User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Been there, done that too.


just for the sake of it:
i've been pretty much going in the opposite direction... so from a rhetorical standpoint, i think our experiences are a wash. just because one person has changed their mind doesn't mean they're automatically right for having done so.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
It must have been amazing to be with him.


it's a wonder that most of the people he interacted with didn't believe him.

btw, i was just messing with ya. trust me, i'm well aware of the doctrine... i come from a fairly strict religious background myself.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


all that is fine... and i have no way of proving you wrong (nor do i care to). but note that you have absolutely no way of proving yourself right... which invites the question: why do you believe in what you said above and not something else?


ETA: (concerning my first sentence) i would, however, debate you on innatism... especially the version(s) posited by this guy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=453073


First of all, can you define innatism? I am unfamiliar with the term.

Secondly, the question why is the most dangerous one. Why? It's personal man, it happened to me. I experienced it first-hand. It's a personal real-life story of what happened in my life to change me from a Devout Atheist and Secular Humanist for seventeen years. I'll go into detail should it be required, but i do have an answer.

I felt what is called the "baptism of love (in Christ)" when i came to a very low point in my life. It took a lot to break down the pride and it put me in a very very dark place. I then experienced some people who had been where i was, and doing what i should be doing (helping others). So i listened. As they talked about God, i told them that God didn't want me..., they had the right answers. They told me about God. They told me about Jesus. Believe you, me, i was not wanting to hear about Jesus. But something changed in me that night. As i read Matthew chapter 5, i knew. THIS is real, this is right, this is what i had been missing for so long.

Blah Blah Blah, the story goes on, but you ask why...there it is in a nutshell.

I can prove myself right. I am a living, breathing, walking miracle who sees God in all things, all day, every day. My witness is justified by how i live my life. The proof is the restored relationships, the restored health, the hope for a future and the many, many blessings in my life. That is one of the easiest ways to witness for Christ. To argue with people who don't believe is probably the worst. But the way i live and treat people. They know you are different, they know and want to know how, and why...that is when you drop the J bomb.

Last edited Aug 11, 2008 00:00:17
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


just for the sake of it:
i've been pretty much going in the opposite direction... so from a rhetorical standpoint, i think our experiences are a wash. just because one person has changed their mind doesn't mean they're automatically right for having done so.


I disagree, what is more relevant to our discussion than our day-to-day, first-hand, living-in-it reality? It certainly is more palpable than aliens in other galaxies.

Don't give up on Christ. It's a world of pain. But the seed is planted, i know you will return to the Truth. But man, the pain in between. I just hope you aren't as stubborn as i am. Yikes.





 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
First of all, can you define innatism? I am unfamiliar with the term.

essentially, innatism is the belief that humans are born already possessing certain knowledge/concepts... which was opposed by the empiricists (nb. not empiricism proper) who believed that all knowledge was learned and that the human mind began as a blank slate (cf. tabula rasa). in its classical sense, innatism somewhat presupposes a supreme being that grants the "innate" ideas... and so some people use 'nativism' if they instead mean that innate knowledge/concepts are programmed genetically/etc.


Originally posted by atom871
Secondly, the question why is the most dangerous one. Why? It's personal man, it happened to me. I experienced it first-hand. It's a personal real-life story of what happened in my life to change me from a Devout Atheist and Secular Humanist for seventeen years. I'll go into detail should it be required, but i do have an answer.

I felt what is called the "baptism of love (in Christ)" when i came to a very low point in my life. It took a lot to break down the pride and it put me in a very very dark place. I then experienced some people who had been where i was, and doing what i should be doing (helping others). So listened. As they talked about God, i told them that God didn't want me..., they had the right answers. They told me about God. They told me about Jesus. Believe you, me, i was not wanting to hear about Jesus. But something changed in me that night. As i read Matthew chapter 5, i knew. THIS is real, this is right, this is what i had been missing for so long.

Blah Blah Blah, the story goes on, but you ask why...there it is in a nutshell.

and that is exactly why i have no interest in trying to disprove your faith (even if i could)... quite honestly, 'simple faith' (not 'simple' in the demeaning sense) is a good thing, so long as it doesn't cause harm. but too many people are only exposed to the ugly side of religion and/or religious people and aren't aware of the great many people profoundly helped by spiritual belief... probably because such people typically aren't the ones who then shout it from the rooftops.

having transited from my background, i find myself somewhat trapped in the middle in these conversations... religious people and non-religious people are just worlds apart and typically do themselves a disservice by the tenor of their conversation. and i wince at all the charismatic/evangelical movements today... i can't help but think of them as one big self-fulfilling persecution complex. but similarly, the anti-christian fervor from certain quarters that are nevertheless spiritual themselves is also puzzling.

but more than anything, most conversations about religion are poisoned by the fact that each side affords themselves epistemological ground while holding the other to an analytical standard. on the rare times that neutral ground is achieved, surprise surprise... both sides have way more in common than they ever thought.
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by Catullus 16



all that is fine... and i have no way of proving you wrong (nor do i care to). but note that you have absolutely no way of proving yourself right... which invites the question: why do you believe in what you said above and not something else?


ETA: (concerning my first sentence) i would, however, debate you on innatism... especially the version(s) posited by this guy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=453073


First of all, can you define innatism? I am unfamiliar with the term.

Secondly, the question why is the most dangerous one. Why? It's personal man, it happened to me. I experienced it first-hand. It's a personal real-life story of what happened in my life to change me from a Devout Atheist and Secular Humanist for seventeen years. I'll go into detail should it be required, but i do have an answer.

I felt what is called the "baptism of love (in Christ)" when i came to a very low point in my life. It took a lot to break down the pride and it put me in a very very dark place. I then experienced some people who had been where i was, and doing what i should be doing (helping others). So i listened. As they talked about God, i told them that God didn't want me..., they had the right answers. They told me about God. They told me about Jesus. Believe you, me, i was not wanting to hear about Jesus. But something changed in me that night. As i read Matthew chapter 5, i knew. THIS is real, this is right, this is what i had been missing for so long.

Blah Blah Blah, the story goes on, but you ask why...there it is in a nutshell.

I can prove myself right. I am a living, breathing, walking miracle who sees God in all things, all day, every day. My witness is justified by how i live my life. The proof is the restored relationships, the restored health, the hope for a future and the many, many blessings in my life. That is one of the easiest ways to witness for Christ. To argue with people who don't believe is probably the worst. But the way i live and treat people. They know you are different, they know and want to know how, and why...that is when you drop the J bomb.



So you believe because some people gave you a god intervention of sorts. You believe because other people "told" you about god. Okay. On that note I have some magic beans I want to give you for that cow you have.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by Catullus 16
just for the sake of it:
i've been pretty much going in the opposite direction... so from a rhetorical standpoint, i think our experiences are a wash. just because one person has changed their mind doesn't mean they're automatically right for having done so.

I disagree, what is more relevant to our discussion than our day-to-day, first-hand, living-in-it reality? It certainly is more palpable than aliens in other galaxies.

Don't give up on Christ. It's a world of pain. But the seed is planted, i know you will return to the Truth. But man, the pain in between. I just hope you aren't as stubborn as i am. Yikes.


i'm a little confused by what you wrote... i also consider myself to be living in reality. my point was limited just to rhetoric: just because you made a decision to go from A-->B doesn't mean someone still at A is automatically wrong. i mean, i guess your anecdotal evidence gives lends some credence to your opinion, but... it still doesn't stand as analytical proof (inductive/deductive). and since i stand as a counterexample, neither of our experiences stand as rhetorical evidence (abductive).
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
So you believe because some people gave you a god intervention of sorts. You believe because other people "told" you about god. Okay. On that note I have some magic beans I want to give you for that cow you have.


while it might not analytically stand up to the correlation/causation test, its certainly in the ballpark. i'm not sold either... but i'm willing to bet you've made the exact same logical move many times in your life. granted, this one is writ large, but still...
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

just for the sake of it:
i've been pretty much going in the opposite direction... so from a rhetorical standpoint, i think our experiences are a wash. just because one person has changed their mind doesn't mean they're automatically right for having done so.

i'm a little confused by what you wrote... i also consider myself to be living in reality. my point was limited just to rhetoric: just because you made a decision to go from A-->B doesn't mean someone still at A is automatically wrong. i mean, i guess your anecdotal evidence gives lends some credence to your opinion, but... it still doesn't stand as analytical proof (inductive/deductive). and since i stand as a counterexample, neither of our experiences stand as rhetorical evidence (abductive).

you said, "our experience is a wash"... that is where i was coming from.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

So you believe because some people gave you a god intervention of sorts. You believe because other people "told" you about god. Okay. On that note I have some magic beans I want to give you for that cow you have.


Their actions and lives were their testimony to the Truth. If you can show me those beans work, i'll trade you my cow.

They had been through what i had gone through and came out better than ever. They took that new lease on life to help others. That was their witness, it helped open my eyes and my heart. I thank God for sending them. I couldn't bear the pain any longer. I was lost and without hope. Now, i have plenty of hope, and guidance. If the Holy Spirit leads me to buy those beans from you, by golly, i will.
Last edited Aug 11, 2008 00:33:17
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
you said, "our experience is a wash"... that is where i was coming from.


well, technically i said "from a rhetorical standpoint, i think our experiences are a wash".

but even from a epistemological/evidential standpoint, it would still have to be a wash... not for either of us personally, but in the eyes of an unbiased stranger. i mean, i could use your own words on you and say:
"Don't give up on Logic. It's a world of pain. But the seed is planted, i know you will return to Reason. But man, the pain in between. I just hope you aren't as stubborn as i am. Yikes."

... and wouldn't that sound a little arrogant and self-righteous?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
If you can show me those beans work


... and there's the logical move right there. whether or not the beans/religion actually do work is a completely separate issue from whether or not you're justified in your belief. given that no human ever has made a completely informed decision, it doesn't work for a fellow human to deride your religious choice as "magic beans".
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


i'm a little confused by what you wrote... i also consider myself to be living in reality. my point was limited just to rhetoric: just because you made a decision to go from A-->B doesn't mean someone still at A is automatically wrong. i mean, i guess your anecdotal evidence gives lends some credence to your opinion, but... it still doesn't stand as analytical proof (inductive/deductive). and since i stand as a counterexample, neither of our experiences stand as rhetorical evidence (abductive).


I didn't mean to imply that you were delusional.

And your stance as a counter-example, well, time will tell. I guess all the results aren't in for your inductive/deductive analysis. For myself however, my own hypotheses (sp? plural?) over the last seventeen years have not panned out. But this new one... i have found NO holes and miraculous (by the real meaning of the word) results. I think i will stick with my new frame of reference, probably for eternity.

It would be counter-productive to tell unbelievers they are "wrong" when it is so much easier to just do what is right, and let that speak for itself.

 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by atom871

If you can show me those beans work


... and there's the logical move right there. whether or not the beans/religion actually do work is a completely separate issue from whether or not you're justified in your belief. given that no human ever has made a completely informed decision, it doesn't work for a fellow human to deride your religious choice as "magic beans".


Well manmade ideas and beliefs like religion is very much like magic beans. They both have the same end result, a fairy tale.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
And your stance as a counter-example, well, time will tell. I guess all the results aren't in for your inductive/deductive analysis. For myself however, my own hypotheses (sp? plural?) over the last seventeen years have not panned out. But this new one... i have found NO holes and miraculous (by the real meaning of the word) results. I think i will stick with my new frame of reference, probably for eternity.


but again, i could just use your own words on you and say: as for your stance as an example... well, time will tell. as for me, i've found no holes in my view, so i'll stick with it.

and just to clarify... i haven't shifted my beliefs because of any "inductive/deductive analysis". if anything, its been more the absence of the same.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.