Originally posted by Ryiotgear
I've said it before in these discussions and I'll say it again, but frankly it makes way too much sense for Bort to have included an X-Factor that I would be a little disappointed and surprised if we ever found out there was no x-factor.
Just think back to the beginning of this game...
Gameplanning consistend of putting 0%-100% in like 8 boxes to "run inside" or "run outside". The playbook only had a dozen or so different plays in it... heck some formations just had 1 play. There were no such thing as VAs and until the last few seasons Bort had not yet increased the weight factor on speed so we didn't even really have a height/weight impact on the game.
Basically there wasn't much to GLB. There wasn't a lot that could be done to distinguish the 1000s and 1000s of players from one and other through gameplanning or builds. For any particular position you had what... 6 or 7 attributes and 4 or 5 special abilities that matter? Since everyone accumulates skill points in the same manner (and Bort never envisioned slow building and other min/max strategies) we aren't working with a lot of room to have diverse builds here in Bort's initial game (and even today with VAs, slow building, and AI there isn't a lot of room for diversity). If all builds converge and perform the same GLB is extremely boring & predicatable and Bort makes no money.
However, if there are superstar dots out there (regardless of how unique their builds are) aided on by the x-factor it gives people something to look up to and strive for in their next build. How many people started building HBs in the last few seasons just gunning to be the next Garret Dooley. How many DEs are still out there only trying to become the next Jimmy Johnston despite the mountains of nerfs against the position?
As long as Bort keeps the x-factor unknown it will continue to put money in his pocket by keeping the myth of an elusive superstar build out there that everyone will chase.
Originally posted by steellithium
If I believed there was an X-Factor, I would have to call Bort a con man. Ruining someone's player with a random roll, and hiding it from them is unethical. To let them keep boosting a player, when it won't make any difference is a jack off thing to do. If you really believe this practice is going on, why do you keep forking over money? Christ, even a junkie will switch dealers, if the product is bad.
To this point, I don't think Bort has to necessarily con people or gimp builds to have an X-Factor. What happens if the X-Factor just gives positive %'s to attributes? What happens if 99% of dots are playing the game with exactly the attributes you see, but 1% are lucky enough to hit the lottery with a superstar roll and get a % bonus? That doesn't necessarily seem cheap - just a way to introduce randomness into the game and give us superstar dots that perform better than imaginable.
Funny, I spent over $3k on this game with the expectation of no hidden factors. Since I found out I haven't spent a dime and will no do so until the data confirms there are no x-factors.
The reason people wanted more in depth abilities to control the plays, the subs, which players get the ball in which situations, two point conversions, on side kicks, the ability to go for it on 4th down, etc is so we would have control. This way you know that no matter what you are competing against other people without having some unknown element impacting the outcome.
I know the study about randomness increasing the addiction but I don't think you need that in the sports world. Competition is an addiction to the human race that comes naturally. We all want to be the best, some may spend more time, energy and money than others but we all want to win. Outside of Punters I have yet to see one free agency add that looks for a shitty team. It is that way because winning is more fun than losing.
Nobody wants to have to worry about whether testers have access to special information. Nobody wants to have a game impacted by a slot machine type x-factor. We want to see who the best dotball players are and the sim is already lold enough that we certainly don't want to add random shit to it.
People pay, train, boost, read, watch film, discuss, etc so they can build a better player. The x-factor takes joy and excitement away from every aspect of this game, at least at the higher levels.
Do you really want to work hard enough to get to the world league then get beat because 1 player on the team basically hit the lotto 10 seasons earlier when rolling a player? What fun is that? If that makes this game then why not just have a drawing every 40 days to let us know which team wins the championship?
I've said it before in these discussions and I'll say it again, but frankly it makes way too much sense for Bort to have included an X-Factor that I would be a little disappointed and surprised if we ever found out there was no x-factor.
Just think back to the beginning of this game...
Gameplanning consistend of putting 0%-100% in like 8 boxes to "run inside" or "run outside". The playbook only had a dozen or so different plays in it... heck some formations just had 1 play. There were no such thing as VAs and until the last few seasons Bort had not yet increased the weight factor on speed so we didn't even really have a height/weight impact on the game.
Basically there wasn't much to GLB. There wasn't a lot that could be done to distinguish the 1000s and 1000s of players from one and other through gameplanning or builds. For any particular position you had what... 6 or 7 attributes and 4 or 5 special abilities that matter? Since everyone accumulates skill points in the same manner (and Bort never envisioned slow building and other min/max strategies) we aren't working with a lot of room to have diverse builds here in Bort's initial game (and even today with VAs, slow building, and AI there isn't a lot of room for diversity). If all builds converge and perform the same GLB is extremely boring & predicatable and Bort makes no money.
However, if there are superstar dots out there (regardless of how unique their builds are) aided on by the x-factor it gives people something to look up to and strive for in their next build. How many people started building HBs in the last few seasons just gunning to be the next Garret Dooley. How many DEs are still out there only trying to become the next Jimmy Johnston despite the mountains of nerfs against the position?
As long as Bort keeps the x-factor unknown it will continue to put money in his pocket by keeping the myth of an elusive superstar build out there that everyone will chase.
Originally posted by steellithium
If I believed there was an X-Factor, I would have to call Bort a con man. Ruining someone's player with a random roll, and hiding it from them is unethical. To let them keep boosting a player, when it won't make any difference is a jack off thing to do. If you really believe this practice is going on, why do you keep forking over money? Christ, even a junkie will switch dealers, if the product is bad.
To this point, I don't think Bort has to necessarily con people or gimp builds to have an X-Factor. What happens if the X-Factor just gives positive %'s to attributes? What happens if 99% of dots are playing the game with exactly the attributes you see, but 1% are lucky enough to hit the lottery with a superstar roll and get a % bonus? That doesn't necessarily seem cheap - just a way to introduce randomness into the game and give us superstar dots that perform better than imaginable.
Funny, I spent over $3k on this game with the expectation of no hidden factors. Since I found out I haven't spent a dime and will no do so until the data confirms there are no x-factors.
The reason people wanted more in depth abilities to control the plays, the subs, which players get the ball in which situations, two point conversions, on side kicks, the ability to go for it on 4th down, etc is so we would have control. This way you know that no matter what you are competing against other people without having some unknown element impacting the outcome.
I know the study about randomness increasing the addiction but I don't think you need that in the sports world. Competition is an addiction to the human race that comes naturally. We all want to be the best, some may spend more time, energy and money than others but we all want to win. Outside of Punters I have yet to see one free agency add that looks for a shitty team. It is that way because winning is more fun than losing.
Nobody wants to have to worry about whether testers have access to special information. Nobody wants to have a game impacted by a slot machine type x-factor. We want to see who the best dotball players are and the sim is already lold enough that we certainly don't want to add random shit to it.
People pay, train, boost, read, watch film, discuss, etc so they can build a better player. The x-factor takes joy and excitement away from every aspect of this game, at least at the higher levels.
Do you really want to work hard enough to get to the world league then get beat because 1 player on the team basically hit the lotto 10 seasons earlier when rolling a player? What fun is that? If that makes this game then why not just have a drawing every 40 days to let us know which team wins the championship?






























