User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by steellithium

Another thing to consider is play to play energy. Does the receiver's stamina allow them to run streak route after streak route without losing speed?

Good point, and we know that energy burns quickly for both WRs and CBs. With that decreased energy, you get a percentage reduction in attributes, narrowing the gap in speed even further.


Read the thread, it has been answered.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


I do...it is a pretty sick build.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


Nope but we had the build of a WR playing with 160 speed and 80 agility with the big heart VA not run nearly as fast as Brooks.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


wat
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by PierreThomas


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


I do...it is a pretty sick build.


Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by PierreThomas


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


Nope but we had the build of a WR playing with 160 speed and 80 agility with the big heart VA not run nearly as fast as Brooks.


was he 6'3" 180lb?

or do you consider height and weight to be "hidden"?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by steellithium


Originally posted by PierreThomas



Originally posted by fallingmercury




Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


I do...it is a pretty sick build.


Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?


deathblade, how about we don't give away any info on our team's builds k?

thanks
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?


Not really my place to say.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Read the thread, it has been answered.

Instead of saying that and expecting me to search through 30 pages, why not just post the supposed answer? You can even call me a moron after you do it, I don't mind.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by steellithium

Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?


Not really my place to say.


Nevermind, PM sent

Just kidding, obviously
Edited by Deathblade on Jul 9, 2009 22:49:07
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by PierreThomas



WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


Perhaps one suggestion is to go with something you posted earlier, about speed being more or less set in stone like height and weight. (at least I think it was your suggestions.)

IF you do that, then something would have to be done about the ability to rerole and instantly retire your player. I think if you keep the ability to rerole players while making the speed of a player a constant, then most players would just rerole until you got someone fast.

I think you could come up with a pretty interesting and diverse player creation model using that idea, although it would be a pretty significant change to the game.

Perhaps the better solution is to, as you suggest, lessen the difference between how fast a dot with 10 speed is to how fast a dot with 100 speed is... Take a 6.0 forty time = 10 speed and a 4.25 forty time = 100 speed.

Anything over 100 would make your player faster, but would offer diminishing returns. (110 speed = 4.24 forty, 120 = 4.23 etc...

Domer
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by PierreThomas




WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


Think about this, CBs used to match WRs speed or at least get close to it. A good CB build had all equipment on speed to hang with WRs. Now people realize they don't need the speed and pump up agility and vision to very high levels to use it as an advantage.

Defenses have safeties and the ability to control exactly who guards what players on every snap. Offenses have limited plays that offer deep routes and no way to specify which WR runs them on different plays. If a WR can outrun a CB and a FS playing up to 20 yards off the ball then more power to them. If a WR is that much faster than a CB then the CB was built wrong. I can push speed up to 110 on a lot of my CBs. A straight up 115 speed WR vs 100 speed CB Would give up about 1 yard for every 10 yards they run. With a CB giving a 5 yard cushion it would take 50 yards for the WR to get past the CB and that isn't even accounting for a safety that can play with zone specialist and ball hawk. I've seen a FS play with over 160 speed.


Cushion (for CBs) fails in this game and isn't a legitimate option.

Seriously though, as soon as getting open becomes about speed, you're going to see every WR in the land stack ALL eq into speed and stock up on every possible speed-influencing SA/VA in the book. Then they're going to boost speed for every meaningful game. And then CBs will have to be the same. GLB will = foot race again, which blew horribly. It will be that important.

Teams with uber-specialized WRs will throw deep as much as possible and teams with less-specialized WRs or lower level ones will fail miserably. The specialized-WR teams will have a load of sick new weapons while the rest of the teams out there will be stuck in today's reality where their WRs can't get open.

Dumb.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by steellithium


Originally posted by PierreThomas



Originally posted by fallingmercury




Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?


Do you have his build?


Nope but we had the build of a WR playing with 160 speed and 80 agility with the big heart VA not run nearly as fast as Brooks.


was he 6'3" 180lb?

or do you consider height and weight to be "hidden"?


Not sure. I commented on Brooks weight earlier. There are other 180lb WRs with 120+ speed that don't even come near Brooks on the speed script and we have all seen what an extra 10 points of speed does on most WRs.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by steellithium

Would people think differently than the common mindset, if they saw it?


Not really my place to say.


I don't want to know the build, that would take the fun out of the game. I was just wondering, if these guys took their own build theory instead of the general theory everyone spouts.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.