User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
mikeedangerr
offline
Link
 
The '200' you don't like was the counter-point to my arguement, without it, I'd just be giving Drifter a reach around. 'Oh its great, wow it's super' kind of style.

I commented on both the '200' but mostly on my suggestions/queries on Drifter's idea.

Read my post.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Look guys...I appreciate mikeedangerr's articulate and sincere discussion. At least he's respectful and genuine when discussing stuff. And Ken1 as always is someone i have a lot of time for too. I didnt mean to derail the thread. I never meant to. But i did mention '200' originally and the NEW-SA ideas i had previously, because when i first read drifter's thread I felt he was touching on stuff i'd suggested previously, and there were certain things in his idea that i felt are not good for GLB (that disparity thing) and not as well implemented as my New-SA idea.

Imo every problem in GLB is due to disparity at the base attributes. And so creating another tier of them and another tier of high-earning XP "just to appease the boredom of vets" is the wrong way imo and would just make GLB an even worse game (in context of parity, 150-0 scores, and the sense of futility in player development...no specialization).

I wanted to enter this thread to voice my "nay" vote to the original OP, but offer the OP/Bort to once again re-think that 200-NewSA type of approach. Perhaps merging the ideas, or help create discussion highlighting the flaws in the OP idea so that better ideas from other people could be brought into the discussion that made Drifter's idea even better.

I apologize to drifter and others for '200' mentions. But im really against a future where there's a second tier of attributes and XP and all just to appease vets. It's always these short-term ideas that get implemented and it only leads to great problems because disparity itself is the bigger problem (the current player creation process where you start off as a 6'5 300 lbs player with childlike 11 strength etc).
 
GG
offline
Link
 
What i mean is....people were just racing forward endorsing the OP idea and there wasnt anyone or very few standing forward to voice their problems with it, highlighting the flaws, and trying to promote debate/discussion towards evolving drifter's raw idea into something better before endorsing it.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I'd very strongly disagree with GG's belief that disparity between player abilities is a problem (rather than a good aspect) in GLB.

Lack of parity within leagues is a problem, and certainly if there wasn't that big a difference between a level 20 player and a level 30 player there'd be more parity. The team of level 20's, with good strategy, could beat the team of level 30's (even assuming both teams' builds were about equally good on the whole).

But then you end up with worse lag than we're experiencing on the bulletin boards today because more people freeload by not boosting, because non-boosters could be competitive. We'd have more people using the site but fewer paying for it.

I've supported incentives for higher level players to play at higher levels, and for players to join weaker teams within a given level. Other parity ideas that I dislike have gone beyond that to forcing more parity between teams; but parity between players would be really awful, as opposed to simply not worth the cost, as it costs paying players specifically in site performance areas.

So he dislikes Drifter's idea because it would allow high level players to improve, ending the snails' pace slowdown that makes that portion of the game dull, even as Drifter's idea also leads to the added customization that both he and I would agree is a good thing.

I actually think ideally Drifter's idea should kick in at level 25 (though all the back exp would be a pain to manage) as that's when regular leveling has slowed too far down; but whenever it starts, it helps to keep players growing, which is something we need to keep the game enjoyable, and GG's opposition is based on the bad premise that Level 20's should be able to compete with Level 30's.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Level 25's cant compete with level 28's. A slight build variation can do that. 50-10 scores. And a few level differences is also a big reason why so many players get benched and ultimately go inactive/leave. Because owners will not want to field a team of level 25's to go against a team of level 28's, they'll get destroyed.

These days, slow building and other 'tricks' enables a team of level 25's to be competitive against level 28's and sometimes win. But soon everyone builds the same way again and so the new soft-built level 25's get destroyed again by the new soft-built level 28's.

Round and round.

Last edited Sep 11, 2008 21:09:14
 
GG
offline
Link
 
So to create a whole second tier of SPs, attributes and fast-earning XP just to appease vets is terrible. All just band-aids skirting around and avoiding fixing the foundation and having a better long-term model/vision of GLB. This all relates to noob players not getting snaps, leaving, games 100-0, chemistry, gutting, cheats that people use to get massive XP, etc etc etc. It all relates to the player creation model being the way it is.

It's like there's a badly built foundation in a home, so instead of re-doing the floor, builders will try to patch it up, but in doing that it means the problems keep arising or getting worse over time. Eventually it will get to a point where the whole house just needs to be demolished. So, dont let the house get fully built (going live) yet by just proceeding along applying band-aid after band-aid each time the cracks re-appear due to the floor. Go back, and re-do the floor first so that the house that is built is a long-standing one, and a place that attracts and keeps more customers and grows even bigger.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Eg....I said this as far back as season 1. That the slow rate of XP growth for vet players would eventually dry up and bore everyone. And that this whole idea of making it slow down so that new players could catch up is a bad idea. a) they'll never catch up, b) by the time they do their players will have to retire or these people wont hang around 5 season being back-ups waiting for a chance, c) in the meantime there'll still be 100-0 scores that further drive people away,...etc.

And that's what happened. And instead of re-doing the whole floor, more band-aids will be brought in that in time will only cause more problems. So we fast-forward to today, and vets are screaming about the slow XP, and so a band-aid like drifter's idea gets endorsed and brought in, which is only going to create more disparity, and problems with VA's needing to be nerfed constantly, etc, that all this will again come back to haunt...cracks everywhere, people whining, complaining, leaving, etc.

It wont fix anything. It will just patch over the appearance of cracks emerging. -- a) eventually the second tier XPs will slow down and vets will get bored again, b) the VAs will end up still creating cookie-cutter builds, c) the disparity that already exists will get worse and a NEW layer of disparity among higher level players will emerge (those not earning enough Prestige XP due to not being starters falling behind others who do).
Last edited Sep 11, 2008 21:31:11
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Build a GLB V2.0 concurrently with GLB V1.0 by hiring people, getting a loan/investment, and so this current GLB could play on for another year or so earning money, meanwhile a newer better more stable model is being created. When the V2.0 is finished, replace the V1.0 with it. Like Mozilla 3 replacing Mozilla 2. They were still updating and patching mozilla 2 while they were creating and testing mozilla 3. Once it was ready mozilla 2 goes out of existence in december 2008. something like that is what im suggesting to Bort. Im not suggesting it from the stance that im better/smarter/etc than him. Not at all. But just there's truth in what i say and things like '200' are just suggestions, Bort ultimately can create whatever new model he sees fit is THE best. But the point is, a NEW model is needed as the current one wont stand the test of time and is driving customers and fun away. Doing a new model for a Baseball version is a bit of a shame imo because then the Football one will die a slow death and Baseball is not even gonna make a good MMORPG as football. Football should be the flagship not the back-burner. Baseball wont be as interesting as football in the replays either. It's not as dynamic as football.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Level 25's cant compete with level 28's. A slight build variation can do that. 50-10 scores. And a few level differences is also a big reason why so many players get benched and ultimately go inactive/leave. Because owners will not want to field a team of level 25's to go against a team of level 28's, they'll get destroyed.

These days, slow building and other 'tricks' enables a team of level 25's to be competitive against level 28's and sometimes win. But soon everyone builds the same way again and so the new soft-built level 25's get destroyed again by the new soft-built level 28's.

Round and round.



The Cairo Emperors, of which I was Head GM and now am owner because the owner felt he had to sell the team due to real life issues (though he still helps run it), beat the Conraky Coyotes twice (once regular season, once in the playoffs) despite their having almost 3 levels on us. We didn't slow build.

They don't anymore, because a lot of their players left and we've added a few, but they did. One of our wins over them was by a big margin, too.

And then, of course, after the post I just replied to, you had to be a douchebag and go way off topic and filibuster again with numerous posts unrelated to Drifter's idea.


Last edited Sep 11, 2008 22:43:24
 
GG
offline
Link
 
So a person is a douchebag for expressing their opinion why they dont want more disparity to enter GLB? Anyway, it doesnt matter, Bort's going ahead with it (as per his 'state of the game' address for season 5). So we can look forward to mid-season 5 or season 6 when the suggestions board is full of complaints related to the idea.

Ive been very respectful towards you and drifter and others. I never name-call. In fact even when naying drifter's idea or replying to your posts I always make mention of how much i appreciate your opinions etc and how intelligent you guys are, etc. Yet all i ever get from you and drifter is name-calling and snot-nosed bratty replies like the bolded stuff you and drifter edited into your posts back on page 1 and page 10.

Now you're calling me a douchebag?

This is where i cease talking to you anymore.
Last edited Sep 11, 2008 23:11:36
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Man, this topic got derailed again.

Drifter's gonna be pissed.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
So a person is a douchebag for expressing their opinion why they dont want more disparity to enter GLB? Anyway, it doesnt matter, Bort's going ahead with it (as per his 'state of the game' address for season 5). So we can look forward to mid-season 5 or season 6 when the suggestions board is full of complaints related to the idea.

Ive been very respectful towards you and drifter and others. I never name-call. In fact even when naying drifter's idea or replying to your posts I always make mention of how much i appreciate your opinions etc and how intelligent you guys are, etc. Yet all i ever get from you and drifter is name-calling and snot-nosed bratty replies like the bolded stuff you and drifter edited into your posts back on page 1 and page 10.

Now you're calling me a douchebag?


Yes, because you turned a thread about his idea into a thread about yours.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ok one last reply Ken1...coming up in a second...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Page 3...

Originally posted by Ken1

It's kind of a way to have more SA's (in a different way) as GG and I worked on (and also allow soft caps to be increased, as another option).


Page 5...

Originally posted by drifter

Ken or GG will need to point you at their specific thread


Page 6...

Originally posted by Ken1

I think what he's referring to is the thread where GG and I came up with a whole bunch of new SA's. You (Bort) said that wasn't feasible. But this is a different way to get more SA-type attributes into the game, so it's along those lines.



Note:- I never saw this thread until about page 10 or so. From the get-go, you and Drifter and Bort saw that Drifter's idea was basically imitating my New-SA idea. You and Drifter both early on encouraging me to go find my thread about the New-SA idea and to link it here and use the ideas I had in that towards fleshing out Drifter's Prestige Attributes.

The expectation from you and Drifter was that GG would come in and help give ideas to this thread seeing as Drifter's idea is kinda copying mine. So you two were requesting me to come in. However, because I stepped in and actually didnt like the idea --- ONLY because of the disparity it would create, suddenly my contribution in this thread is derailing it?? I like NewSA, but I dont like Prestige. Why? Not because I like my idea and dont like someone elses. But because my idea (however Bort found it to be an overhaul) was always centered around parity and specialization. Whilst Drifter's was only about creating more disparity and really cookie-cutter building. And there was no focus in it to answer the disparity problems that it would create. Instead, just one big plea for Bort to give the poor vets something to do to not be bored. But that argument alone is untenable because look at what bort's already brining in for season 5 updates related to training and fame etc etc. That's great and doesnt need a second tier XP and attributes idea which is gonna be terrible for parity concerns.

So, because i voiced a dislike for the idea in its OP state, and mentioned those very threads of mine (200 and NewSA) as a way instead to address these issues, then suddnely im the bad person EVEN THO you and drifter and bort were requesting me to bring in links from my original thread!

All ive been saying since page 10 is....NewSA/Prestige type of ideas are fine, BUT, you need to create parity first (200 just being a suggestion). Dont bring in a second tier of attributes and XP because it will create more disparity. Bring in a NEW form of SAs as a way to get to what Drifter's OP was aiming for.


Last edited Sep 11, 2008 23:34:54
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Page 3...

Originally posted by Ken1


It's kind of a way to have more SA's (in a different way) as GG and I worked on (and also allow soft caps to be increased, as another option).


Page 5...

Originally posted by drifter


Ken or GG will need to point you at their specific thread


Page 6...

Originally posted by Ken1


I think what he's referring to is the thread where GG and I came up with a whole bunch of new SA's. You (Bort) said that wasn't feasible. But this is a different way to get more SA-type attributes into the game, so it's along those lines.



Note:- I never saw this thread until about page 10 or so. From the get-go, you and Drifter and Bort saw that Drifter's idea was basically imitating my New-SA idea. You and Drifter both early on encouraging me to go find my thread about the New-SA idea and to link it here and use the ideas I had in that towards fleshing out Drifter's Prestige Attributes.

The expectation from you and Drifter was that GG would come in and help give ideas to this thread seeing as Drifter's idea is kinda copying mine. So you two were requesting me to come in. However, because I stepped in and actually didnt like the idea --- ONLY because of the disparity it would create, suddenly my contribution in this thread is derailing it?? I like NewSA, but I dont like Prestige. Why? Not because I like my idea and dont like someone elses. But because my idea (however Bort found it to be an overhaul) was always centered around parity and specialization. Whilst Drifter's was only about creating more disparity and really cookie-cutter building. And there was no focus in it to answer the disparity problems that it would create. Instead, just one big plea for Bort to give the poor vets something to do to not be bored. But that argument alone is untenable because look at what bort's already brining in for season 5 updates related to training and fame etc etc. That's great and doesnt need a second tier XP and attributes idea which is gonna be terrible for parity concerns.

So, because i voiced a dislike for the idea in its OP state, and mentioned those very threads of mine (200 and NewSA) as a way instead to address these issues, then suddnely im the bad person EVEN THO you and drifter and bort were requesting me to bring in links from my original thread!

All ive been saying since page 10 is....NewSA/Prestige type of ideas are fine, BUT, you need to create parity first (200 just being a suggestion). Dont bring in a second tier of attributes and XP because it will create more disparity. Bring in a NEW form of SAs as a way to get to what Drifter's OP was aiming for.




But instead of just dissenting about the idea, you turned it into a thread about the 200 idea, derailing the entire discussion.

If you didn't see you were doing that, it was pointed out, and you apologized. But then you started to do it again!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.