User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
steelers75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Originally posted by Animalmother

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Originally posted by RTJakarta



Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


I have a level 33 with 5 vp and another with 33 with 9. 1 vp will not break the game there is no rhyme or reason to how they were handed out in the first place...trust me we compared hundreds of guys.


I watched that thread tbh, it was the one where HULK tested the VP bug.

At the same time though, you get 1% to an attribute of your choice, it isn't much, but it's MORE than enough payment for being teased by Bort.


still
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Originally posted by Animalmother


If Ed McMahon showed up at your door with a big check and you tried to cash it and they told you to piss off I bet you would feel like an ass for getting all excited. Prob even be pissed off a bit...


Ya sure I would be, but I wouldn't go out and demand payment for the mix up


lmao im sure you wouldnt /rolls eyes


So that's the way you go through life? Somebody pulls the old "NOT!" joke on you and you go on a rampage to get what they tricked you with?

Even then Bort realized his mistake AND is giving you compensation. Beggars can't be choosers.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steelers75
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Originally posted by RTJakarta


Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Cash is one thing, VP would just be unfair, players would be getting to much better


I thought I had a +2 agility +1 jumping +15% deflect ball for a season and if I got 1 VP I would end up with just +1% to something. And you think that is unfair to everyone else? Excuse me for not understanding your side here.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steelers75
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Let's keep the sarcasm and stuff out of this. Discuss. If you disagree, give reasons why - but other people are permitted to have their own ideas.


VP is just uncalled for.. next idea


But worthless cash is fine. I cant wait for the next round of people to get screwed so we can see the names switch with the ideas. I dont care if its a VP tbh but at least its something worthwhile not a epic kick to the nuts.
 
Taha19
offline
Link
 
sorry I didnt read this whole thread.. what about players who played in peewee last seaon...

my QB won 2 awards and was argubly the best player in that peewee league last seaon..

I think he should get an endorsement..


also I like you idea bort.. ANY idea is better then the current mess up
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JugheadASFN
Originally posted by tautology

"Suggested levels" is a wide range. You could have level 35 vs level 45...that is a blowout for sure. Helps with the complete gut jobs thought....


and also those teams tanking seasons on purpose only to bring in ultra high level players into the "A"/"BBB" leagues.

The number I used was just an example - I was thinking of taking it off the Leagues "suggested" calculations inwhich each conference has a running calculation to include player level development.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/leagues.pl


Am I missing something? Have you looked at the suggested levels? 36-60? Those are some very wide disparities...point me to what you mean, if you had something different in mind...
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by steelers75

Originally posted by DrkSandman


Let's keep the sarcasm and stuff out of this. Discuss. If you disagree, give reasons why - but other people are permitted to have their own ideas.


VP is just uncalled for.. next idea


But worthless cash is fine. I cant wait for the next round of people to get screwed so we can see the names switch with the ideas. I dont care if its a VP tbh but at least its something worthwhile not a epic kick to the nuts.


Your choice of AEQ or bonus/training tokens is the best ideas I've seen.
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Originally posted by steelers75

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Originally posted by RTJakarta



Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Cash is one thing, VP would just be unfair, players would be getting to much better


I thought I had a +2 agility +1 jumping +15% deflect ball for a season and if I got 1 VP I would end up with just +1% to something. And you think that is unfair to everyone else? Excuse me for not understanding your side here.


You never even got to use your equipment. If Bort never implemented endorsements and you got a free VP I'm more than sure you would be happy with that.

Just curious, what do you think is fair payment for a buggy endorsement deal you got?
 
Ricky Roma
offline
Link
 
This whole endorsent thing is a load of bollix.
 
l4boMb4
offline
Link
 
An overhaul of the stats need to be implemented before we can accurately gauge the worth of various players.

I can't believe we haven't added other STATS that can be given as individual awards. You could even add funny stuff like Missed Tackles, Dropped Passes, Fumbles, Worst Throwing Percentage, etc. It should be relatively easy to implement and encourage people to actually try not to get 'bad' trophies...all the while promoting smack talk banter on the forums. What about sacks allowed for O-linemen. I'm sure smarter people than myself can come up with trophies and stats that could actually increase the chance of getting these endorsements assigned correctly instead weighing Championships so heavily towards Fame. By being creative with trophies and stats, that's where you generate interest and replayability. People want to see all the things their players do, right or wrong.
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Originally posted by RTJakarta

Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Didn't Bort say something about trying to have some sort of compensation for people who got their hopes up with the first round of stuff? Sure, a single VP point is a form of compensation, and better than nothing, but it's hardly going to be worth anything.

But I don't run the game, nor do I really care. So whatever.
 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Kk,

I've been hashing out some ideas, and I wanted to note them down for feedback:

1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula. With a bit of fiddling, I think it could work pretty well, and add a fun element of "MVP race" to each league. This will make glamor players more glamorous as well. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference.(if you are doing these MVP's by a game to game basis...then yes.If you are doing a season or midseason statistcal formula for MVP's,it will not work.WHY?Because every League and Conference has it's own Parity Bort.Some teams play 5 to 6 good teams in their league,some play 3 or 4...Sure the fame won't be any higher,but the stats will be for those playing gutted teams or computer controlled teams.You need to have a game to game MVP (like my thread in suggestions) per team,to accurately calculate MVP's.You take each game and find a way to calculate who the MVP for Offense,Defense and Special teams were for each team.At the end of the season,you count up the players on each team...that made Game MVP for(off,def,ST's) and the number of times they were MVP,is the number of lottery Balls they get in the system for that Conference/League.Another words...you will have 16 Offense,Defense and Special team Game MVP's per season,or should I say 48 Lottery balls per team.Now some will have multiple Game by Game MVP's and some will only get 1.Doesn't matter....If you have 1 or 16(MAX MVP's/per player per season)those are the amount of balls that go into the lottery with ALL the other teams.Those who did NOT get a game by Game MVP are not qualified for an endorsement.)

2. We give 3 top "corporate" endorsements per conference at the end of the season, which will be taken from the current endorsements that are given for that league level. This is given to the top O/D/ST MVP's in the MVP race. They can take this item with them if they are promoted.(OK!...Give the 3 "corporate" endorsements to the top game by game MVP's in that conference....3 different teams of course at end of season....one from drawing and 2 from season end MVP game by game accomplishment)

3. We give 1 "national" endorsement per team that is equal to the current endorsements from 2 tiers down, ranked by the same MVP system. Alternatively, we could do a lottery per team based on the MVP calculation = more tickets. We do this at week 8, and base it on the current league results.(this guy gets the "national" endorsement from the major drawing with all MVP's combined in conference/League for the big Prize from the major drawing with ALL game by game MVP's for Off,Def and ST's.)

4. We give 2 "local" endorsement per team that is equal to the current bottom tier endorsements. So Pro teams get the ones from BBB, which are +2's, and AAA gets +1's from the current pool of pee-wee items. We hand these out at weeks 4/8/12 based on the current season's rankings, with a general lottery system based on current fame values. These items last 4 weeks. I see this as a fun way to keep the items circulating and keep interest up throughout the season.(These 2 guys get a local endorsements from being the 2 top Game by Game MVP's of the season in Conference/League...NO drawing)

- Teams cannot get more than 3 endorsements. If they already have 3, they lose out on national or local deals depending on if they got all the MVP awards or not.(I like it)

- A player cannot get more than 1 endorsement.Yes..if a player wins the "national" endorsement,he cannot get either of the two Local endorsements and vice versa)

- Only 3 endorsements can be active in a game. This heads off MVP players who become FA's at the end of a season joining other teams to stack them.Yes

- If you are traded or cut, you lose your item. (debatable since 3 endorsements active heads off a lot of problems) If you are cut...YES...if you are traded....NO

- We scrap the "one per position" idea and just give out items that are made for the selected player's position.(Yes...since game by game MVP's from different teams can be from the WR position,it's very possible to have all 3 WR's win the endorsements.(1 WR gets National and two others get the local)

- Leagues below AA are not eligible for the national or corporate endorsements, and instead each team gets 3 local endorsements.(my 3 endorsements is per conference and not team)

- We remove the current items, let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble. We then do our first set of per-team local items in 6 days. This should give some time to adapt the script I have and test it on the test server, though it'd be pretty straight forward.Since I have an endorsement,I'm OK with starting over bort for the new idea,but they will be mad(Pro league endorsements)...(I'm cool with starting over) but Yes keep money and I would be cool with Bonus tokens or flex or whatever you feel is appropriate

- If we can come up with an MVP formula everyone likes by week 8, we can do the national ones then. If not, we just wait on that until next season.(you could in theory do the (2)locals by week 8,but the (1)national is a drawing,so must be at seasons end)

Some feedback on the idea would be great; The folks I have pitched it to so far think it's pretty good and helps keep everyone feeling involved.(your welcome)

Note: Please try to keep things civil in this thread and help be constructive with ideas. The mods and I will not hesitate to suspend people for flaming and trolling.



easy summary for bort...

There are 3 endorsements per Conference each season

One is called a "National endorsements" and will go into a huge drawing at the end of the season.All Game-by-Game MVP's are put into a big Lottery (except 2 Local winners if giving them a week 8 midseason prize)but everyone else in the massive drawing that was a MVP on OFF,DEF or ST's at least one time in the 16 games played that season.This is done for each Conference...so there would be 2 national endorsements per 1 in Alpha and 1 Zeta.

There are 2 Local endorsements as how you explained them, that can go out Midseason (week 8) or end of season...doesn't matter.These 2 players per conference had the most game ball MVP's won.
(max would be 16)they are not a SWEET as the national one,but good.and NO drawing..

So Alpha has a national and 2 local endorsements

And Zeta has a national and 2 Locals

this in each League to your discretion
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 22:13:14
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Originally posted by butler312

Originally posted by steelers75


Originally posted by bossinthe831



Originally posted by RTJakarta




Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Cash is one thing, VP would just be unfair, players would be getting to much better


I thought I had a +2 agility +1 jumping +15% deflect ball for a season and if I got 1 VP I would end up with just +1% to something. And you think that is unfair to everyone else? Excuse me for not understanding your side here.


You never even got to use your equipment. If Bort never implemented endorsements and you got a free VP I'm more than sure you would be happy with that.

Just curious, what do you think is fair payment for a buggy endorsement deal you got?


I was still given the equipment. The fact that I never got to use it just makes it even worse, I got absolutely nothing out of it. I personally would just say let everyone keep their equipment for this year. It's only 16 people in each league for one year, its not a huge deal. I wouldn't be happy unless I got something equal in return. Obviously anything worth 1/4 as much as the equipment pisses everyone off, so I know there is no way I'm getting something of equal value in return.

 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Originally posted by RTJakarta


Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Didn't Bort say something about trying to have some sort of compensation for people who got their hopes up with the first round of stuff? Sure, a single VP point is a form of compensation, and better than nothing, but it's hardly going to be worth anything.

But I don't run the game, nor do I really care. So whatever.


If you argue, you care.

My only point is there shouldn't be a big compensation for something you never even used. Sure if you played a game with your endorsement then heck, I would say keep it for the season. But the case is, all it is was a little teaser and 1 VP is more than enough IMO
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 22:02:18
 
steelers75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Originally posted by butler312

Originally posted by steelers75


Originally posted by bossinthe831



Originally posted by RTJakarta




Not really the point.


What about seeing you're build get better temporarily makes it worth more than a VP and some cash? Because you were blessed enough to get an endorsement in a bugged system you are already getting an advantage, how big does it have to be?


Cash is one thing, VP would just be unfair, players would be getting to much better


I thought I had a +2 agility +1 jumping +15% deflect ball for a season and if I got 1 VP I would end up with just +1% to something. And you think that is unfair to everyone else? Excuse me for not understanding your side here.


You never even got to use your equipment. If Bort never implemented endorsements and you got a free VP I'm more than sure you would be happy with that.

Just curious, what do you think is fair payment for a buggy endorsement deal you got?


a perma VP would be too much
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.