User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB - aren't you removing the fun out of the game?
Page:
 
jtrav21
taco
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Good post PT.. Agree with everything.

If you did make EQ much cheaper though, wouldn't you see more players having two sets of EQ, with the possibility to change the outlook of that player by a lot from game to game..? Could be done effectively for CBs, WRs and HBs maybe.. So when my CB was playing slow/agility based WRs he would have EQ set 1 equipped, and when he was playing speedsters he would have EQ set 2 equipped..?


I actually think that would be a great idea on the basis that it would allow the players to be more involved in the gameplanning. Depending on opponents you move it around and allows alot more flexibility.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
This may sound weird since this is an online multiplayer dotball game... But its not very realistic (...) when a player suddenly gains +20 speed, +20 carrying or whatever. And it would make gameplanning a lot harder, if you played against a team with 55 players that all had 2 sets of EQ....

I'm not saying all this will happen, but that would be the wrong way to get players/agents more involved in gameplanning.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
TBQF the game should just be base EQ and let SA's actually play a part in build before the build is on it's last legs. Just saying.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Good post PT.. Agree with everything.

If you did make EQ much cheaper though, wouldn't you see more players having two sets of EQ, with the possibility to change the outlook of that player by a lot from game to game..? Could be done effectively for CBs, WRs and HBs maybe.. So when my CB was playing slow/agility based WRs he would have EQ set 1 equipped, and when he was playing speedsters he would have EQ set 2 equipped..?


Yes to some extent. There is nothing really keeping most players from having two sets of equipment in the past using cash farms but I really don't see much of a benefit with the exception of maybe a dual threat QB or TE. I have a rushing QB that has two sets of equipment but the way the sim is set up he sucks as a rusher and a passer so kind of a mute point.

I guess I could take one my combo backs and turn him into a pure power back or more of a speedster but then it would take away from what he does best anyway.

If it is that big of a deal they could always limit normal equipment pieces to one piece per slot or just alow a set maximum.
Edited by PierreThomas on Feb 22, 2010 00:48:34
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Equipment is pretty much fundamentally bum jumped
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
lol this shit is still going?
 
jxgator33
offline
Link
 
Great post PT, PT for Catch V2 imo
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanb1979
lol this shit is still going?


when PT is rolling out pure gold at the average of once a week, this could last forever...
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Nobody wants to publicly agree with account mergers... lulz...
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
True but there are so many out there
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
True but there are so many out there


 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by onepeat
burn this mutha fucka down!!!

if you people do not listen to PT, your game will remain broke and people will continue to bail. its just a matter of time before i run through my flex...


Very close to the end myself.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by odg62

No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.

Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.

Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?

The poor decision was reversing the original plan.



Something tells me you just don't get it. I see you don't own a team, you don't have any players that have reached level 64 and needed equipment, you have one player that has reached level 56, you don't have any players in pro or WL. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being a noob of sorts but you really don't have any experience to speak from when it comes to managing finances at a high level or managing a competitive team.

Mergers are not the problem. The problem is when a majority of the really good teams have left the game from boredom and burnout that there is very few highly competitive teams left and when those good teams go away the players migrate to the handful of great teams that can pay for equipment upgrades and they know they'll win. This is what created the parity void, not mergers.

The rule change wasn't going to hurt the elite teams because they are already set, it was going to hurt the up and coming agents such as yourself because they would never be able to get an equal competitive advantage. Don't believe me? We have several slow build teams about the same level as most of your players, each of the teams have well over a hundred million in the bank and they will all get home field just about every season. Those teams will be able to afford lvl 64 equipment and will be able to rework equipment whenever needed.

These teams didn't cheat or game the system. They simply started over and have a truck load of cash from it. So which team has the advantage, the one scrapping by each season to upgrade about half the team or the one that if fully upgraded and can rework equipment to adapt to an ever changing sim?

I think you completely misinterpreted my post. I'm not for cash farm teams. I've been against them for a long time but I'm also not dumb enough to think they aren't needed to keep up with the Jones'. As far as the thrones go, what better way to take away the hierarchy's advantage than to level the playing field by making equipment equally affordable to all?



If you are simply complaining about teams being able to remain competitive by bringing in new players each season to replace the old then I'm not quite sure hot to comment on that. Would that be kind of like an NFL team having to try and build through the draft and unrestricted free agent rookies every ten seasons instead of using free agency, the draft, trades and practice squads? Yeah, doesn't make much sense now does it?


You may think that the agents with big accounts that have been around forever and are constantly online are trying to whine to game the system but you might be surprised how many people are not. You might be quite surprised to find out just how many of these players are really concerned about the state of the game because they not only have a lot of money, time and energy invested in the game but they also really enjoy playing it and enjoy the friendships that have been made. Most of the long term agents in this game really do want improvement for the game. When we first started in season one and two, it was almost impossible to find level one players willing to sign. I remember the day I got my team I spent 30 consecutive hours recruiting and managed to sign on about ten level one players. I made about fifteen more players and the agents that had already signed created a few more dots and over the next couple weeks managed to get a full team. It probably took 80 hours of recruiting to get it done, now new players have a very difficult time even finding a team. There were 600-750 teams a season being released and the game was doubling in size every few days. By season 7 there were a hundred really good teams and the parity from pro league all the way down to A leagues was pretty damn good. There were some teams in A and BBB leagues that could beat some pro teams. The game was full of excitement, people stayed on the game all day long and the forums had hundreds of threads a day.

Since that time the game has gone down. More people are leaving or losing interest now than are coming in. One of the main reasons is that the game has gotten so damn complicated that a new player can't walk in and possibly fully grasp the game for months. When the game started, a defensive coordinator could set to defend the pass XX%, defend the run XX% and choose how often to defend the inside/outside run or how deep to defend and whether to run zone or man. That is it. A gameplan took ten minutes. Now I'm not saying it should be that simple now but I do think the more we as agents crave the ability to do new stuff like custom depth chart spots, tagging, packages, defensive play creator, route progressions, etc. we are improving the realistic aspect of the game and open endless possibilities. However, at the same time we are making it harder and harder to bring in new players so when the old die out there aren't enough people there to take their place. Not only are there not enough newer players but they can't connect to the game like the early agents could because it was so easy to get involved in the early seasons compared to now where you need to get an online bachelor's degree in AI management just to understand how to play. Before you could worry about stuff like posting in the team forum and shooting the shit with other players, now you have to spend hours on gameplanning. While I would love parity, I'm sure as hell glad that the two main teams I do the most with wont have another competitive game until week thirteen. I used to look forward to the competitive games, now I like looking forward to them way off but as they get close I lose the excitement because I know I'll have to spend hours gameplanning.

This is the best part of the season for me because I can relax. The playoffs are extremely stressful because I have to gameplan for hours for one game for every team I help with and then each of these teams have back to back to back games resulting in a 2-3 games a day @ 2-3 hours a piece for a week straight. If I didn't own my business I would literally have to take a week off work just to get gameplanning done for the playoffs. That is followed by the offseason where we have to manage a handful of rosters, recruit, get players signed, rework VAs and learn a completely new sim each season.

While the realism is great, I don't think working the same hours as an NFL GM was ever really the realism goal. It is no wonder owners can't find coordinators, coordinators get burned out to the point they completely lose interest in the game and suddenly the game starts really declining.

I know Catch is working on putting together another type of league in between casual and the advanced leagues and I even suggested this several seasons back but at this point I think that is a terrible idea as well. Casual leagues had a chance to be an incredible tool for the game but it fell short by not allowing teams to transfer to casual and limiting the casual leagues to lower level players immediately eliminating half the game from being able to participate without starting at level one. Then the casual leagues were too casual. it was like showing up in board shorts and wife beater to a nice steak house that advertises casual dining.

Now a middle league is basically just going to pull some people craving something new from casual and normal leagues giving us three types of leagues with no parity and a huge void in all three leagues.


These are my suggestions to really fix this game quickly or at the very least make it much more stable.

The very first thing that needs to be done is to make equipment very affordable. My suggestion to make things easy to simply make equipment 30% less expensive at each level that way you can keep finances exactly the way they are you don't have to rework the entire finance system. Allow users to get a full flex credit when swapping out custom equipment once each offseason to ajust to the sim. Allow 30 VA point reset each offseason. This will allow teams to adapt to the sim every season. It will allow parity between the rich and the poor. This will eliminate the need to cheat because lets face it, the financial system in this game is not so enjoyable that it makes trying to police the cheating and colluding worth it.

Allow full account mergers for one week again then put the clamps down on multi's because it seems like everyone I talk to has multiple accounts now and it isn't enforced it is something that needs to be done away with. I don't care if you have to charge 500 flex to merge accounts it really needs to get done. The combination of the affordable equipment and the account mergers will instantly eliminate almost all of the useless teams out there making these 255-0 games and free up a lot more players that are sitting on farm teams to collect huge amounts of money so they can sign with the teams that really are trying to compete.

This will also give you a much more realistic idea where the game stands. Now that you have gotten here, condense the leagues instead of filling the holes with computer teams. Computer teams and players should be a last resort of sorts. When reworking the leagues have them set up with appropriate level caps and floors. You can still have some uncapped minor teams but make the owners choose whether they want to play in a competitive league or have their friend with an inappropriately high/low level player on the roster. It they are in uncapped leagues then it is by their own choice and they can't complain about the lack of parity. When setting up the cap leagues find a way to work in creation date to get rid of SSB teams. Make it to where there is a limit on how many SSB and non boosters can play on one team.

Those things will instantly create parity where there is none. Sure, every game wont be a nail-biter but at least people will log on to see if they won, they might even go into the league forums to see rankings and find discussion. This will go such a long way to really help the game as a whole.


The next thing that needs to be done is find a way to greatly reduce the workload on owners and coordinators. Fixing equipment prices will do a lot of that because they wont have to recruit player x to team B, load up the cash in team B for player x, wait 6 days then trade player B from team x to team y just to buy equipment for a player.

I don't know enough about coding to really help much in this area. I know the AI needs to be made much simpler. Maybe have a skeleton AI that has just about every possibility listed and set accordingly already so teams just have to add the plays but can still expand on it. Another thing I know is needed is to have the inputs expanded to where you can set them to fire between certain times. ie: 2nd down 5, strong i, between 200 seconds and 500 seconds run x. Not a lot but something that would help.

One thing I do know that could be a huge time saver is a real comprehensive scouting program. I love the scouting feature that was added but when it comes time to really gameplan it becomes a pretty big waste since it isn't nearly comprehensive enough. Features need to be added but it would help so much. Make dropdown boxes for down and distance so it is much more specific. Right now 3rd and 3-10 just doesn't cut it. Also add another drop down feature to sort plays based on where on the field they take place. Plays inside the 5 are usually very different from plays between the 40s. Then another drop down box with player names that breaks down the play calls based on which players are in, also combinations of players. If you want to keep tagging this is an option that makes tagging much less work. This would save so much time from trying to watch replays, see which formation is being run from which down and distance and figure out which players are on the field then trying to find like situations to see if there is a trend.

The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers.


I know some of this would cost some short term flex monies but I promise it would be returned with plenty to spare.

This turned into a mega post and I can't believe I took the time but it feels like time is running out on keeping GLB around as a great and fun game. I will put myself out there to help out in some areas of the game. I know I've been a very harsh critic for a long time but I really do think Bort is taking steps to try and fix some long term problems. The hiring of Catch was a great step in the right direction and if you guys think I can help then I'd be willing.











Sorry this is late but I was home sparingly over the last 3 weeks and didnt really get a chance to check the fourms, glad i checked in here.

I expected my post to ruffle a few feathers but man that is one long post, shame is you wasted your time with a lot of it as i'll point out soon.

First things first - If you want to go around calling people noob and questioning their experience in the game, make sure you direct those comments at the correct individuals.

For the record, I signed up day 1 season 2 and have DC'd 3 diffrent teams at the pro level (2 before WL, 1 overlapped) while being involved significantly in the finances and overall operation of two of those teams, both of which i worked with from A leauges up to pro.

All three of my fully built first generation players went well past lvl 56 and played in the pro's and my FS would be there now if I wasent loyal to his current team and my lvl 49 CB could go pro next season if i decide to do so with him.

As i said before, make sure you get it right next time you decide to try to put someones point of view down by questioning their GLB credentials.

So in short, yes i do know about managment and finances of high level competitive teams. I have been directly involved in managment and have had several players on such teams, so the 50% of your mega post that mistakenly condesended to me as a "noob" while rehashing a bunch of aspects of the game that someone as expereinced as you or me already knew a long time ago really was just a waste of time and space in this case.

OK, now that that is out of the way back to the actual issue....

To start, bottom line, the fact that it is so easy to replace an entire roster is no doubt one of the top reasons that parity is non existant in GLB.

85% of the top talent is on 5% of the top teams.

Right away, you hit the nail on the head when you talk about how top teams merging is what killed parity, go search my posts way back and you will see i have been saying that for a long time and no where did i say anything diffrent.

Guess what the proposed roster limits would have done....Severly limited that practice!

Yeah, bad change for the game....

You talk about how good teams are already set and up and comers would be hurt as a result of the change. That dosent make sense. How does the top teams continuing to pull 85% of the best talent while everyone else battles over whats left (the way it is now) not hurt the game the way you say the change will?

And on a side note, how many of those elite teams are still enjoying the benefits of the early GLB bug in ticket sales that gave a few teams 10's of million more dollars than everyone else?

Now, farm teams for the most part, i dont have a problem with. There is a problem with farm teams and that is being able to concievably turnover your entire roster as needed.

You talk about NFL teams only building through the draft and RFA's. Not really a good point or a a good represntation of how rosters would work post change. The thing wrong with your logic is you act like the changes would keep you from getting new guys for 10 seasons, wrong, it would keep you from replacing your entire starting defense with younger players that are the same talent level or better every 3 seasons.

Try looking at it like this - Name me one NFL team that has the kind of turnover that GLB teams with farm teams have? How many NFL teams have an entire starting roster thats ready to play competitivley from day 1 just waiting in the wings ready to step in ASAP every three seaons or as soon as the current guys turn 31? How often does one NFL team just up and decide to funnel all their best players to another team at the start of the season? How many NFL teams have 55 starters on their roster? Thats how GLB is right now. Dosent make much sense does it?

If you think its normal for NFL teams to change the rosters the way GLB teams do, you need to reevaluate your perception of how rosters really work.

With farm teams, its more of the same as the mergers. It condenses the talent onto a few teams while everyone in the middle fights for whats left. As long as teams can just turn over entire rosters while 30 mid tier teams fight over the same player who isnt in a network there will never be any change in the team heirarchy of the game. Tell me thats good for the game.

You limit it to 5 players per season from farm teams and you open up a floodgate of talent to everyone else. Farm teams can still send their best, just not a whole new team, and everyone else gets a lot more to choose from.

In other words, you give a major boost to the up and comers prevent elite teams from having a permanent top notch roster and most importantly PROMOTE PARITY.

Bottom line, if you want to make this game right and maximize FAIR PLAY and ENJOYMENT for ALL users then you make the changes.

Everyone of them would have promoted overall parity and stopped shady money practices.

If you (you is in general here, not you specifically PT) really are interested in the attainment of parity and the old level of competition that GLB used to have then you would support these changes....unless your not as good as you want everone to think and you know you need to hog all the talent in order to keep getting W's.

If your really that good at GLB you should not be scared of these changes and in fact should welcome them so you can win a leauge and not a 4 team playoff.

#####

For the rest of your post - You talk about reasons people ar losing intrest and all legitimate, but i feel pretty confident saying that none of those reasons even come close to the fact that anyone with any intellegence can look at the game now and realize in about 15 seconds that they will never be able to compete with the teams that are on top due to the way they condense all the talent and anyone who has been playing for even a few seasons can predict within a game what their teams record will be before the season even starts.

All your suggestions are good, i especially agree with making equip affordable for whatever it may be worth. But none of them come close to taking the hard stance that the changes did and forcing all teams to draw talent on a much, much, much more level feild, again fair play and enjoymanet for all should be the goal of the game.

 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
too long : did not read
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
too long : did not read


Well PT's called me out so i kinda had to read his....

But anyway, nice to see the fourms are still overflowing with original thoughts after a few weeks!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.