User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Yes, we are aware the I slam play is frequntly cheesy and many teams are running it over and over. No, we are not updating things in-season.
Page:
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Bort



The thing that's overpowered about the slam is the speed at which you can get to the line and then fall forward for 5 yards. Many of the other plays take longer to set up and get moving, which makes them less effective, though you can still get yards with them.



But let it be known that Bort totally does seem to appreciate what the deal here is and what would constitute the problem we have.

That's very good news, tbh.
I almost want to feel optimistic here.


Almost...just almost. Not going to get my hopes up until I start seeing some preseason sims.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Darkstrand
you shouldn't have a poll about updates on the day a bunch of people got owned and are bitter and wish they hadn't lost

Its pretty rare that I quote Darkstrand, but this is 100% on target.

Well, I think that's SOME of why that poll is garbage.
I think most the rest of the reason is because people are stupid and don't really know what they want.

I mean.... I'm gonna assume most people are saying they like the idea of the sim "being fixed" during the season.
I'm certain that if the sim starts getting changed then we're gonna have quite a number of ROITS being caused because of that.
So what is that poll going to do, Bort?
That's right. It's going to either be "listened to" and people will get pissed later when you "screw their team" because of a "fix" you make or you're "not going to listen to them" and not do what they claim to want right now... either way, you screwed yourself, tbh.

I know that you mean well with the polls and such... but I really don't think such things work out very well for ya, tbh.


the main problem with the poll is that it doesn't tell us what is or isn't a "bug" or "exploitive play".

we need case-by-case polls for this sort of thing.
 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
i mean i love how everyone is whining and complaining about 1 play, but no one seems to be complaining that about 10 games a season are 100+ point blowouts one way or the other

waaaah, we didnt win 175-0, the game is broken bort

come the fuck on - a play that gets 3-4yds is FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR from the biggest issue in GLB. try getting half the games to actually be closer than 50 points first
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tshizzle
Originally posted by Signalsgt

Originally posted by tshizzle


i fail to see what is broken about a play in between the tackles - theres not much that can be "broken" about it. its fucking little league level execution - snap, and handoff, run straight. i mean you literally cannot break that


It is not the play, it is the execution of the code to make the play work. So to use your analogy and your avatar..it would be Jamal Lewis running into a High School Defense behind the Browns line.



hey jamal is good for about 3ypc no matter what


Yes he is

Not for 96 straight plays though even in his prime.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SeattleNiner
How bout we just take that play OUT OF THE PLAYBOOK?


Originally posted by maz621
why not just remove the abused play >.>


Do we really need a poll on this?

Bort, your hesitation to make a post-week 12 change is understandable, but you’ve already acknowledged the play is being abused. All bets should be off for the sake of the game.

Frankly, this isn’t even a change to the sim. We’re talking about the elimination of 1 freaking play.

I just don’t understand the rationale for simply not taking it out of the playbook.

By the time any poll is conducted, how many more playoff games will have been decided by the Slam?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tshizzle
come the fuck on - a play that gets 3-4yds is FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR from the biggest issue in GLB. try getting half the games to actually be closer than 50 points first


the problem is that it always gets that many.

if you're guaranteed 3 yards per down, you never need to punt.
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by SeattleNiner

How bout we just take that play OUT OF THE PLAYBOOK?


Originally posted by maz621

why not just remove the abused play >.>


Do we really need a poll on this?

Bort, your hesitation to make a post-week 12 change is understandable, but you’ve already acknowledged the play is being abused. All bets should be off for the sake of the game.

Frankly, this isn’t even a change to the sim. We’re talking about the elimination of 1 freaking play.

I just don’t understand the rationale for simply not taking it out of the playbook.

By the time any poll is conducted, how many more playoff games will have been decided by the Slam?


Can't shut the barn door now that the horse is gone now can they? If he would have done it prior to the first round of playoff's that would be a different matter.

 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
biggest thing that needs to happen is the chance of a 1-8 team beating a 8-1 team. pretty much every league has a 16-0 team, and a 15-1/14-2 team that lost to the #1 and #2 team above them. upsets are rare as fuck. blowouts are pretty much every other game. how bout some real scores first? a 16-0 team should beat a 0-16 by maybe 40 at the most - not fucking 250.

this is what makes sports fun - in GLB a 6 or 9 point overall difference is a 99.9% guaranteed blowout game
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by Ravenwood

Originally posted by SeattleNiner


How bout we just take that play OUT OF THE PLAYBOOK?


Originally posted by maz621


why not just remove the abused play >.>


Do we really need a poll on this?

Bort, your hesitation to make a post-week 12 change is understandable, but you’ve already acknowledged the play is being abused. All bets should be off for the sake of the game.

Frankly, this isn’t even a change to the sim. We’re talking about the elimination of 1 freaking play.

I just don’t understand the rationale for simply not taking it out of the playbook.

By the time any poll is conducted, how many more playoff games will have been decided by the Slam?


Can't shut the barn door now that the horse is gone now can they? If he would have done it prior to the first round of playoff's that would be a different matter.



There are still two games to be played before a champion is declared. It's not too late.
 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by tshizzle

come the fuck on - a play that gets 3-4yds is FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR from the biggest issue in GLB. try getting half the games to actually be closer than 50 points first


the problem is that it always gets that many.

if you're guaranteed 3 yards per down, you never need to punt.



but isnt it much more important that you dont win games 188-0 and 255-0 ?? or since that suits you, thats cool and not cheesy at all?
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemiken
Originally posted by jktooley

My season was completely ruined by the play...

We ran it of course, but we HAD to... sucks after starting the season with a victory (without exploiting the slam) over Monmouth, before watching the game completely deteriorate.


I'm not buying this. We didn't have a problem getting a home playoff game this season w/o having to resort to spamming Strong I runs every game and neither did Green Bay or Detroit.

The win over Monmouth shows you've got a talented team, but to say you had no choice but to spam the Strong I runs is nothing but a cop out.


really? You think two equally matched teams, with one running 100% strong I slam, and the other running a regular offense would turn out any way except the Slam team winning?

You're far too knowledgeable to be that out of touch....
 
tansien
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BMoreAbsurd
Originally posted by tansien

No big deal it is supposed to happen that way.

Tans.


Except that it ISN'T, per Bort, per the testers, per everyone who has seen this played above the Pee Wee level you damn donkey.

You know, I used to think that you were thick as a brick like Tshizwhatever. Now I'm pretty much convinced you're one of those pricks who likes to play dumb and take up a contrarian argument for no other reason than to get people worked up.



Actually you are pretty spot on about the getting people worked up part, but completely off base on the rest. tshizzle happens to be right in regards to the running game as anyone who actually played in a professional league would attest to. I doubt any of you forum warriors have so I will leave it at that.

Once Bort does his analysis (obviously he hasn't had the time since the crying started yesterday) and realizes that the losses were mainly due to poor builds and tactics then it will be a different story in which the lemming crowd will then complain about their 'builds' getting nerfed. Even if he does put in the shift or modify it somewhat so that inferior teams can adequately defend against it, the response will be to shift to another run play to counter. Then the lemmings will complain about that until they get a nerf.

The cycle will continue over and over so long as incompetents continue to play this game.

Tans.
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood


There are still two games to be played before a champion is declared. It's not too late.


Tell that to the 1-4 seeds that have already been upended by the islam.

 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tshizzle
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by tshizzle


come the fuck on - a play that gets 3-4yds is FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR from the biggest issue in GLB. try getting half the games to actually be closer than 50 points first


the problem is that it always gets that many.

if you're guaranteed 3 yards per down, you never need to punt.



but isnt it much more important that you dont win games 188-0 and 255-0 ?? or since that suits you, thats cool and not cheesy at all?


You are battling Tans for the worst poster. I wish you luck.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by jktooley

My season was completely ruined by the play...

We ran it of course, but we HAD to... sucks after starting the season with a victory (without exploiting the slam) over Monmouth, before watching the game completely deteriorate.

If there's a huge exploit play, that can't be stopped no matter what, it should be addressed... Even if it's the day before the playoffs....

If you can't win without it, you don't deserve to be in the playoffs anyways.


How on earth can you feel that way, when in your first game in the regular season against us you ran the ball 98 times and passed 3 times. Your runs were two plays, the Slam and an I formation outside run.

Once you did that, you pretty much ensured that our playoff game would be a Slam fest when it didn't need to be.


I saw what you guys were doing in your scrimmages....

Pretty much 100% slam... that's when I made the decision to do the same.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.