User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is some BS..INT out of bounds lost our game
Page:
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Can you please explain how if it should be a touchback and it isn't there is no bug then? And perhaps you could also explain the long standing and long admitted bug of (x yard gain)(incomplete) which the admins have accepted exists.

So yeah, you are absolutely wrong. I have no vested interest in this whatsoever, other than fairness, and I can see no reason why this person should just "move along" like you suggest when it's clear that play isn't right. At the very least there is the LoS bug on top of which there is the strong similarity between the out of bounds reception bug and this one as regards how they present from the text and graphical engines engines which should at least be explained by an admin person.

99% of stuff posted on this forum is rubbish or whining but this isn't.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
I'm wrong? Are you kidding? Interceptions are marked as incompletions in QB statistics in real life football and the 2D view in GLB is rarely accurate. Don't be stupid.

There have been other plays that don't result in a touch back when it should have; I saw a thread around here about it a week or so ago.



It is a bugged play, that's not in dispute. The question and disagreement lies with what is the main error due to contrary output---Was there an mistake change of possession or not?

Only the ones who coded know for sure...
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
Can you please explain how if it should be a touchback and it isn't there is no bug then? And perhaps you could also explain the long standing and long admitted bug of (x yard gain)(incomplete) which the admins have accepted exists.


Did I say there wasn't a bug? Unless I'm mistaken, he wasn't complaining about the LoS bug (which is known). He's complaining about the graphical representation of what happened, which everyone should know by now is not accurate.


Originally posted by hemprobot
So yeah, you are absolutely wrong.


If you think I'm wrong, then you're an idiot.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
If you think there is 0 chance of there being a bug at play here in the change of possession code then you know nothing about computer programming, in an even general sense, and are posting here in ignorance.

With complex logical programs like the play engine it is extremely easy for a procedure to be called in error as could have happened in this case. An example code stub of something like this would be:


input = <Result_Of_Pass>
[in this case the results returned were <Interception>, triggered by an opponent catching the ball and <Out_of_Bounds>, triggered by the catch co-ordinates]

if <Result_Of_Pass> = Interception {
output.to.screen(<QB> <Pass_Type> to <Intended_Receiver> <Direction> intercepted by <Intercepting_Player> (<Return_Yards> return))
change.possession
}
if <Result_Of_Pass> = Out_Of_Bounds {
output.to.screen((<QB> <Pass_Type> to <Intended.Receiver> <direction> incomplete)
ball.to.original.los
next.down
}

This very basic example shows a simple logical error that would result in unintended behaviour similar to what we saw in this play whilst looking fairly ok at first glance. Given that the GLB match engine is far more complex and neither of us know anything about it then I would suggest that your misplaced self-assurance that all is ok comes more from unfounded arrogance than anything else. Once again I think this play merits being looked at by the admin team and that the guy should get a response in due course.

So yes, you are still wrong to say he should move on and utilising ad hominem attacks on me personally does nothing but demonstrate even more ignorance than your answer would otherwise.

edit: fix spelling
Last edited Aug 31, 2008 11:16:51
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Fire hazard. You are wrong in regards to telling this player to move along. This is a bug and not a graphical representation issue. The text says both interception and incomplete. Which is it?

Many of us feel that it was intercepted out of bounds. Not because of the graphics, but because of the similarities to the (x yd gain) (incomplete) bug. Which is well known. The latter bug happens when the ball is caught out of bounds, at least that is the explanation we were given. Now, the only thing that can really resolve this is Bort looking at the play and telling us what happened. I for one, believe it was intercepted out of bounds and the ball should be placed back at the LOS and the offense gets its chance to kick a FG, which may or may not have won the game. Since this game has playoff implications, the best one can hope for is a re-sim.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
1. Interceptions ARE considered incompletions.
2. The 2D view is not accurate.

Move along.


You are right, statistically. But the text of the game does not report both when an interception happens.
 
vmonsta
offline
Link
 
DId anybody even get near the ball that was to confusing
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
this guy has a legitimate beef and should post here to get a proper response by the admins. if you dont like it firehazard, y dont u just move on? y rain on his beef?
 
kjayb51
offline
Link
 
I just want to clear this up cause it caused my team to miss the playoffs.
Last edited Sep 1, 2008 05:07:22
 
kjayb51
offline
Link
 
Bump before playoffs start
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
You'll be lucky to get a response by then man. To be honest I reckon once the games have ticked over today it will be too late anyway. The admin team are generally very slow to acknowledge posts with actual bugs in them which is unfortunate. Even the "Known Bugs" thread hasn't been updated since May or something.

While I don't think Bort should waste his own time here (and 99% of it would be a waste) he should at least find a sensible and reliable mod to keep this forum (in particular) straight and the "Known Bugs" thread updated. It's a mess at the moment and I suspect the current mod team are just fed up with it. He could even hire a $30k a year scrub to do it and help out with some other stuff aswell or something. He's certainly making enough money now and there's certainly plenty to be done, too much for one person in all seriousness.

Time to graduate from college into the MMORPG pros Bort, you can't do it all yourself man!
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
bump for bort to read.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
I'm wrong? Are you kidding? Interceptions are marked as incompletions in QB statistics in real life football and the 2D view in GLB is rarely accurate. Don't be stupid.

There have been other plays that don't result in a touch back when it should have; I saw a thread around here about it a week or so ago.



Have you watched football before? Interceptions are NOT marked as "incompletions" in QB statistics. There is a little category for "INT" that shows INTs.

Just because a QB went 5-8 with 1 interception does not mean he threw 3 incompletions. In that instance, he threw 2 incompletions and 1 interception. Never do you say he threw "3 incomplete passes" for this instance because he didn't, one was completed, albeit to the other team. You can go look up the definition of an "incompletion" if you need to but you definitely don't understand it from the looks of things.

http://www.nfl.com/rulebook/forwardpass
"Any forward pass becomes incomplete and ball is dead if:

(a) Pass hits the ground or goes out of bounds.

(b) Pass hits the goal post or the crossbar of either team."
 
usafdirtboyz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
Originally posted by firehazard

I'm wrong? Are you kidding? Interceptions are marked as incompletions in QB statistics in real life football and the 2D view in GLB is rarely accurate. Don't be stupid.

There have been other plays that don't result in a touch back when it should have; I saw a thread around here about it a week or so ago.



Have you watched football before? Interceptions are NOT marked as "incompletions" in QB statistics. There is a little category for "INT" that shows INTs.

Just because a QB went 5-8 with 1 interception does not mean he threw 3 incompletions. In that instance, he threw 2 incompletions and 1 interception. Never do you say he threw "3 incomplete passes" for this instance because he didn't, one was completed, albeit to the other team. You can go look up the definition of an "incompletion" if you need to but you definitely don't understand it from the looks of things.

http://www.nfl.com/rulebook/forwardpass
"Any forward pass becomes incomplete and ball is dead if:

(a) Pass hits the ground or goes out of bounds.

(b) Pass hits the goal post or the crossbar of either team."




Actually a INT DOES go down as an incompletion in his stats. The ball is still considered incomplete because a member of his team did not catch the pass.
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
Originally posted by firehazard

I'm wrong? Are you kidding? Interceptions are marked as incompletions in QB statistics in real life football and the 2D view in GLB is rarely accurate. Don't be stupid.

There have been other plays that don't result in a touch back when it should have; I saw a thread around here about it a week or so ago.



Have you watched football before? Interceptions are NOT marked as "inco+mpletions" in QB statistics. There is a little category for "INT" that shows INTs.


Please tell me that you're kidding. Nope, doesn't look like you are. Seriously, know what you're talking about before opening your mouth.

As far as an "interception out of bounds" issue. Have you guys ever seen any other evidence that would lead you to believe that a receiver caught it but was out of bounds? I haven't, so I'd think that it's probably not coded that way and that the interception had to have happened in bounds.

But whatever, I guess Occam's razor doesn't apply to logic in the bugs forum.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.