User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
For all of this cat's noisemaking on the shuffle, I simply had to check out his case. Admittedly, he's not in great shape at the moment.... there's about four teams that he can likely beat. Maybe another two he could pull an upset on but apart from that, pretty outleveled.

But then I saw the size of dude's stadium and what he's got in bankroll going into the offseason. Dude, you've got MORE than enough money to recruit some higher level players and the infrastructure to support a ton of EQ costs. So rather than complaining about why you're not competitve, make yourself more competitive...

Or just flat out say, if my team's not the dominant team in the league, I'm not happy.

Take your lumps and build your team with your ridiculously large stadium and cash flow. With cash like that, it really shouldn't be too hard.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
If you are responding to me.. I do not WANT to change my roster. I don't want to have to cut players and force them to all find new teams when we have been sticking together after we decided to make low level players together.

The answer to an ill thought out promotion is NOT to gut the team and recreate it with new players to be competitive in the league they shouldn't have been promoted to.

The only reason we promoted was because the other teams in the former USA BBB#1 were not good. If we had been ina more competitive league with teams that were competitive, we wouldn't have gotten to the conference finals. In fact, against teams that were our level/comparable we were about 50% win/loss. I'm not asking to be placed somewhere where we go 16-0, I'ld be happy with a 8-8 season, give or take a game or two from either side. Something competitive but not where we're going to be a pansy game.

We were promoted and we shouldn't have. There was no reason to promote the top three teams from USA BBB#1. If he had followed his normal promotion rules and promoted only the winner of the conference finals, then the two teams that were promoted but shouldnt have been WOULD HAVE MOVED DOWN LATERALLY in the shuffle.

Last edited Apr 8, 2009 08:43:51
 
bigtrunk69
offline
Link
 
Ok I thought I understood this. If you had a Median average of 24 and say a player at level 33, you'd be placed in a Capped 34 League, correct? So since I understood Bort on this issue, I chose a level 34 capped league because apparently I was going to be placed in that league regardless because of the 2-3 guys I had. Well apparently there were some minor flaws because I was placed in a 34 capped league and there are teams with a few level 40+. Had I known the formula wasn't going to be followed, I would have selected a Level 28 league.

I just feel like complaining.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
You don't have to gut your roster....simple upgrades at a few spots would make you alot more competitive.

You can't just stand pat on your roster every year and think that you're going to be successful every year. You need to upgrade. I'm not saying gut your team but look for opportunities to make your team better. You can't bitch and moan just because you got promoted and don't want to replace some of your players with more effective ones.

Welcome to the wonderful world of being an owner. Yeah, loyalty to players is good but if you want to get ahead, sometimes you need to make a tough decision to put the team above an individual.

Its a shame you don't WANT to change your roster. If you don't want a 4-12 team this year, you'll HAVE to change your roster. You have the cash, go get the players.

And the last I checked, it was a fairly regular occurance that top three got promoted rather than just top two.

And hey, if your team really wants to stick together, then take your damn lumps and look to move up the chain as per normal relegation methods.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Dude, we are a team of people who are playing together. Adding 'upgrades' would force me to push players who have been with me to barely getting any playing time if we were to compete. SURE I could have signed a level 45 Quarterback or even higher as I had one of my own available, but then I would have to have played him 60+ downs a game like some other teams in our league.

I'm not saying I wanted to be 16-0. I think you are failing to see where I said I would be happy to be 8-8 +/- a game or two on either side as long as we were in a league with some parity.

You DO NOT need to upgrade your team every year. If you are in a league with Parity, you'll move up as your players move up, instead of signing new players each season.

Our team has had the same core of players for the three seasons it has been in existance together. I took over from the previous owner who I was a GM on his team. He quit being an owner due to real life time needs and so I inherited the team, built it up with young players and we wanted to advance normally. We were forced into a promotion that came because last years (Season 8's) USA BBB#1 was very uncompetitive.

We DID NOT move up the chain from 'normal relegation methods' if Bort had used the defined promotion/relegation standards we would have remained in USA BBB#1. He moved us up into USA A#1 even though we should not have been there.

NORMAL promotion/relegation methods would have left us in USA BBB#1 and then the SHUFFLE would have pushed us down to likely USA BBB#5 through USA BBB#3 based on talent levels.

We should not be forced to change our roster because we were promoted wrongly. Players who want to have team cohesion and play together should not be forced to accept crappy roles with 15 plays a game so I can recruit level 40's players to play all the starting positions to be competitive when the ONLY reason we are not competitive is because we were promoted EVEN THOUGH WE DID NOT WIN THE CONFERENCE FINALS OR THE LEAGUE FINALS.

By the _RULES_ we would not have promoted. What part of this is confusing to you.

Bort promoted us without looking at our league and seeing that our record was based wholly on playing crappy teams (No offense to them, they were crappy because they were building teams and we had an edge on them.. not because their owners sucked) Our team, if it were in any other/more competitive league would instead of been an 8-8 team. Our previous season together (In the Africa A#6.. as I said, we moved all the players last season when I inherited a team) we were 7-9, and the season before that we were right at the bottom of our conference in the #16 place.

I'm NOT looking to be relegated somewhere where we kick ass. Just somewhere where we have a chance to actually compete. Again, why not take just a moment to look at USA A#1 again, and then look at USA BBB#1 where we were promoted from. After the Shuffle we couldn;t have competed in the USA BBB#1 either. We would have been laterally moved except for the promotion to A#1 where we were removed from the Shuffle chances EVEN THOUGH WE DON'T BELONG IN USA A#1.
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 09:12:00
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
You can keep your team together. Just revise your expectations and look at a 2-3 season plan, or recruit high level players. You do have choices and it's not the end of the world.

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Lets look at the Season 8 USA BBB#1 - Eastern Conference.

Teams that Advanced to USA A#1:
1. Charlotte Gamebreakers (Won Eastern Conference Finals) - Avg Level 33.. They are advancing legitimately (EG they won the conference finals so one of the two teams that should normally promote) and they are going to have, at best, a 5-6 win season.
2. San Dimas Sea Monkeys (Lost Eastern Conference Finals.. would not normally advance by the promotion/relegation rules - Avg Level 32. Avg _Starter_ Level is actually closer to 30. We had a couple higher level players (Started season over level 45) that played near exclusively ST's) Looing at likely a 4-12 season for many seasons to come unless roster is completely overhauled and players who have been together for three seasons scattered OR made to barely receive any experience.
3. Cleveland Disco Ninjas - (Lost to San Dimas in second round of playoffs. They shouldn't have lost that game) They actually have the highest average level and were playing a level 45 or so Quarterback against teams they outleveled - Avg Level 36 - They MIGHT go 8-8 in the USA A#1 this next season.

Teams that remained in BBB but were shuffled
USA BBB#1 - Not a single team that was in Season 8's USA BBB#1 remain in USA BBB#1. The Talent in the new USA BBB#1 rivals the USA A#1.
USA BBB#2 - One Team, Chicago LMG Accountabilibuddies was moved laterally to USA BBB#2. They beat San Dimas (My Team) 30-26 in the regular season. Their team averages, just looking at it, about level 35 or so.
USA BBB#3 - No teams from the former USA BBB#1 made the move laterally into this league.
USA BBB#4 - One Team, the Richmond Rams, moved down from USA BBB#1 to USA BBB#4. San Dimas beat them 34-24 in Season 8. Game would have been different without turnovers.
USA BBB#5 - Two Teams from the Season 8 USA BBB#1 were moved laterally down to USA BBB #5. Detroit Pyros and Lawmed's Destroyers. These teams actually have close to the same average level as San Dimas.
USA BBB#6 - Two Teams were shuffled laterally down from USA BBB#1. Arkansas Rebels and the New Berlin Blitzkrieg. New Berlin's levels are close to San Dimas, Arkansas is not as good as San Dimas.
USA BBB#7 - A CPU team from USA BBB#1 went 6-10 in Season 8. They are still CPU and were dropped here. Makes little sense.
USA BBB#8 - One Team, the Columbus Spartans, was dropped to this tier in the Shuffle.
USA BBB#9 - No teams shuffled down from the USA BBB#1
USA BBB#10 - Four teams from USA BBB#1 were shuffled down into USA BBB#10. Dallas Patriots, Manhattan Minotaurs, Appalachian Dental Plan, and the Syracuse Samurai. All were teams in their building phases.
USA BBB#11 - The Roanoke Renegades from Season 8 USA BBB#1 were laterally shuffled down all the way to #11.
USA BBB#12 - No teams shuffled down.
USA BBB#13 - The Tormena Falcons (CPU team that went 4-12) were shuffled down to USA BBB#13

I did not go further because that was the end of USA BBB#1 Season 8 teams.

So, you can see 10 of 16 Teams were shuffled down to USA BBB6 or less. Thats a 10-6 record right there, these were teams that were beatable by anyone in the league as evidenced by the CPU teams having a 4-12 and 6-10 record.

Of the teams that were forced to Promote or promoted naturally, none of them are really competitive for the league they were moved into because the NEW USA BBB#1 is too much for them, let alone dealing with the USA A#1.


Last edited Apr 8, 2009 09:49:39
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
You can keep your team together. Just revise your expectations and look at a 2-3 season plan, or recruit high level players. You do have choices and it's not the end of the world.



So, a team that should not have promoted, should be promoted and its players forced to suffer 2-3 additional losing seasons where they have no fun, no chance of a 50% winning record, while teams who COULD compete should be left in the BBB?

The whole point of the Shuffle was to move teams into leagues with parity. Parity was not created. Mine is not the only team affected. I'm just one of the more vocal folks protesting this forced promotion because I am advocating for my players.

The game is NOT FUN when you go from being a team that was developing and finally equalling its competition and then is instead fored to be in a situation where they will not ever equal their opposition for at least 3 seasons, maybe more. ESPECIALLY considering how the leveling curve drastically stops at level 29 where my majority of players are located.

Bort should not have promoted us to the USA A#1 to begin with. If we had been left in the USA BBB#1 we would have been moved LATERALLY down. I'm not asking to be made the top dog in a league of CPU teams. I just want my guys to have a chance to be competitive and have fun.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

You can keep your team together. Just revise your expectations and look at a 2-3 season plan, or recruit high level players. You do have choices and it's not the end of the world.



So, a team that should not have promoted, should be promoted and its players forced to suffer 2-3 additional losing seasons where they have no fun, no chance of a 50% winning record, while teams who COULD compete should be left in the BBB?

The whole point of the Shuffle was to move teams into leagues with parity. Parity was not created. Mine is not the only team affected. I'm just one of the more vocal folks protesting this forced promotion because I am advocating for my players.

The game is NOT FUN when you go from being a team that was developing and finally equalling its competition and then is instead fored to be in a situation where they will not ever equal their opposition for at least 3 seasons, maybe more. ESPECIALLY considering how the leveling curve drastically stops at level 29 where my majority of players are located.

Bort should not have promoted us to the USA A#1 to begin with. If we had been left in the USA BBB#1 we would have been moved LATERALLY down. I'm not asking to be made the top dog in a league of CPU teams. I just want my guys to have a chance to be competitive and have fun.


Your team participated in 9 blowouts so I'm not sure I can believe your statement about "finally equaling the competition". You needed to be promoted. If it isn't fun when you have to actually compete then sell the team.

 
packrabid
offline
Link
 
I have a couple questions that may already have been addressed but looking through 400+ posts is exhausting.

1. After the reshuffle my team is in a level 13 league. I have 3 level 14 players that signed prior to the shuffle...do I need to cut them or is a little latitude given?

2. One of the level 13 guys signed today...then boosted to 16. How will this be handled when Bort looks at the levels of the teams in the league?

If anyone knows these answers I appreciate the help.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
9 blowouts and as you will see above, against a league that had a lot of building/cpu teams.

The two CPU teams in our League.. Doomsday Sin and the Tormena Falcons had a 6-10 and 4-12 record respectively.

Against teams our 'equal' (The teams that promoted) the games were much closer or resulted in a big loss on our part and could have been coin flips and in one case, I have No idea how we came away with the win except for crazy random number generators and a lot of the Strong I HB Slam being called.
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 10:11:42
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by packrabid
I have a couple questions that may already have been addressed but looking through 400+ posts is exhausting.

1. After the reshuffle my team is in a level 13 league. I have 3 level 14 players that signed prior to the shuffle...do I need to cut them or is a little latitude given?

2. One of the level 13 guys signed today...then boosted to 16. How will this be handled when Bort looks at the levels of the teams in the league?

If anyone knows these answers I appreciate the help.


Players who are already on your team will not be removed if past history is a guide.

One of the standard practices for level 13 capped leagues is to find level 13 players who still have their three boosts. You sign them, and then they boost.

If you look at your league competitors you'll likely see MANY teams are signing guys who then boost. When the season starts you will see some teams who have level 16 players at nearly all their positions and after the first game, they'll already be level 17.

Quite a few players plan for this intentionally. You may want to make sure the players you recruit are level 12-13 and have all their boosts available if you want to compete. Otherwise, you'll just have an extra season or so of 'building' before you can compete.
 
packrabid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Originally posted by packrabid

I have a couple questions that may already have been addressed but looking through 400+ posts is exhausting.

1. After the reshuffle my team is in a level 13 league. I have 3 level 14 players that signed prior to the shuffle...do I need to cut them or is a little latitude given?

2. One of the level 13 guys signed today...then boosted to 16. How will this be handled when Bort looks at the levels of the teams in the league?

If anyone knows these answers I appreciate the help.


Players who are already on your team will not be removed if past history is a guide.

One of the standard practices for level 13 capped leagues is to find level 13 players who still have their three boosts. You sign them, and then they boost.

If you look at your league competitors you'll likely see MANY teams are signing guys who then boost. When the season starts you will see some teams who have level 16 players at nearly all their positions and after the first game, they'll already be level 17.

Quite a few players plan for this intentionally. You may want to make sure the players you recruit are level 12-13 and have all their boosts available if you want to compete. Otherwise, you'll just have an extra season or so of 'building' before you can compete.


Thanks...I knew about the practice of boosting to 16 in a capped lvl 13 league but wasn't sure how closely Bort or the mods would look at that when examining team roster levels to ensure nobody asked for a 13 league and then signed higher level players.

---Thanks for the clarification!
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Well I'm not a mod, and I can't say for sure how closely they'll look but I think you are likely safe as they expect level 13 capped leagues to actually likely average out at level 14-15.

But who knows. They promoted my team to USA A#1 even though as soon as we played a team 'equal' to us we promptly lost and we would likely go 2-12 in the current USA BBB#1... So anything can happen.

But I think you're safe.
 
Sean Bishop
offline
Link
 
In ENkidu's defence, there are at least 2 teams in BBB1 that would be a better fit in A than his team.

Not advocating his position, but part of his argument is valid.

Although with a setup like his, he is NOT a BBB team. BBB teams should not have a maxed out stadium
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.