User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort, just come out and confirm or deny the X-Factor.
Page:
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by NSchmidt10




There is so much we don't know and the "x-factor" is real. My first team proved it in season 3, some players were born to be great and others weren't. It sucks, but I'm over it.


If I believed there was an X-Factor, I would have to call Bort a con man. Ruining someone's player with a random roll, and hiding it from them is unethical. To let them keep boosting a player, when it won't make any difference is a jack off thing to do. If you really believe this practice is going on, why do you keep forking over money? Christ, even a junkie will switch dealers, if the product is bad.


Beta = Get out of con free card is what I'm told.


Not if he flat out lies about a product he is charging money for. If he doesn't acknowledge or deny an x-factor he can't be held legally liable. If he lies about it then he can.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
how is this even a debate?


as others have said - there is plenty of 'evidence' ----- it exists


and Bort will probably never confirm it - as many people would be pissed that there is a random roll that affects your players' ability to be a stud - no matter the build (within reason)



yeah who knows how many of these new lvl 1s running around now have the 'it' factor, probably the ones that already have 2's in all their SAs
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
You guys need to stop trying to bait Bort. Here is the only way he will care.

Stop buying flex.

From a business point of view customers, who complain constantly, but come back everyday are not really your biggest concern. If transparency is a priority for you, hold off on spending money till you feel satisfied with the information given out.


 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Wow, after rereading what I've posted for the past few pages, it would seem like I'm very anti-Bort.

Not the case at all. Especially the use of "conning" people. I really don't see how it would factor into a grand scheme of stealing people's monies. Acting like he is purposely conning people out of money, even if there are hidden attributes, is kind of ridiculous. Hell, it would be completely counter-productive if that was his goal.

I'd say it would have been added to keep players "interesting" so not everyone is the same...while missing the fact that boosting gets to be expensive, and expecting the average person to make 20 players so that they get 1-2 superstars is kind of ridiculous. Maybe it was a bad judgment call.
 
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
I've said it before in these discussions and I'll say it again, but frankly it makes way too much sense for Bort to have included an X-Factor that I would be a little disappointed and surprised if we ever found out there was no x-factor.

Just think back to the beginning of this game...

Gameplanning consistend of putting 0%-100% in like 8 boxes to "run inside" or "run outside". The playbook only had a dozen or so different plays in it... heck some formations just had 1 play. There were no such thing as VAs or AE and until the last few seasons Bort had not yet increased the weight factor on speed so we didn't even really have a height/weight impact on the game.

Basically there wasn't much to GLB. There wasn't a lot that could be done to distinguish the 1000s and 1000s of players from one and other through gameplanning or builds. For any particular position you had what... 6 or 7 attributes and 4 or 5 special abilities that matter? Since everyone accumulates skill points in the same manner (and Bort never envisioned slow building and other min/max strategies) we aren't working with a lot of room to have diverse builds here in Bort's initial game (and even today with VAs, AE, slow building, and AI there isn't a lot of room for diversity). If all builds converge and perform the same GLB is extremely boring & predicatable and Bort makes no money.

However, if there are superstar dots out there (regardless of how unique their builds are) aided on by the x-factor it gives people something to look up to and strive for in their next build. How many people started building HBs in the last few seasons just gunning to be the next Garret Dooley. How many DEs are still out there only trying to become the next Jimmy Johnston despite the mountains of nerfs against the position?

As long as Bort keeps the x-factor unknown it will continue to put money in his pocket by keeping the myth of an elusive superstar build out there that everyone will chase.


Originally posted by steellithium

If I believed there was an X-Factor, I would have to call Bort a con man. Ruining someone's player with a random roll, and hiding it from them is unethical. To let them keep boosting a player, when it won't make any difference is a jack off thing to do. If you really believe this practice is going on, why do you keep forking over money? Christ, even a junkie will switch dealers, if the product is bad.


To this point, I don't think Bort has to necessarily con people or gimp builds to have an X-Factor. What happens if the X-Factor just gives positive %'s to attributes? What happens if 99% of dots are playing the game with exactly the attributes you see, but 1% are lucky enough to hit the lottery with a superstar roll and get a % bonus? That doesn't necessarily seem cheap - just a way to introduce randomness into the game and give us superstar dots that perform better than imaginable.
Edited by Ryiotgear on Jul 16, 2009 15:46:48
Edited by Ryiotgear on Jul 16, 2009 15:37:00
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
What's funny about it all (under the assumption you believe in the "X" factor) is you'd think the way to go about it is to FIRST figure out the nuts and bolts "IE...Base stats & SA's/VA's = XYZ return of production"...then when those are nutted and bolted down, THEN add some kinks like X Factor....considering the way things are.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Wow, after rereading what I've posted for the past few pages, it would seem like I'm very anti-Bort.

Not the case at all. Especially the use of "conning" people. I really don't see how it would factor into a grand scheme of stealing people's monies. Acting like he is purposely conning people out of money, even if there are hidden attributes, is kind of ridiculous. Hell, it would be completely counter-productive if that was his goal.

I'd say it would have been added to keep players "interesting" so not everyone is the same...while missing the fact that boosting gets to be expensive, and expecting the average person to make 20 players so that they get 1-2 superstars is kind of ridiculous. Maybe it was a bad judgment call.


Maybe he should change his avatar to the guy who goes from town to town selling MONORAILS!
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
You guys need to stop trying to bait Bort. Here is the only way he will care.

Stop buying flex.

From a business point of view customers, who complain constantly, but come back everyday are not really your biggest concern. If transparency is a priority for you, hold off on spending money till you feel satisfied with the information given out.


Trying to make sense of the game =/= complaining
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Wow, after rereading what I've posted for the past few pages, it would seem like I'm very anti-Bort.

Not the case at all. Especially the use of "conning" people. I really don't see how it would factor into a grand scheme of stealing people's monies. Acting like he is purposely conning people out of money, even if there are hidden attributes, is kind of ridiculous. Hell, it would be completely counter-productive if that was his goal.

I'd say it would have been added to keep players "interesting" so not everyone is the same...while missing the fact that boosting gets to be expensive, and expecting the average person to make 20 players so that they get 1-2 superstars is kind of ridiculous. Maybe it was a bad judgment call.


This. I'm not saying his intentions were bad, just that it was very poorly thought out.

He has spent a ton of time and effort trying to prevent cookie cutter builds but the x-factor isn't the answer and isn't fair to people that were expecting total control of their players build.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Wow, after rereading what I've posted for the past few pages, it would seem like I'm very anti-Bort.

Not the case at all. Especially the use of "conning" people. I really don't see how it would factor into a grand scheme of stealing people's monies. Acting like he is purposely conning people out of money, even if there are hidden attributes, is kind of ridiculous. Hell, it would be completely counter-productive if that was his goal.

I'd say it would have been added to keep players "interesting" so not everyone is the same...while missing the fact that boosting gets to be expensive, and expecting the average person to make 20 players so that they get 1-2 superstars is kind of ridiculous. Maybe it was a bad judgment call.


But the REAL way to keep players interesting is to code the game where you don't have everyone and their mother building speed/agility and then whatever imo. As it stands now EVERYONE starts a build the same way up into the level 20's , and some even continue on higher , nothing interesting there.
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
You guys need to stop trying to bait Bort. Here is the only way he will care.

Stop buying flex.

From a business point of view customers, who complain constantly, but come back everyday are not really your biggest concern. If transparency is a priority for you, hold off on spending money till you feel satisfied with the information given out.


I've been saying this too but don't care enough to keep repeating it, nor are enough people actually going to get it.

But keep on keepin' on!
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
But the REAL way to keep players interesting is to code the game where you don't have everyone and their mother building speed/agility and then whatever imo. As it stands now EVERYONE starts a build the same way up into the level 20's , and some even continue on higher , nothing interesting there.


Of course....I mean hell, the game would probably be better if all players had "base" attributes, and instead of adding directly, they add modifiers. Like WR's could add +15% speed to their "base" 80 speed that is otherwise unchangeable. That way, everyone would have a player that could compete and wouldn't need to pump speed and agility for 20 levels, but at the same time could customize.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59


Maybe he should change his avatar to the guy who goes from town to town selling MONORAILS!


You know, a player with money for flex is a lot like a mule with a spinning wheel. No one knows how he got it, a damned if he knows how to use it.
Edited by steellithium on Jul 16, 2009 15:43:55
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by PsychoMan

pierre, switch your EQ around on those WRs for next season so they are actually equal (strength/conf/carry/etc) and reset their VAs to be the same.

then experiment a bit more.


Fuck that, I'm retiring the one that sucks balls. It isn't any of that stuff though. You have to keep in mind that I have 4 WRs but right now I can see about 500 other WR builds.

WRs with no VAs can do just fine anyway since the WR VAs are complete garbage.


why should pierre have to pay flex to test out something bort should confirm himself. as a matter of fact, bort should be paying all you guys doing this testing on your own players/money to test his beta game
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Deathblade

Wow, after rereading what I've posted for the past few pages, it would seem like I'm very anti-Bort.

Not the case at all. Especially the use of "conning" people. I really don't see how it would factor into a grand scheme of stealing people's monies. Acting like he is purposely conning people out of money, even if there are hidden attributes, is kind of ridiculous. Hell, it would be completely counter-productive if that was his goal.

I'd say it would have been added to keep players "interesting" so not everyone is the same...while missing the fact that boosting gets to be expensive, and expecting the average person to make 20 players so that they get 1-2 superstars is kind of ridiculous. Maybe it was a bad judgment call.


This. I'm not saying his intentions were bad, just that it was very poorly thought out.

He has spent a ton of time and effort trying to prevent cookie cutter builds but the x-factor isn't the answer and isn't fair to people that were expecting total control of their players build.


Advanced equipment should be the x-factor that prevents cookie cutter builds, and it is for all intents and purposes.

A DE who lucks out and lands a +1TV/+5% breakblock piece, has a good chance of being a superior player assuming he doesn't F up his build. Random sim aberrations from player builds aren't needed. If there is an x-factor Bort should just quietly remove it's influence from the game, if he cops to it there will be a shit storm.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.