User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
JP_Specialist
offline
Link
 
You just need to be ready for whatever comes guys, like the real deal, today your on top tomorrow your guys out for the season, its how it goes.
Originally posted by Warner
Originally posted by vzone

Originally posted by TrevJo


Announcing the change to 8 bonus token rollover now instead of earlier really sucks. Generally I am all in favor of making changes as needed to make the game better for the future, and I do think allowing a max of 8 makes sense. I just don't understand why it wasn't done earlier. This seemed like a no-brainer to do at the beginning... why pull the switch all of a sudden at the end of the season?
(Why do I care? I planned out my training such that my players would have 5 bonus tokens at the end of the season. That means I bought some pieces of equipment that I otherwise wouldn't have bought, and used some training points on Normal training when I would have otherwise used it on Intense.)


Same here. Have to play the cards we are dealt even if they come from the bottom of the deck. There were other ways around the 5 tokens anyway.


I've got the same problem, having taken care of my bonus tokens to be sure not losing ones for next season. For once, those who have not really thought about it will be glad. It sucks for the other ones !


 
Play4Blood
offline
Link
 


Lots of stuff.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Play4Blood
o_O

Lots of stuff.


haha no doubt
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forum rules
# No threads to talk about threads that have been locked/deleted
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
I think the addition of lots of new offensive plays will make defense nearly unfeasible until they remove holding.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand
I think the addition of lots of new offensive plays will make defense nearly unfeasible until they remove holding.


I most be the only defensive coordinator that does not run my defense by offensive formation. I do it by down and distance. It has worked really well and adding new plays will not affect me at all. I think it will actually separate my team from the rest. Really happy this is going in.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I coordinate on both sides of the ball, and here are some issues I'm pulling from the current update:

1. If you are going to allow the offense to put in a specific HB, FB or TE based on play, you need to allow the defense to adjust to those players if they see fit. If I see the power back in the lineup, I should be able to choose whether I want to adjust the LB's to stack the back. If I see their blocking TE in, I should be able to focus the D to stop the run. Sure, you're cheating your D in the hopes you're right, and the offense could play tricks and pass with their blocking TE in or run outside with their power back, but DC's should have the choice. This kinda goes in-line with playing specific CB's on specific WR's, which is definitely required along with this and should be a high priority.

2. Same thing if the TE can switch sides...I assume if a DC puts the strong side shift on, they'll shift to the side of the TE. Just putting it out there to ensure there aren't any exploits.

Basically, my only concerns are that this seems to give an advantage to the offense without the proper defense countermeasures. Maybe I'm wrong, but might as well address these now.

Otherwise, love the updates and can't wait to test things out.

Matt

PS - I coordinate on both sides of the ball, so I have no bias -- I just want to see things fair for both sides and we get back to playing a real football SIM, not "who can find the best exploit".
 
A Dub
offline
Link
 
Does anyone else think that defenses are going to struggle a lot next season?

Maybe if we had some QB spies, zone blitzes, zone coverage was more effective, defensive stunts, and we could shift the D-line too then it would be a little more equal.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
With you SCACE. The D will need some counter measures, especially with added control over personnel, play side, and blocking assignments for the offense.

The LB auto-drop on run plays should be removed as well since the offense will now have the ability to run any play type from any formation - reading/reacting is going to be more important than ever for the D and the LB group should no longer be handicapped.

(And, I do not coordinate on both sides of the ball, so I do have a bias. )
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I coordinate on both sides of the ball, and here are some issues I'm pulling from the current update:

1. If you are going to allow the offense to put in a specific HB, FB or TE based on play, you need to allow the defense to adjust to those players if they see fit. If I see the power back in the lineup, I should be able to choose whether I want to adjust the LB's to stack the back. If I see their blocking TE in, I should be able to focus the D to stop the run. Sure, you're cheating your D in the hopes you're right, and the offense could play tricks and pass with their blocking TE in or run outside with their power back, but DC's should have the choice. This kinda goes in-line with playing specific CB's on specific WR's, which is definitely required along with this and should be a high priority.

2. Same thing if the TE can switch sides...I assume if a DC puts the strong side shift on, they'll shift to the side of the TE. Just putting it out there to ensure there aren't any exploits.

Basically, my only concerns are that this seems to give an advantage to the offense without the proper defense countermeasures. Maybe I'm wrong, but might as well address these now.

Otherwise, love the updates and can't wait to test things out.

Matt

PS - I coordinate on both sides of the ball, so I have no bias -- I just want to see things fair for both sides and we get back to playing a real football SIM, not "who can find the best exploit".


Agree with everything, especially the first point.
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
I thought exactly the same thing.

I saw the extra offense, and sat here trying to figure out how to combat it on the defensive side.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
With you SCACE. The D will need some counter measures, especially with added control over personnel, play side, and blocking assignments for the offense.

The LB auto-drop on run plays should be removed as well since the offense will now have the ability to run any play type from any formation - reading/reacting is going to be more important than ever for the D and the LB group should no longer be handicapped.

(And, I do not coordinate on both sides of the ball, so I do have a bias. )


Yes, the LB auto drop has to go. Season 5, for the most part, gave the defense too much power all season. Balancing was required, but now these changes don't just balance the playing field, they project that Season 6 will be advantage = offense. I hope this will get balanced out a bit in the offseason so we can get a balanced season in...if not, maybe season 7
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
As a DC for a team, the changes to the offense have me VERY worried. We got run over a few times by the famous "Strong I - Off Tackle" and it's hard enough to stop for four downs when you know its coming...even harder now that the offense can run it to either side.

There needs to be some balance, or at least some boost to the defense to prevent this new offensive AI from being overpowered.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i agree with some - as we can choose offensive and defensive plays - it will be very hard to keep the game balanced - as there will be plays that just can't be stopped - or are very hard to stop - that sort of thing.

the game is following the same path as all mmo's - but instead of player classes that dominate then get nerfed - we will be looking at plays (and builds) that dominate and get nerfed.


programming a game that is perfectly balanced is probably impossible
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
i agree with some - as we can choose offensive and defensive plays - it will be very hard to keep the game balanced - as there will be plays that just can't be stopped - or are very hard to stop - that sort of thing.

the game is following the same path as all mmo's - but instead of player classes that dominate then get nerfed - we will be looking at plays (and builds) that dominate and get nerfed.


programming a game that is perfectly balanced is probably impossible


Possibly...but if I'm reading it right....

1. The TE can only move to help when blocking on passing plays. It doesn't sound like the TE can move to the "weak side" to run the offtackle to that side -- no flip plays yet. And it doesn't sound like the TE can move to that side for a passing route -- its to help vs. the RDE, or the blitzing ROLB. If these options do become available, the simple fix is to make the TE side the "strong side", regardless of whether it is left or right side of the line, and have the defense outputs adjust accordingly.

2. If the auto LB drop gets scrapped, teams will be able to play the run a lot better, which would be one way to "nerf" the strong I offtackle run. Right now, you either let the LBers drop back and hope they contain the play after a short gain, or you blitz them and hope they don't get picked up and can make a play after a short gain...either way is not optimal.

3. I'll reiterate -- the bigger concern is that the offense can now choose specific personnel based on formation or play. The defense needs the ability to either...

----A. Alter their personnel based on what HB/FB/TE is in the game...would be nice if we could get the CB vs. specific WR in as well
----B. If X player is in the game in X formation, use X defensive formation
---------i.e. If the power HB is in the game in I-formation, 4-3, cover 1, stack the box. If the elusive back is in during I-formation, 4-3, cover 2, balanced.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.