User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Bad Owners need to be NERFED
Page:
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
Originally posted by oldskool

Buyout clause decent, but should be mandatory for all contracts.

It just seems like it would be too big of a sticking point otherwise; players feel like they're going to get screwed if the owner doesn't/won't offer it, owners feel like the players are going to be disloyal if they insist on having it offered.

Owners should have to treat every player fairly, not pick & choose which players 'can' get screwed because they don't have a clause to escape.


If mandatory, owners need protection too, so they don't get screwed without a starting HB a day before a big game. Maybe some kind of grace period between when a player exercises it, and when it actually happens? An alert can be sent to the owner so he could have, say, two days to try and convince the player to stay.


Good point...maybe 24 hours pending, and then it goes through in the rollover with trades that night. Gives the owner 36-40 hours (more if it goes through after a gameday, to replace the player.

Also still critical is the 'black-out' period where a buy-out can't be exercised between the trade deadline and the end of season.
 
Graythreat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
The best solution I've seen to date (and have supported elsewhere) is some type of 'buy-out' option that can be negotiated into a contract.

If done right, this would allow players to escape the so called 'bad-owner' (I know they are out there, but I don't think quite as prevalent as some would suggest)...but the same clause could be designed in such a way that the financial cost would protect reasonable owners.

There doesn't have to be a reason for a buy-out (i.e. depth chart position, playing time, etc.) just has to be a balance between the cost of the buy-out and the benefit. This way a player will only do a buy-out if they are really feeling trapped, and an owner will recover his funds.

My suggestions for such a clause would be

1) Make it optional, like the no trade clause is currently
2) Make the amount negotiable (I'd suggest that a good amount if it must be fixed would be 100% signing bonus (all bonuses given in last 40 days + 5 days salary)
3) NO Buy-outs between the trade deadline and end of season. This prevents the "I'm going to leave to go play for my buddies playoff team" or top level guys upsetting the balance of a playoff race
4) Pro-rate the buyout based on contract served
for a 1 season contract cut 20% off the amount for every 10 days played
Buyout original 100% of bonus + 5 days salary
Buyout after day 10 80% + 4 days salary
Buyout after day 20 60% + 3 days salary
Buyout after day 30 40% + 2 days salary

The contract buyout needs to be calculated off of all signing bonuses for the last 40 days so that the lv24 and higher bonuses can be calculated into the formula.


The problem with buyout clauses is that it creates a major issue for teams retaining personnel. IF I just signed a guy, and turned others down for the position I'll be PO'd if he walks off with a bit of my money and costs me hours of hunting down another position. Buyout penalties would have to be very high IMO to discourage players from leaving a team hanging.

Your also going to have to revise the entire bonus system as right now you have to offer 2 contracts to equip players for lvl 24 equipment. Meaning potentially a guy can sign, get 2 contracts, buy himself out, and make off with over 100K. That'd be really really nasty.

I understand the reason for buyouts, but I think there would have to be SEVERE penalties for doing so. It's not just immaginary money that the team is out, it's also a lot of time and effort ut into scouting for positions.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
^^^Graythreat,

I proposed that you would include all bonuses in the last 40 days in the buyout formula...so lv24 equipment, etc. is covered.

As for him making off with your money he'd have to serve at least a quarter of his contract to get away with anything...personally I'd use buyout clauses to sign more 2 year contracts. This way the first pro-ration doesn't occur for 20 days, and then it will still cost the player 80% of their bonus and 4 days salary to buy out. I'm guessing it won't be worth it financially until later in the contract unless the player is being abused. That's the point of the buy-out clause. To protect players from abusive ownership tactics. If you are reasonable as an owner none of your players would find the cost of this proposal worth escaping.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Graythreat
Originally posted by rbedgood

The best solution I've seen to date (and have supported elsewhere) is some type of 'buy-out' option that can be negotiated into a contract.

If done right, this would allow players to escape the so called 'bad-owner' (I know they are out there, but I don't think quite as prevalent as some would suggest)...but the same clause could be designed in such a way that the financial cost would protect reasonable owners.

There doesn't have to be a reason for a buy-out (i.e. depth chart position, playing time, etc.) just has to be a balance between the cost of the buy-out and the benefit. This way a player will only do a buy-out if they are really feeling trapped, and an owner will recover his funds.

My suggestions for such a clause would be

1) Make it optional, like the no trade clause is currently
2) Make the amount negotiable (I'd suggest that a good amount if it must be fixed would be 100% signing bonus (all bonuses given in last 40 days + 5 days salary)
3) NO Buy-outs between the trade deadline and end of season. This prevents the "I'm going to leave to go play for my buddies playoff team" or top level guys upsetting the balance of a playoff race
4) Pro-rate the buyout based on contract served
for a 1 season contract cut 20% off the amount for every 10 days played
Buyout original 100% of bonus + 5 days salary
Buyout after day 10 80% + 4 days salary
Buyout after day 20 60% + 3 days salary
Buyout after day 30 40% + 2 days salary

The contract buyout needs to be calculated off of all signing bonuses for the last 40 days so that the lv24 and higher bonuses can be calculated into the formula.


The problem with buyout clauses is that it creates a major issue for teams retaining personnel. IF I just signed a guy, and turned others down for the position I'll be PO'd if he walks off with a bit of my money and costs me hours of hunting down another position. Buyout penalties would have to be very high IMO to discourage players from leaving a team hanging.

Your also going to have to revise the entire bonus system as right now you have to offer 2 contracts to equip players for lvl 24 equipment. Meaning potentially a guy can sign, get 2 contracts, buy himself out, and make off with over 100K. That'd be really really nasty.

I understand the reason for buyouts, but I think there would have to be SEVERE penalties for doing so. It's not just immaginary money that the team is out, it's also a lot of time and effort ut into scouting for positions.


Good point. Maybe there can be a "waiver period" just like in fantasy? Say if a player buys himself out, the waiver period is a mandatory 4-10 days; this gives the dual purpose of allowing other teams to send contract offers while also semi-punishing the player since he can't get game experience. It would help reduce the opportunity for abuse since if an agent does this too often, it could really stunt the development of his player.

Another way to prevent abuse is publicly showing the number of times a player exercises a buyout; owners will be wary of those with multiple buyouts. That type of thing would be public information in real life anyways, so it fits with the sim feel of the game.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
^^^ 10 days would be way too long. 3-4 days (which would be 1-2 games) would be reasonable. Also showing contract history would be great...a chart on each players page showing contract start date, amount of contract, original expiration date, termination date and termination reason.

Start date---obviously the date contract was signed
Amount---salary/bonus info as deemed appropriate to share
Original expiration date---show when contract was supposed to expire
Termination date---contract actually ended this date
Termination reason---- Expired, Traded, Released, Buy-out, Re-negotiated, etc.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
^^^ 10 days would be way too long. 3-4 days (which would be 1-2 games) would be reasonable. Also showing contract history would be great...a chart on each players page showing contract start date, amount of contract, original expiration date, termination date and termination reason.

Start date---obviously the date contract was signed
Amount---salary/bonus info as deemed appropriate to share
Original expiration date---show when contract was supposed to expire
Termination date---contract actually ended this date
Termination reason---- Expired, Traded, Released, Buy-out, Re-negotiated, etc.


I think 6 days would be a reasonable compromise. Just enough to make the player feel the weight of his decision, but not enough where it's obscene. He'll still be able to train (as long as he has cash), just no game experience.

And complete contract history is an even better idea than just buyouts... again, it's all public in real life so it's still appropriate. Although, signing bonuses are currently hidden from other agents so I think that should remain intact.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
Originally posted by rbedgood

^^^ 10 days would be way too long. 3-4 days (which would be 1-2 games) would be reasonable. Also showing contract history would be great...a chart on each players page showing contract start date, amount of contract, original expiration date, termination date and termination reason.

Start date---obviously the date contract was signed
Amount---salary/bonus info as deemed appropriate to share
Original expiration date---show when contract was supposed to expire
Termination date---contract actually ended this date
Termination reason---- Expired, Traded, Released, Buy-out, Re-negotiated, etc.


I think 6 days would be a reasonable compromise. Just enough to make the player feel the weight of his decision, but not enough where it's obscene. He'll still be able to train (as long as he has cash), just no game experience.

And complete contract history is an even better idea than just buyouts... again, it's all public in real life so it's still appropriate. Although, signing bonuses are currently hidden from other agents so I think that should remain intact.


...but if he just bought out of his contract he likely won't have any cash.

As for bonuses, I was thinking that the contract history page would just show total contract amount...(eg. 1 year contract with 50,000 bonus and 100,000 contract would just show as 150,000)
 
CoachB05
offline
Link
 
I also believe that there should be stipulations to a contract, to where if they aren't being fulfilled, THEN the player should be able to buyout. Like being promised starting role, so many plays per game, an inactive owner.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachB05
I also believe that there should be stipulations to a contract, to where if they aren't being fulfilled, THEN the player should be able to buyout. Like being promised starting role, so many plays per game, an inactive owner.



...are you saying that the player would be able to buy-out less expensively under these circumstances? Or are you saying that he can ONLY buy-out if one of these conditions is met?

If the 'discount' is being proposed this is too ripe for abuse. A player will simply train on intense until his owner is forced to bench him, and then get a 'discounted' buy-out.

If you are suggesting restricting buy-outs I think you get back into the whining and complaining about not being able to get out of a contract.

I like leaving it as an open option for any player to exercise, but it is costly in both in-game money and also in development (with WallySmith's waiver proposal)
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood

...but if he just bought out of his contract he likely won't have any cash.


Another factor in limiting buyouts. It empowers the player but it prevents abuse of a system in which an owner SHOULD have more leverage, just like in real life.
 
Link
 
Buy outs are a fine idea assuming we can balance the hurt of the owner with that of the player. The biggest issue with Buyouts is obviously that it puts owners on the defensive, which for obvious reasons, is backwards. Something that makes it a distastful situation for the player as much as it would the owner is likely the only way to make it work.

In short, buy outs should be a "so it's come to this" sitution, not a drop of a hat situation.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
It would help if in these situations the Moderators (mouthpiece of Bort and DD) were trying to broker peace instead of piling on.

I'm most disappointed when I see a Mod in a thread like the one at 40+ pages in the GLB forum piling on and encouraging owners to squat on a player leaving him on the bench to rot or basically saying that it's okay to do that. There are some mods who forget that this is a business and these are customers. They should be responding that this is a discouraged practice and trying to broker a fair resolution. There should/could easily be a grievance forum and the Mods could serve as an official board to resolve some of these issues over contracts, playing time, etc.

If I didn't like a mod (let's use Serenity for example) today based on what the Mods are saying I could go to the owner of every team she's on, offer an outlandish trade for her players until one of them accepts, then sit that player on my bench to rot until the contract expires. Maybe that's what it will take to get players some protection from this kind of thing, because owners hold all the power today once a player is under contract. (And I'm an owner)
Last edited Aug 19, 2008 17:49:57
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
don't nerf bad owners...just nerf power backs...bring them back down to earth...like kickers were...
 
ViperGuy02
offline
Link
 
Interesting thread, I like the idea of a buyout option.
 
Graythreat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
Originally posted by rbedgood


...but if he just bought out of his contract he likely won't have any cash.


Another factor in limiting buyouts. It empowers the player but it prevents abuse of a system in which an owner SHOULD have more leverage, just like in real life.


This is quality actually.

There could be a stipulation (i.e. Starter, #2 #3 or whatever), that if it's met you are locked into your contract. Thus, no buyout option.

The reverse has to also be true...

1. Player must have 90+ energy per game (to prevent someone from killing their character and getting pulled out of a starting position)

2. Must play on normal at the least

3. Must be fully equipped all of the time

If the player doesn't meet those requirements, he can be benched, no qualms about it. If the owner doesn't meet his end of the bargain, the player can buy out. Which would be a substantial amount of money, and a "time out"

As long as the contract is a 2 way street...i.e. if your guaranteed to start, you have to guarantee your playable, there should be no problem. An owner couldn't just bury a guy out of spite, and a player couldn't just threaten to take off his equipment, and tank his player.

It would be balanced, and in both of their interest to resolve the situation.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.