User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > League fix for player disparity
Page:
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by turnerhero

Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.


I read your post... You think Bort would like to implement something that will make agents wary to boost their players? If I knew I may have to retire my guy after just a couple of seasons, there is no way I would boost all of my players (As I do now, spending 55$ a month on this game). Then after I play 8 seasons only to find out my guy won't be able to play in the pros, I'd be pretty pissed to have to retire him and start all over.


Most of the pro leagues are full of gutted teams anyways. I agree a huge restruction needs to be done. I think the op has a good idea, but it maybe a bit overboard.
Until GLB can come up with a way that can keep the high level guys up in the pro leagues, it will always be full of gut jobs. And that problems comes from people that want to play with friends and the over abundance of teams out there.

Every idea Bort has come up with people shot it down, and now every league is starting to pay for it. Pretty soon, it will be empty, because it will be to difficult for level 1-4's to find anything out there. Who the hell wants to play the game if they dont get play time. I know that when I finally retire my guys, I have no intentions of creating more, and just sitting their watching them get 10 plays a game, so when the 10th season comes, for them to retire again they will be at like a level 30? If I decide I want to boost them or not.

Its so easy to sit and think about the now, but what happens with the future rolls around and all your high guys are gone, and your forced to compete with a level 30 in a basement league, and your not getting any play time.

Btw this wasn't entirely aimed at the quote, just a summary of what I read here.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Demonic, Which is exactly why I think a cap on every league except pros is the way to go. It will keep the lower guys coming into the game, the higher guys moving up teams or leagues because either they get promoted, or they don't want to lose the XP by playing in a lower lvl league average.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Demonic, Which is exactly why I think a cap on every league except pros is the way to go. It will keep the lower guys coming into the game, the higher guys moving up teams or leagues because either they get promoted, or they don't want to lose the XP by playing in a lower lvl league average.


Problem is when ever that C word is mentioned all of GLB goes into a frantic. They dont relize that around December, maybe earlier, that GLB will be in a serious state. As much as we have boosters, we need the non boosters here as well. The amount of players might be the same, but the diffrence is that people like me are creating more players just to keep teams afloat. How often do you see a player anymore that has only 1 guy?

If you dont boost, eventually you will become more useless than you already are. You watch level 1-4's will be a waste of time. No one will create them to put them on the market, and then bam!!! the great player depression of 08 hits. Why did it hit? Cause no one wanted to fix the teams back 6 months ago, when Bort was trying to do this.

What will happen then? A forceful cap? that people will get angry? My solution is this, you get to pick what league you want. If you buddy decides that he wants a expansion team, then tough luck, he should of waited on a pro team instead.

Now to fix the gut jobs. This offseason, bort needs to take GLB offline. Rearrange the entire leagues. Redo all the teams. We are halfway through the first cycle of players, this should give a great aspect of good cap levels that can go with it. Once all the teams are rearranged, open it back up. Give all the teams a good week, with no penalties, to fix their teams. If you have a friend that you want to play for, to bad, its ruining GLB. Create a player and play on his team that way.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Couldn't agree more.. Teams need to be moved all around as I said earlier in this post. Hard caps (perhaps with a slight float every season) need to be in place on every league with the exception of Pros. If you get on a team with a cap and you rise above it, you are grandfathered in, this will help teams stay together and if friends really want to be together they're in it for the long haul. However, you'll be penalized for staying on a lower level team in a lower level league.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Yes, something needs to be done. Here is my problem with the lack of systems thinking going on here:

We don't even know what is going to really happen to players when they hit their 11th season. Will they decline drastically? Will they be able to play several more years? Who will take their place? Most likely a season 9 or 10 (as they will be the highest level). Then they will be replaced by a season 9 or 10 guy. Ultimately, if you are lucky enough, you will get 2 seasons in the pros. Even then, the odds are against you. I know adding more teams is not the way to go. It has entirely become a watered-down version of the football experience.

That is why I support the OP's idea (with arena leagues). You basically would have season caps for leagues. If you end your highschool career without boosting, you will end up in a low-end, shitty college division. Then, after 4 seasons there, you will end up going to some crappy arena league team. You still get to play, but you don't get the rewards associated with paying to play (making it to the Pros for the big money and the limelight).

To take it a step further, add a short attention grabber at the top of each player's page for pro-league highlights. Click on the link and see the day's results. Give them a reason to try and make it to that level.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Couldn't agree more.. Teams need to be moved all around as I said earlier in this post. Hard caps (perhaps with a slight float every season) need to be in place on every league with the exception of Pros. If you get on a team with a cap and you rise above it, you are grandfathered in, this will help teams stay together and if friends really want to be together they're in it for the long haul. However, you'll be penalized for staying on a lower level team in a lower level league.


My suggestion, and only suggestion, for capped leagues (as I think they are a must), is to allow teams 3 players over the cap to join. This would add an extra element of strategy to the game. Do you want a stellar QB (if you can find one) or do you want to beef up your secondary? You have 3 spots to fill above the cap. Choose wisely.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Yes, something needs to be done. Here is my problem with the lack of systems thinking going on here:

We don't even know what is going to really happen to players when they hit their 11th season. Will they decline drastically? Will they be able to play several more years? Who will take their place? Most likely a season 9 or 10 (as they will be the highest level). Then they will be replaced by a season 9 or 10 guy. Ultimately, if you are lucky enough, you will get 2 seasons in the pros. Even then, the odds are against you. I know adding more teams is not the way to go. It has entirely become a watered-down version of the football experience.

That is why I support the OP's idea (with arena leagues). You basically would have season caps for leagues. If you end your highschool career without boosting, you will end up in a low-end, shitty college division. Then, after 4 seasons there, you will end up going to some crappy arena league team. You still get to play, but you don't get the rewards associated with paying to play (making it to the Pros for the big money and the limelight).

To take it a step further, add a short attention grabber at the top of each player's page for pro-league highlights. Click on the link and see the day's results. Give them a reason to try and make it to that level.


Sounds like your talking about a non booster team and leagues. That wont happen. But Bort needs to grow a set of balls, and say ya know what this friend thing is killing the game. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE KEEP A ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF LEVEL1-4'S. Without them this game will be tanked very very very fast. If there is a cap, people will bitch and cry, but I doubt that they will have invested so much money, and then just turn around and leave. I say call their bluff.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Yes, something needs to be done. Here is my problem with the lack of systems thinking going on here:

We don't even know what is going to really happen to players when they hit their 11th season. Will they decline drastically? Will they be able to play several more years? Who will take their place? Most likely a season 9 or 10 (as they will be the highest level). Then they will be replaced by a season 9 or 10 guy. Ultimately, if you are lucky enough, you will get 2 seasons in the pros. Even then, the odds are against you. I know adding more teams is not the way to go. It has entirely become a watered-down version of the football experience.

That is why I support the OP's idea (with arena leagues). You basically would have season caps for leagues. If you end your highschool career without boosting, you will end up in a low-end, shitty college division. Then, after 4 seasons there, you will end up going to some crappy arena league team. You still get to play, but you don't get the rewards associated with paying to play (making it to the Pros for the big money and the limelight).

To take it a step further, add a short attention grabber at the top of each player's page for pro-league highlights. Click on the link and see the day's results. Give them a reason to try and make it to that level.



I don't mind that so much, The one thing I don't think many will like is the owning of a team portion. Who gets what teams? How are new players delivered to the new teams (drafting or what?) You know what I mean, will it come down to a popularity contest, or will it come down to perfomance and stat wise? If that's the case what happens when an actually really good player ends up on a pretty good team but only gets decent stats because he plays against good competition as well. Same token, what happens when a mediocre player ends up on a shitty team in HS and college, but puts up great stats because he plays shitty players.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Couldn't agree more.. Teams need to be moved all around as I said earlier in this post. Hard caps (perhaps with a slight float every season) need to be in place on every league with the exception of Pros. If you get on a team with a cap and you rise above it, you are grandfathered in, this will help teams stay together and if friends really want to be together they're in it for the long haul. However, you'll be penalized for staying on a lower level team in a lower level league.


My suggestion, and only suggestion, for capped leagues (as I think they are a must), is to allow teams 3 players over the cap to join. This would add an extra element of strategy to the game. Do you want a stellar QB (if you can find one) or do you want to beef up your secondary? You have 3 spots to fill above the cap. Choose wisely.

I like that as well, 3 is probably a good number. That way if a guy wants to play with a friend then he can bring a player or two over. The problem I see is the inflated stats though. Maybe there should be a cap on the cap. I shouldnt be allowed to bring my level 35 hb to a expansion team. That would show no realism. He would end the season with 50,000 yards, and the fun of this game IMO is being a league leader, with this cap it would be like a team ICON. Kind of like a payton manning etc.... Every team has that one or two guys that are a little better than rest of the NFL, but not by a huge margin.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Couldn't agree more.. Teams need to be moved all around as I said earlier in this post. Hard caps (perhaps with a slight float every season) need to be in place on every league with the exception of Pros. If you get on a team with a cap and you rise above it, you are grandfathered in, this will help teams stay together and if friends really want to be together they're in it for the long haul. However, you'll be penalized for staying on a lower level team in a lower level league.


My suggestion, and only suggestion, for capped leagues (as I think they are a must), is to allow teams 3 players over the cap to join. This would add an extra element of strategy to the game. Do you want a stellar QB (if you can find one) or do you want to beef up your secondary? You have 3 spots to fill above the cap. Choose wisely.


That would be a great addition as well... However, they would still take the XP hits, so they'd have to be willing to drop down in the leagues for that, none the less I like that idea.
 
Link
 
The GLB vets and dedicated players, before the decline, will have already made new players and have them in the D-Leagues. That's how games survive. Me, I'm thinking about season 7 getting some flex and making a bunch of new players to eventually take my players place.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Demonic, You could have a league cap of LVL 13, with an exception cap of 17 (for your 3 players that you desire)
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jonathanmcnutt
The GLB vets and dedicated players, before the decline, will have already made new players and have them in the D-Leagues. That's how games survive. Me, I'm thinking about season 7 getting some flex and making a bunch of new players to eventually take my players place.


Ok so now we are all depended on the "vets" persay. It comes down to what I said earlier, The amount of football players are still the same, but the amount of agents are declining. Eventually when a agents leaves the game it will have a bigger impact, because a bigger percentage of his/her players are gone now.

We have to start thinking long term here, not short term. We shouldnt be relying on Vets to create more players just to keep the markets up.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Demonic, You could have a league cap of LVL 13, with an exception cap of 17 (for your 3 players that you desire)


Actually that would work out. The problem now is to get the rest of the GLB community to relize that this needs to get fixed. The minute the C word comes out people start the flame wars. If someone could get majority of the GLB community to agree it would be great. No African A team wants to give up there level 29 Qb's though, and Bort just needs to stick to his guns, and call their bluff.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Demonic, You could have a league cap of LVL 13, with an exception cap of 17 (for your 3 players that you desire)


Actually that would work out. The problem now is to get the rest of the GLB community to relize that this needs to get fixed. The minute the C word comes out people start the flame wars. If someone could get majority of the GLB community to agree it would be great. No African A team wants to give up there level 29 Qb's though, and Bort just needs to stick to his guns, and call their bluff.


Well prior to capping it needs to just be a massive restructuring of the leagues. All leagues should be shuffled and teams sent into leagues with their AVG player level being that league, and that league having an AVG level cap based on the league. Once that happens teams will be even and set up properly. Gutted teams will be the bottom dwellers with the LVL 13ish caps.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.