Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Herram this guy goes back to 2007 with Elenin and planetary alignment quakes. http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.2036
Originally posted by Herram
Thank you. I'll read this tonight.
Ah, wow, this gentleman is an interesting character.
Here's the rub: He goes out of his way in this thesis to illustrate correlation, but fails to make any justifiable links with causation. None. He mentions that the celetial bodies "resonate", and that is his perceived cause of the seismic activity, but he does nothing to explain what this imaginary force is, or why it has any effect on Earth at all.
In addition to failing to prove any causal relationship, he omits data when attempting to imply correlation. For instance, he defines a quiescent (tranquil) period between the 17th and 19th of July, and omitted an earthquake in Kyrgystan that measured a 6.1, even though he indicates that his data is inclusive of all data 6.0 and above. He is filtering the data such that it fits his thesis, not building a thesis around data.
More to the point, not making his data inclusive of all earthquakes is a serious error. The Richter formula is ML = log10 A - log10 A0(delta), where A is the maximum point out on the W-A seismograph, and A0 is collected from several stations to act against the distance from the epicenter.
This means the difference between a 5.9 and 6.0 is about 70-75%? Why would you define an arbitrary limitation like that when more data would only substantiate your claim, unless the data under the measurement defies your theory?
His theory also completely eschews any mention of larger-than-average size comets, and a host of dwarf planets that make a comet, including Elenin, look insignificant. Do they not "resonate"? He has omitted bodies that would swallow Elenin, like Ceres, Vesta (which I think is almost 100x the size of Elenin).
The most significant detriment to his work is the scarcity of data related to the moon. He does mark lunar alignments when it is convenient, but his data fails to represent a statistical majority of the alignments with the most significant celestial body to our planet.
His graphs in Figure one show series of earthquakes in the form of magnitude opposite time, but the data points are equidistant, even with the time between the earthquakes are not. He omits earthquake touch points from this Figure as well, when it would favor displaying as an increasing curve. This is blatant data manipulation.
Here's the most major problem: Not once in 12 pages does he define the terms he uses as an alignment. Never.
In summation, his analysis is misleading. He demonstrates a misunderstanding of physics. It fails to prove causation between Elenin and earthquakes, and it laughably fails to prove even a reasonable correlation.
Edit: Typos