User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
Well manmade ideas and beliefs like religion is very much like magic beans. They both have the same end result, a fairy tale.


uh... and how is your comment not also a man-made idea/belief?
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
i think our experiences are a wash"

well, technically i said "from a rhetorical standpoint,

but even from a epistemological/evidential standpoint, it would still have to be a wash... not for either of us personally, but in the eyes of an unbiased stranger. i mean, i could use your own words on you and say:
"Don't give up on Logic. It's a world of pain. But the seed is planted, i know you will return to Reason. But man, the pain in between. I just hope you aren't as stubborn as i am. Yikes."

... and wouldn't that sound a little arrogant and self-righteous?


Yeah, i got a little self-righteous there, but you told me of your background, so i was reaching out to it i guess, your church experiences. Your example with word-swapping has me a little confused. I lived on logic and reason, they failed me, because i am a spiritual being, first and foremost. I do use reason and logic, however, it is not enough for me. I need more. And i've found the resources i need in the spiritual realm, even an overflowing abundance of such.

Epistemologically, our choices in those experiences define our eternal well-being, so i can't agree they are "a wash"

 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

Well manmade ideas and beliefs like religion is very much like magic beans. They both have the same end result, a fairy tale.


uh... and how is your comment not also a man-made idea/belief?


Great point, thanks.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


but again, i could just use your own words on you and say: as for your stance as an example... well, time will tell. as for me, i've found no holes in my view, so i'll stick with it.

and just to clarify... i haven't shifted my beliefs because of any "inductive/deductive analysis". if anything, its been more the absence of the same.



u left out the Miraculous Results = )
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Arguing logic with me will only get you so far. My frame of reference is the Bible and it truly is supernatural, whereas logic and reason are simply natural. The Bible includes the natural AND the supernatural concepts whereas your current stance completely ignores the supernatural. My frame of reference also has a final authority. A beginning and an end (Alpha and Omega). The experiment is already proven, it's just working its way through, so to speak.

So, what i'm saying is that eventually my points are not going to stand up to the limited analysis of the world's logic. Which, coincidentally is my point. God's way is not the way of the world, it is far different in its standards. However, the two can and do co-exist and therein lies the difficulty. Supernatural beings living in natural bodies... no wonder i was all screwed up. I didn't know. LOL
Last edited Aug 11, 2008 01:01:35
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Yeah, i got a little self-righteous there, but you told me of your background, so i was reaching out to it i guess, your church experiences. Your example with word-swapping has me a little confused. I lived on logic and reason, they failed me, because i am a spiritual being, first and foremost. I do use reason and logic, however, it is not enough for me. I need more. And i've found the resources i need in the spiritual realm, even an overflowing abundance of such.


well honestly, i was intentionally using those swapped words inaccurately, in the fashion of an unthinking atheist (nb. as differentiated from thinking atheists). i don't see a natural divide between logic/reason and religion... at a minimum, most religions are driven by an internal logic, else they wouldn't have any appeal at all. i'm guessing that as you approach your spiritual side, its with the exact same logical toolbox that you've always had. there's this common notion that somehow religion is devoid of reason and that the non-religious have a monopoly on logic... i completely disagree.

Originally posted by atom871
Epistemologically, our choices in those experiences define our eternal well-being, so i can't agree they are "a wash"


maybe i'm not being clear... i'm not trying to convince you that you should valorize our experiences equally. i'm saying that an unbiased stranger would have no other initial choice.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Arguing logic with me will only get you so far. My frame of reference is the Bible and it truly is supernatural, whereas logic and reason are simply natural. The Bible includes the natural AND the supernatural whereas your current stance completely ignores the supernatural.


i think i speak both tongues fluently... and it was my earlier point that empiricism presupposes the absence of the supernatural. however, logic and reason are tools, not beliefs... and so we can indeed use them to approach/understand the supernatural. in fact, the birth of these tools comes from that exact study.

and for the record, i do not presuppose against the supernatural. indeed, i'm even open to challenges against the presupposition of the natural... but that's another story.


Originally posted by atom871
So, what i'm saying is that eventually my points are not going to stand up to the limited analysis of the world's logic. Which, coincidentally is my point. God's way is not the way of the world, it is far different in its standards. However, the two can and do co-exist and therein lies the difficulties. Supernatural beings living in natural bodies. No wonder i was all screwed up. I didn't know LOL


there's still common ground, though. and that's why i have yet to try to prove/disprove any articles of your faith. i'm more than happy to bracket those things out, because they're idiocultural elements and thus unapproachable with only analytics. so my whole point is to shift away from induction/deduction and, with an eye on epistemology, instead move towards abductive reasoning or even rhetorical justification.

really, it all depends on what our goals are. i'd rather not aim at suasion, but instead go for understanding.
Last edited Aug 11, 2008 01:08:22
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


well honestly, i was intentionally using those swapped words inaccurately, in the fashion of an unthinking atheist (nb. as differentiated from thinking atheists). i don't see a natural divide between logic/reason and religion... at a minimum, most religions are driven by an internal logic, else they wouldn't have any appeal at all. i'm guessing that as you approach your spiritual side, its with the exact same logical toolbox that you've always had. there's this common notion that somehow religion is devoid of reason and that the non-religious have a monopoly on logic... i completely disagree.


I'm glad you see it that way, there is truth to that. The logical toolbox, great concept. Yes, i have one, but i went from SAE to Metric LOL. I had to throw out a lot of concepts i believed were logical and correct. I think i can use logic better now, in personal choices than before. I was blessed with an intellect and some capacity to use it, so my logical toolbox is intact, perhaps a bit larger now, different measurements, and probably a different color.


Originally posted by Catullus 16

maybe i'm not being clear... i'm not trying to convince you that you should valorize our experiences equally. i'm saying that an unbiased stranger would have no other initial choice.


OK, im with you now. The stranger would have no point of reference. Much like yourself, unless you choose to believe my story.

 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
I'm glad you see it that way, there is truth to that. The logical toolbox, great concept. Yes, i have one, but i went from SAE to Metric LOL. I had to throw out a lot of concepts i believed were logical and correct. I think i can use logic better now, in personal choices than before. I was blessed with an intellect and some capacity to use it, so my logical toolbox is intact, perhaps a bit larger now, different measurements, and probably a different color.

ha, yes... all part of the process.

ETA: and just to mention it, there's a twin notion that the non-religious are somehow devoid of morality because the religious have a monopoly on it... something i also disagree with.

Originally posted by atom871
OK, im with you now. The stranger would have no point of reference. Much like yourself, unless you choose to believe my story.

right... but when evaluating both our stories, i'm neither unbiased nor a stranger to my own. and i guess its that familiarity that makes us assume that if we could just articulate it well enough that anyone else would be similarly convinced. however, its probably good for us to try and fail on that... keeps us from just living in our own head, i suppose.
Last edited Aug 11, 2008 01:15:42
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

i think i speak both tongues fluently... and it was my earlier point that empiricism presupposes the absence of the supernatural. however, logic and reason are tools, not beliefs... and so we can indeed use them to approach/understand the supernatural. indeed, the birth of these tools comes from that exact study.


That would be like trying to frame out a wall with a frying pan and chef knife, wouldn't it? I guess reason and logic were applied to understand the supernatural, but ultimately, you would wind up with sauteed 2X4's in a cream sauce?

Originally posted by Catullus 16
and for the record, i do not presuppose against the supernatural. indeed, i'm even open to challenges against the presupposition of the natural... but that's another story.


i'm glad you clarified that. Logic and Reason presuppose against, but you aren't limiting yourself to that, correct?

Originally posted by Catullus 16


really, it all depends on what our goals are. i'd rather not aim at suasion, but instead go for understanding.


Ultimately, my goal would be persuasion, as i'm trying to convince you of something, to be quite honest. But i act only out of compassion for your current and eternal well-being. However, understanding is one pathway to that goal. You won't care how much i know until you know how much i care, eh?

 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
That would be like trying to frame out a wall with a frying pan and chef knife, wouldn't it? I guess reason and logic were applied to understand the supernatural, but ultimately, you would wind up with sauteed 2X4's in a cream sauce?

well, humans may be fundamentally ill-equipped for most of these types of inquiries... but that doesn't invalidate the attempt. besides... if your approach to the supernatural is through a text, then you can still use reason to differentiate between interpretations of that text. at a minimum, whatever your understanding of the supernatural, i'm guessing you apply its meaning to your life in a rational fashion.

the next move here isn't necessarily to cast doubt on logic (which i technically view as a subset of reason), but to cast doubt of propositional logic (a subset of logic proper). mathematicians and computer programmers have made strides in higher-order logic, but most philosophers (and the rest of us) are stuck with using language to discuss these things. i'm not convinced we have the semiotic wherewithal to grapple with the universe... at least, i think it should be recognized as a unsupported presupposition.


Originally posted by atom871
i'm glad you clarified that. Logic and Reason presuppose against, but you aren't limiting yourself to that, correct?

my little rant above notwithstanding, i am primarily bound by reason... but i am willing not to be overly analytical about it. but again, logic and reason don't presuppose anything... not even their own existence. its beliefs like empiricism (and most other strands of materialism) that are doing that sort of supposition... not the tools that serve to both undergird and challenge.


Originally posted by atom871
Ultimately, my goal would be persuasion, as i'm trying to convince you of something, to be quite honest. But i act only out of compassion for your current and eternal well-being. However, understanding is one pathway to that goal. You won't care how much i know until you know how much i care, eh?

well, to be frank... that's not a conversation i want to have... but then, most people don't appreciate unsolicited advice (no matter how well-intentioned).
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
btw, i'm going to call it a night (but not because of that last thing)... i'll swing by this thread tomorrow.
Last edited Aug 11, 2008 01:41:26
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


my little rant above notwithstanding, i am primarily bound by reason... but i am willing not to be overly analytical about it. but again, logic and reason don't presuppose anything... not even their own existence. its beliefs like empiricism (and most other strands of materialism) that are doing that sort of supposition... not the tools that serve to both undergird and challenge.


My problems arose as i limited myself to reason and logic, they failed, i needed a new toolbox, i suppose. Later, i found one that is more than adequate. I am free from the bonds of reason and logic, not that they are bad, just limited. In fact, they are useful and necessary. But, I have power tools now (ugh! ugh! Ruff!) a mighty fine workbench in my garage and i only use the wrenches and screwdrivers when situationally appropriate.

I was lumping empiricism, generally, in with logic and reason, though they should be seen at different levels. But all are subsets under God's laws which include all natural or supernatural arguments and devices.

Originally posted by Catullus 16
well, to be frank... that's not a conversation i want to have... but then, most people don't appreciate unsolicited advice (no matter how well-intentioned).


This is the Christian Club thread. You came here to talk about the nature of our existence as it relates to Jesus, knowing full well about the "Great Commission" (If i understand your background education correctly). You can't expect to debate here and not receive some preaching! LOL


 
Baghern
offline
Link
 
God only had one son.....

His name was....























KEVIN SORBO!!!!





 
smoy686
offline
Link
 
If this thread dies...will it be resurrected after three days?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.