Originally posted by Rix2Sam
Originally posted by redwolfe11
quality wins are worth more than quality losses.
Careful, careful, careful. We would not have had the title in 1993 with that thinking.
I agree with Gorilla in principal - in a string of one loss teams, the one with the worst loss comes out on top when you go based on head-to-head. Hypothetically say that FSU, Florida, and Tennessee each lost one game and were in contention for the National Championship Game. Tennessee lost to UF and UF lost to FSU (this is the part I like). Based on the head-to-head, FSU should go to the national title game. But consider that FSU picked up their loss against a team with 2 or more losses. We'd be sending the team with the WORST loss to the title game (incidentally I'm fine with that in this scenario). Shouldn't we send the team with the highest-quality loss - Tennessee? Incidentally, UF doesn't go to the game either way in this scenario, which is also fine with me.
That being said, I think his rankings are fair.First, let me say I think your scenario sucks.

While I agree with the overall logic, head-to-head can only be useful to a point, especially in leagues with a lot of parity. And going beyond head-to-head complicates it exponentially. Look at a real life example last year. Georgia was pounded by Tennessee, yet Georgia pounded UF who had pounded UT, and nobody would say Tennessee was better than Georgia last year.
It's even worse on GLB, where a team can vary from very bad at the beginning of the season to very good at the end or vice versa. Use the Exiles as an extreme example this season. Miami beat them 26-14, Hogtown beat them 49-13. No way in hell is that representative of the two teams strength. As fluid as team strengths are in this game, even on a game by game basis, if I were doing rankings, I'd think twice about using games more than 2 or 3 previous as a measure of a team's strength. In GLB, "What have you done recently" truly is very important.