I took in account of stats, and what the player did against our team. thats about all I did when making my list.
taekwonden
offline
offline
Originally posted by morbid
Originally posted by cane__boy
Originally posted by morbid
Originally posted by cane__boy
Originally posted by Tibs
ha! just curious how were these votes brought about..#1 in our division last year. #1 in receptions this year, 3rd in yards, and 3rd in TD's and not even ranked in the top 4. I guess better luck to me next year.
-tibs
they were voted on and your average is alot lower than the 4 receivers voted in
So your saying only avg. per reception makes you a better WR. Thats more of a team scheme then actually a players ability. With that logic you could have a less talented speed WR considered better then a quality WR. Thats definitly not how you judge a WR. Thats a total joke. Tibs could finish with 150+ receptions this year but unless your running for the big play all the time your not a top 4. Sorry for the pun but the rest of the owners dropped the ball on this one IMO.
um if a player is averaging over 5 yards a reception more he deserves it more than the guy who gets targeted more
first of all: We dont target any players on team. So apparently he is getting open consistently
second: didnt know we were voting off avg, I would have changed some of my votes then also for other positions.
Some of the guys I voted for were out of respect for there player not stats. If a team has a killer front 4 and not run on they get respect votes even tho there stats may not be the same as ones that are. If a WR is constantly going deep and has a better avg. does that make him better then a WR who constantly is open and running a different scheme but is moving chains. Sorry dont get my vote just because you run deeper routes and catch 30+ less receptions. This is in no way is a slight to the WR's who made it. There all really good as we played them all. Just makes no sense that the league leader (not conference) doesnt make top 4.
Most important thing is we know who we have in Tibs. Im done my ranting on it now.
I can agree morbid. If the WR is constantly open especially in the league we play in and getting grabs (top 5 in league) would get consideration. Then I break it down from there with most TD's, YD's and less dropped passes. If he's got 100 receptions and 35 dropped then to me thats not good. I would much rather see the WR not drop passes and be affective at moving the chains for me. Unfortunately, it doesn't show dropped passes at least that I can't find. To me Elvis, Tibs & Ocho are the top and that would be a tough decision. Player lvl Tibs is 27 - Ocho is 28 and Elvis is 29. Thats a tough decision for the top WR of the league. Just my thoughts if this makes sense to anyone. Distracted by my kids tight now. ha
Originally posted by cane__boy
Originally posted by morbid
Originally posted by cane__boy
Originally posted by Tibs
ha! just curious how were these votes brought about..#1 in our division last year. #1 in receptions this year, 3rd in yards, and 3rd in TD's and not even ranked in the top 4. I guess better luck to me next year.
-tibs
they were voted on and your average is alot lower than the 4 receivers voted in
So your saying only avg. per reception makes you a better WR. Thats more of a team scheme then actually a players ability. With that logic you could have a less talented speed WR considered better then a quality WR. Thats definitly not how you judge a WR. Thats a total joke. Tibs could finish with 150+ receptions this year but unless your running for the big play all the time your not a top 4. Sorry for the pun but the rest of the owners dropped the ball on this one IMO.
um if a player is averaging over 5 yards a reception more he deserves it more than the guy who gets targeted more
first of all: We dont target any players on team. So apparently he is getting open consistently

second: didnt know we were voting off avg, I would have changed some of my votes then also for other positions.
Some of the guys I voted for were out of respect for there player not stats. If a team has a killer front 4 and not run on they get respect votes even tho there stats may not be the same as ones that are. If a WR is constantly going deep and has a better avg. does that make him better then a WR who constantly is open and running a different scheme but is moving chains. Sorry dont get my vote just because you run deeper routes and catch 30+ less receptions. This is in no way is a slight to the WR's who made it. There all really good as we played them all. Just makes no sense that the league leader (not conference) doesnt make top 4.
Most important thing is we know who we have in Tibs. Im done my ranting on it now.

I can agree morbid. If the WR is constantly open especially in the league we play in and getting grabs (top 5 in league) would get consideration. Then I break it down from there with most TD's, YD's and less dropped passes. If he's got 100 receptions and 35 dropped then to me thats not good. I would much rather see the WR not drop passes and be affective at moving the chains for me. Unfortunately, it doesn't show dropped passes at least that I can't find. To me Elvis, Tibs & Ocho are the top and that would be a tough decision. Player lvl Tibs is 27 - Ocho is 28 and Elvis is 29. Thats a tough decision for the top WR of the league. Just my thoughts if this makes sense to anyone. Distracted by my kids tight now. ha
MattyP
offline
offline
Congrats to everyone and thanks Otis for running this! It's things like this that make the game more fun. 

You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























