User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
VenomCoach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by TxSteve

i agree with some - as we can choose offensive and defensive plays - it will be very hard to keep the game balanced - as there will be plays that just can't be stopped - or are very hard to stop - that sort of thing.

the game is following the same path as all mmo's - but instead of player classes that dominate then get nerfed - we will be looking at plays (and builds) that dominate and get nerfed.


programming a game that is perfectly balanced is probably impossible


Possibly...but if I'm reading it right....

1. The TE can only move to help when blocking on passing plays. It doesn't sound like the TE can move to the "weak side" to run the offtackle to that side -- no flip plays yet. And it doesn't sound like the TE can move to that side for a passing route -- its to help vs. the RDE, or the blitzing ROLB. If these options do become available, the simple fix is to make the TE side the "strong side", regardless of whether it is left or right side of the line, and have the defense outputs adjust accordingly.

2. If the auto LB drop gets scrapped, teams will be able to play the run a lot better, which would be one way to "nerf" the strong I offtackle run. Right now, you either let the LBers drop back and hope they contain the play after a short gain, or you blitz them and hope they don't get picked up and can make a play after a short gain...either way is not optimal.

3. I'll reiterate -- the bigger concern is that the offense can now choose specific personnel based on formation or play. The defense needs the ability to either...

----A. Alter their personnel based on what HB/FB/TE is in the game...would be nice if we could get the CB vs. specific WR in as well
----B. If X player is in the game in X formation, use X defensive formation
---------i.e. If the power HB is in the game in I-formation, 4-3, cover 1, stack the box. If the elusive back is in during I-formation, 4-3, cover 2, balanced.


Defensive strength is determined by the TE in most defenses. You move the TE left and I'll blitz your right. The shotgun set should have the RB on the weak side. The ace set should have the RB checking weak on pass plays.

Rather than flipping the TE the formation should be able to be flipped. When the formation flips the LB's and S's flip with it. Not DL or CB as most don't flip sides. This allows you to run at the insane speed DE and just blow him up.

CB's could be allowed to lock up but I haven't thought through the logistics.

Also, not having a list of defensive ai out anywhere is silly. As a DC, I don't know where players will go in a game unless I try it out in a game???? I have DC'd high school football and that is crazy.
 
A Dub
offline
Link
 
I think vision should be more important. It would be the only way to stop these offenses.
 
Lugnut
offline
Link
 
Most agents have been soooo busy keeping other stats up and typically ignore vision and confidence. Why was Deon Sanders one of the best cover corners ever? Yes he was fast, but he had great vision and he dripped confidence. Ronnie Lott a great safety, he was not extremely fast, but great vision and confidence. Marvin Harrison and Jerry Rice are not fast receivers but they are always open and they always had the confidence that the would win the game. I just showed my age to everyone.....
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Freddie Bilitnikov!!!!!!!
 
Noleman
offline
Link
 
As an owner of a punter I am exstatic that we are getting coffin corner punts!
 
chrisway
offline
Link
 
Will there be a sportsmanship penalty this coming season for having so many players on the same team?
 
Quas
offline
Link
 
I read somewhere a post from Bort where he said he had been working on Offensive plays, and one of the things that was taking so much time was making sure all the defenses reacted properly to the offense. With that I take it to mean that a TE switching sides would mean the LB's adjust accordingly. So DC's don't get your panties bunched up yet.

Now the speed back vs Power back thing is a bigger concern. Yes this is an obvious change to the offense that the defense should be able to react too. But how are they going to impliment this and how do we counter it. If they simply put different boxs on the depth chart, they can be swapped last minute to throw off defenses. That would be a problem. Maybe the Depth chart for the offense needs to be locked an hour before the game.
 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Quas
Maybe the Depth chart for the offense needs to be locked an hour before the game.


Maybe not...since the AI came out the defense has always been able to react to what the offense put on the field...but nowhere is there a "When defense is in this set we adjust to this set" setting for offense! Give the offense an opportunity! I mean I go out there 5 wide...you throw a dime at me. You go out there Goalline I don't get a chance to audible to motion out my players to a 5 wide to get good matchups!
 
Tomhusker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stumanroo
Originally posted by Quas

Maybe the Depth chart for the offense needs to be locked an hour before the game.


Maybe not...since the AI came out the defense has always been able to react to what the offense put on the field...but nowhere is there a "When defense is in this set we adjust to this set" setting for offense! Give the offense an opportunity! I mean I go out there 5 wide...you throw a dime at me. You go out there Goalline I don't get a chance to audible to motion out my players to a 5 wide to get good matchups!


Yes, that!!
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocomo
Freddie Bilitnikov!!!!!!!


Great Stickem
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by madmal
Originally posted by rocomo

Freddie Bilitnikov!!!!!!!


Great Stickem


I think he had 110 Catching+110 Confidence

 
West Coast
offline
Link
 
I rock
 
telencephalon
offline
Link
 
I roll.
 
Rook33
offline
Link
 
Im confused didnt the defense already have more flexibility than the offense until these upgrades? I have read about unfair balance but I am not sure that is the case where the defense's will be struggling ALL season.

Maybe the first few games but I know there are some very good DC's who will make the proper adjustments once a team plays a few games. So that to me is where it can be matched up with most likely more scouting once the season begins.

As mentioned I would give it time to see what defense's can do and what adjustments can be made during the season before we over think a possible simple solution.

 
Quas
offline
Link
 
Silly me. I thought we were talking about Football. You know the game where the Defense reacts to the offense. Maybe the Defense should have a 20% chance of lining up for a Kick return on first down.

In Football the Defense would see who was in the back field and would react accordingly. So in order for this game to emulate that they need to allow the defense to react the same way. Locking the Offense is simply a way to stop the other teams from abusing a situation.

I run both offenses and Defenses, I just want the game to be fair.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.