If they do something like this, they also have to come up with a solution to prevent gutting in the future. Like league level minimums, or a straight up cut/trade limit per team per season.
Forum > Suggestions > This off season will be time to realign the teams in the USA tree.
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
Originally posted by thehazyone
Average level of the entire roster I think would be a good indicator.
I don't know about that... look at the levels of Painmaker's team, pwning the AA3, while everyone else is level 28+: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1196
Average level of the entire roster I think would be a good indicator.
I don't know about that... look at the levels of Painmaker's team, pwning the AA3, while everyone else is level 28+: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1196
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
But how do they determine which teams get promoted?
Or relegated, for that matter?
They have a tiebreaker in place for who gets the championship home game, no reason for it to be any different. You work back through the playoffs, starting with the conference finalists and using the the tiebreakers.
Relegation is the guts moving to the bottom - the whole point of this thread.
#1 More than just the playoff teams will be promoted. Especially once you get down to the A and BBB level.
#2 How do you define "gutted"? What is the cutoff?
#3 Do all "gutted" teams go all the way to the bottom? Or do some only drop a couple of levels?
It's really more complicated than most people seem to realize.
I'm not saying it shouldn't be done. I'm just saying it's not as simple as people seem to think it is.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
But how do they determine which teams get promoted?
Or relegated, for that matter?
They have a tiebreaker in place for who gets the championship home game, no reason for it to be any different. You work back through the playoffs, starting with the conference finalists and using the the tiebreakers.
Relegation is the guts moving to the bottom - the whole point of this thread.
#1 More than just the playoff teams will be promoted. Especially once you get down to the A and BBB level.
#2 How do you define "gutted"? What is the cutoff?
#3 Do all "gutted" teams go all the way to the bottom? Or do some only drop a couple of levels?
It's really more complicated than most people seem to realize.
I'm not saying it shouldn't be done. I'm just saying it's not as simple as people seem to think it is.
Reggie Smash
offline
offline
Not average level. You go by playoff record (and then season standings if necessary) from the top down.
So all Pro league teams that have been gutted are moved to the very bottom leagues. And the top finishers in the AAA 1 & AAA 2 league tournaments are moved up (tiebreakers for spots could be determined by whatever playoff tiebreaker systems are in place already - like records, then point differentials or however it works).
That's the best way to keep the existing relegation system in place, maintain many of the existing rivalries, and yet still balance the competition at the same time.
So all Pro league teams that have been gutted are moved to the very bottom leagues. And the top finishers in the AAA 1 & AAA 2 league tournaments are moved up (tiebreakers for spots could be determined by whatever playoff tiebreaker systems are in place already - like records, then point differentials or however it works).
That's the best way to keep the existing relegation system in place, maintain many of the existing rivalries, and yet still balance the competition at the same time.
bigpimpin123
offline
offline
This isn't only happening in USA you know. I see this happening all the time in all the higher leagues.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
But how do they determine which teams get promoted?
Or relegated, for that matter?
You're making it out to be far harder than it would have to be
Originally posted by PP
Teams that get moved up vrs down wouldn't be that hard to figure either. Start at the top and drop down every team that's X lvls below the average PO teams (5ish or more maybe) to the bottom league. Then go to the next lvl down and base those moving up on either where they finished in the POs or reg season (POs would seem more accurate because of boosting, but either would be a huge improvement). Bump down the ones that are under X lvls of the PO teams, drop down another lvl and repeat. With the way the leagues fan out towards the bottom, there'd be plenty of space in the bottom leagues.
But how do they determine which teams get promoted?
Or relegated, for that matter?
You're making it out to be far harder than it would have to be
Originally posted by PP
Teams that get moved up vrs down wouldn't be that hard to figure either. Start at the top and drop down every team that's X lvls below the average PO teams (5ish or more maybe) to the bottom league. Then go to the next lvl down and base those moving up on either where they finished in the POs or reg season (POs would seem more accurate because of boosting, but either would be a huge improvement). Bump down the ones that are under X lvls of the PO teams, drop down another lvl and repeat. With the way the leagues fan out towards the bottom, there'd be plenty of space in the bottom leagues.
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by sickie8305
good Idea for season 6, some people like the divisions there in thou
Some people probably like beating up on 5 or 6 gutted teams a season and having an almost guaranteed playoff spot too...
good Idea for season 6, some people like the divisions there in thou
Some people probably like beating up on 5 or 6 gutted teams a season and having an almost guaranteed playoff spot too...
Whiskeybilt
offline
offline
Agreed, great idea.
Also, stop releasing so many new teams every year.
If a team is sold, it is automatically dropped and capped to the rebuild league for one season.
Nothing will get done though.
Also, stop releasing so many new teams every year.
If a team is sold, it is automatically dropped and capped to the rebuild league for one season.
Nothing will get done though.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by thehazyone
Average level of the entire roster I think would be a good indicator.
I don't know about that... look at the levels of Painmaker's team, pwning the AA3, while everyone else is level 28+: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1196
Yea, trust me I know all about that. I was the team he beat in the conference championship game.
Maybe a combination of average level and scouting bars then?
Originally posted by thehazyone
Average level of the entire roster I think would be a good indicator.
I don't know about that... look at the levels of Painmaker's team, pwning the AA3, while everyone else is level 28+: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1196
Yea, trust me I know all about that. I was the team he beat in the conference championship game.
Maybe a combination of average level and scouting bars then?
phthalatemagic
offline
offline
Please consider this, Bort. No one wants to play in a league with several gutted teams that do not belong. More people will leave if this isn't fixed.
Carbor123
offline
offline
Would it really take that long for a Admin or someone to go through and move that teams that have been gutted down, and move the top finishers up?? If it does take a while, have an admin that is dedicated to watching specific leagues. Have a USA official who watches over USA Pro and AAA and is the overseerer of all the USA league. Then have a AA and A offical. He goes though and checkes out A and AA to make sure they are running smoothly. Then have a BBB offical who does the same with the BBB. You will have an admin keeping an eye on how the leagues are running, and if a team has been gutted.
I would volunteer for this, and im sure there are plently of others who would aswell.
I would volunteer for this, and im sure there are plently of others who would aswell.
Tito716
offline
offline
I'm not sure that even a full reset would be needed.
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























