User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
James128
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by James128

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by PackMan97



Originally posted by lukin83





It is still not an equal opportunity for the inferior regions and leaves USAPL as the cream of the crop league (which it should not be).


How is that? BTW - If they are inferior? should they receive equal representation in a "Best of the best" league? as long as every region promotes the top two teams every season that's equal opportunity.

The current solution only gives inferior teams a chance in the World League as oppose to those teams that have helped build the GLB community.


Stop being bias and go somewhere else. You have no clue how good other teams are compared to teams in other leagues. You are USAPL bias, and on the Washington Wolfpack. Seriously.....the USAPL whiners are the reason this thing almost didn't happen in the first place. You also suggested using fake tournaments and biased polls. Thats a fail...did the wolfpack do well or something?

Cobra Kai is not on top 25 rankings yet we beat top 25 teams. We were not invited to tournaments...we don't care. The ONLY thing that is legit is how your team plays when it counts.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/playoff_bracket.pl?league_id=15&conference_id=0

Leg Swept! Now take that bias somewhere else. The GLB community as a whole is getting very sick of all the USAPL crying and bias that goes around.


Let me make something clear. The polls aren't biased... You guys just haven't been very good the past couple of seasons. We gave you guys the benefit of the doubt in the first pwt and you guys went 0-3. As for the tournaments you guys weren't invited to the pwt or toc. Not sure if you signed up for the Hazy/Addict but you could of. As for you guys not being in the top 25 lets see you have 1 win over a top 25 team and 2 loses going into the playoffs. There is talk that you guys should get in after your playoff run. Washington has 3 quality wins over top 15 teams HHW, Emmaus, and Krazy. There loses are to Monmouth, HHW, Marblehead, and ***O***. Not to mention 15-1 in Usa pro west compared to 12-4 in Slap dizzy.


cool....this isn't related to demotion. Your opinion is your opinion and mine is mine. Lets agree to disagree and talk demotion and the WPL.


Thats fine but don't shit on are rankings...
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.


 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Bort:

While its of course evident that around 75% of owners want the world league, I still believe it is not for the best and people truly do not know what is best for them. In the end this is your game and you need to do what you feel is best, and ignore the whining as no dedicated owners are gonna quit the game because there is no world league.

Hell, I feel the idea was much more practical seasons 3-4, and when you brought it up last off-season you unnecessarily put the idea back in a ton of peoples mind.

At any rate, if you do truly want equality among the leagues, and to have a single top league, I'd STRONG suggest....

1. Remove current league region names, in favor of cool colors or something (Cyan Region, Magenta region, whatever).
2. The only way it makes sense to feed leagues into 1 league yet still suppose the things like rivalries, demoting to correct leagues, as well as a fair jump in talent at each level is to have 1 giant pyramid.

It is 100% retarded to have leagues go 2 into 1 at every level, then at the top suddenly have 8 go into 1. Its too big of a jump in talent, it discourages league continuity, and with retirement right around the corner (which is gonna be a whole nother issue) neither of those are things that people want.

I'd argue that keepings things as they are along with your tourny idea is for the best (and 25% of owners know it), but if you truly do want 1 league at the top, you need to move into 1 giant pyramid and ignore the whiners who are gonna argue against it. Its your game, make a gut check and decide whats best for it, because majority is not always right...
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by PackMan97


Originally posted by lukin83




It is still not an equal opportunity for the inferior regions and leaves USAPL as the cream of the crop league (which it should not be).


How is that? BTW - If they are inferior? should they receive equal representation in a "Best of the best" league? as long as every region promotes the top two teams every season that's equal opportunity.

The current solution only gives inferior teams a chance in the World League as oppose to those teams that have helped build the GLB community.


Stop being bias and go somewhere else. You have no clue how good other teams are compared to teams in other leagues. You are USAPL bias, and on the Washington Wolfpack. Seriously.....the USAPL whiners are the reason this thing almost didn't happen in the first place. You also suggested using fake tournaments and biased polls. Thats a fail...did the wolfpack do well or something?

Cobra Kai is not on top 25 rankings yet we beat top 25 teams. We were not invited to tournaments...we don't care. The ONLY thing that is legit is how your team plays when it counts.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/playoff_bracket.pl?league_id=15&conference_id=0

Leg Swept! Now take that bias somewhere else. The GLB community as a whole is getting very sick of all the USAPL crying and bias that goes around.


Let me make something clear. The polls aren't biased... You guys just haven't been very good the past couple of seasons. We gave you guys the benefit of the doubt in the first pwt and you guys went 0-3. As for the tournaments you guys weren't invited to the pwt or toc. Not sure if you signed up for the Hazy/Addict but you could of. As for you guys not being in the top 25 lets see you have 1 win over a top 25 team and 2 loses going into the playoffs. There is talk that you guys should get in after your playoff run. Washington has 3 quality wins over top 15 teams HHW, Emmaus, and Krazy. There loses are to Monmouth, HHW, Marblehead, and ***O***. Not to mention 15-1 in Usa pro west compared to 12-4 in Slap dizzy.




In summary:

Kai is better (maybe much better) than people give them credit for.

Wolfpack is a great team that would very likely beat 16 of the WL teams (mine included).

Wolfpack lost in the playoffs, they'll get another shot.

Kai has gained the attention of folks with legit wins and even legit losses...they'll get more credit in the future, if they continue to earn it.


Back on topic please?

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by jamz


Originally posted by Bort



I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


This is the only way Bort, that the game will progress.

Again, what right does the extra 3-13 team in Pro League have to be there because there are 2 below him that already demoted, Promote the AAA Teams, Demote the WPL Teams as needed, and force more Pro teams that suck back to AAA.


I agree with Jamz.... teams that are 3-13 or 4-12 seem to stick around Pro leagues for ever....give people more of a chance. Plus it will increase the chance that new teams can work their way up the ranks faster and play in the WPL sooner than 9 seasons.


And give those teams a chance to maybe win some games in AAA instead?


Moving more up and more down would give people more of a chance to win. Winning turns franchises around, keeps guts from happening, increases team interest and morale. Hanging around the same league at 3-13 hurts/kills teams.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ArthurRiot
Ok, can I say this?

PROMOTION I think should be for 2 teams per season. The 8 league winners play 2 games (all 8, and all 4). The two remaining champion teams go to the WPL. Whichever leagues lose those teams gain the bottom 2 teams in the WPL.

It makes the season 4 days longer, and solves everything.

As for which team goes where, it becomes a case by case deal. Obviously 2 Pro leagues are losing 2 GREAT teams, so this should really bring parity back, in the most fair way.

I think Bort and co. work a little too hard to please everyone. At some point, we just need a basic rulebook that is followed so all of this is not based on the apparent whim of Bort.
Most people agree that demoting 2 WPL teams is way way too little. Almost every other suggestion involves demoting 8 or 16 teams ... makes you wonder why they don't do something like that in the other leagues.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by lukin83




Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


Why?
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Originally posted by walker1

Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.




 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by beenlurken

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by lukin83




Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.








That's basically the division idea. Not sure if I like it, tbh.


I am not sure I understand you reasoning that it will not "ensure the best of the best year in and year out". There is no way to ensure that the very best teams are in this league every year (at least for the first few seasons... unless you hand pick the teams that are perceived to be the very best). Also this is predicated on the notion that leagues are superior to others. Eventually all regions will be on the same level and you will have the best teams of each region representing them.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
I still believe it is not for the best and people truly do not know what is best for them.
I think that's how slavery started.

 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Originally posted by walker1

Originally posted by walker1


Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.






 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pariah
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by jamz



Originally posted by Bort




I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


This is the only way Bort, that the game will progress.

Again, what right does the extra 3-13 team in Pro League have to be there because there are 2 below him that already demoted, Promote the AAA Teams, Demote the WPL Teams as needed, and force more Pro teams that suck back to AAA.


I agree with Jamz.... teams that are 3-13 or 4-12 seem to stick around Pro leagues for ever....give people more of a chance. Plus it will increase the chance that new teams can work their way up the ranks faster and play in the WPL sooner than 9 seasons.


And give those teams a chance to maybe win some games in AAA instead?


They deserve AAA much more than Pro. And they will compete a lot more in AAA than Pro. And if they are deadbeats at least they aren't holding a coveted spot in a Pro League.


 
GBPackerFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Originally posted by walker1

Originally posted by walker1


Originally posted by walker1



Can someone explain what the "Extra Demotion System" is? Thanks.








 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Bort, you mentioned possibly having demotion and the teams can rank in order their preferences of league.

Then why can't the promoting minor teams do the same? We only get one choice... new teams got 3... now you're talking about letting WPL leagues choose all 8 in order. I have an epic suggestion and 2 days left to implement to let us minor teams have more than a crapshoot at what league we get...
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN

I still believe it is not for the best and people truly do not know what is best for them.
I think that's how slavery started.



I was going to point out how dangerous this statement is.

Voting is the best system and the results are clear.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.