLD ONTO THE BALL. Instead, we have HBs with speed and agility nearing 180 combined and carrying in the low 30s.

It'll be interesting seeing a 30 carrying / strength HB getting tackled by 70 / 70 TCK/STR LBs. I wonder if this would lead to more FFum. No one has tried this out really yet.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
of course for figuring these things out, we could also treat 48 as the middle of a bell curve, with the 3:1 being within 1 standard deviation, and the 4:1 within 2 standard deviations.

I'm stretching statistices here, but 68 tackling (with appropriate str) should make tackles 97.5% of the time
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Rusty Trombone



now what's your definition of adequate tackling? cause if that's substandard speed, then no one should have under 60 tackling to be decent. thus you need 80 tackling to stop power backs consistently, right?



Wtf are you talking about? There are lots of 180 lb. CBs that would have about 48 speed that can take out the legs of Brandon Jacobs once in a while, and there are a lot of safeties that can consistently bring him down. Safety = 60 tackling and strength imo. Perfectly reasonable.


if 60 is safe for strength and tackling, why would they ever put more points in? you defined a 55 in speed as slow. then a 55 in tackling should be poor at tackling, right? there shouldnt be some sliding scale, all stats, ideally, should be equal.

if 60 is slow, then 60 is not "safety" for tackling and strength.



should the scale be equal? I mean throwing is there for us to put into...but we dont have to throw any points into it....blocking is said to help defenders break blocks...but nobody needs to throw 100 into that stat to be amazing at getting through the line (i think)...not all stats should have to be equal...altho I would rather Bort keeps it to himself on whether we should have to over power a single attribute in order to be successful
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
I think a tackle high, tackle low is a good idea, but It needs to be able to be selected vs. each HB the team has as your player is smart enough to figure out which HB is in the game.

It should also have a vision based roll to deciding the correct way to tackle. Vison is about the only stat I can think of that can be an intelligence attribute this game really needs. The more "vision" the higher % chance your player has of picking the right way to tackle each HB.
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
of course for figuring these things out, we could also treat 48 as the middle of a bell curve, with the 3:1 being within 1 standard deviation, and the 4:1 within 2 standard deviations.

I'm stretching statistices here, but 68 tackling (with appropriate str) should make tackles 97.5% of the time


You can't put a figure like that. Tackling requires Vision, Technique (Tackling), Agility and Strength.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.