Originally posted by GG
I like the idea of having new tiers of SAs (not attributes). But like our original idea called New-SA (free form buffet style) and all part of the one XP tier (just opening up XP gain now for all levels) rather than second tiers of XP and attributes that would generate more cookie cutter builds etc.
While I supported New-SA and still would, I don't see Drifter's idea as creating cookie cutter builds, as long as the extra attributes were balanced. They'd have to in the free form SA proposal we supported, as well.
I still really like Drifter's concept, and in a game with no more disparity than Season 4 I'd continue to support it. There really ought to be more chances for higher level players to place points. It's just that the differences between players of 3 levels' difference (or 5, or whatever) are much bigger than they used to be.
Originally posted by GG
Even in season 4, tho disparity was less than season 5, it was still quite hefty. At heart I'm just opposed to creating any more disparity. I dont mean good teams being good and bad teams being bad, but in a lot of other ways too.
Outside of gutted teams, which have been as issue for a long time, I didn't see the level of disparity in Season 4 as being a problem. When looking for close games to compare ypc and ypa to, any league I looked at, usually 10 of the 16 games would be close enough (within 21 points or so) to be worth looking at.
So, the majority of the games were reasonably competitive, probably the same number as in NCAA football. Now, we have the majority of the games not being reasonably competitive, with my best idea as to why being that the sim has become in some way more meritocratic in its outcome for each play.
I know that neither the team we trounced nor the team that trounced us had a bigger disadvantage or advantage in levels this season than last season, when we beat the first team by more like 20 points instead of 50 and were ahead in one of our games against the second after the 3rd quarter.
Originally posted by GG
And I'm disappointed that I got savaged in this thread for just trying to express my concerns of the idea being implemented, trying to urge caution in ringing in ideas that create disparity instead of ringing in ideas urgently that create parity. That priority went wrong putting disparity first.
I don't want to rekindle that argument, but you took the thread way, way off course, and that was what led to that. Instead of just saying what you thought, like, "This idea would be awful, as it will create more disparity, and the extra disparity isn't worth it," (and arguing that) you went into a lot of unrelated areas.