User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by PierreThomas





WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


Think about this, CBs used to match WRs speed or at least get close to it. A good CB build had all equipment on speed to hang with WRs. Now people realize they don't need the speed and pump up agility and vision to very high levels to use it as an advantage.

Defenses have safeties and the ability to control exactly who guards what players on every snap. Offenses have limited plays that offer deep routes and no way to specify which WR runs them on different plays. If a WR can outrun a CB and a FS playing up to 20 yards off the ball then more power to them. If a WR is that much faster than a CB then the CB was built wrong. I can push speed up to 110 on a lot of my CBs. A straight up 115 speed WR vs 100 speed CB Would give up about 1 yard for every 10 yards they run. With a CB giving a 5 yard cushion it would take 50 yards for the WR to get past the CB and that isn't even accounting for a safety that can play with zone specialist and ball hawk. I've seen a FS play with over 160 speed.


Cushion (for CBs) fails in this game and isn't a legitimate option.


I didn't read the rest of your post. Wouldn't it just make more sense to fix the cushions for CBs?
 
Link
 
It would make sense for you to read my post.

 
GroovyCheetah
offline
Link
 
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


wat
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


Depends.

If the offensive people are arguing for not nerfing elusives, then yes, CB's should have tackling to at least 90, with 120 vision.

If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.
 
GroovyCheetah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah

but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


wat


as in they have to also put SPs in tackling am not to sure i don't make CBs
 
GroovyCheetah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah

but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


Depends.

If the offensive people are arguing for not nerfing elusives, then yes, CB's should have tackling to at least 90, with 120 vision.

If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


kk
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by steellithium


Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?


Not really my place to say.


I don't want to know the build, that would take the fun out of the game. I was just wondering, if these guys took their own build theory instead of the general theory everyone spouts.


he definitely doesn't have a 'normal' build.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
It would make sense for you to read my post.



It makes even less sense than me not reading it.

If you fix the cushion and have 100 speed CBs with 120 speed safeties and Cbs can actually intercept passes then let them throw deep all they want but I don't think they will like the results.

Guess what, all CBs have the same builds right now and very few WRs builds outside of speed being the primary even have a chance to work.

If a Cb has to go all speed to keep up with speedsters then all the sudden high agiltiy WRs might actually work. Juking and elusive built receivers might work because they don't have as much vision. Possession receivers might actually work now that they can use route running SA and agility to get open enough to actually have passes thrown there way.

Seriously, you don't think you could shut down a speed WR with cushions that worked properly and the ability to line up any player you want however far away from a WR you want with high speed CBs?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by GroovyCheetah


but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling


wat


as in they have to also put SPs in tackling am not to sure i don't make CBs


They do. TMI's corners all have it at 60. You should match that.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Deathblade


If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Deathblade



If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.


Yeah, I'm not sure what that even meant.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
I think people fail to realize that it's not so much the speed that creates the separation in the NFL, it's how fast people can get up to speed - and in GLB thats measured in Agility.

A WR capable of running a 4.40 forty is obviously faster than a CB running a 4.50 - but in a straight line race the WR would only have 1.5 FEET of separation all things being equal. If that ball isn't thrown to hit that WR perfectly in stride the CB is gonna have a play on the ball from a speed perspective.

To get the kind of separation someone here was talking about (1 yard over 10 yards) you'd need to have a .5.00 forty Center covering that WR.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Deathblade



If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.


Bingo. If getting open was a function of speed, WRs wouldn't need things like jumping and could get by on very little carrying, etc.


Jumping and carrying doesn't help a receiver get open, it only helps him make the catch after the ball has been thrown.


True, but agility/strength/vision do. Also there are some good receivers with damn good carrying bars.

edit: I hate to even invoke this name, but the links people gave me to Flames' post and profile. it looked like he was trying to convince everyone GLB is a glorified foot race. When I looked at his players season stats, they didn't seem to be out performing other players though.
Edited by steellithium on Jul 9, 2009 23:15:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.