User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
grugnur
offline
Link
 
"But I do expect a guy built as a KR to be a better KR than a slow/strong TE or HB."

the max/min nerf has yet to be applied to the power runners... i suspect that they are next on the list
 
fumblestruck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grugnur
"But I do expect a guy built as a KR to be a better KR than a slow/strong TE or HB."

the max/min nerf has yet to be applied to the power runners... i suspect that they are next on the list


I sure hope so...its ridiculous seeing a RB blow past a DT/LB/SS/CB and to the house. Granted sometimes that may happen, but its extremely rare. That's why it would be a highlight. Remember that even a guy like Barry Sanders (not a power back BTW) had games where he was held to negative yardage. There has to be a trade-off or else it is just as much of an exploit as speed was.

On top of the power back - what about WR's that can remove 3 LB's from a play with a single block? Yeah that's realistic...
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare


That matters little to the players who were making their builds in season 1, 2 or early 3. Those who bought CE back in season 1, 2, or early 3 and allocated their points in season 1, 2, or early 3 completely got screwed over because they were paying and playing for the rules that were in place then....not now.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 08:42:08
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare

I like the new changes, the game is fixed now, if you don't like it then leave already


I reject that too. If the forum search worked, I could show you that it was actually announced at about playoff time, and I was lucky enough to have read it and had time to make adjustments, as you apparently did as well. Dont tell me for a second that you had ANY idea how much stuff was going to change at once midway through last season.

You know I like you man, but you arent THAT smart. Again, I think people should adjust and learn, but the pace of change is so slow at higher levels, I feel it is clear that there should be some allowance for helping with that adjustment.

Hell, if you want to make it for everyone but me and Shaknbake, I have no issue with that, but a limited, one time, minor respec is in order.

I already have one pillar of my team who just stopped boosting because of being painted into a corner. I dont want more.


I hear ya Xeef, you know I'm cool with you. I knew of the changes by around day 20 at the latest season 3. Toric, my GM had a hunch, we gambled. We started making changes then, you played with me and know my team wasn't a powerhouse last season. Season 3 was a bug, players were good based on stuff that to me, were not football skills, speed & power mostly. This isn't track or weightlifting. We kept our players pretty well balanced knowing this is a beta sim and there will be changes that we're gonna have to adjust for


Don't take it as disrespect boss, a lot of you guys are stand up people. There are a lot though that are just whiny little biatches though which is aggravating after a while

It's not fair to the teams that planned ahead and took a gamble, like we did, then in the end let everyone get a chance to fix their builds now. We could have been wrong about the change rumors and screwed up our whole roster of players, and having a loosing season. I had to release, at the time, a level 24 HB and sign a level 16 power HB. A major gamble? Yes! Paid off? Yes!


EDIT: Also I've probably paid out 4-5 million dollars to redo equipment for a lot of players on my team. That seemed to help a lot as well
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 09:00:19
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by megaman1337
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare


That matters little to the players who were making their builds in season 1, 2 or early 3. Those who bought CE back in season 1, 2, or early 3 and allocated their points in season 1, 2, or early 3 completely got screwed over because they were paying and playing for the rules that were in place then....not now.


I've been here since sometime in season one boss, no problems here
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by megaman1337

Originally posted by ShakeNBake


The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare


That matters little to the players who were making their builds in season 1, 2 or early 3. Those who bought CE back in season 1, 2, or early 3 and allocated their points in season 1, 2, or early 3 completely got screwed over because they were paying and playing for the rules that were in place then....not now.


I've been here since sometime in season one boss, no problems here


So have I and I had the luxury of going inactive for about a month and then coming back so the changes weren't as hard on me as they could have been. Just because you're fine with them does not mean other's builds are fine with them too.

What you said in no way refuted what I had said earlier. I was talking in general terms and understand that some people were not affected as much as others.

Hmm, it looks to me like your level 28 DT was pretty bad to begin with. No wonder you're not complaining.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 09:10:45
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
I agree, the people who built super strength and super speed were affected more heavily. Those were never good builds though, just good for Season 3 which was crap IMO

Now the sim is fixed and everyone is freaking out.


Your right, my DT wasn't good because I didn't invest completely in strength. I knew that's not the way to build a solid player. So bad he was for season 3 but now it's fixed, the sim recognizes good builds, YAY


by the way my WR had 1 touchdown last season, so he sucked too. Wanna know y? I didn't want to build a WR that had speed and nothing else, that would be a crappy build, instead i sucked it up, didn't complain and had a shitty season. The sim recognizes good builds, YAY


I'm not being a dick by the way, I know it's hard to tell through typing so I'm throwing it out there.


 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
most players can be fixed with an equipment swap anyhow, the ones that aren't built extremely bad anyhow. Trick is to have a decent owner who wants to win and will empty the bank to do so
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
I agree, the people who built super strength and super speed were affected more heavily. Those were never good builds though, just good for Season 3 which was crap IMO

Now the sim is fixed and everyone is freaking out.


Your right, my DT wasn't good because I didn't invest completely in strength. I knew that's not the way to build a solid player. So bad he was for season 3 but now it's fixed, the sim recognizes good builds, YAY


by the way my WR had 1 touchdown last season, so he sucked too. Wanna know y? I didn't want to build a WR that had speed and nothing else, that would be a crappy build, instead i sucked it up, didn't complain and had a shitty season. The sim recognizes good builds, YAY


I'm not being a dick by the way, I know it's hard to tell through typing so I'm throwing it out there.




Those builds were at least good for season 1 and 2 as well. Your DT still doesn't seem much improved to me and I'm not sure why you're celebrating.

I didn't invest completely in strength either. In fact my build is very balanced, yet I had and still have to make some big changes to make my DE more effective. It's crap and Bort is making a killing off these people who are buying extra flex points to again change around their custom equipment to what works. He's making a killing anyway.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 10:23:26
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
my NT is third on the depth chart in a 3-4 genius, he does fine when he plays

The changes are for the better of the game boss

It doesn't cost real money to redo regular equipment which will fix most builds in itself or at least band-aid the problem until you can fix it completely.

If we hadn't known about the changes that would be one thing, these were all expected changes that make the game a lot better IMO





 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
my NT is third on the depth chart in a 3-4 genius, he does fine when he plays

The changes are for the better of the game boss

It doesn't cost real money to redo regular equipment which will fix most builds in itself or at least band-aid the problem until you can fix it completely.

If we hadn't known about the changes that would be one thing, these were all expected changes that make the game a lot better IMO







Wasn't talking about your NT. I'm talking about your level 26 DT who's at the starting position.

Either way, that doesn't matter and it's not the point. The point still stands that season 1 2 and early 3 players spent their money on the game that was in place then...not now.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Ken1

Chaos, funny.

None of my builds have been bothered much by the changes. But then I don't expect my LB's with tackling over 40 to make every tackle, because there's plenty of room above 40, nor my WR that has Catching over 50 and Vision of almost 40 to catch every pass-- because if that happened, there'd be no reason to every raise Catching above 50.

People don't want their players to make mistakes, but balanced, minmax, whatever, they all will and should.

And Druez is right that this thread should be locked. It's not a bug report.


And I don't expect any of my players to play 100% perfect games either.

But I do expect a guy built as a KR to be a better KR than a slow/strong TE or HB.


I agree. He should. That's an issue that is generally recognized. Basically, on ST's they have to allow people who normally couldn't block or tackle well to do so much better on ST's than in a game, or people would have to play their starters there.

I think some of that's the case (a backup QB of mine plays ST's; obviously, his tackling sucks and if someone with his tackling had the same high tackle percentage on regular plays as he does on ST's-- even with his high strength-- I'd be appalled).

But more has to be done to make ST's more realistic.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Fine, we may have been given some info about tackling and speed needing to be changed - but what about the huge stamina hits ST players now get?


I don't think that's new. I don't especially like it, but I don't think that's even a change.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Or how agility is now the new speed?


It isn't. An "Agility 80, Speed 20" player is even weaker than a "Speed 80, Agility 20 player...well, maybe the one exception would be if we were a HB with the Elusive SA's; but even so he'd be better off with more balance.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Or how quite a few other random attributes have an effect on seemingly unrelated skils (I read somewhere about punters needing jumping???)


We should know these things, and I wouldn't have intuited it (given there aren't bad snaps). But jumping is meant to apply to all "explosive" actions, as it helps make diving tackles, so it's not ridiculous.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos
With SO many changes and SO many attributes needed addressing, again, the ONLY people that are making huge benefits are the players with uber strong HBs - probably built with all strength, rather than 'realistically', as they smash their way through 10 or more tackles per play on an unrealistically frequent basis.


There's a power back on the a team I GM. He also has solid Speed, Agility, and Vision, as well as, of course, Carrying. Power backs do so well because no one builds LB's to stop them, so far. Let LB's get their Tackling and Strength as high as the power backs' Strength and Carrying and we'll talk.

If someone has an unbalanced build without some Speed, Agility, and Vision, maybe that's overpowered; I don't know. I just know I haven't had a team play a team whose power back dominated us, and the one on the team I GM is far from dominating, either.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by megaman1337
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

my NT is third on the depth chart in a 3-4 genius, he does fine when he plays

The changes are for the better of the game boss

It doesn't cost real money to redo regular equipment which will fix most builds in itself or at least band-aid the problem until you can fix it completely.

If we hadn't known about the changes that would be one thing, these were all expected changes that make the game a lot better IMO







Wasn't talking about your NT. I'm talking about your level 26 DT who's at the starting position.

Either way, that doesn't matter and it's not the point. The point still stands that season 1 2 and early 3 players spent their money on the game that was in place then...not now.


again, we play a 3-4 genius, do you know what that means?
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 11:48:28
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by 1VBChaos

With SO many changes and SO many attributes needed addressing, again, the ONLY people that are making huge benefits are the players with uber strong HBs - probably built with all strength, rather than 'realistically', as they smash their way through 10 or more tackles per play on an unrealistically frequent basis.


There's a power back on the a team I GM. He also has solid Speed, Agility, and Vision, as well as, of course, Carrying. Power backs do so well because no one builds LB's to stop them, so far. Let LB's get their Tackling and Strength as high as the power backs' Strength and Carrying and we'll talk.

If someone has an unbalanced build without some Speed, Agility, and Vision, maybe that's overpowered; I don't know. I just know I haven't had a team play a team whose power back dominated us, and the one on the team I GM is far from dominating, either.


+1
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by megaman1337

Originally posted by ShakeNBake


my NT is third on the depth chart in a 3-4 genius, he does fine when he plays

The changes are for the better of the game boss

It doesn't cost real money to redo regular equipment which will fix most builds in itself or at least band-aid the problem until you can fix it completely.

If we hadn't known about the changes that would be one thing, these were all expected changes that make the game a lot better IMO







Wasn't talking about your NT. I'm talking about your level 26 DT who's at the starting position.

Either way, that doesn't matter and it's not the point. The point still stands that season 1 2 and early 3 players spent their money on the game that was in place then...not now.


again, we play a 3-4 genius, do you know what that means?


Why not respond to what he said the point was?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.