Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by grugnur
the next logical progression is to make your overall power a combination of 1) physical strength 2) speed and 3) technique which only certain positions will be able to effectively master... right now slow moving FB power is able to overcome DT power but it doesn't take into consideration the fact that the DT probably weighs 70 pounds more... a DT or OL should be able raise strength high but should struggle to get agility, jumping and speed high... a FB should not be able to get strength anywhere near a DT without sacrificing ALOT of his inherent abilities and skills... designers need to tailor how skill points are applied to each class... a DT or OL could spend one point each to get strength into the 60s where a cornerback would need to spend 5 points each to get over 40 (just an example)
The only problem I would see with that is it would lead to too many cookie cutter builds, with everyone almost having to follow the same builds. then we won't have the high jumping CBs, or blocking WRs that make everyone a little different.
Thing is, at all levels in the real world, there are "cookie cutter builds" Nfl linemen are all basically the same, stats wise. Only the upper tier guys have a slight edge over the average ones. Its the same with any other positions. They're all pretty much the same
Originally posted by grugnur
the next logical progression is to make your overall power a combination of 1) physical strength 2) speed and 3) technique which only certain positions will be able to effectively master... right now slow moving FB power is able to overcome DT power but it doesn't take into consideration the fact that the DT probably weighs 70 pounds more... a DT or OL should be able raise strength high but should struggle to get agility, jumping and speed high... a FB should not be able to get strength anywhere near a DT without sacrificing ALOT of his inherent abilities and skills... designers need to tailor how skill points are applied to each class... a DT or OL could spend one point each to get strength into the 60s where a cornerback would need to spend 5 points each to get over 40 (just an example)
The only problem I would see with that is it would lead to too many cookie cutter builds, with everyone almost having to follow the same builds. then we won't have the high jumping CBs, or blocking WRs that make everyone a little different.
Thing is, at all levels in the real world, there are "cookie cutter builds" Nfl linemen are all basically the same, stats wise. Only the upper tier guys have a slight edge over the average ones. Its the same with any other positions. They're all pretty much the same






























