User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Comet Elenin Tetrahedral Force Shield
Page:
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Hurricane hits the Newfies

DAMN YOU COMET ELENIN
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Herram this guy goes back to 2007 with Elenin and planetary alignment quakes. http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.2036






 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
2007?!?!?!?!?!?

how are we still alive???
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Herram
I understand that earthquake data may correlate with Elenin alignments, but there is a distinction between correlation and causation.

Moderate amount of math to follow:

It has been estimated that the total mass of all of the comets in our solar system approaches 2% of the mass of the sun. http://www.springerlink.com/content/q2p26v0521hj7lg3/

If Elenin was ~190 million miles away from the Earth on March 11th, and gravity is the only known force that Celestial bodies can impart on one another at that distance (forces that may influence plate tectonics, that is), then it needs to have a significant gravitational force.

The mass of the Earth is ~ 6 x 10^24 kilograms, and (to be fair, I'll make an assumption on the mass of Elenin based on the average mass of comets in the solar system) Elenin is probably close to 4 x 10^12, maybe as much as 4 x 10^16 kilograms.

Using the heavier of the weights for Elenin there, the difference between the Earth and Elenin's mass is ~ 10^8 kilograms, or 100 million kilograms. Using the lesser (10^12), it would be 1 trillion kilograms.

At ~190 million miles, a heavier Elenin would deliver 38,504,806.3 pounds of force on our dear old Earth. A lighter Elenin would deliver 3,850.5 pounds of force.

The Moon exerts its gravitational pull at a fairly constant rate of 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 kilograms from a mere 250,000 miles away.
In comparison, that is 4,200,000,000,000,000,000, or 4.2 quintillion pounds of force. This is a significant difference, for anyone unfamiliar with the term quintillion.

On March 11, 2011 that means Elenin got to pull on Earth at 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 38,504,806.3 = 1.1 x 10^12 (heavy Elenin) or 4.2 x 10 ^ 19 / 3,850.5 = 1.1 x 10 ^ 16 less force than the Moon applies to the Earth all day every day.

So, even using the probably way too heavy number for Elenin, it exerted 1/1,100,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth that day. With the lighter Elenin, 1/11,000,000,000,000,000 of the Moons effect on the Earth.

For all of the additional force of the Moon, its only appreciate effect on our planet is the tides.

Edit: Incorrectly referenced May 11th as the date of the Japanese earthquake.


math... Killing retarded thoughts since 1892
 
Xteh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Herram this guy goes back to 2007 with Elenin and planetary alignment quakes. http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.2036


Thank you. I'll read this tonight.

 
Xteh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Herram this guy goes back to 2007 with Elenin and planetary alignment quakes. http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.2036
Originally posted by Herram
Thank you. I'll read this tonight.



Ah, wow, this gentleman is an interesting character.

Here's the rub: He goes out of his way in this thesis to illustrate correlation, but fails to make any justifiable links with causation. None. He mentions that the celetial bodies "resonate", and that is his perceived cause of the seismic activity, but he does nothing to explain what this imaginary force is, or why it has any effect on Earth at all.

In addition to failing to prove any causal relationship, he omits data when attempting to imply correlation. For instance, he defines a quiescent (tranquil) period between the 17th and 19th of July, and omitted an earthquake in Kyrgystan that measured a 6.1, even though he indicates that his data is inclusive of all data 6.0 and above. He is filtering the data such that it fits his thesis, not building a thesis around data.

More to the point, not making his data inclusive of all earthquakes is a serious error. The Richter formula is ML = log10 A - log10 A0(delta), where A is the maximum point out on the W-A seismograph, and A0 is collected from several stations to act against the distance from the epicenter.

This means the difference between a 5.9 and 6.0 is about 70-75%? Why would you define an arbitrary limitation like that when more data would only substantiate your claim, unless the data under the measurement defies your theory?

His theory also completely eschews any mention of larger-than-average size comets, and a host of dwarf planets that make a comet, including Elenin, look insignificant. Do they not "resonate"? He has omitted bodies that would swallow Elenin, like Ceres, Vesta (which I think is almost 100x the size of Elenin).

The most significant detriment to his work is the scarcity of data related to the moon. He does mark lunar alignments when it is convenient, but his data fails to represent a statistical majority of the alignments with the most significant celestial body to our planet.

His graphs in Figure one show series of earthquakes in the form of magnitude opposite time, but the data points are equidistant, even with the time between the earthquakes are not. He omits earthquake touch points from this Figure as well, when it would favor displaying as an increasing curve. This is blatant data manipulation.

Here's the most major problem: Not once in 12 pages does he define the terms he uses as an alignment. Never.

In summation, his analysis is misleading. He demonstrates a misunderstanding of physics. It fails to prove causation between Elenin and earthquakes, and it laughably fails to prove even a reasonable correlation.

Edit: Typos
Edited by Herram on Sep 17, 2011 01:19:01
Edited by Herram on Sep 16, 2011 22:16:44
 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bushido Zin
no seriously: how is elenin causing earthquakes?


 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Herram
Ah, wow, this gentleman is an interesting character.

Here's the rub: He goes out of his way in this thesis to illustrate correlation, but fails to make any justifiable links with causation. None. He mentions that the celetial bodies "resonate", and that is his perceived cause of the seismic activity, but he does nothing to explain what this imaginary force is, or why it has any effect on Earth at all.

In addition to failing to prove any causal relationship, he omits data when attempting to imply correlation. For instance, he defines a quiescent (transquil) period between the 17th and 19th of July, and omitted an earthquake in Kyrgystan that measured a 6.1, even though he indicates that his data is inclusive of all data 6.0 and above. He is filtering the data such that it fits his thesis, not building a thesis around data.

More to the point, not making his data inclusive of all earthquakes is a serious error. The Richter formula is ML = log10 A - log10 A0(delta), where A is the maximum point out on the W-A seismograph, and A0 is collected from several stations to act against the distance from the epicenter.

This means the difference between a 5.9 and 6.0 is about 70-75%? Why would you define an arbitrary limitation like that when more data would only substantiate your claim, unless the data under the measurement defies your theory?

His theory also completely eschews any mention of larger-than-average size comets, and a host of dwarf planets that make a comet, including Elenin, look insignificant. Do they not "resonate"? He has omitted bodies that would swallow Elenin, like Ceres, Vesta (which I think is almost 100x the size of Elenin).

The most significant detriment to his work is the scarcity of data related to the moon. He does mark lunar alignments when it is convenient, but his data fails to represent a statistical majority of the alignments with the most significant celestial body to our planet.

His graphs in Figure one show series of earthquakes in the form of magnitude opposite time, but the data points are equidistant, even with the time between the earthquakes are not. He omits earthquake touch points from this Figure as well, when it would favor displaying as an increasing curve. This is blatant data manipulation.

Here's the most major problem: Not once in 12 pages does he define the terms he uses as an alignment. Never.

In summation, his analysis is misleading. He demonstrates a misunderstanding of physics. It fails to prove causation between Elenin and earthquakes, and it laughably fails to prove even a reasonable correlation.

Edit: Typos



Originally posted by Mightyhalo

wait wait... that wasnt the guy i wanted you to disprove since most of my data and the foundation of my story is based on all of his work......



all joking aside. this is why i bring up space debris and satellites all the time. They are held by nothing by the earths gravity and speed. if this comet was causing earthquakes, we would have no satellite tv, gps, cellphones or any other space based communications/defense/locators. if this comet was influencing tectonic plates that are closer to the center of the earth..... these sats would have been flung off a long time ago.
Edited by Whatsdafus on Sep 16, 2011 22:45:58
Edited by Whatsdafus on Sep 16, 2011 22:42:51
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
2007?!?!?!?!?!?

how are we still alive???


SCIENCE
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
We have satellite doom. Perfect timing too. http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/09/15/7782656-satellites-doom-coming-sooner

For Herram, I certainly appreciate the effort and I have never said I had all the answers, all I know is when Elenin has lined up with the earth and the Sun, mega earthquakes have happened the last 3 times.

The good but wacky Doctor took it even further with his paper.

I think this page gives a visual example of one of the theories that all planetary bodies in the solar system are connected to the sun with a Magnetic band, and somehow that band is disturbed when Elenin aligns with the Earth and the Sun and disturbs our own magnetic field, which has lead some people to speculate that there will be a pole shift when Elenin aligns again in 10 days. http://iswa.gsfc.nasa.gov:8080/IswaSystemWebApp/iSWACygnetStreamer?timestamp=2038-01-23+00%3A44%3A00&window=-1&cygnetId=261
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Elenin should be moving into LASCO 3 field of view in the next couple of days which should give us a good look at her. http://sohodata.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/soho_movie_theater

Also around the same time Elenin shows up on LASCO 3 and the NASA satellite crashes to earth, small asteroid 2007 TD will also pass close to the earth. http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=2007%20TD;orb=1

This article on the satellite says, "Although NASA has said the chances of the wreckages of the defunct satellite falling to the Earth is very remote, yet the space agency officials cautioned that the uncontrolled falling of the debris may cause risk to billions of people.
http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/211637/20110910/nasa-falling-satellite-uars-satellite-debris.htm
Edited by Mightyhalo on Sep 17, 2011 05:48:02
Edited by Mightyhalo on Sep 17, 2011 05:45:15
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
The other thing that bothered me last night was the limited information, especially limited infrared pictures of Elenin and it lead to some interesting videos from Brazil.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_NjyuaGimE

I like this one, especially the image of what looks like a cluster or even a spiral at 14:50.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mgc9dL-DaF8&feature=feedu

Probably the best one because he finds that there has never been a comet recorded that has an orbit closest to Earth. Since Elenin is riding along the ecliptic plane while passing by and in front of our orbit, unlike any comet ever recorded before, we will actually take the brunt of the debris field/gas cloud in Early November head on? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pn4gAZYPW3Q

At one point they scared the crap out of everyone when they said Elenin's coma was bigger than Jupiter. http://spaceobs.org/en/2011/08/04/diameter-of-coma-of-comet-elenin-exceeded-200000-km/

Even looking at the Elenin-Honda-Levy JPL program you can see how Honda and Levy have orbits that don't even come close to Elenins.http://elenin.org/honda-levy.php

Elenin just keeps on giving.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
I'm gong to pull out all my RRSPs

no need for retirement with Elenin coming
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
I'm gong to pull out all my RRSPs

no need for retirement with Elenin coming


some massive earthquakes probably aren't going to kill you.

you have at least another year to enjoy your games
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Herram
I understand that earthquake data may correlate with Elenin alignments, but there is a distinction between correlation and causation.


I agree with you and we are just trying to figure out why this correlation exists.

Maybe someone is using these Elenin alignments as the time to fuck around with the HAARP system. It would certainly deflect attention. We don't know.

So I'm interested in hearing new speculation. We all know it SHOULDN'T be happening, but it is. Instead of being a dickhead about it (not you, but others), why not just have fun with it?

If something major happens around Sept 25th-26th, then we aren't going to gloat that we were right, because we still don't know what is causing this to happen. We are simply guessing and throwing out new theories. After all, Einstein and other pretty smart guys admitted that we don't have it all figured out when it comes to the universe. It is kind of funny that some people in here think that they have.

Until you all have a better explanation for why this stuff is happening near the alignment dates, then at least be open to hearing some wild theories. Nearly all of which are going to be proven to be false.
Edited by SteelersInsider on Sep 17, 2011 11:23:00
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.