User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Current Top 60 teams in GLB
Page:
 
Wylker
offline
Link
 
OK I'll contribute for 30 seconds to a loldots discussion, but only to make fun of SI. Your logic makes no sense. You have 4 teams in the top 10 from USA PRO that all have "notable" wins against the same 2-3 teams. Isn't this an indicator that those losing teams just aren't that good as opposed to elevating the teams that beat them?

Then you have the top 3 CPL teams all fucked up. First you acknowledge it's a crapshoot (which is wrong anyway) but then you have them spread out between 3th and 14rd place (lolwhobos). Not to mention you've dropped the Hobos based off what, them blowing out their last two opponents of the season. Not that I care too much where our little homeless squad falls on your rankings, but really, logic seems to be missing in a lot of these rankings.
 
nautilus
offline
Link
 
I agree with rankings for the most part. I think Tonga of OPL should be in top 5 based on who they've played and record but very solid rankings imo. Thanks
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
11->39

You really think there is that much difference between the top 4 in the USA Pro West and the next 4?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
11->39

You really think there is that much difference between the top 4 in the USA Pro West and the next 4?


I'm not sure that 11-39 is that big a jump when you are factoring in every single team in the game. I mean there are a ton of teams out there, and having nothing more then scrimmages to tell many apart is certainly an imperfect science...but (and I can't believe I'm defending SI here) its all anyone has to go by.
 
nautilus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Galkuris

11->39

You really think there is that much difference between the top 4 in the USA Pro West and the next 4?


I'm not sure that 11-39 is that big a jump when you are factoring in every single team in the game. I mean there are a ton of teams out there, and having nothing more then scrimmages to tell many apart is certainly an imperfect science...but (and I can't believe I'm defending SI here) its all anyone has to go by.


Agree, I think there is little difference between 11-39 and 1-10 on paper. Having the scrimmages to go off and season play are the only ways to filter through who goes where.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
11->39

You really think there is that much difference between the top 4 in the USA Pro West and the next 4?


I think there isn't much difference at all between #11 and #39. You are the one making that assumption.

#1 was in the 30's last week I believe. Anyone can beat anyone these days.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
11->39

You really think there is that much difference between the top 4 in the USA Pro West and the next 4?


Forum where you should be is ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Also, SI did you make the mistake of posting this only in CPL? Because there's a lot of people here who care too much about their dots, yet are still posting in CPL for some reason.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Untouchable
OK I'll contribute for 30 seconds to a loldots discussion, but only to make fun of SI. Your logic makes no sense. You have 4 teams in the top 10 from USA PRO that all have "notable" wins against the same 2-3 teams. Isn't this an indicator that those losing teams just aren't that good as opposed to elevating the teams that beat them?

Then you have the top 3 CPL teams all fucked up. First you acknowledge it's a crapshoot (which is wrong anyway) but then you have them spread out between 3th and 14rd place (lolwhobos). Not to mention you've dropped the Hobos based off what, them blowing out their last two opponents of the season. Not that I care too much where our little homeless squad falls on your rankings, but really, logic seems to be missing in a lot of these rankings.



Here's why Hobos got knocked down a few spots:

1.) Teams jumped over you with quality wins over higher ranked opponents. Mean Machine beat the Krazy Monkeys and the Invaders beat the Mustangs. Both are ranked higher than anyone you guys have beat. Mean Machine beat the Invaders earlier in the year. Not only that, the Mean Machine have ROUTED almost everyone they have played. Not close last minute or come from behind wins that the Hobos have done vs some "lesser" competition. This happens in the BCS all the time. If you are #10 and you beat #1, then you are likely going to jump over #6, #7, #8, #9, etc......even if they had impressive wins of late.

2.) You highest quality win was vs the Drinkin Hellraisers. And they haven't been playing well lately with 2 losses. So your quality points for that win aren't what they used to be.


And yes, I still think teams like the Mustangs, Pushovers, and Coyotes could still crush most teams in the top 100 just by showing up. Even if their opponent only has 1 or 2 losses and they have 3 or 4.

Last edited Oct 23, 2008 13:13:02
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Also, SI did you make the mistake of posting this only in CPL? Because there's a lot of people here who care too much about their dots, yet are still posting in CPL for some reason.


I was just talking about it with gart..... maybe VT should move it somewhere else? I know CPL hates people who care about their silly dot teams.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle

Also, SI did you make the mistake of posting this only in CPL? Because there's a lot of people here who care too much about their dots, yet are still posting in CPL for some reason.


I was just talking about it with gart..... maybe VT should move it somewhere else? I know CPL hates people who care about their silly dot teams.


yeah, it really couldn't hurt to have this moved to the glb main forum.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Better yet, copy and paste into a new thread on GLB Main with updated subject (it's now 100 teams or something, right?
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
And by copy and paste, I mean the OP, not the whole thread.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
And by copy and paste, I mean the OP, not the whole thread.


why not just move this thread?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by kurieg

And by copy and paste, I mean the OP, not the whole thread.


why not just move this thread?


mislabeled? VT to change the title also, then move??
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 13:02:33
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.