User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by beenlurken


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by lukin83




Originally posted by lukin83





Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


I am not sure I understand you reasoning that it will not "ensure the best of the best year in and year out". There is no way to ensure that the very best teams are in this league every year (at least for the first few seasons... unless you hand pick the teams that are perceived to be the very best). Also this is predicated on the notion that leagues are superior to others. Eventually all regions will be on the same level and you will have the best teams of each region representing them.


 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Originally posted by Pariah

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by jamz




Originally posted by Bort





I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


This is the only way Bort, that the game will progress.

Again, what right does the extra 3-13 team in Pro League have to be there because there are 2 below him that already demoted, Promote the AAA Teams, Demote the WPL Teams as needed, and force more Pro teams that suck back to AAA.


I agree with Jamz.... teams that are 3-13 or 4-12 seem to stick around Pro leagues for ever....give people more of a chance. Plus it will increase the chance that new teams can work their way up the ranks faster and play in the WPL sooner than 9 seasons.


And give those teams a chance to maybe win some games in AAA instead?


They deserve AAA much more than Pro. And they will compete a lot more in AAA than Pro. And if they are deadbeats at least they aren't holding a coveted spot in a Pro League.




Exactly Bort, the game is more enjoyable for all teams involved if they all can compete more evenly, regardless of level.

Going 2-14 sucks, even if you're in the Pros.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by beenlurken

Fuck it... obviously no decision is going to be made until USA is happy. Promote them (the Pro league... they deserve it... they are the uber league) to the WPL for season 11. Realign the USA league to make up for this. For season 12, relegate the non-playoff teams to where ever. They shouldnt care... all of their friends/rivalries are still in WPL (they had their chance to stay there). From there we promote 2 conference champions from each league and demote 16 teams to where ever (again the USA whiners had there chance and are split everywhere now). Repeat.....




Edited by beenlurken on Jul 27, 2009 20:40:40
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GBPackerFan
Originally posted by walker1

Originally posted by walker1


Originally posted by walker1



Originally posted by walker1




Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.










Simple. If your not in the playoffs you go back to the region you were promoted from. If more teams are demoted to that region then were promoted and there are no cpu teams to make up the difference the worst pro team in that region will be demoted to AAA so the pro league has room for your WL demotion.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by beenlurken



Originally posted by lukin83




Originally posted by lukin83





Originally posted by lukin83






Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


I am not sure I understand you reasoning that it will not "ensure the best of the best year in and year out". There is no way to ensure that the very best teams are in this league every year (at least for the first few seasons... unless you hand pick the teams that are perceived to be the very best). Also this is predicated on the notion that leagues are superior to others. Eventually all regions will be on the same level and you will have the best teams of each region representing them.




 
Link
 
If you are going to demote randomly, then you need to randomly reorganize pro, aaa, and aa in all regions. Demoting teams back to their original region will likely just cause another cpu team or gutted team to move back down like they were going to anyways. If they aren't cpu or gutting then they will likely be 3-13 or 4-12 and really have no argument that they can compete in the upper leagues anyways.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Originally posted by GBPackerFan

Originally posted by walker1


Originally posted by walker1



Originally posted by walker1




Originally posted by walker1





Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.










Simple. If your not in the playoffs you go back to the region you were promoted from. If more teams are demoted to that region then were promoted and there are no cpu teams to make up the difference the worst pro team in that region will be demoted to AAA so the pro league has room for your WL demotion.


Alright thanks.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by beenlurken



Originally posted by lukin83




Originally posted by lukin83





Originally posted by lukin83






Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


I am not sure I understand you reasoning that it will not "ensure the best of the best year in and year out". There is no way to ensure that the very best teams are in this league every year (at least for the first few seasons... unless you hand pick the teams that are perceived to be the very best). Also this is predicated on the notion that leagues are superior to others. Eventually all regions will be on the same level and you will have the best teams of each region representing them.




Outside of a tournament this is the best he can do. The "WPL" is the peoples choice.....not Borts..I think people need to remember that as we move forward. Pro league teams are about to plateau...there is no way to predict who the up and coming teams and leagues will be. By keeping entrance to the WPL even over time parity between leagues will exist.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2
If you are going to demote randomly, then you need to randomly reorganize pro, aaa, and aa in all regions. Demoting teams back to their original region will likely just cause another cpu team or gutted team to move back down like they were going to anyways. If they aren't cpu or gutting then they will likely be 3-13 or 4-12 and really have no argument that they can compete in the upper leagues anyways.


There's no need for randomness. All we need to do is demote a bad pro team to AAA to make room for the WL demotion.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.
 
HULK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Stop being bias and go somewhere else. You have no clue how good other teams are compared to teams in other leagues. You are USAPL bias, and on the Washington Wolfpack. Seriously.....the USAPL whiners are the reason this thing almost didn't happen in the first place. You also suggested using fake tournaments and biased polls. Thats a fail...did the wolfpack do well or something?


ITT: ITS looking to avoid the best of the best teams.

Why don't you accept ***O*** challenge if you want to prove how good the Kai is?



Playing the Cobra Kai is a privilege. I received several nasty pm's from the owner. I don't accept challenges from people who are rude/disrespectful. I told him in my first response I would play him first thing next season because Im busy and he threw a fit and sent nasty pms. That guy will never get a scrim from me. He will have to play me in the WPL if he wants a shot at the Cobra Kai. He is a waste of 25fp. Had he been nice and respectful I would have considered accepting. Now Im going to refuse to spite him......that alone will make it burn even more and does more damage than any scrim victory we would have over him could do.

ETA: Enough of this....please stay on topic.



I don't want to go off topic, but please don't lie. I did NOT send you "several nasty PMs". I sent you two and they were not nasty.

Here they are, uneditted:


----------------------

Thats a pretty weak excuse.

---------- Original message ----------
From: ImTheScientist
Date: Jul 26, 2009 08:07:14
Subject: Re: Scrim Challenge Sent for D39
To: HULK

All my teams are in the playoff hunts, and I OC for all of them. No time for scrims right now. Maybe next season.

Regards,
ITS

---------- Original message ----------
From: HULK
Date: Jul 26, 2009 08:03:34
Subject: Scrim Challenge Sent for D39
To: ImTheScientist

Please accept.

No token boosting in scrims.



--------------------
You don't want to play us, fine. You don't have to lie and make up excuses though.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
My suggestion....

Exact same structure in place now, except remove the clouds, and have regions again right thru and capping each league. All regions even in number of teams and leagues.

League split up into 2 conferences of 9 teams each. Each conference plays 8 games against only their conference.

This right thru from pro down to B.

Playoffs occur as per normal, with top 4 teams each conference, in a knockout of 8.

Culminates in league championship wins, etc.

Completion of which....

WL (world league) Tournament starts up (sometime around day 20 ish).

Top 2 or 4 teams from every LEAGUE (not conference) from every region get split off into WL sub-divisions.
Pro-AAA-AA-BBB-BB-B.
Begins series of round robin or knockout tournaments culminating in WL Trophy wins for the winning team.
Pro WL Champion.
AAA WL Champion.
etc.

Teams not split off to participate in WL sub-divisions have series of LIVE scrimmages against teams in their same league but from the other conference. These games will also help determine in the end which teams are demoted from league to league.

League games, WL, and Live scrimmages will earn XP and level up.

Overall attempted outcome is that every team ends up playing 16 games and fitting into the 40 day season span.
Just split down into a 20 day League Structure involving 9 teams per conference, 18 per league.
Then the next 20 days involving WL games and Live regional scrimmages for those who did not make the WL.

And the point is that a whole SEASON remains in a season. League champions, WL champions from every league sub-division, will all occur and fit inside a 40-ish day season. And demotions and promotions all contained within that one overall season.....from season to season like this.
Edited by GG on Jul 27, 2009 20:47:54
Edited by GG on Jul 27, 2009 20:44:32
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by beenlurken


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by beenlurken




Originally posted by lukin83





Originally posted by lukin83






Originally posted by lukin83







Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


I am not sure I understand you reasoning that it will not "ensure the best of the best year in and year out". There is no way to ensure that the very best teams are in this league every year (at least for the first few seasons... unless you hand pick the teams that are perceived to be the very best). Also this is predicated on the notion that leagues are superior to others. Eventually all regions will be on the same level and you will have the best teams of each region representing them.






 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
If the WL is not going to have an impact on the perception of the current pro leagues (USAPL is #1, OPL is a joke), then there will never be parity in this game. USAPL will continue to be the #1 league. Unless you give some incentive for players to want to go to teams in inferior regions, they will remain inferior regions. Give those inferior regions an equal shot at the WL and you will start to see them close the gap between themselves and USAPL.

If you want USAPL to remain the dominant league, Bort, then, by all means, don't make a minimum requirement of 4 teams from each region. That is a slap in the face to OPL, APL, SEAPL, etc., but it is ultimately your call.


100% right on.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Look what is the problem with randomly demoting? Pro leagues are NOT the top anymore. If anything this will balance out the leagues, and a team can get back into the Pro league the next year anyway. If random demotions have happened every season up to this point, then why change the system? And to those saying the 3-13 teams don't deserve to stay, if 2 teams finish below them then they do IMO. You can't just "push out" teams that don't deserve to be.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.