User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
gherman
offline
Link
 
I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
One thing that has been big on everyone’s wish list for this game is to be able to scrimmage your offense and defense. How about having Coaches have this ability? Their money can be used to purchase practices for 1 play or 1 series of plays or whatever amount seems fair.

This would allow teams to see if their defense actually works as they intend or their offense or even special teams, but more importantly it would be using the Coaches to actually Coach. Not only would you be able to see if the play works, but running the play could improve the team’s on field chemistry or morale for that play.

So if you ran the Single Back Flanker Drag 100 times in practice, your players could be able to run that play without any problems. To keep teams from creating another exploit, make the cost of running the same play increase during the season.

Say it costs a coach $1,000 to host a practice for 1 play. If he runs the same play, it will cost him $2,000, but the team get’s a 1% success rate of performing that play. So to get it to 100% success, you’d have to have a coach pay $100,000.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Bingo. Both scale the number of slots available up as the seasons go on, and by leagues.

An idea would be specializing your coach. After 2 seasons, you can turn an o-coach into a WR coach or something.

In this way, we'd have a few seasons without the possibility of position coaches, but they'll slowly open up as coaches mature, and new players turn into coaches as the seasons go on.

Also only make those specialized slots available for higher tiers. Cloud leagues don't need more than a few coaches, really.
 
gherman
offline
Link
 
bump VOTE NO
 
soulcrshr
offline
Link
 
sigh this coaches idea falls under the "polish a turd, its still a turd" genre. Fix the dam sim first and leave all the side show stuff alone.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by soulcrshr
sigh this coaches idea falls under the "polish a turd, its still a turd" genre. Fix the dam sim first and leave all the side show stuff alone.


He wanted something done in time for the decline. I think the best thing he can do now is allow players to put their potential retired player into a frozen state until "retired to become coaches" becomes a viable option.
 
gherman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gherman
I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies


add this to OP
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gherman
Originally posted by gherman

I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies


add this to OP


done.
 
JJudo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gherman
bump VOTE NO


herman, the idea is great, just not fine tuned yet, give it some time.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gherman
I would like to do the same thing EXCEPT we instead create the coaches from birth and train him like a player good idea imo same rules apply u will be able to upgrade ur coaching abilities and so on...you get xp like a player from games or day to day u can also instead of train "Create plays" or something like training needs a lot of work but I think this idea gives everyone a fair shot think of the newbies


Except Bort needs to make it less obvious like he does with player builds.

"Argh, I've got 100 points into Intelligence and 80 points into Motivation, but I just can't get my players to learn that new play I made!"

"Needs more vision?"
 
Mynno
offline
Link
 
Going to throw two out of the box suggestions with one of them being very controversial for a coach to spend his money on.

1. Practice film: The coach can purchase game film from an opponents practice sessions. What it does is randomly opens 3 players builds from your opponents team for that coach to see. If an OC does it then it will be defensive players, an DC it will be offensive players and of course ST will be special teams. (problem here is people could post builds so there would have to be a rule in place that if you post someone elses build you can be banned) This is the controversial one. Can only be done once per coach per team to be played.

2. I like this idea but it may be a bit out there, give each player position another set of skills in a third skill tree that they can choose to invest points in. But they can only be unlocked by the coach. The higher the level of the coach the more of the third skill tree he can unlock for his palyers. Where the money comes in is he pays for those skills to be unlocked for each game. If the money is not there the skill is greyed out and can not be used for that game. A bit of risk for the players to put points into but with a good coach their best skills can be brought out in the game.
Edited by Mynno on Sep 8, 2009 18:30:55
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Mo' money mo' problems

remember that Bort
 
stevemm033
offline
Link
 
instead of coaches why not just put room on team page or a link it for a TEAM hall of fame/ring of honor whatever you call it. If money needs to be made from it then either pay to have one
or pay to add player. If you want to spend the $$ you will if you don't you don't
Edited by stevemm033 on Sep 8, 2009 18:50:05
 
Arcadic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arcadic
Suggestion to placate the need for coaches for all teams in S12: (i am unclear as to if coaches have their own levels, but my idea is based on a independent coach level.)

Put Caps on each league for the level of coach they can sign. Cap the AA-Pro leagues, and don't allow coaches to go below the AA tier. Raise the caps similar to the old cap system every season, and add one more tier of the pyramid to be allowed coaches.
The tiers allowed coaches this coming season could be based on who is actually making them, IE, if only enough coaches are made to cover the Pro leagues, then simply only allow the pro leagues to have coaches. My biggest issue with coaches existing, is that teams i compete on do not have access to coaches in the next season or two.

I also support a limit per tier of coaches, as described by others in this thread.

I am totally against the the idea of coaches as a whole, but if they are going to happen, i want it to happen in a fair manner to all who play this game. Letting coaches run wild in their first season is not going to make anyone happy. Capping where the coaches can go for 5-6 seasons will at least make the game playable to those who have no S1-S2 player/connections. I'm quite ticked off about this only being announced as a feature this season, as i had two players who could have become S13 coaches, but instead i retired them this season. Very poor implementation there imo.


bump, maybe put the first two paragraphs in the OP?
 
Thom Yorke
offline
Link
 
Ranting better be a skill

You play to win the game
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.