User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
Link
 
drifter always has good ideas.

I liked his rivalry idea, but that never happened apparently. I can't blame Bort though, IMO fixing bugs and play balancing more important than installing new features right now.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Ken1


Tremetal's thinking (I don't know how you see it) is pretty clear to me: Subs don't get full exp, and if you're buried you can get none.

I think you're seeing it as something at which we can level as if Level 1. I don't care exactly how the points are obtained; I definitely like the idea.

I'd change the performance enhancers in some areas: "Go To Guy" shouldn't just improve the chances of being thrown the ball, but the chances of catching it in the clutch or something (a reason why he's the go-to guy).

Interesting ideas on tackling to encourage more use of balanced tackling.

Are the performance boosters also 5 points/point? They could be a point for a point, but simply the amount of difference a point makes scaled to the fact that they are a point for a point. I agree that soft-cap adjusters would have to be 5 points per point.



What I wanted to avoid was duplication of existing SAs. Receivers already have Sticky Hands - I don't want another Prestige Performance Booster that duplicates Sticky Hands.

The backup issue is no different than XP gain now so unless regular XP gain is going to be looked at, I don't think this systems should differ.

I intentionally left the exact Performance effects blank as I thought that would best be determined by Bort. The effect should be pretty minimal as to not overbalance things.


I'm just thinking with Go-To Guy as it is that if the person with it isn't one of a team's best receivers it could actually hurt team performance.

I love the concept, though, either way, and I have some other ideas as you can see. I'd like the performance boosters to be as many and as worthwhile as to discourage Prestige XP from being used only or mostly just to raise soft caps.

It's kind of a way to have more SA's (in a different way) as GG and I worked on (and also allow soft caps to be increased, as another option).
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Some other performance boosters:

Acceleration: Enhances acceleration (duh). Bort's admitted he should have made it its own attribute, so it could at least be a prestige attribute.

Crease Closer: Improves a DB's performance in zone defenses.

Quick Feet: Improves a player's Head Fake and Juke moves at all times, as well as Quick Cuts when running with the ball.

Reliability: Decreases the chance of the player fumbling, dropping a pass, blowing coverage on defense, and the like.

First Down Marker: Knows where the first down marker is, and if he needs an extra half a yard to get the first down, has a better chance of getting it.

Scat Back: Increases a HB or FB's abilities as a receiver on pass plays (maybe even making him almost...useful). When used as such, he gains a bonus to speed, agility, vision, and catching.


I'm all for there being a ton of performance boosters. I just want to make sure they don't duplicate what regular attributes or SAs already do:

Acceleration - On board

Crease Closer - How is it different from Closing Speed?

Quick Feet - How is this different from higher agility?

Reliability - on the fence. A lot of those things are covered in specific SAs (Cover Up, Sticky Hands, etc). Seems a bit too general.

First Down Marker - I like it. Some overlap with 4 yard Dive, but I think it's still good.

Scat back - Can't a player build thse thigns into his player instead of needing a Performance Booster for it? Maybe it just eliminates the position bonus for moving from HB to WR?
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Ken1



Tremetal's thinking (I don't know how you see it) is pretty clear to me: Subs don't get full exp, and if you're buried you can get none.

I think you're seeing it as something at which we can level as if Level 1. I don't care exactly how the points are obtained; I definitely like the idea.

I'd change the performance enhancers in some areas: "Go To Guy" shouldn't just improve the chances of being thrown the ball, but the chances of catching it in the clutch or something (a reason why he's the go-to guy).

Interesting ideas on tackling to encourage more use of balanced tackling.

Are the performance boosters also 5 points/point? They could be a point for a point, but simply the amount of difference a point makes scaled to the fact that they are a point for a point. I agree that soft-cap adjusters would have to be 5 points per point.



What I wanted to avoid was duplication of existing SAs. Receivers already have Sticky Hands - I don't want another Prestige Performance Booster that duplicates Sticky Hands.

The backup issue is no different than XP gain now so unless regular XP gain is going to be looked at, I don't think this systems should differ.

I intentionally left the exact Performance effects blank as I thought that would best be determined by Bort. The effect should be pretty minimal as to not overbalance things.


I'm just thinking with Go-To Guy as it is that if the person with it isn't one of a team's best receivers it could actually hurt team performance.

I love the concept, though, either way, and I have some other ideas as you can see. I'd like the performance boosters to be as many and as worthwhile as to discourage Prestige XP from being used only or mostly just to raise soft caps.

It's kind of a way to have more SA's (in a different way) as GG and I worked on (and also allow soft caps to be increased, as another option).



Go To Guy won't make the QB automatically throw it to him, but it will just give him a boost in that area. If another guys is dramatically more open or an earlier read, it's still going to get thrown to the other guy.


 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by turnerhero

Originally posted by Snakebite99


I think he means 600 XP at prestige level 1, 520 (or whatever) at level 2, so on and so forth, like regular XP we gain now. I really like this idea. I dont know how easy it would be to program, but Bort's pretty much a genius, so im sure he can figure it out


In my opinion, I like the overall idea very much, but the exp gain should be the same as originally thought of, such as the above, but each lvl of prestige or whatever should take twice as much to hit the next level as normal player lvling, just so it doesn't have a cascade effect of a player reaching around lvl 50 or so and each one lvls so horribly slow it's to the point of wanting to pull your hair out.

I'm not sure if this made any sense...I haven't fully absorbed the idea yet...hehe


Are you saying that the XP gain should be based on the original chart but that you Prestige level at 2000, 4000, 6000, etc?


If he is, I'd disagree with him. But perhaps partially to address his concerns and partially to address TreMetal's, prestige exp from playing could be halved but from training could be doubled-- so that playing time still matters, but less, and leveling is slowed, but not slowed by half?
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
drifter always has good ideas.

I liked his rivalry idea, but that never happened apparently. I can't blame Bort though, IMO fixing bugs and play balancing more important than installing new features right now.


I got some positive feedback on it from on high so there might be something put in place somewhere down the road.

I'd bump that one and my post retirement Coaching idea and Legacy Offspring ideas if I could search the forums and find them.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by turnerhero


Originally posted by Snakebite99



I think he means 600 XP at prestige level 1, 520 (or whatever) at level 2, so on and so forth, like regular XP we gain now. I really like this idea. I dont know how easy it would be to program, but Bort's pretty much a genius, so im sure he can figure it out


In my opinion, I like the overall idea very much, but the exp gain should be the same as originally thought of, such as the above, but each lvl of prestige or whatever should take twice as much to hit the next level as normal player lvling, just so it doesn't have a cascade effect of a player reaching around lvl 50 or so and each one lvls so horribly slow it's to the point of wanting to pull your hair out.

I'm not sure if this made any sense...I haven't fully absorbed the idea yet...hehe


Are you saying that the XP gain should be based on the original chart but that you Prestige level at 2000, 4000, 6000, etc?


If he is, I'd disagree with him. But perhaps partially to address his concerns and partially to address TreMetal's, prestige exp from playing could be halved but from training could be doubled-- so that playing time still matters, but less, and leveling is slowed, but not slowed by half?


I'm not convinced that it needs to be slowed. Without being able to boost the Prestige Level, a player who hit level 31 in their 4th season, would probably just about get to Prestige Level 35 or so by the time they hit the 10 year decline mark. That's 175 Prestige Points. If they had poured all of that into raising only one specific soft cap, I think that would put their soft cap in that one skill at about 70. I don't think that's too bad considering they would have had to sacrifice all other Prestige development to do it.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

Some other performance boosters:

Acceleration: Enhances acceleration (duh). Bort's admitted he should have made it its own attribute, so it could at least be a prestige attribute.

Crease Closer: Improves a DB's performance in zone defenses.

Quick Feet: Improves a player's Head Fake and Juke moves at all times, as well as Quick Cuts when running with the ball.

Reliability: Decreases the chance of the player fumbling, dropping a pass, blowing coverage on defense, and the like.

First Down Marker: Knows where the first down marker is, and if he needs an extra half a yard to get the first down, has a better chance of getting it.

Scat Back: Increases a HB or FB's abilities as a receiver on pass plays (maybe even making him almost...useful). When used as such, he gains a bonus to speed, agility, vision, and catching.


Originally posted by Drifter
I'm all for there being a ton of performance boosters. I just want to make sure they don't duplicate what regular attributes or SAs already do:

Acceleration - On board

Crease Closer - How is it different from Closing Speed?


It specifically affects performance in zone defense. Closing Speed helps in various ways, such as helping players run up to stop running plays. This wouldn't. It also likely wouldn't be implemented with better speed and acceleration, but more like Vision, of seeing where there's a crease that's likely to be exploited and covering it.

Originally posted by drifter
Quick Feet - How is this different from higher agility?


It's much more specific. It helps only agility SA's, and not all of them. If you have no agility SA's it doesn't help you at all, but it's better than agility in helping agility SA's.

Originally posted by drifter
First Down Marker - I like it. Some overlap with 4 yard Dive, but I think it's still good.


I think Dive 4 Yards is active in all situations. This specifically affects cases where a play would be just short of a first down without the attribute.

Originally posted by Drifter
Scat back - Can't a player build these thigns into his player instead of needing a Performance Booster for it? Maybe it just eliminates the position bonus for moving from HB to WR?


Well, of course many RB's are built with Speed and Agility. This does what many SA's do, by enhancing attributes in given situations. I really see these as a different type of SA.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 12:47:44
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Along the lines of how I modified Ken's scatback ability to reduce the out of position hit, I think you could have a bunch of those.

Reduce penalty to playing Oline or Dline or Linebacker or Safety or whatever you wanted. If you wanted to build an olineman and pump a bunch of pts into reducing his penalty when playing WR, more power to you. THe initial penalty is probably so big that even with the reduction, you'd still stuck, but if you wanted to do it you could.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
I like the idea overall, but the rich getting richer is not good in my opinion.

In your example you have 100 XP per day training, 600 MAX per game (800 per 2 days). I would change that to 300 XP per day training, 200 MAX per game (also 800). Or some other number scheme where everyone, not just starters, get these bonus levels.
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
As long as it gives me something to shoot for on a given week once I reach those higher levels than I'm all for it. Since game stats doesn't really matter unless your player is number one in that stat than there's no point to checking up on your player once he reach a high level so People become less active more and more

but this is a great solution to problems ahead for new users
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
I like the idea overall, but the rich getting richer is not good in my opinion.

In your example you have 100 XP per day training, 600 MAX per game (800 per 2 days). I would change that to 300 XP per day training, 200 MAX per game (also 800). Or some other number scheme where everyone, not just starters, get these bonus levels.


It's not the rich getting richer at all. It's not like players on bad teams won't have the same options. There's lots of teams out there in need of starters if you aren't getting enough time in a backup role. Also, just like with regular XP, you'd gain the bulk of your XP with 20-30 plays. Anyting above that has a diminishing return, just like regular XP.

My example is based off the normal XP gain at level 1. When they hit Prestige lvl 2, they would get the same amount of Prestige XP that a player would get at level 2.

None of the Prestige Points gained could be applied to Normal Attributes or Special Attributes and the cost of boosting your soft cap or the effect of performance boosters is fairly minimal.

As I said, if the general XP structure changes, this should match it, but I see no reason for it to differ from normal XP gain as the devs have implemented.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddencoach
As long as it gives me something to shoot for on a given week once I reach those higher levels than I'm all for it. Since game stats doesn't really matter unless your player is number one in that stat than there's no point to checking up on your player once he reach a high level so People become less active more and more

but this is a great solution to problems ahead for new users


That was the main motivation. The added bonus is that it takes us away from the cookie cutter builds that we are all gravitating towards. Differentiation is KEY.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
great idea, as usual drifter.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by turnerhero



Originally posted by Snakebite99




I think he means 600 XP at prestige level 1, 520 (or whatever) at level 2, so on and so forth, like regular XP we gain now. I really like this idea. I dont know how easy it would be to program, but Bort's pretty much a genius, so im sure he can figure it out


In my opinion, I like the overall idea very much, but the exp gain should be the same as originally thought of, such as the above, but each lvl of prestige or whatever should take twice as much to hit the next level as normal player lvling, just so it doesn't have a cascade effect of a player reaching around lvl 50 or so and each one lvls so horribly slow it's to the point of wanting to pull your hair out.

I'm not sure if this made any sense...I haven't fully absorbed the idea yet...hehe


Are you saying that the XP gain should be based on the original chart but that you Prestige level at 2000, 4000, 6000, etc?


If he is, I'd disagree with him. But perhaps partially to address his concerns and partially to address TreMetal's, prestige exp from playing could be halved but from training could be doubled-- so that playing time still matters, but less, and leveling is slowed, but not slowed by half?


I'm not convinced that it needs to be slowed. Without being able to boost the Prestige Level, a player who hit level 31 in their 4th season, would probably just about get to Prestige Level 35 or so by the time they hit the 10 year decline mark. That's 175 Prestige Points. If they had poured all of that into raising only one specific soft cap, I think that would put their soft cap in that one skill at about 70. I don't think that's too bad considering they would have had to sacrifice all other Prestige development to do it.


I'm not fully convinced it needs to be slowed, either; but, how about the general thought of having it less dependent on game exp and more on training? Maybe halve the game exp and triple the amount from training, so it's somewhere near as fast but less dependent on whether you get lots of playing time?

Maybe even make prestige exp more dependent on the type of training as well, with game exp halved? (Relaxed = 2 * normal training exp, Normal = 3 * normal training exp, Intense = 4 * normal training exp?)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.