User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djc6535
I can't believe that people are actually defending a DE having nothing but speed, with no strength or sometimes even agility to back it up.

In that world wouldn't you expect to see 160 lb DEs that look a hell of a lot like Cornerbacks and punt return men?

There is no way to defend the level 4 DE against the 31 OT... even if the 31 OT had a TERRIBLE build I guarantee it still should be good enough to stone a 4DE every time. If not, then this game has no business calling itself football.


So you want to see more str des?

Make them effective. Right now their about as useful as a guy that just kinda sits there that can't get pressure on the qb, cant make tackles on HBs because their too fast, and can't break a block for the life of him. Want to make them more effective? There really isn't much of a way to do it with the way the sim runs.

Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
Originally posted by djc6535

I can't believe that people are actually defending a DE having nothing but speed, with no strength or sometimes even agility to back it up.

In that world wouldn't you expect to see 160 lb DEs that look a hell of a lot like Cornerbacks and punt return men?

There is no way to defend the level 4 DE against the 31 OT... even if the 31 OT had a TERRIBLE build I guarantee it still should be good enough to stone a 4DE every time. If not, then this game has no business calling itself football.


So you want to see more str des?

Make them effective. Right now their about as useful as a guy that just kinda sits there that can't get pressure on the qb, cant make tackles on HBs because their too fast, and can't break a block for the life of him. Want to make them more effective? There really isn't much of a way to do it with the way the sim runs.

Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.


This. I had a Strength DE for the first 3 seasons. It worked fine, then in the 4th season I got 1 sack in 9 games so I had to change everything over to speed to be effective again.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iwan Owen
Originally posted by xylo

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243455&pbp_id=1130476

Thought this might make you smile - level 4 ,slow build DE - All SP on speed -60 -
against levl 31 OT.


That was actually against my team and i can assure you the OT has a good build (his owner is Vawn off GLB radio who difinitely knows how to build players).

However, what is not mentioned is that we were so far up at that point my whole team had visibly slowed down to about a third of their usual speed. If you look at those WR`s i can assure you they are normally very fast (i`m talking Flames territory here almost) but you can see for yourselves how slow they are in that particular replay. That is also reflected in the score, in that we scored 98 points in the first half compared to around half of that in the second when the players slowed down. Hardly the best example to show really.


Yeah, I think that's the 'Cruise Control' programming that brought down your team's skills to fall more in line with that of the weaker team you were facing.

Here's a couple plays of my OT(LvL 33 at the time of these replays) getting beat by a LvL 36 speed DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419932
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419862

Here are the rest of the pass plays in that same game where my OT faced the same DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419744
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419802
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419809
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419879
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419978
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419982
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420022
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420040
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420048
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420072
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420095
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420101

As you can see, outside of the 1 play where the DE just blew by my OT for the sack, none were plays where the two didn't engage.

Also, my OT did a solid job of keeping the DE at bay when facing him 1-on-1 with no help from a RB.

You always see my OT getting back, set quickly, and then engage the DE - keeping him at bay except for the two sacks. But even on one of those the DE had to work for it by shedding my OT's block first.

Again, this was against a speed DE who was 3 levels higher. Some good, realistic battles to. Probably the result of a couple of good builds going at it.
 
djc6535
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
Originally posted by djc6535

I can't believe that people are actually defending a DE having nothing but speed, with no strength or sometimes even agility to back it up.

In that world wouldn't you expect to see 160 lb DEs that look a hell of a lot like Cornerbacks and punt return men?

There is no way to defend the level 4 DE against the 31 OT... even if the 31 OT had a TERRIBLE build I guarantee it still should be good enough to stone a 4DE every time. If not, then this game has no business calling itself football.


So you want to see more str des?

Make them effective. Right now their about as useful as a guy that just kinda sits there that can't get pressure on the qb, cant make tackles on HBs because their too fast, and can't break a block for the life of him. Want to make them more effective? There really isn't much of a way to do it with the way the sim runs.

Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.


I'm not complaining against people who are exploiting the problem. When speed is the only stat that matters, I fully expect every DE to build that way. I don't expect people to handicap their players in order to make their builds realistic.

I do expect Bort to make realistic builds effective and unrealistic builds worthless. I do expect people to understand that an all speed build is unrealistic and to quote someone else, a lineman shouldn't have to have the speed of a WR and the agility of a halfback to be effective.

I don't mind inflated stats, so long as they came against overmatched opponents and CPU teams. I don't mind a freakishly good DE so long as the agent has struck the right balance of strength, agility, technique, and yes speed, as REAL DEs have. Monster strong DEs that can't move don't exist in Football any more than super fast weaklings do. I don't want 'Strength DEs' to be super effective anymore than I want 'Speed DEs' to be super effective. I want realistic DEs to be effective.
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
hows the vision?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.


The difference is:

http://www.nfl.com/stats/player

The NFL leader in yards passing through 11 games has 2985 passing yards. The QB with 1800 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in passing.

The NFL leader in yards rushing through 11 games has 1015. The guy with 650 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in rushing.

The DE with 32 sacks has accomplished almost triple in two games what NFL leader Joey Porter (12 sacks) has in 11 games.

Yes. The top GLB players should accomplish more than the top NFL players, because there's much more talent disparity in GLB (not just between teams) than in the NFL.

But look at the frigging difference.

The top passers or rushers are able to, in two games, get about half of the NFL leaders' totals through 11. That's "ordinary" inflation, and without it, the average player wouldn't meet the average result.

But the top sackers are able, in two games, to triple what the NFL leaders can do in 11.

See the difference?

THIS NEEDS FIXING.

Last edited Nov 14, 2008 18:06:04
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs.


Guilty: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=390819



But good point about gutted teams. I'm guessing this game will never get out of Beta. lol! There will always be something people will demand needs nerfing/fixing no matter what. Even sports video games (madden and the like) are never 'finished'. Yet we pay real money to test the game and use our time and energy coming up with viable solutions/ideas free of charge to improve the product. Video Game forums are a gold mine for developers - milk those hardcore gamers for their cash and ideas without paying them a red cent. Love those 100 Flex Points at season's end...just enough to help create another player to spend more real cash on. Smart.

My apologies for getting off-topic.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs.


Guilty: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=390819



But good point about gutted teams. I'm guessing this game will never get out of Beta. lol! There will always be something people will demand needs nerfing/fixing no matter what. Even sports video games (madden and the like) are never 'finished'. Yet we pay real money to test the game and use our time and energy coming up with viable solutions/ideas free of charge to improve the product. Video Game forums are a gold mine for developers - milk those hardcore gamers for their cash and ideas without paying them a red cent. Love those 100 Flex Points at season's end...just enough to help create another player to spend more real cash on. Smart.

My apologies for getting off-topic.


Guiltier?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=531331

Gutted teams will always skew stats, it is virtually inevitable.

The biggest difference? NFL players and coaches are professionals, with a lot to lose if they just up and suck.

GLB has no great barriers to exit (or entry) so gutting will always be a part of life.

Get used to it...
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
So...

DEs in seasons 1-3 were fine. From season 4-6, only speed DEs were good, and they'd sack QBs waaayyy too much
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by SAGA45

Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA


Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs.


Guilty: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=390819



But good point about gutted teams. I'm guessing this game will never get out of Beta. lol! There will always be something people will demand needs nerfing/fixing no matter what. Even sports video games (madden and the like) are never 'finished'. Yet we pay real money to test the game and use our time and energy coming up with viable solutions/ideas free of charge to improve the product. Video Game forums are a gold mine for developers - milk those hardcore gamers for their cash and ideas without paying them a red cent. Love those 100 Flex Points at season's end...just enough to help create another player to spend more real cash on. Smart.

My apologies for getting off-topic.


Guiltier?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=531331


Oh definitely. I'm only getting lethal injection. You're getting the old electric chair with the guy from Green Mile putting a dry sponge on your head. You poor bastard.

Last edited Nov 14, 2008 18:17:36
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA


Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.


The difference is:

http://www.nfl.com/stats/player

The NFL leader in yards passing through 11 games has 2985 passing yards. The QB with 1800 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in passing.

The NFL leader in yards rushing through 11 games has 1015. The guy with 650 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in rushing.

The DE with 32 sacks has accomplished almost triple in two games what NFL leader Joey Porter (12 sacks) has in 11 games.

Yes. The top GLB players should accomplish more than the top NFL players, because there's much more talent disparity in GLB (not just between teams) than in the NFL.

But look at the frigging difference.

The top passers or rushers are able to, in two games, get about half of the NFL leaders' totals through 11. That's "ordinary" inflation, and without it, the average player wouldn't meet the average result.

But the top sackers are able, in two games, to triple what the NFL leaders can do in 11.

See the difference?

THIS NEEDS FIXING.



all i see is that OT are too stubborn to change their build and just complain
Last edited Nov 14, 2008 18:22:44
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA



Seems like there is a new nerf every season for DEs. First str DEs were made completely useless with new pathing/pass rushing styles a season ago, and now you guys are trying to take away essentially the last of the successful builds

Stats will be inflated, get over it. Theres a DE with 32 sacks in my DE's league, theres also a QB with 1800 yards and 3 TDs, theres a RB with 650 yards and another with 18 TDs. Hell there is even a kicker with 56 XPs already.


The difference is:

http://www.nfl.com/stats/player

The NFL leader in yards passing through 11 games has 2985 passing yards. The QB with 1800 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in passing.

The NFL leader in yards rushing through 11 games has 1015. The guy with 650 yards will eventually surpass him, but hasn't yet, because the stats aren't as inflated for the leaders in rushing.

The DE with 32 sacks has accomplished almost triple in two games what NFL leader Joey Porter (12 sacks) has in 11 games.

Yes. The top GLB players should accomplish more than the top NFL players, because there's much more talent disparity in GLB (not just between teams) than in the NFL.

But look at the frigging difference.

The top passers or rushers are able to, in two games, get about half of the NFL leaders' totals through 11. That's "ordinary" inflation, and without it, the average player wouldn't meet the average result.

But the top sackers are able, in two games, to triple what the NFL leaders can do in 11.

See the difference?

THIS NEEDS FIXING.



all i see is that OT cant are too stubborn to change their build and just complain


I only have one OT, and he's quite successful at pass blocking; but I'll tell you, they should not need Speed.

Speed needs at least one more nerf, and that is in line play. It was too important compared to real life everywhere else; I guess it should be no surprise that it's unrealistically important in line play.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xylo
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243455&pbp_id=1130476

Thought this might make you smile - level 4 ,slow build DE - All SP on speed -60 -
against levl 31 OT.

This should be quoted on every page until it's fixed. Plus I still find it funny.
Last edited Nov 14, 2008 18:38:57
 
Sabataged
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=268787&pbp_id=2332300

Quarter Defense in, 3 down linemen rushing and they still mangle my QB.
 
Sabataged
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by xylo

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243455&pbp_id=1130476

Thought this might make you smile - level 4 ,slow build DE - All SP on speed -60 -
against levl 31 OT.

This should be quoted on every page until it's fixed. Plus I still find it funny.


+1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.