User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doc Scurlock
Originally posted by nfratami

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by nfratami



The Test Server Being Open to All Seems Like a Logical Solution

Why?

1. There can be no unfair advantage claims.
2. No need to disclose information from tests. You don't have to make posts about builds people used and their success, preventing the best builds from becoming posted public info.

Allowing everyone access to the test server, with the ability to test players themselves will allow people to figure things out for themselves and still keep some secrets about builds.

It is either this or bort conducts the tests alone, grab tactics from some of the best teams and test with those (in response to the claim that bort can't develop his own tactics made by some mod lol, thats like saying bill gates cant navigate windows).

Or even have all those who want to participate on the test server sign up, then have a rotation, limited access for periods of time would eliminate the need for mad servers.


Not even server space, access, or desire, nor than their be any good information given to the programmers using this idea.


why


Because if everybody had access imagine how hard it would be to keep track of everything not to mention filtering all the BS so that you can actually get the useful info. You want people who know what they're doing and not some guy who doesn't know how the game works and makes user errors and then blames it on faulty coding etc. You want a small amount of users so that you can tell them to try this or that and so you can gather information as to how it'll affect a build. Basically, testing comes down to communication and the more people involved the more complicated things get.


other games conduct betas and test servers in wide spread manners

and who is to say that the people on the test server know that they are doing?

take drksandman for example

makes santa hats> gets mod> gets on test server

does that make him an expert qualified to test?
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
I know a ton about this game, I want to be a tester and I don't care who knows it


I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger


I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Doc Scurlock

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by nfratami




The Test Server Being Open to All Seems Like a Logical Solution

Why?

1. There can be no unfair advantage claims.
2. No need to disclose information from tests. You don't have to make posts about builds people used and their success, preventing the best builds from becoming posted public info.

Allowing everyone access to the test server, with the ability to test players themselves will allow people to figure things out for themselves and still keep some secrets about builds.

It is either this or bort conducts the tests alone, grab tactics from some of the best teams and test with those (in response to the claim that bort can't develop his own tactics made by some mod lol, thats like saying bill gates cant navigate windows).

Or even have all those who want to participate on the test server sign up, then have a rotation, limited access for periods of time would eliminate the need for mad servers.


Not even server space, access, or desire, nor than their be any good information given to the programmers using this idea.


why


Because if everybody had access imagine how hard it would be to keep track of everything not to mention filtering all the BS so that you can actually get the useful info. You want people who know what they're doing and not some guy who doesn't know how the game works and makes user errors and then blames it on faulty coding etc. You want a small amount of users so that you can tell them to try this or that and so you can gather information as to how it'll affect a build. Basically, testing comes down to communication and the more people involved the more complicated things get.


other games conduct betas and test servers in wide spread manners

and who is to say that the people on the test server know that they are doing?

take drksandman for example

makes santa hats> gets mod> gets on test server

does that make him an expert qualified to test?


So you know drksandam is a tester? How? Haven't seen him post about being one.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by smallbugger



I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.


No, not everyone, I don't want in, I could care less about testing
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by smallbugger



I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.


Go on.
 
Doc Scurlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Doc Scurlock

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by nfratami




The Test Server Being Open to All Seems Like a Logical Solution

Why?

1. There can be no unfair advantage claims.
2. No need to disclose information from tests. You don't have to make posts about builds people used and their success, preventing the best builds from becoming posted public info.

Allowing everyone access to the test server, with the ability to test players themselves will allow people to figure things out for themselves and still keep some secrets about builds.

It is either this or bort conducts the tests alone, grab tactics from some of the best teams and test with those (in response to the claim that bort can't develop his own tactics made by some mod lol, thats like saying bill gates cant navigate windows).

Or even have all those who want to participate on the test server sign up, then have a rotation, limited access for periods of time would eliminate the need for mad servers.


Not even server space, access, or desire, nor than their be any good information given to the programmers using this idea.


why


Because if everybody had access imagine how hard it would be to keep track of everything not to mention filtering all the BS so that you can actually get the useful info. You want people who know what they're doing and not some guy who doesn't know how the game works and makes user errors and then blames it on faulty coding etc. You want a small amount of users so that you can tell them to try this or that and so you can gather information as to how it'll affect a build. Basically, testing comes down to communication and the more people involved the more complicated things get.


other games conduct betas and test servers in wide spread manners

and who is to say that the people on the test server know that they are doing?

take drksandman for example

makes santa hats> gets mod> gets on test server

does that make him an expert qualified to test?


Other games might be run by major companies, hence they have the manpower and resources to do it.

As for drksandman I'll leave that alone as I don't know him so can't comment on him.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by smallbugger



I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.


it was a joke Bones... but you basically admit to why people have an issue to "select" people getting the advantage.

I have to pay money to run a scrimmage to try to learn something about the game....
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Here's how I see it since I'm sure 0 people were sitting around waiting for me to expound on this subject.

Firstly, I agree with the concept of test servers. What Bort is making for us with that new D AI that can essentially be fully tested definitely requires a serious amount of testing for bugs. I get that, I understand that and fully accept it.

Where I feel a serious line is being crossed is if this test server went beyond JUST the new D AI. If players were on this test server, trying out things using existing players at positions OR having the ability to test customized players in different situations, this is a serious advantage. I'll put it simply, any testable and verified information learned in this game is a HUGE advantage. If you can even figure out a rough estimate as to what would be a great build at any position, this is a HUGE advantage. Let's be honest with ourselves people. When we add skill points, we assume something will work. Or we have an idea of how it might work. But TO KNOW how it will work is completely unacceptable.

If any tester was given an advantage such as this, even for a brief amount of time, this is an irreversible problem even with the perpetual nerfing or changes to how effective builds are season to season.

I sincerely hope testers were given limited access with specific tasks they were required to accomplish and nothing more. If they were given free reign to test whether it be from February 1st and beyond or in the past at any time, Bort owes us all something as owners, GMs or player agents.

Personally, I'm not happy with this situation but I also have to accept the need for the test servers. I think the logical thing to do (or the fair action) is that current players should not have been given access to a free reign testing. And if testing was allowed, strict oversight would have been the only way to allow limit testing. And just from the perception I have about GLB, there was no oversight.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by ฿ones

Originally posted by smallbugger




I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.


No, not everyone, I don't want in, I could care less about testing


But you don't want in, so that statement doesn't concern you

Por Cerneo.

Everyone wants to know more about the sim so they can learn what works and what doesn't. The reason they are there is for a select group to test things and I'd assume at an accelerated rate. More data to be had/less risk to take in experimenting = easy way for someone to learn. No one is stopping us from testing on real GLB it just takes time like my previous tests.
 
Savage Smurf
offline
Link
 
What if the testers are all on 0-16 teams.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
What if the testers are all on 0-16 teams.


they arent
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
What if the testers are all on 0-16 teams.


U!!!!!!! why didnt I see it earlier. OBVIOUS TESTER IS OBVIOUS
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Savage Smurf

What if the testers are all on 0-16 teams.


they arent


orl?
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by ฿ones


Originally posted by smallbugger





I don't know enough about this game yet. I want to be a tester so I can learn more, lol


Everyone but Bort has this at their reason for wanting in. EVERYONE.


No, not everyone, I don't want in, I could care less about testing


But you don't want in, so that statement doesn't concern you

Por Cerneo.

Everyone wants to know more about the sim so they can learn what works and what doesn't. The reason they are there is for a select group to test things and I'd assume at an accelerated rate. More data to be had/less risk to take in experimenting = easy way for someone to learn. No one is stopping us from testing on real GLB it just takes time like my previous tests.


Time and money, and more time and more money, infact it would take months and if you got it wrong a few times your talking $50+.

Please don't tell me bort made all you guys drink kool-aid or be demoded?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.