I posted this back in November, but...
Originally posted by
Having played in the minors for some time now (and doing quite well), I noticed that basically, teams have to be slow build or super slow build in order to compete. As such, new players are often pushed away from the game because of the utter annihilation they receive from SSB teams looking to get some cheap trophies.
Bort has since said he is willing to find a way to sort out the leagues that would hinder or stop the advantage of those who SSB.
That is what I am trying to do. Instead of doing anything too crazy that would involve a lot of human judgement, I am instead trying to come up with a formula that will act as a "composite" to make future leagues possible and easy for Bort to do.
The basis for the cap structure is no longer level based, but age based. This key change immediately eliminates a lot of the disparity between SSB teams and regular teams, since teams will be facing those of the same age, not the same level.
As of right now, this composite takes into account three key parts of any team:
1. Median Level
2. Median Age (in days)
3. Win Percentage
When leagues are made for the Day 120 Cap, players from level 13-24 will be all in the same cap, all anywhere from 80-160 days old (if not more). Immediately, this formula would set them into leagues that would best give a good level of competition:
Composite = (Level/7 + Age/40 + Win%)/3
Here is an example of the composite in action using the 120 Day Cap and random team data: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0Am4gexSADI2_dHdjZkw4NXZRbDhzMGQ4Z0dyRUd3Rmc&hl=en
Some key concerns...
What does this do to stop SSB?
- Since the caps are based on age, SSB players will be playing against players of their own age, which immediately lowers their chances of being better because of incredibly long spans of training.
What does this do to stop tanking to stay in the same cap?
- Teams are immediately moved up to the next cap and reshuffled based on the composite score. If a team tanks, they are still going to be facing players the same age, but will be facing teams of a similar composite score.
What about non-boosters?
- Because level is taken into account, non-boosters will be placed into leagues predominantly filled with younger players or with other non-boosters. They will still have fair competition.
Wouldn't that discourage boosting?
- No, those teams that boost will always have an advantage over those that don't. With this system, teams would actually see a benefit to boosting because the difference between builds is far more surmountable by boosting, as opposed to a 40 day old level 13 trying to boost to compete with a 120 day old level 13.Basically, sorting by record is fine, but why not include age and level into the mix?