I think I've proven to be impartial here. I pretty much called Speedy's posted build BS but him having a player on my team that I have seen develop I can guarantee you that he can build players and that Speedy will be a great CB -- if he isn't right now. I've watched a few of his games mainly because there's a whole thread about this stuff on my teams forum. It has garnered a lot of interest and ultimately laughs from us because of how big a lightning rod Speedy has become. That being said, I pretty much call it like I see it... and I'm not deliberately trying to take Dan's side but these plays you posted of him "looking bad"... I mean, I don't see it. If my CB's worst plays this season were like these I'd be ECSTATIC! But I'll go through them one by one.
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123883&pbp_id=6884204
Eh, the only thing that makes this bad is it's a TD catch. Still, he's playing off the man in what appears to be a 4-3 Base Defense inside the 5. The game gives a "cushion" to the WR's on plays like that. Any other CB in that same situation gives up the TD as well. If that was my team and he was CB for my team I'd be more upset that my defense put itself in that situation and with the coverage call than Speedy's play. He didn't really do anything wrong.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123882&pbp_id=6420543
LMAO! That's a bad play indeed and it's hysterical that a player would do that. I think it speaks more to the flaws inside GLB than anything else as I've seen plenty of GREAT players do similarly retarded stuff. A 2,500 yard rushing back this year ran for a first down and then ran backwards and sat down half a yard short of the first down to get tackled. On FOURTH DOWN! This appears to be one of those freak plays where it makes zero sense... with the worst vision in the world a player shouldn't do that.
Even still, the D-Line got parted like the red sea and the LB missed the tackle and Speedy came all the way over across the entire field to even be in position to make a tackle. While the play was indeed ridiculous and a bad play on his part ultimately, that TD is hardly his fault.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123882&pbp_id=6423303
Ummmmm, ok? What did Speedy do wrong here? I totally fail to see it. He's playing man to man coverage and it's a goalline run up the middle from the 1 yard line. Are you seriously saying a CB's job is to stuff 1 yard goal line runs?
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4512934
Yet again, I fail to see it. A pass to the opposite side of the field he comes flying over and the entire defense trips over itself. All it proves, really, is the same thing people have been saying forever about GLB. It lacks "real football" sense. Instead of taking proper pursuit angles all of these defenders clumped up and stopped. It happens to EVERY player on GLB, regardless of talent level. This is tantamount to me posting the play of that 2,500 yard back I was talking about earlier when the game made him do retarded shit and saying he sucks. This is the _game_ and nothing else.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4514359
He made the tackle? What is the problem? What, does your corner back break free and stuff every sweep in the backfield or something? I tell you, I've watched 1,000 games on this game having functioned as a Coordinator, player on teams and now an owner. That is a GOOD play in my book.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4514444
FINALLY a completion on the guy. Yeah, he definitely was slow to react to the WR's cut on that one but yet again... unless he followed it up by getting burtn constantly by the WR, it's no big deal. If he's D'd up on that guy 30 plays and THIS is all he had to show for it, yet again, WIN for Speedy.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4517059
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4517134
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4961825
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4965691
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4966190
Seriously, the only thing "lol" about these is that you think making tackles in the running game is apparently bad?
Originally posted by
See i can make you look just as bad.
You really didn't. You showed a 12 yard completion and a 4 yard TD pass. Neither of which were "bad" really. It was good coverage on both plays, really. Like I said, I've pretty much stated I think his posted build is bullshit but I'm also a realist and these plays you posted trying to make him look bad have only made me think his CB is as good as advertised. Like was said earlier, if these are his worst plays then he's a hell of a corner.
Originally posted by Savage Smurf
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123883&pbp_id=6884204
Eh, the only thing that makes this bad is it's a TD catch. Still, he's playing off the man in what appears to be a 4-3 Base Defense inside the 5. The game gives a "cushion" to the WR's on plays like that. Any other CB in that same situation gives up the TD as well. If that was my team and he was CB for my team I'd be more upset that my defense put itself in that situation and with the coverage call than Speedy's play. He didn't really do anything wrong.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123882&pbp_id=6420543
LMAO! That's a bad play indeed and it's hysterical that a player would do that. I think it speaks more to the flaws inside GLB than anything else as I've seen plenty of GREAT players do similarly retarded stuff. A 2,500 yard rushing back this year ran for a first down and then ran backwards and sat down half a yard short of the first down to get tackled. On FOURTH DOWN! This appears to be one of those freak plays where it makes zero sense... with the worst vision in the world a player shouldn't do that.
Even still, the D-Line got parted like the red sea and the LB missed the tackle and Speedy came all the way over across the entire field to even be in position to make a tackle. While the play was indeed ridiculous and a bad play on his part ultimately, that TD is hardly his fault.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123882&pbp_id=6423303
Ummmmm, ok? What did Speedy do wrong here? I totally fail to see it. He's playing man to man coverage and it's a goalline run up the middle from the 1 yard line. Are you seriously saying a CB's job is to stuff 1 yard goal line runs?
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4512934
Yet again, I fail to see it. A pass to the opposite side of the field he comes flying over and the entire defense trips over itself. All it proves, really, is the same thing people have been saying forever about GLB. It lacks "real football" sense. Instead of taking proper pursuit angles all of these defenders clumped up and stopped. It happens to EVERY player on GLB, regardless of talent level. This is tantamount to me posting the play of that 2,500 yard back I was talking about earlier when the game made him do retarded shit and saying he sucks. This is the _game_ and nothing else.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4514359
He made the tackle? What is the problem? What, does your corner back break free and stuff every sweep in the backfield or something? I tell you, I've watched 1,000 games on this game having functioned as a Coordinator, player on teams and now an owner. That is a GOOD play in my book.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4514444
FINALLY a completion on the guy. Yeah, he definitely was slow to react to the WR's cut on that one but yet again... unless he followed it up by getting burtn constantly by the WR, it's no big deal. If he's D'd up on that guy 30 plays and THIS is all he had to show for it, yet again, WIN for Speedy.
Originally posted by
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4517059
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=125961&pbp_id=4517134
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4961825
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4965691
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123879&pbp_id=4966190
Seriously, the only thing "lol" about these is that you think making tackles in the running game is apparently bad?
Originally posted by
See i can make you look just as bad.
You really didn't. You showed a 12 yard completion and a 4 yard TD pass. Neither of which were "bad" really. It was good coverage on both plays, really. Like I said, I've pretty much stated I think his posted build is bullshit but I'm also a realist and these plays you posted trying to make him look bad have only made me think his CB is as good as advertised. Like was said earlier, if these are his worst plays then he's a hell of a corner.






























